News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You Can Prove a Negative [pdf] by wfo on Saturday August 08, 2015 @04:33PM (#10028585)
I think the article dances around what people really mean when they say "you can't prove a negative". The writer touches on it but somehow skirts the real issue. When we say "you can't prove a negative" you're really saying that in order to prove a statement of the form "not exists x P(x)", it's equivalent to proving "for all x not P(x)" and so you're really making a statement about EVERYTHING that has or does or could ever exist somehow. These proofs are either analytic and trivial (i.e. there doesn't exist a rectangular circle) or not proofs.

He suggests you get around this by providing an argument about unicorns and then goes on to talk about how premises don't always need to be justified, but the problem is proving the nonexistence of a thing -- and he provides a formal deductive example of a proof of nonexistence of a thing by instead substituting as a premise nonexistence of another thing (evidence). Sure, if you can prove no evidence for unicorns exists and that for unicorns to exist they MUST have left evidence you can prove they don't exist. But the first one is a reduction to the original problem -- in order to show something doesn't exist (be it unicorns or evidence for unicorns) you need complete and total knowledge about existence, which no human up to this point has had enough hubris to claim, and the second requires a level of certainty that doesn't really exist.

If we're discussing the existence of a thing that doesn't leave evidence (god) especially it's very fair to say you can't prove a negative and I think his attack on this tactic is a non-starter.

There has never been even the tiniest bit of evidence against the existence of god. There is certainly evidence against a god with specific qualities; a benevolent god, a god that wants this to happen, etc. But if you don't require god to have any specific qualities there isn't a shred.

Re:You Can Prove a Negative [pdf] by cristianpascu on Saturday August 08, 2015 @04:51PM (#10028628)
I think the problem of proving the (non) existence of something is as simple as understanding that (most of the time) it can not be deductive. I'd say that when it comes to existence, it is always inductive. What kind of proof can anyone give me that she/he exists? Or the rest of the world? There is no such thing. Even in mathematics, if one doubts basic entities as numbers and their properties, the whole establishment of mathematics starts to crack, at least for that particualr one human being.

All of our reasoning about the world is inference based, hence probabilistic. That's in the nature of science, religion and everything else in between. There is strong evidence for the existence of God, but it's inherently inductive. Not to mention various conceputal complication which follow from in different kind of reasoning about God (in whatever view).

Re:You Can Prove a Negative [pdf] by shkkmo on Saturday August 08, 2015 @05:10PM (#10028672)
You can, in fact, prove non-existence deductively through proof by contradiction.

Proofs can be valid even if their premises (assumptions) are not true. Mathematics does not rest on the truth of it's assumptions, but on the validity of it's proofs.

If you can create an interesting system of proofs off of an a different sent of premises, then that can also be very useful (see non-euclidean geometry). If you can't create an interesting system, then those premises have no value.

I also disagree that all our reasoning about the world is probabilistic. By saying that all reasoning is inductive, you make you earlier assertion that "I'd say that when it comes to existence, it is always inductive." empty because you are claiming that all reasoning is inductive.

Re:You Can Prove a Negative [pdf] by Dylan16807 on Saturday August 08, 2015 @05:20PM (#10028705)
> Even in mathematics, if one doubts basic entities as numbers and their properties, the whole establishment of mathematics starts to crack, at least for that particualr one human being.

That's not how it works. Numbers are their properties. You are free to use any properties you want when you commit mathematics, and you will get different sorts of behavior from your numbers depending on your choices. There is nothing to doubt about a set of properties being itself. No 'establishment' tells you how numbers work. Use whatever you like.

Re:You Can Prove a Negative [pdf] by danielam on Saturday August 08, 2015 @11:01PM (#10029361)
Well, if mathematics is to say anything about the world, then the foundations must be sound (and drawn from experience which brings us back to empiricism). Sometimes the problem isn't necessarily with the concepts in our heads but the formalizations we choose to proceed from. Set theory is a great example. Take Russell's paradox, for instance, and the different responses to it (e.g., ZFC, Lesniewski's mereology).

I'm reminded of Duhem's rather humorous "German Science" where he characterizes German mathematics as being disproportionately oriented toward rigorously deducing nonsense from arbitrary axioms as opposed to the French tendency to rely on intuition to arrive at sensible axioms but neglecting systematic rigor afterwards.

Re:You Can Prove a Negative [pdf] by Dylan16807 on Sunday August 09, 2015 @03:30AM (#10029780)
Physics says things about the world.

Math is a tool to help you make logical conclusions.

Re:You Can Prove a Negative [pdf] by Kenji on Saturday August 08, 2015 @04:48PM (#10028622)
About the part with god, there's a specific expression for that: God of the gaps. As our (scientific) understanding increases, a proposed god people want to believe in has to lose one characteristic after another because they would not hold up against reason and evidence.
Re:You Can Prove a Negative [pdf] by shkkmo on Saturday August 08, 2015 @05:13PM (#10028684)
Do you have an example of one such characteristic that has been disproved?

I would posit the opposite: As the capability of our language to describe characteristics of god expands, it becomes harder to disprove god because the number of possible descriptions increases.

Re:You Can Prove a Negative [pdf] by amlgsmsn on Saturday August 08, 2015 @08:53PM (#10029135)
Lightning? Aurora borealis? Eclipses? Earth being center of universe?
Re:You Can Prove a Negative [pdf] by shkkmo on Sunday August 09, 2015 @08:58AM (#10030199)
I wasn't aware that any of those were ever viewed as characteristics of god.

If I believe John knocked the book off the table, but then I learn it was the wind, that doesn't change the characteristics of John.

Re:You Can Prove a Negative [pdf] by Kenji on Monday August 10, 2015 @02:36PM (#10036370)
It does if you believed that John knocked the book off the table to punish you. You nitpicker :D
Re:You Can Prove a Negative [pdf] by shkkmo on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @03:54PM (#10043889)
> You nitpicker :D

Most certainly, guilty as charged.

> It does if you believed that John knocked the book off the table to punish you.

I don't see how my belief about the reason John took that action makes whether John took that action (or not) a defining characteristic of John.

Re:You Can Prove a Negative [pdf] by cristianpascu on Saturday August 08, 2015 @04:54PM (#10028633)
True, my father told me that the day science came up with the tunneling effect, he stoped believing in a loving God. How can one believe in God when we have computers so powerful that we can post pictures of cats on the internet?