Re:You Can Prove a Negative [pdf]
by Kenji on Saturday August 08, 2015 @04:48PM
(#10028622)
About the part with god, there's a specific expression for that: God of the gaps. As our (scientific) understanding increases, a proposed god people want to believe in has to lose one characteristic after another because they would not hold up against reason and evidence.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Do you have an example of one such characteristic that has been disproved?
I would posit the opposite: As the capability of our language to describe characteristics of god expands, it becomes harder to disprove god because the number of possible descriptions increases.
Lightning? Aurora borealis? Eclipses? Earth being center of universe?
I wasn't aware that any of those were ever viewed as characteristics of god.
If I believe John knocked the book off the table, but then I learn it was the wind, that doesn't change the characteristics of John.
It does if you believed that John knocked the book off the table to punish you. You nitpicker :D
> You nitpicker :D
Most certainly, guilty as charged.
> It does if you believed that John knocked the book off the table to punish you.
I don't see how my belief about the reason John took that action makes whether John took that action (or not) a defining characteristic of John.
Re:You Can Prove a Negative [pdf]
by cristianpascu on Saturday August 08, 2015 @04:54PM
(#10028633)
True, my father told me that the day science came up with the tunneling effect, he stoped believing in a loving God. How can one believe in God when we have computers so powerful that we can post pictures of cats on the internet?