Others have given some good answers, but I think there is another factor: the way discussions are organized.
In a typical BBS, or on UseNet in days of old, a thread was linear, identified only by its subject line. Multiple people could stay with a thread for a relatively long time and have an extended discussion.
Today, most online forum software (HN, Reddit, etc.) displays threads as trees. Each reply begins a new subthread. As a result, a conversion involving more than 2 people will rarely be linear, and a reply 2 or 3 or 4 levels in will be read by almost no one.
But the solution is not to move back to linear threads. Those were abandoned for a good reason: they do not scale. Six active posters might be able to have a reasonable linear discussion. 100 cannot. Linear threads are also much easier for one poster to hijack. Among 6 people, there is a decent chance that none of them is a jerk. Among 100 people, the chance is pretty much zero. So the thread gets filled with troll posts. Conclusion: tree-shaped discussions, along with voting, are what prevents us from being drowned in troll posts & flamewars.
So, what is the solution? I don't know. It's an interesting problem to consider.
Partly because there's no OOTB way to follow up on a thread, especially if it's not one you're participating in. I had to write a user script [1] to highlight new comments and collapse threads without new comments, to make it _possible_ to follow discussions beyond the initial read.
[1] https://github.com/insin/greasemonkey/blob/master/hncommentt...
Although you're right, it is interesting to consider the way the structure of a site shapes its community. Imageboards and PHPBB style forums are linear, and derailing threads on those is practically an art form.
Same goes for mailinglists. Posts get sorted in threads.
Yes, using the "References:" and/or "In-Reply-To:" headers. Later clients tended to do this, I think.
> ... to get the benefits.
Yes, and the drawbacks: in-depth discussions involving multiple people were harder to come by.
In any case, in both Usenet -- late in the game -- and many mailing lists, there are relatively few participants, so scaling is not really an issue.
I would be interested in seeing some sort of mesh network become popular, completely separate from "The Internet", with completely different protocols and paradigms, that you could access and participate in, just by sticking an antenna on your roof, plugging in some kind of adapter, and running some software.
Or perhaps you could utilize existing Wifi hardware and run a completely different set of protocols on it.
I find that enlightening discussions happen there with a surprisingly high frequency, even today.
If I had the inclination I'd build a QRP station and learn Morse. My days of burning fingers on a soldering iron and climbing up trees is gone now.
However there are still plenty of people congregating both anonymously (see 4chsn and other specialist forums) or pseudonymously (see HN, slashdot, reddit, many IRC channels and many other places), even in greater numbers than in the good old BBS/Usenet days.
It just feels they it's disappearing because it is the exception now instead of the rule but places to share (sometimes weird) interests where nobody knows you're a dog are plenty and varied.
Remember back when you'd join a new forum, and they'd have a Welcome Thread just for you, asking you about your interests, etc.? When's the last time you've received a real personalized welcome to a web community? I think it's been at least 15 years for me.
I'm not sure how many people on Hacker News actually remember that internet, most of the community here might be too young to even know what we're talking about.
Edit: Someone ought to make a Web 1.0 emulator, that is invite only. People can set up their own websites, etc. but there is a limited amount of people allowed to join. We can live in the old days FOREVER. XD
So, imagine a website like Reddit, where upon registration, you get assigned at random to a Reddit Company—a little shard of Reddit with its own posts and comments. Imagine further that you could give people an invitation link to allow them to move from their company to yours—again, permanently, though if you made friends in the original company they'd likely be willing to invite you back.
This would have a lot of the Web 1.0 feel, I think; the users would probably get to know one-another quite well, and those "welcome threads" would be perfectly common.
Interestingly, even though a given user's view of the website would only show items from their partition, you could still use statistical information collected from the entire user-base to do "wisdom of crowds" things, like ranking items. In a company-partitioned Reddit, each post's votes could be aggregated by URL across all Companies, with the Company itself then getting to decide to what degree they care about the tastes of the masses, versus the tastes of their (presumed) peers.
I also see the possibility for both immigration and some form of exclusion or shunning. There are further complications: the 90/9/1 rule, multiple personals, etc. But I find it interesting.
Between about 2006 and 2012 I used to spend a ton of time in the Amiga community. It was an interesting mix of experiences, each of the different forums had their own feel and different core users, though there was a lot of cross-pollination between them, with discussions often a mix of underdog us-against-the-world wide-eyed optimism, nostalgia, caustic technical posturing and kitchen sink dramas. It was varied enough to keep my interest, but small enough to get to know the people involved (I recognise some people who post in HN who I knew from my Amiga days). I also learnt a bunch, first exposure to FPGAs was through Amiga developments, for example. If you're interested in classic computing I'm sure it'll still be relatively active, would start lurking at amigaworld.net and see where it takes you. I'm also sure you could find other similar communities if Amigas weren't your thing.
I think you're a bit older than me, I never really experienced the BBS-days for example. Nonetheless, I agree completely. I remember especially a gaming forum in my language that I used to hang out on for years, where I knew 80% of posters, knew who was the trolls and who was the pros and we'd meet up for pizza every now and then etcetera. I miss those days. I see the forum is still up, but at some point it was overrun with users and the old sense of some kind of fellowship died out.
But not in the same way.
I used to know people's lives from IRC and ICQ. I remember chatting online for hours. I was interested in their lives and they were interested in mine, and not just in the current vapid "HN cares inordinately about young successful people and old rich people because it gets you in their good graces" sort of way. Now I can't get anybody to return a direct iMessage in less than 3 hours to 2 days and that's from people I already know.
HN is kinda useless from a "developing friendships" point of view because it's topic hopping, not just open for daily rambling discussions. Reddit is even worse off because you can't have a meaningful community of 300 million people.
We've definitely lost something. I think it'll come back, but we have to engineer it—the past won't circle back on its own with the current barrage of centralized-only, for-private-profit only, fast-flux, buzzfeed-adhd-driven discussion platforms being shoved down our keyboards.
I still use IRC and don't have this problem at all. I've even been in the same IRC channels for nearly 5-6 years now. These random strangers from around the globe know more about me and my interests than my own family.
I still do. Not even holdover communities; I joined a new community about a year ago, and another two years before that. These folks are cool, I like them, I've met a bunch of them in person whenever they come to town for PAX or whatever.
> Now I can't get anybody to return a direct iMessage in less than 3 hours to 2 days and that's from people I already know.
That sounds like a friend-selection problem to me.
A much larger issue IMHO is the lack of any provision for private messaging (aside from email addresses in profiles).
Not saying that you won't meet awesome people, but I think the demographic is a lot less diverse than most people like to think.
Also, it was nice meeting you at jQSF :)
> These days, I don't know a single person on the internet
Getting to know people is a function of spending time with them. As you get older, you spend less time socializing on the internet.The internet, especially a forum, is a really time-consuming and inefficient way to socialize. You meet more of a person saying "hi" to their face than you do after months of reading their posts online.
When I was a teen stuck at home with the family and school, I had time for that back when the internet and games were an escape and a way to have some control over my social life. It's me that's changed, not the internet.
I wonder if the proxy interactions, things such as likes, karma and retweets, etc. have replaced the desire to get any approval from other people? Maybe we never really cared about the heartfelt appreciation from a person we didn't actually know, but it turned out the number of people we reached was always more interesting. You don't actually have to get to know or interact with other people; you can shout into the void and know someone else heard you from a couple numbers, and maybe we collectively decided that's all we really wanted.
edit: I suppose I'm using "we" as "people" in this comment, also I didn't consider how old danneu might actually be; Maybe younger is 5 years ago.
Yes, but that don't stop you from reaching out and saying "hi".
I am (mainly) a front-end developper, and I occasionally send emails to the developper of product or websites that I love and simply offer to help them out. I don't work for free, but what I am doing isn't working. It's sharing knowledge.
I would email "Hi there! I love your product! I noticed that your X isn't working correctly... did you try Y solution? I had the same problem a while back." Sometime, this email is ignored. Sometime, a developper end up reading it. Sometime, it's some guy who is passionate about his product but has no idea what code even is.
Yes, the internet is turning into a mall. That doesn't stop you from becoming friend with the managers of the store next to yours.
https://medium.com/message/tilde-club-i-had-a-couple-drinks-...
You live in a filter bubble. Start clicking like on things that challenge instead of gratify you. Upvote things that are different.
Get off HackerNews and go hang out at a sceptics' message board. Or go hang out at an artist's community. They exist. They don't care about tech and startups as much.
The internet is still out there. It's still interesting. It's still fun. But the big data/community silos are afraid of offending you because most people really really don't want to be challenged.
It's up to you. You have to go find the challenge. Just like always. Step out of your comfort zone.
The internet isn't boring because the internet has changed. The internet is boring because you got older and don't enjoy a good flamewar anymore. Or just don't have the time and energy to consistently challenge yourself with new ideas and communities.
It happened to me too. And it sucks.
If you care to do some exploring, there's plenty of communities out in the boonies but you would never know if you never went searching.
They're still out there. They don't advertise, for obvious reasons.
This article highlighted the existence of Urbit to me (and probably many more)... and I shouldn't probably talk about your startup, since this thread is arguing exactly against it. Just to say: you're doing good work – and I might meet you some time in Urbit's chat :D
Something has definitely changed though, the internet communities of the past used to be very VERY tight-knit.
There just wasn't that many of us, so you'd talk to people unlike you. I knew my bbs friends all by their first and last names, had photos of them, would talk to the better ones on the phone, they were some of my best friends despite them usually being completely different from myself.
These days, I don't know a single person on the internet, and I rarely interact with people on the internet who are different from me, so I never get into the depth of conversation I once did. That's something lost.
The internet used to be like a dive-bar in an ivy-league college town, full of geniuses and weirdo townies. These days it's more like the city of New York -- no one knows you, and no one cares to.