thrwy10
IMHO, this is misleading. LCAs don't have a 1-1 corelation to 'Green Cards'. This data is based on the PERM process which is just 1 stage in the green card process. LCAs aren't green card applications, but a labour market test based on which green cards are applied for.
The science behind this 33yo race car driver forgetting 20 years of his life
DHS Extends Eligibility for Employment to Certain H-4 Dependent Spouses
Delhi govt considering cancellation of Uber’s permit to operate in Delhi
Does that mean being a citizen entitles one to a job regardless of qualification? Also, does that mean 100% of the US should be employed before bringing in foreign workers? I think such generalizations are far fetched. The conspiracy theory that claims that H1s are all low paid workers falls flat when examined closely.
Could you paste a link to those studies (unbiased or bipartisan) to support my wrongness. I've read opinions and emotional outbursts but am yet to find concrete evidence to support it. Until then I go by my own experience.
Yes, there are firms that get blanket visas. Yes, there are some people who deliberately abuse this sytem. But that is a generalization of few examples.Yes, giving visas to the employee rather than employer is better (Canadian, Australian systems is are an example). DOL's PERM process is what makes it more exploitative than not and is rampant with abuse. That needs to change, the H1 on its own is not indentured servitude.
I disagree with this statement. I am on an H1 and know several other people who are on H1s and can testify that this is a generalization. There are many ways to end up on an H1, overseas body shops is one avenue and American grad schools are another. Most H1s I know, myself included, graduated from good schools, have worked hard within the framework of their visas, have absorbed local culture and have invested almost 100% of what they made back into the local economy, not to mention the out-of-state fees they paid their institutions. From what I see and understand, they are pretty well paid, in some cases better than the local populace and have succeeded solely because they are talented. The hardships that their spouses on H4s go through is an entirely different matter!
That said, I can understand where you are coming from and know that there is abuse within the system. Truly, fake resumes are rampant among H1 consultancies. And although the visa itself is severely constrained, these people thrive due to lack of enforcement. That should change.
Edit: For people who say H1 is indentured servitude.
H1 is not quite indentured servitude, and you can switch employers. Although there is quite a bit of uncertainity associated with it, its still not the worst part. What bothers me, is the DOLs PERM process which is the first step to obtain a green card. This one step in itself is what can be said to make H1s bonded laborers. First, the company makes you sign a statment saying you can't leave until after 2 years upon getting your Green Card - else you'll be billed for it (approx 25K). Second, the DOL takes its own sweet time adjudicating these applications - currently 6 months (or 1.5-2 years if your application is audited, which 30-40% chance). And while you are free to switch employers, this process takes a hard reset and you've to go back to the end of the line. Unless, you stick with the shitty job, and wait out the approval and file your I-140. At this point, the H1 can be renewed indefinitely in terms of 3 years as long as each new company goes through the above process or you get your Green Card. Hopefully, the recent executive order will make this better, but only time can tell. Personally, the reset button has been hit twice for me.
HIV May Evolve to Cause AIDS Less Frequently, Researchers Find
White House fact sheet on Obama immigration plan
Destroy All Software Talks – “Wat” (2012)
Indian Govt.'s Biometric Attendance System
Ask HN: Phone interviews during work
Forgive me if this has been asked before.How do people deal with interviewing when actively working? Phone interviews take 45 mins to an hour and are not always worth taking an entire day off, besides the fact that there could be several. If your employer doesn't like you working from home and you have limited PTOs, what is your solution? Has anyone used Regus business lounges? What about...
The question is about before getting there, how do you even think about starting up and applying to YC while on an H1. How can you attract customers, when you can't legally do anything?
Again, this is for after, and there are other options, like being on a B1 or dependent visa while doing YC. You can own shares in that company and not derive income and at completion move out of the US.
But the question here is, how do you go about doing the ground work to even have a product that is competent enough to stand a chance?
To clarify, how do you do the ground work and launch / pre-launch while on an H1 so that your new startup can stand a chance among other applications to YC from people that are much futher along?
For After, you could move from an H1 to a B1, or apply for a H1 using the newly formed company with the money YC gives you. But what about before? Looks like no one has done this yet.
Also, please correct me if I'm wrong here, but despite assurances from YC folk and Sam himself that you can and should apply even if you have just an idea or prototype, blog after blog suggest you need to be much further than that to get through the tough competition.
Ask HN: Can you get into YC while on an H1B?
Most blogs that describe tips and best practices when applying to YC have one advice in common - "Get customers", "Prove that someone needs your product", "Get signups, email addresses" etc. And while that is a very valid and important point, for some of us though its harder than that. Even if one has a prototype, the companies they work for have strict policies...