News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Joining a Different YC by OopsCriticality on Monday August 03, 2015 @01:46PM (#9998188)
For biotech, I'm interested in understanding why YC would be a better choice than the SBIR/STTR route.
Re:Joining a Different YC by jrkelly on Monday August 03, 2015 @03:38PM (#9999205)
I'd recommend an SBIR/STTR (or other govt grants) first for wet-lab biotechs - it's a good source of patient money while you show early technical traction. YC after you've got things rolling can be throwing gas on a fire. It was for us (Ginkgo Bioworks, S14). Awesome founder community/ partner advice / investor connections.
Re:Joining a Different YC by bbgm on Monday August 03, 2015 @04:16PM (#9999449)
SBIRs have been super effective for many people. It takes time to show technical feasibility and building up real partnerships. SBIRs are well designed for that but also don't allow you to overspend.
Re:Joining a Different YC by OopsCriticality on Monday August 03, 2015 @05:43PM (#10000091)
That's an interesting thought, SBIR then YC. How would you recommend dealing with the SF relocation issue? I ask from the prospective of a biomedical startup not in CA.
Re:Joining a Different YC by jrkelly on Monday August 03, 2015 @09:38PM (#10001145)
We didn't relocate to SF. We are in Boston and kept the lab and the majority of the team there while we did YC. + lots of red-eyes.
Re:Joining a Different YC by tlb on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:15PM (#9998465)
They're not mutually exclusive -- some YC startups have gotten SBIR funding too. In addition to money, YC provides advice, community and connections useful for building a startup company.
Re:Joining a Different YC by sama on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:16PM (#9998474)
Money is among the least useful things YC gives. There are a lot of ways to get money; good advice and a strong community are very hard to find.
Re:Joining a Different YC by OopsCriticality on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:42PM (#9998739)
Sure, but I was thinking more along the lines of the SBIR/STTR-based incubator ecosystems at major research universities. They too have good advice and a strong community, and also have more domain experience, rentable high-end lab equipment, proper wet lab space, clean rooms, contract personnel, regulatory consultants, industrial hygiene assistance, etc. I don't understand (but would like to) what the value proposition of YC is over a good university incubator---superior general business advice? (I could easily see that!)

Apologies, my original post was incompletely expressed.

Re:Joining a Different YC by jacquesm on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:33PM (#9998646)
Advice on how to build a scaleable web company is not universally applicable on how to build biotech companies.
Re:Joining a Different YC by sama on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:42PM (#9998740)
Advice about how to create a good startup turns out to be more generalizable that I originally thought. The hardest problems--mostly around people--are more similar than they seem.
Re:Joining a Different YC by jacquesm on Monday August 03, 2015 @04:19PM (#9999477)
> The hardest problems--mostly around people--are more similar than they seem.

That's a good point and reflects my own experience. But I'd be hard pressed to generalize what I've learned in my career in IT/IT related start-ups and take that and apply it to say a company that creates a new medicine or one that tries to commercialize some new medical instrument. The sales avenues in that domain are radically different from 'just' IT based start-ups and just like I wouldn't see a bio-tech person run an IT firm the reverse probably holds true as well, ditto for advice to such management.

I recently had a long and in-depth look at an organization that sells a lot of physical goods on-line and even in that case there was so much domain knowledge wrt to the retail portion of it that without a CEO with significant knowledge in that particular field they wouldn't have stood a chance.

Anyway, you're doing pretty good so far, can't wait to see you prove me wrong :)

Re:Joining a Different YC by untilHellbanned on Monday August 03, 2015 @06:57PM (#10000461)
>The hardest problems--mostly around people--

Not quite. YC has been successful selling to people. Biotech isn't selling to people. The drug sells itself. It either works or it doesn't. Science doesn't care what we want.

Re:Joining a Different YC by eitally on Monday August 03, 2015 @03:18PM (#9999056)
The more I read HN, the more I am convinced that the dearth of leadership & management experience among founders is the biggest reason (besides bad ideas) so many young companies fail. Seriously, reading some of the questions & answers here gives one the impression that the value YC and other incubators provide -- besides networking -- is just in keeping founders from making stupid business & management decisions.
Re:Joining a Different YC by jacquesm on Monday August 03, 2015 @04:32PM (#9999565)
That alone might make it well worth the investment. If I knew back in '95 what I know today (as in lessons learned the hard way, not 'invest in apple')...

One thing I don't see happening in biotech is an end-run around the law such as AirBNB pulled off. That's going to get you into a lot of very hot water.

Re:Joining a Different YC by technotony on Monday August 03, 2015 @04:47PM (#9999667)
I'm not sure exactly what you mean by 'end-run' but there are massive opportunities in biotech for reading the letter of the law and understanding what you can do that other people don't realize.

For instance my company (Glowing Plant, YC S14) is entirely predicated on such an understanding. We read the rules and realized that if we engineered a plant with a gene gun instead of agrobacterium it would not be regulated in the United States. This saves us millions of dollars in getting a product to market and means we can pursue an agile product development strategy. Game changer.

I'm aware of another 4-5 such opportunities for syn bio products where you can get to market for low or zero regulatory permission.

Re:Joining a Different YC by OopsCriticality on Monday August 03, 2015 @05:32PM (#10000005)
With respect, there is a large gap between the letter of the law and the spirit of the law. Yours is a good example: using a gene gun may not be regulated in the US at present, but as was pointed out in a Nature piece covering the controversy around your company [0], that may not hold for the future [1]. My experiences with the FDA, and I have reason to believe they hold true at the USDA, lead me to conclude that regulators are fickle. What is the plan for when Monsanto, seeing your early success, copies your business plan and regulators respond to their terrified constituents in order to "fix the glitch"?

Trying to move fast and break things in a regulated industry strikes me as producing fragile business plans, at best.

[0] http://www.nature.com/news/glowing-plants-spark-debate-1.131...

[1] http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v475/n7356/full/475265b...

Re:Joining a Different YC by eitally on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @09:31AM (#10003240)
Thanks for the counterpoint, and I agree. Some areas of biotech are much less mature than others when ti comes to regulation.

Most of what people think about when they hear biotech still falls under typical FDA CFR regulations for either pharmaceuticals or durable medical devices. I think that's what the grandparent was talking about.

Re:Joining a Different YC by liseman on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:40PM (#9998721)
It's about optionality: startups of all types can now do more with less. SBIRs, access to college labs, in-house prototyping facilities: these can certainly help, but what's exciting is that they're no longer required to iterate on prototypes. So little funding and time is that it looks a lot like software.
Re:Joining a Different YC by OopsCriticality on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:53PM (#9998850)
So you're looking for a class of problems that you can better address than the existing system? Something for which SBIR/STTR takes too long to fund, needs more money/support than self bootstrapping, doesn't need exotic equipment, etc.
Re:Joining a Different YC by thearn4 on Monday August 03, 2015 @01:54PM (#9998282)
I am imagining that what they're going for will be biotech problems that can be addressed as software problems in disguise (since they would most certainly be in the right place and connected to the right people for that). Those connections may be worth more than the $2M or from SBIR (assuming they reached phase II), for companies that are fundamentally software shops.

Otherwise, I'm very curious what their strategy is for breaking into the bioscience and technology space in a broader sense, and if that would lead them to opening shop in other metro areas outside of the bay area.

Re:Joining a Different YC by thecosas on Monday August 03, 2015 @01:59PM (#9998335)
San Diego would be a nice place to have a base of operations for getting more involved in biotech.
Re:Joining a Different YC by w1ntermute on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:23PM (#9998541)
Let's be honest - the only place that really matters for biotech is Boston, and the movers and shakers there have no desire or need to work with YC or anyone in Silicon Valley. San Diego's biotech scene is mostly just companies mindlessly pursuing cheaper and faster sequencing.
Re:Joining a Different YC by jrkelly on Monday August 03, 2015 @09:44PM (#10001165)
I'll take a pro-Boston comment on hackernews however it comes!! It is true that BOS is basically unrivaled for pharma-biotech. Biotech is moving into other markets now too though. That said, we (Ginkgo Bioworks) are mostly non-pharma but are in BOS anyway. There is an awesome pool of bioengineering talent here.
Re:Joining a Different YC by jacquesm on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:34PM (#9998655)
I wouldn't call that 'mindlessly', faster sequencing is going to unlock a whole slew of new offerings just like 'faster transistors' powered the computer revolution.
Re:Joining a Different YC by w1ntermute on Monday August 03, 2015 @06:21PM (#10000312)
Re:Joining a Different YC by CPLX on Monday August 03, 2015 @05:13PM (#9999858)
> the only place that really matters for biotech is Boston

The Washington DC area I believe disproves your hypothesis.

Re:Joining a Different YC by w1ntermute on Monday August 03, 2015 @08:33PM (#10000912)
DC doesn't even come in the top 4 for biotech. The top 4 are probably Boston, SF, San Diego, and Seattle.
Re:Joining a Different YC by CPLX on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @11:17AM (#10003941)
The presence of NIH and the Federal Government apparatus alone (not to mention Johns Hopkins next door) should disprove your hypothesis.

As do facts and numbers:

http://www.fiercebiotech.com/story/top-15-cities-biotech-ven...

http://www.genengnews.com/insight-and-intelligenceand153/top...

Re:Joining a Different YC by owensmp on Monday August 03, 2015 @09:48PM (#10001182)
If we are naming cities NYC should be included. With 8 leading medical research institutions, the second highest annual NIH funding, and a wealth of talent/capital in adjacent industries - NYC's foundation for Biotech is extremely strong.
Re:Joining a Different YC by OopsCriticality on Monday August 03, 2015 @09:01PM (#10000998)
What about RTP?
Re:Joining a Different YC by OopsCriticality on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:09PM (#9998412)
Yes, I too could see YC bringing value to a software-intensive project. Perhaps I put too much weight on the "wetware" mention in the link, that makes me think "wet lab".

I would be fascinated to hear how they will handle the regulatory challenges, and how they bridge the cultural differences inherent to a group in a regulated industry vs. the more stereotypical software startups.

Re:Joining a Different YC by w1ntermute on Monday August 03, 2015 @01:50PM (#9998234)
They don't have the domain expertise, so it's comparatively easier to trick them with some startup buzzwords and a slick "vision".
Re:Joining a Different YC by jerf on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:23PM (#9998538)
This type of domain expertise may not be perfectly purchaseable, but it is purchaseable, and given the money involved, I'm sure they will. (And partially have already.)

Also, gaining the relevant knowledge to filter nonsense from sense here isn't necessarily as hard as you might think. And some of the filtering can be done with information theory, basic economics, probing deeper until you find the "and them some magic happens!" step, and some other non-biological tools that apply everywhere. I'm not saying it's easy, it's still months of work potentially, but it's only months. You don't actually need a PhD for nonsense filtering.

Re:Joining a Different YC by etrautmann on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:30PM (#9998604)
Two possibilities (among many others)

1) SBIR/STTRs are specific solicitations that serve the specific goals of funding agencies. If you don't see one that matches your tech exactly, it's a nonstarter.

2) Often times, the call for proposals are written with a specific company in mind that the funding agency already has some relationship with or interest in funding. Breaking into this can be challenging for a new company to learn the landscape.

Re:Joining a Different YC by OopsCriticality on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:35PM (#9998672)
NCI SBIR/STTR applications can be contract solicitations for specific problems, as you point out. The majority are (as I understand it) funded however through the omnibus solicitation, which can be directed to high-priority research areas or to general problems within the scope of the NCI. I assume the same is true for other NIH agencies.