News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by ruffrey on Sunday August 02, 2015 @02:27PM (#9991741)
Some fellow entrepreneurs had an awesome idea recently to create a jukebox-like service for businesses, where they could get payed per request and pay a monthly fee for the streaming service.

I coded up an MVP and we got a few customers that agreed it was something they would pay for, as long as they had a decent chance to make even a small profit on song requests.

Once it looked like a viable product idea, the financial numbers guy did his magic and researched more details about how royalties worked.

We got conflicting information from different lawyers and royalty aggregators. After a couple months of research we determined it was completely impossible to make a profit, until we hit maybe 5 million in revenue and could start to negotiate better rates with copyright holders.

This assumed extremely cheap tech and bandwidth, and almost no salaries for us three founders.

We killed the project because it became clear how sadly broken the music industry has become. They wanted about 50% of our revenue, no matter how we sliced the business model. We are totally miffed at how pandora or spotify survive.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by k-mcgrady on Sunday August 02, 2015 @02:42PM (#9991819)
>> "We killed the project because it became clear how sadly broken the music industry has become. They wanted about 50% of our revenue, no matter how we sliced the business model. We are totally miffed at how pandora or spotify survive."

Aren't Spotify running at a huge loss?

I don't see how this means the music industry is broken. They are trying to get as much money for the content they own as possible. If they don't think your service is worth much to them they probably don't want to bother licensing you the content. Seems like simple business strategy. The problem is with your business - you need to find a way to make money. If a business can't make enough money to afford the thing it can't survive without then you have a problem, you can't just blame the problem on someone else. I get where you're coming from (they make it too expensive) but they have no need to license you content. In fact it just fragments the market more making marketing more difficult for them. I think ideally they would want one store where everyone goes for everything.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by disantlor on Sunday August 02, 2015 @03:15PM (#9991989)
Startups and labels constantly jockeying for better position to maximize profits, etc etc and so on; the plight of the artist at the bottom of the food chain is generally brushed over, often with the supposed consolation that "it's never been easier to get your music into people's ears". That may be true in a technical sense but it's completely meaningless in reality. I've worked as a full time programmer to subsidize basically every detail of actually getting the music heard (recording, merch, subscriptions to soundcloud and bandcamp and tunecore, gas money for shows). Granted we're exactly striving for mainstream popularity but it's hard to even conceive of how we could possibly make enough money, split three ways, to sustain it without sacrificing most of the remaining hours to working to pay for food and rent; and none of us have children to worry about. Yet we press on, for nearly a decade, primarily because we love it of course but also people seem to think we're not half bad. I suppose all these discussions matter but I guess all I'm saying is if you really care and truly like a band (even a little) go to their website or bandcamp and buy a tshirt and a record. PLEASE. And just cut all this bullshit in the middle right out.
Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by morgante on Sunday August 02, 2015 @05:15PM (#9992502)
Maybe artists should accept the fact that the supply of music vastly outstrips the demand.

99% of consumers would be happy if there were only 10,000 employed musicians in the entire market.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by disantlor on Sunday August 02, 2015 @07:45PM (#9992991)
Of course my point is that as a musician it's annoying at best to hear people talk about musicians like a) as a cog in the broader free-market disruptive strategy blah blah and b) as though they should be grateful that there are all these cool whiz-bang ways to be heard.

Secondarily, I'm just reiterating how much more helpful it is to the musician to take the extra effort to buy from them directly. The penalty in ones convenience is greatly outweighed by the benefit to the indie/DIY artist.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by morgante on Sunday August 02, 2015 @07:52PM (#9993009)
First off, I don't think it's actually about some sort of disruption.

Being a musician has never been a very good career path.

Why should I buy music from you at a much higher price than paying Spotify $10/m? I have no ethical obligation to ensure that you can make a living off your music, especially considering that I'm pretty ambivalent about whether you make music at all.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by disantlor on Sunday August 02, 2015 @09:06PM (#9993191)
If you don't care all that much about music then there's no reason you should and that's fine. I too pay 10/mo for spotify. It's worth noting though that mostly likely the huge majority of that 10$ goes to music you aren't even listening to.
Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by ende on Sunday August 02, 2015 @11:43PM (#9993651)
Question: I buy vinyl directly from artists I like because I want to support them w/o the label getting a cut (and bc for me the physical vinyl has more meaning as a representation of their product. Curious to know if I am in fact helping them directly by doing so.
Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by enraged_camel on Sunday August 02, 2015 @08:13PM (#9993069)
>>as a musician it's annoying at best to hear people talk about musicians like a) as a cog in the broader free-market

The flip side of the coin is that it's pretty annoying to see every musician think of themselves as some sort of unique snowflake, when their music is 95% identical to everything else in the genre.

I know that writing, recording and marketing songs is difficult, but just because something is difficult doesn't mean it is worth a lot.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by disantlor on Sunday August 02, 2015 @09:10PM (#9993201)
I understand that but I don't think you realize how hard it is for even those who are widely accepted (not self proclaimed) unique snowflakes. Also I would hope you find it easier to feel compassion for the struggling artist over the corporation, in this scenario where two sides annoy you.
Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by williamcotton on Sunday August 02, 2015 @07:06PM (#9992859)
You're looking at this completely wrong.

Imagine you write a song. I take that song and I turn it in to a bunch of holes punched in a big long reel of paper. Now I put that reel in to a specially designed piano that will read the sequence of holes and use it to trigger notes. Now I sell that roll of punched holes. Do I need to give you any money?

Imagine you write a song. I take that song and I record it on to thin plastic disc. I sell these plastic discs. Do I need to give you any money?

Imagine you write a song. Someone else records it and I play that recording over a radio broadcast. I sell spots in the broadcast to advertisers and make a profit. Do I need to give you any money?

Imagine you write a song. Someone else records it and puts that song on a website I run. I sell spots on the website to advertisers and make a profit. Do I need to give you any money?

Imagine you write a song. Someone else records it and uploads it to their own website. They don't have ads. However, I have a website that indexes every other website on the Internet. I sell ads around the content that is returned in these search results, including your song. Do I need to give you any money?

This has nothing to do with supply and demand. It has everything to do with people like me making money off of things that people like you made and if that is or isn't how we expect a lawful and just society to work.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by morgante on Sunday August 02, 2015 @07:45PM (#9992988)
Who are people "like me" and people "like you?"

Your entire comment is completely nonsensical and frankly insulting. Being a musician was an unprofitable pursuit long before digitalization.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by williamcotton on Sunday August 02, 2015 @08:00PM (#9993033)
In case it isn't clear, "people like me" and "people like you" refer to the hypothetical characters in the above paragraphs.

I made you the "songwriter character" in order to try and get you to empathize with their position.

As for the examples, the first three scenarios are based on the actual history of intellectual property as it pertains to music in the United States.

The invention of player pianos led to the foundation of what is known as "mechanical royalties" in the music industry. That is, you can't say that you're just selling a roll of paper with holes in it and that you have the rights to all the profits, rather you have to license that song from the rights-holders.

While my rhetorical approach might not have been the best choice, the points I'm making are not at all nonsensical and were not intended to be insulting.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by dang on Sunday August 02, 2015 @11:07PM (#9993516)
> Your entire comment is completely nonsensical and frankly insulting.

This comment breaks the HN guidelines, which say:

When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names. E.g. "That is idiotic; 1 + 1 is 2, not 3" can be shortened to "1 + 1 is 2, not 3."

Similarly, this comment could be shortened (and considerably improved) by deleting the above sentence.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by morgante on Sunday August 02, 2015 @11:29PM (#9993599)
I should have redacted the "nonsensical" part, but I did find the comment very insulting. It was quite insulting to say that my work is unfairly yielding some other group profit, thereby implying that I'm some naive dunce. (To be clear, this is the line I object to: "people like me making money off of things that people like you made.")
Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by dang on Monday August 03, 2015 @01:07AM (#9993927)
I hear you, but that's a really specific interpretation. It's easier and less annoying just to look for a different possible meaning in the OP. Most of the time no insult was intended, and even if one was, it's rarely really about you.

(This is not a criticism. I'm just reflecting.)

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday August 02, 2015 @07:46PM (#9992994)
There's no way the industry would be willing to employ 10,000 musicians full-time. Even on a near-poverty wage of $30k that would be $300m a year just for wages, without counting equipment, recording, and other costs.

It's not just about the artists. There's a huge support industry of recording engineers, studio owners, mix engineers, producers, tour managers, festivals, session musicians, electronic designers, software developers, web developers, app developers, and old-style physical instrument makers - among others.

Global music revenue alone is around $15bn. When you include all the support services, that number gets a lot bigger.

So supply/demand is not a very insightful way to look at this. With more investment in better content at every level, there's huge potential for revenue growth.

Nickel and diming the artists kills that for a short term hit of profit that isn't sustainable.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by morgante on Sunday August 02, 2015 @07:50PM (#9993006)
> With more investment in better content at every level, there's huge potential for revenue growth.

How so? Fundamentally: why do you think we need more music or more professional musicians?

10,000 was chosen as an arbitrary number. I actually suspect the demand for professional musicians is far lower than that.

The fundamental fact is that there are way more people who want to be a musician than people who are willing to pay for random music from indie artists.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by aikah on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:28AM (#9994129)
> Maybe artists should accept the fact that the supply of music vastly outstrips the demand.

This isn't a supply and demand problem. If you could steal at the supermarket and know you'd never get caught or there would be 0 consequences you'd do that. The supply would still be limited.

Piracy is the problem, period. If everybody pirates your awesome and unique commercial software will you still be talking about supply and demand even if your software is the unique on the market? Oh sorry, there are millions of software out there ... supply and demand. Too much supply therefore I should not buy your software but pirate it... /s

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by ruffrey on Sunday August 02, 2015 @03:43PM (#9992105)
You're totally right though I should clarify what I meant by broken. There are so many hands in the cookie jar and so much bureaucracy with payouts that it takes millions of investment to get this business off the ground. And it wouldn't be profitable. It's a technically simple concept and we had this (albeit false) feeling that "this should be easy to do." I mean think about it, a DJ charging people for song requests would essentially run into the same problems that we did. We were just adding one layer to the business model and enough to try to cover operating expenses.

There are jukeboxes that do make the business model work, but they are hardware that cost 10s of thousands of up front investment for the bar or coffee house. We found, in market research, that 100% of the surveyed businesses would use this kind of service, but they wouldn't pay more than $25 - $100 per month for it, absolute max.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by cwyers on Monday August 03, 2015 @01:41AM (#9994031)
The music industry is broken because they wouldn't give you a license to use their product at a price you wanted? And you shut the whole product down because you couldn't get the licensing, so clearly you have no product without those music rights. How is your idea adding so much value to these music catalogs that 50% of revenue isn't a good deal for you?
Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by frankdenbow on Monday August 03, 2015 @01:05AM (#9993923)
Pandora has a statutory radio license that requires no negotiation, which is why you have restrictions on what you can play. The cost is less to them which is why they have survived.
Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by S_A_P on Sunday August 02, 2015 @09:00PM (#9993177)
So the problem as I see it is the layers of complexity of record deals. In my limited experience with the music biz(released a record on itunes, a few side soundtrack projects, and 3 friends with major label deals) there isnt much chance of making money from the record deal itself until you have accomplished the following: 1) > 2 profitable and high selling records 2) a solid fan base 3) luck

One of my friends was signed to Barsuk records, and released 2 albums with them. He made about 25k per year including touring. He released 2 more albums independently and licensed a song for a microsoft zune commercial. He was telling me about some of the details of his record deal, and it obviously wasn't a super good deal for him, but he was just taking whatever he could to get on. He maintained a near constant touring schedule which broke up his marriage, and it generally just made his life really hard. This guy still struggles, I havent spoken to him in about a year or so but he may have given up.

Another was signed to hollywood records, got major label promotion as a VH1 artist to watch with heavy rotation. His first album didnt sell very well and he got dropped. He is still a semi full time musician in Austin right now.

I recently stayed at an up and coming country musicians apartment(she is a friend of a friend), she sold 1 million copies of her self penned single. While she is doing way better than I was at that age, she lives very modestly.( I dont know all the specifics of her deal, and she is young and wants to live simply so she could have a million bucks in the bank but I doubt it)

Anyway, I mention this because from what I know of their deals, the record companies still treat them largely like they still spend big bucks at a big studio, and manufacture vinyl, CDs and cassettes for the bulk of the revenue. The music biz is making a killing on streaming because manufacturing is so low these days, and anyone can have a laptop studio capable of professional recording for 5-10k. The situation for artists wont change until record companies are not their main outlet.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by rectang on Sunday August 02, 2015 @06:26PM (#9992730)
What I would really like to see is a non-profit alternative to Tunecore/CDBaby/DistroKid, submitting music for digital distribution and disbursing streaming royalties.

Tunecore has a nice model and they were great for a while, then they jacked prices and forced out their founder. Distrokid seems good right now, but what's stopping them from pulling a Tunecore in the future?

The only way to guarantee transparency and stability permanently is for the musicians themselves to control the distributor -- similar to how individual Members of the Apache Software Foundation control it.

Speaking as a former mastering engineer and graphic designer, whatever QC DistroKid and Tunecore are doing can't be too hard to reproduce. I've often thought of writing some open source software for this purpose.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by Zigurd on Sunday August 02, 2015 @08:30PM (#9993102)
Those services as investor owned enterprises are not the problem, and and a coop is not the solution.

Don't assume there is any way to make selling, or streaming, recorded music pay for more than a few highly promoted musicians, and don't assume that the business of promoting those musicians can stay clean. Compared to performing and teaching music, selling a recorded performance is a relative novelty, and the business of it was always an irrational hits business and always more or less dirty.

Recorded music disrupted performance, and vastly reduced the demand for music performers. Figure out how to reverse-disrupt that and you will do more to put more money in the pockets of more musicians than a novel way of selling recorded performances.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by aikah on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:10AM (#9994089)
> Recorded music disrupted performance, and vastly reduced the demand for music performers.

This is totally untrue, on the contrary, recorded music has always been a way to promote music performances. It never disrupted performance. How can anyone say that? Before pop music and the record industry, there were no big concerts with thousands of people attending them. Recorded music boosted the demand for music performances.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by rectang on Sunday August 02, 2015 @08:48PM (#9993159)
Investor-owned distribution would be a substantial incremental improvement over today, and it answers David Byrne's challenge to improve transparency. So what if it can't compete with vaporware?
Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by aikah on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:01AM (#9994075)
> The only way to guarantee transparency and stability permanently is for the musicians themselves to control the distributor -- similar to how individual Members of the Apache Software Foundation control it.

Musicians are just musicians. You can't expect them to be developpers, sysadmin, sellsmen, accountants all at the same time while selling their music for pennies in a world fully of youtubes and co and where the audience don't want to pay for music anymore. Being Musician is a tough job at first place.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by CamperBob2 on Sunday August 02, 2015 @06:15PM (#9992689)
Question for David Byrne (rhetorical, of course, since he's unlikely to read HN):

   I asked Apple Music to explain the calculation of 
   royalties for the trial period. They said they disclosed 
   that only to copyright owners (that is, the labels). I 
   have my own label and own the copyright on some of my 
   albums, but when I turned to my distributor, the 
   response was, “You can’t see the deal, but you could 
   have your lawyer call our lawyer and we might answer 
   some questions.”
At some point, you signed a contract with that distributor. (Why you need a "distributor" at all is an obvious question, but never mind that for now.) Why did you accept terms like these?
Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by rectang on Sunday August 02, 2015 @06:35PM (#9992757)
David Byrne is associated with Tunecore, so I'm guessing that's the distributor in question. The alternatives to Tunecore (CDBaby, Reverb Nation, Distrokid) all have their own problems. Most indie musicians, perhaps including even David Byrne, are not in a position to negotiate terms.
Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by williamcotton on Sunday August 02, 2015 @06:30PM (#9992745)
From what I can gather a lot of deals are being done without the consent of the artists.

I wouldn't be surprised if we see a series of class-action lawsuits in the near future, probably starting with songwriters.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by davidgerard on Sunday August 02, 2015 @06:15PM (#9992687)
Contrariwise, Steve Albini - who's been at the sharp end of this stuff as well, but without the "I used to be a rock star" bit - considers this the golden age, and that the Internet has solved The Problem With Music: http://www.theguardian.com/music/2014/nov/17/steve-albinis-k...
Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by williamcotton on Sunday August 02, 2015 @07:45PM (#9992989)
From my part, I believe the very concept of exclusive intellectual property with respect to recorded music has come to a natural end, or something like an end. Technology has brought to a head a need to embrace the meaning of the word “release”, as in bird or fart. It is no longer possible to maintain control over digitised material and I don’t believe the public good is served by trying to.

It is with this paragraph the Steve's ignorance to the societal and legal foundations around intellectual property and exclusive copyright are brought to full attention.

It technically became "no longer possible to maintain control" over intellectual property hundreds of years ago with the invention of the printing press.

The idea that the decreasing marginal cost of making copies is somehow a new concept and unique to the digital world is completely absurd.

The fact that the copyright system has been abused by corporate interests doesn't mean we should blindly throw out one of the cornerstones of the Western world.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by alexvoda on Monday August 03, 2015 @07:20AM (#9994978)
Actually you are incorrect in multiple ways.

First of all, Steve's article refers strictly to music. I would argue maintaining control was no longer possible since the invention of magnetic tape. If you really want to stretch things, you can go as far back as grooved disks (LPs, Vinyls, gramophone records) and claim it was possible to copy them like so: http://www.theguardian.com/music/2015/jan/29/bone-music-sovi... This is at least some hundred of years after the invention of the printing press. As for music scores, see the next paragraph.

Secondly, it was never possible to control information represented as glyphs (text, music scores, etc.). People could easily copy such information as long as they knew how to write and had some sort of writing utensil. In fact a person doesn't even need to know how to read in order to copy written or printed information. The more control is exerted the more determined people will be to copy.

Thirdly, it was very much possible to control what was printed with a printing press by using the might of an authoritarian regime. Printing presses were not things you could easily hide. Sooner or later the source of unwanted printed content could be tracked down. Besides, the very first copyright like laws were made exactly to avoid such an adversarial situation. The British government offered the publishers the power to control distribution (protected by the government) as long as the government gained control over what was being printed.

Also, I don't quite get what you mean by your last sentence.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by williamcotton on Monday August 03, 2015 @08:25AM (#9995220)
Calling a government that enforces a limited monopoly on intellectual property an "authoritarian regime" is quite a stretch. Copyright is a foundation of liberal democracies all over the world.

Again, I hold heartedly agree that "it was never possible to control information represented as glyphs". So did the people who dreamed up copyright. That's the whole point!

What happened was many hundreds of years ago someone wrote something, and then someone else came along with a printing press and made 1000 copies and sold them for a profit, but they didn't give any money to the guy that wrote it. Someone pointed out that this didn't seem fair or just, and after a bunch of arguments and legislation, copyright was born.

The very same arguments about limiting people's freedoms with what they can or can't do with their own printing press have been going on for hundreds of years. It's really boring to keep having to prove the same points.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by l33tbro on Sunday August 02, 2015 @11:29PM (#9993598)
I was signed to a major label at one point and would do so again in a heartbeat.

What you're getting in exchange for surrendering publishing and the masters is the huge network majors are tapped into. Syncs, marketing spend, publicity, festival circuits, key relationships with tastemakers, etc - I found the music industry incredibly nepotistic and benefitted over equally or more talented unsigned artists. There's a Hollywood Accouting hustle to what the majors say they are spending on you, but I believe you're building a better fanbase with a major, which generally means a greater touring revenue.

Another point missed: it's hard to speak globally about "musicians". Artists have very different outcomes and objectives, so it's very easy to project a mainstream mentality on to the indie, as so with the converse.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by Qantourisc on Sunday August 02, 2015 @05:48PM (#9992620)
In the old days you REALLY needed the record companies. But with digital distribution for sales. And the possibility to accurately log each play of a song on streaming services, and compensate the artists for that. Why are they still used ?

The biggest problems will occur from artists want a$ per play, but the streaming services only has b$/(month*plays).

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by davidgerard on Sunday August 02, 2015 @06:16PM (#9992694)
1. Streaming is comparable to radio plays, not record sales. Radio plays got royalties, but they were tiny as well.

2. Spotify has more tracks than subscribers. Essentially, it's the vast oversupply of artists in the modern age.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by Jgrubb on Sunday August 02, 2015 @08:37PM (#9993129)
Re: #1 - Radio play generates mechanical royalties for the publisher (usually the songwriter). They vary I think based on when the song was published, but they're currently at $.091 per play - https://www.harryfox.com/license_music/what_mechanical_royal.... This is probably 3, maybe 4 orders of magnitude more than what online streaming rates are currently.
Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by davidgerard on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:39AM (#9994148)
That's not per-listener, though, which would be the relevant number for comparison.
Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by bjterry on Sunday August 02, 2015 @10:13PM (#9993337)
That makes sense, as a radio play is probably heard by 3 or 4 orders of magnitude more people.
Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by amelius on Sunday August 02, 2015 @05:40PM (#9992589)
> Perhaps the biggest problem artists face today is that lack of transparency. I’ve asked basic questions of both the digital services and the music labels and been stonewalled. For example, I asked YouTube how ad revenue from videos that contain music is shared (which should be an incredibly basic question). They responded that they didn’t share exact numbers, but said that YouTube’s cut was “less than half.”

Transparency is the problem not only with music labels. It is also a problem with services like Uber, and with the App Store. The sad thing is: people think they can make a decent amount of money on these services, but that might just turn out to be an expensive mistake on average (there will always be outliers, and those cases will hit the news, but they are not the norm).

I think the government should step in and demand complete disclosure on these services.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by hackuser on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:06AM (#9994082)
> Musicians are entrepreneurs. We are essentially partners with the labels, and should be treated that way.

There's no reason that Byrne and other musicians shouldn't earn as much as they can, but let's try to remember that musicians are artists. I seem to remember many of those disliking record labels for imposing onto their art the desires of commerce.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by aikah on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:17AM (#9994102)
> but let's try to remember that musicians are artists.

Well according to HN musicians should be artist, developer,sys-admin, graphic designer,sells-man, accountant,lawyer all at the same time because "evil labels". And if they can't do all these things well they shouldn't be paid fairly for their art because they didn't try hard enough ...

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by sparkzilla on Sunday August 02, 2015 @03:48PM (#9992128)
Hmm. I can see the problem right there. Google takes 50% for distribution. If that figure was less then artists would get more.
Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by nugga on Sunday August 02, 2015 @05:42PM (#9992594)
The labels take most of the money because artists have agreed to very one-sided contracts. Then the artists proceed to complain how spotify is screwing them when in fact they screwed themselves signing on major labels.

MAFIAA et al do suck but you should read what you sign.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by bnj on Sunday August 02, 2015 @06:51PM (#9992813)
Is it preferable to accept a tiny slice of a large pie, or decide pre-emptively not to put the pie in the oven?

I've been baffled by the contracts that artists sign with major labels, but you have to remember that artists are confronted with a difficult choice. If they don't accept these ridiculous deals, how do they achieve the mainstream recognition required to be able to live off their craft?

Society should provide basic resources to people so that they can work less and pursue music as a serious hobby without cutting into their food supply.

Re:Open the Music Industry’s Black Box by weems on Sunday August 02, 2015 @07:29PM (#9992926)
great article. we need some disruption