Re:Jamestown excavation unearths four bodies and a mystery i...
by kelvin0 on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @03:44PM
(#9971114)
"Grave “A” contained the skeleton of the Rev. Robert Hunt, who was about 39 and was the first Anglican minister in the country, experts concluded from records and studies of the remains."
How did they find out who was buried in which grave?
Re:Jamestown excavation unearths four bodies and a mystery i...
by philwelch on Thursday July 30, 2015 @08:01PM
(#9979094)
From historical records, they can gather the sex and approximate age of the people who would have been buried, and sometimes other physical details. This is information that can be cross-referenced against inspection of the remains. If they know that Robert Hunt was a 39 year old male, and there's four skeletons, they just have to find the skeleton that's probably a 39 year old male and that's Robert Hunt.
Re:Jamestown excavation unearths four bodies and a mystery i...
by sandworm101 on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @02:46PM
(#9970742)
Why not open it? Archaeologists examine grave goods and open tombs all the time. Is there something special about this one? Is its curse somehow more powerful than all the others?
I really wonder about the ethics of opening up graves. What is the rule that separates a cemetery from an archaeological site?
Re:Jamestown excavation unearths four bodies and a mystery i...
by ickwabe on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @03:01PM
(#9970824)
The archeologist in this NPR story (http://www.npr.org/2015/07/28/425700788/bones-in-church-ruin...) reported that the box was too fragile to open. Likely opening the box would destroy all or part of it or its contents. Using MRI (or other scanning methods) as opposed to opening/disassembling is fairly common now in archeology when dealing with fragile objects.
But I agree with your skepticism regarding graves vs sites. I seriously doubt the folks who were buried or did the burying expected or wanted the remains exhumed for any purpose whatsoever.
Re:Jamestown excavation unearths four bodies and a mystery i...
by Retra on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @06:24PM
(#9971982)
The benefit of satisfying curiosity greatly outweighs the benefit of considering the feelings of the long dead. Namely, leaving things buried in the ground forever offers no benefit at all.
Re:Jamestown excavation unearths four bodies and a mystery i...
by nivla on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @07:48PM
(#9972440)
>The benefit of satisfying curiosity
And if left unchecked it leads to things like this [1], where a graduate student cut down a tree to count its age only to realize it was the oldest living tree in existence.
Re:Jamestown excavation unearths four bodies and a mystery i...
by nivla on Thursday July 30, 2015 @04:14AM
(#9973692)
Just because I am not making a direct comparison to your exact wording, doesn't make my comment any less relevant.
Your basis of argument that if the benefit of satisfying curiosity greatly outweighs the benefit of X, it should be undertaken is absolutely wrong. To cite along the same track so you call out on relevancy again: Digging out historical graveyards and examining the bodies has its merit especially to increase our knowledge about the time period, however in reality going around digging into sacred places is also considered a douche bag move. Thus as said in the first comment, curiosity is something that should be kept under check.
Re:Jamestown excavation unearths four bodies and a mystery i...
by whoopdedo on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @02:37PM
(#9970675)
I don't know if it's the same graves, but the book The Cradle of the Republic[1] from 1906 mentions an excavation that found
> several graves and tombstones, as well as mortuary tablets,
> were discovered in the old foundations. In the chancel, lying
> with its head to the north, was an iron tablet, probably
> formerly a cenotaph, once embossed with inlaid brasses,
> now missing.
'Studies and scans showed that the box was made of non-English silver, and originated in continental Europe many decades before it reached Jamestown.
Horn said he believed it was a sacred, public reliquary, as opposed to a private item, because it contained so many pieces of bone.'
'There are no plans to open it.'
I really wonder about the ethics of opening up graves. What is the rule that separates a cemetery from an archaeological site?
But I agree with your skepticism regarding graves vs sites. I seriously doubt the folks who were buried or did the burying expected or wanted the remains exhumed for any purpose whatsoever.
Native Americans clearly considered this kind of thing grave robbing (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Native_American_Graves_Protect...). I can't see a substantial difference here.
I'm not sure where the line is. It seems like there should be a substantial benefit beyond just satisfying curiosity.
And if left unchecked it leads to things like this [1], where a graduate student cut down a tree to count its age only to realize it was the oldest living tree in existence.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prometheus_(tree)
Your basis of argument that if the benefit of satisfying curiosity greatly outweighs the benefit of X, it should be undertaken is absolutely wrong. To cite along the same track so you call out on relevancy again: Digging out historical graveyards and examining the bodies has its merit especially to increase our knowledge about the time period, however in reality going around digging into sacred places is also considered a douche bag move. Thus as said in the first comment, curiosity is something that should be kept under check.
2) Test to see if they are his mother's bones.
They walk on eggshells when it comes to Judaism or Christianity. They are still treated as far more holy than any other religion.
> several graves and tombstones, as well as mortuary tablets, > were discovered in the old foundations. In the chancel, lying > with its head to the north, was an iron tablet, probably > formerly a cenotaph, once embossed with inlaid brasses, > now missing.
[1] https://books.google.com/books?id=4R4SAAAAYAAJ&pg=PA126#v=on...