Re:Jamestown excavation unearths four bodies and a mystery i...
by Retra on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @06:24PM
(#9971982)
The benefit of satisfying curiosity greatly outweighs the benefit of considering the feelings of the long dead. Namely, leaving things buried in the ground forever offers no benefit at all.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Jamestown excavation unearths four bodies and a mystery i...
by ickwabe on Thursday July 30, 2015 @08:50AM
(#9974520)
It does? Depends on what weight you give to the opinion of the folks buried. I doubt they would agree that curiosity by itself is sufficient benefit.
Re:Jamestown excavation unearths four bodies and a mystery i...
by nivla on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @07:48PM
(#9972440)
>The benefit of satisfying curiosity
And if left unchecked it leads to things like this [1], where a graduate student cut down a tree to count its age only to realize it was the oldest living tree in existence.
Re:Jamestown excavation unearths four bodies and a mystery i...
by Retra on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @08:32PM
(#9972597)
I really don't see how digging up graves is comparable to killing things.
Re:Jamestown excavation unearths four bodies and a mystery i...
by nivla on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @09:55PM
(#9972822)
I never compared the two. Hence quoting only the part that is relevant.
Re:Jamestown excavation unearths four bodies and a mystery i...
by Retra on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @10:50PM
(#9972961)
If you're not making a comparison, then I don't see the relevance either.
Re:Jamestown excavation unearths four bodies and a mystery i...
by nivla on Thursday July 30, 2015 @04:14AM
(#9973692)
Just because I am not making a direct comparison to your exact wording, doesn't make my comment any less relevant.
Your basis of argument that if the benefit of satisfying curiosity greatly outweighs the benefit of X, it should be undertaken is absolutely wrong. To cite along the same track so you call out on relevancy again: Digging out historical graveyards and examining the bodies has its merit especially to increase our knowledge about the time period, however in reality going around digging into sacred places is also considered a douche bag move. Thus as said in the first comment, curiosity is something that should be kept under check.