- Brian Eno
This is my favorite quote to bring out when people are discussing the merits (or demerits) of pixel art. It's really spot on.
The best real-world example I know is the resurgence of cassette tapes. Whenever I go to see a not-very-popular (indie, for want of a better term) band, the merch stand, without fail, has cassettes and vinyls and sometimes no CDs or optional Internet downloads. Is there a practical reason? No, not really, it's all marketing. Making tapes and vinyls is hard, burning CDs is easy, but people want the nostalgia of the more interactive process of flipping tapes and vinyls.
I guess they could be moving to those mediums for the "grit" of the sound produced. But that sound can easily and effectively be reproduced with an equalizer, sound filters and effects.
Yes - I am an out of touch old fogey.
This is why it is dark in a night club. People look better.
It's not a limitation of the medium, but a function of how we construct images from visual inputs.
Pixel art (and other art as well) is often stylized, which means it's trying to present a more appealing version of reality. The viewing angles are carefully chosen, the colors and lights are more vibrant, the shapes of everyday objects are more varied and graceful, the people are better looking, etc. The end result is that you're looking at a rough description of something that you want but don't have.
You could achieve the same effect with a high resolution image, but then you need to make all the little details beautiful as well, which takes much more work. There are certainly high resolution paintings that manage to be as haunting and evocative as the best pixel art, for example Shan Qiao's "Story of the city" (https://www.artstation.com/artwork/story-of-the-city), Nivanh Chantara's "Babiru 02" (https://www.artstation.com/artwork/babiru-02), or pretty much anything on http://reddit.com/r/backgroundart.
The first animated GIF from the article is based off of this higher resolution image:
http://kusakabeworks.net/gallery/the-house-with-signs-of-mar...
...so it would be interesting to see which people find more appealing.
[1] http://designmadeinjapan.com/site/wp-content/uploads/2015/07...
Also reminds me of some of the points made in Understanding Comics[0]
"...Another is the universality of cartoon imagery. The more cartoony a face is, for instance, the more people it could be said to describe."[1]
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Understanding_Comics [1] http://www.proprofs.com/quiz-school/user_upload/ckeditor/und...
http://www.animationsensations.com/media/catalog/product/cac...
That doesn't look too detailed, but imagine drawing four of those every day for a year without weekends. 365 x 4 is about equal to 24 x 60. Congratulations, you've created a minute of footage. To make a feature film, you'll spend a life.
I guess Disney-style animated characters occupy a kind of sweet spot. They are carefully stylized to look good enough that adding more detail won't really make them much better, and simple enough that a large team of animators with top-down planning can make a complete movie in a few years. Japanese anime has slightly more detailed characters, at the cost of having fewer frames per second. If you want a lot more detail with good enough framerate, you need more money than your audience is willing to pay.
It's easier to draw a cartoon then to paint the mona lisa. I respect detail and high resolution artistry more than sketching cartoons due to the higher amount of skill required to pull it off. One screw up in a super high detailed painting and you could end up in the uncanny valley.
Either way, lots of respect for both forms of art.