I have to note that it's only true about late Soviet Union (1955 onwards?), because earlier Soviet Union was explosively unsafe country where you could be shot "for being a spy to Japan", relocated to uninhabited island in Siberia during Winter to freeze there, or just starve in one of famines.
And then there were external threats (causing paranoia) and massive mismanagement because they ran their economy according to utopian phantasies, similar to what the Chinese did. (which also resulted in tens of millions starving to death)
Only after the second world war the continent was sufficiently stabilized for a few decades and that's when the masses lived a decent life compared to what they had before.
And yes that is as Orwellian as it sounds
Garage sales and lending your buddy five bucks are also part of that "informal" economy. Without cash, the government would be dipping its beak into those transactions as well.
I don't think it will actually work. Were the US to get rid of cash tax cheats and drug dealers would simply switch to GBPs, euros, or yen. Or drugs.
The only people who will be absolutely locked into the system are cubicle dwellers, but that's already pretty much the case.
Some guy who want some help with his yard-work one Saturday, probably is just going to skip hiring a day laborer if he has to register with the state as an employer and fill out all the local, state and federal income tax and employment tax forms for a days work. Even if the amount of money to pay that tax is trivial.
I think the informal economy exists to avoid both taxes and paperwork. And for some things the cost of the paperwork is significantly higher than the cost of the taxes.
http://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/double-irish-with-a-dutc...
To the extent that funds from the above-board economy transfer to the informal economy, the taxes are simply paid by the last person in the chain who paid taxes.
*they're narrowing now, but it is anyone's guess as to whether the big jump from the 2008 time frame is permanent or not.
Unless, of course, they lived in the same country as some people who didn't stay clear.
also, to date i have not been unable to spend cash anywhere or with anyone, that i can remember. this includes traveling to asia and europe and south america. in fact the global trend is that most people still prefer to be paid in cash. i know i sure do. when people ask me if i take venmo or paypal i just roll my eyes.
it almost seems the more electronic methods pop up, the scarcer cash gets, the more cash is in demand.
hmmm. didn't they teach us something about that in econ 1a...
I'm against the government having too much power and regulating every detail of life.
Cash is desired by some businesses because of lower transactional costs, though, not due to scarcity. It's a superior good (along some axes and for some people) and is valued as such.
It's mostly rich people and corporations that are not paying taxes through legal holes, off shore accounts, special tax breaks from their pals in the gov etc, and they'll continue to do so, cash or not. Heck, they already do it with virtual money.
And seeing as 10% of the population (or less) holds 80% of the money, it's those few that the big losses result from.
>Gang criminality can be fought of more easily simply because it will harder for them to earn money illegally.
There are lots of ways they can launder their virtual money. Mafia has tons of reputable establishments for example. A guy gets his drugs and in return has to buy X or Y overpriced good with a credit card.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interest_rate#Negative_interes...
Of course once the data is all aggregated within the databases of the two or three credit card providers in the country, it's easy for the state to dip his fingers in.
You don't need to incorporate to be self-employed. The costs are essentially zero.
I'm giving you here an example of Austria (EU): If you want to earn more than around 5000 dollars a year, you HAVE to incorporate. The cheapest setup will still cost you a few hundred dollars per year, but from start to incorporation it will take you at least 2-3 weeks.
Many will need the services of a tax consultant to deal with the taxes, which also involves some costs. (If you are employed the company has to deal with the taxes for you)
Then there are also liability issues depending on how you incorporated. Something similar to a LLC costs more to incorporate, but with the cheaper ones you are liable with your private property. (if you get sued by a customer they could take your house)
Another issue is that you don't receive social services like unemployment benefits if it didn't work out for you. And then you also pay more for health services than normal employees.
These are a lot of issues for someone just trying to make a few bucks because he/she has for some reason or another financial problems.
It's not some insurmountable problem for entrepreneurs that have a reasonable plan and some money saved up, but we are talking about people that are trying to get through a tough year. In such a situation the additional risks when you are already at the bottom are for many not acceptable.
In my country to be self-employed you have to register and pay "freelancer" insurance cost to the state that add up to something equivalent to $800 per month (nominally $300-$400 in our economy).
People incorporate for a reason, though. If you don't your personal assets aren't protected if the business gets sued or becomes insolvent.
There's a reason Donald Trump still has lots of money after having his businesses go bankrupt four times.
Trump is/was doing multimillion dollar real estate development with outside investor's money, and observing lots of corporate formalities. That's why his businesses could go bankrupt without wiping him out.
If I represent a creditor, I'm not going to care if your chickenshit small business is incorporated or not, particularly if it's just a professional services business like a consultant. I'll just sue you AND your corporation. Besides, most creditors that loan to small businesses demand personal guarantees from the owners.
Just having a corporation won't make you Donald Trump. But it might earn your tax preparer some fees.
You can sue anybody you want. The question is always whether or not you can prevail. If you're just a creditor you would almost certainly be unable to get a judgement against the individual unless he did something stupid like spend corporate money on personal items.
On the one hand the state would know about every transaction made, on the other hand the state would hold immense power over its citizens by being able to flip a switch and shut certain persons out of this system. (by freezing their accounts)
And then there's another aspect: In a cashless society only the ones that have jobs or can afford to incorporate a business could earn money. All the others would have to barter with smuggled cigarettes or vodka and even then they'd be unable to pay their electricity bill with whatever they've earned this way.
In tough economic times there are many people that cannot get a regular job nor can afford to incorporate a business, and working illegally on construction sites or something like that has traditionally been a way for them and their families to survive and work themselves out of the gutter.
If you take that away from them, they'll have to fully submit to the social system and I honestly doubt that this is a better way.
Our western societies are slowly turning in a modern version of the Soviet Union, where the state has even more control over its population and its thoughts than the Soviet Union ever had.
At least the Soviet Union had the decency to grant the masses that stayed clear of politics a safe life without a care in the world.
Here in the West they are not even willing to give us that for giving our governments absolute control. The masses at the bottom have to struggle for mere survival.