Re:The Death of Cash
by jbuzbee on Saturday July 25, 2015 @12:41PM
(#9948115)
Cash is pretty much dead for me and has been for years. My wife and I use a credit card for every purchase we can, big or small. And we've never carried a balance, paying it off in full each month. I'm continually astounded at the offers that arrive in the mail such as "Spend $3000 in the first three months and get $500 in gift cards" (to places we go anyway). It's free money to us, paid for I assume by the high rates and carried-balances that others have.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
> paid for I assume by the high rates and carried-balances that others have.
And the merchant fees the retailers pay, to receive the money at the point of sale. Credit card companies make their money at both ends :)
Yeah, that "free money" is priced in to the cost of goods/services at firms that accept the cards. This is why you sometimes see a lower cash price, like at smaller gas stations etc.
Now think how an average Greek person feels when their banking system no longer works, denied access to electronic transactions and when bank accounts hold mere numbers that may or may not be actually recognized (or downright confiscated).
It's hard to imagine how the Greek banking system is going to recover from this. Everyone loaned them all of their money, and they weren't even getting any interest on it. Now they have to stand in line for 60 euros per day when it could have been in their mattress the whole time.
The bigger problem is that money people have in banks, which is not borrowed and only belongs to private citizens is being plundered or destroyed. Second to that is an inability to access modern forms of transactions, which make running IT companies (and not only) an impossibility.
What's more, with the miracle of credit creation by modern banking, only 5% of their money is actually in the bank--the rest is out making more money for the bank.
It's all a consensual hallucination which works only as long as everyone still has confidence in the system.
It's only an illusion when the central bank is unwilling to inject money into the system in the event of a bank run. The central bank has to maintain somewhat of an equivalence between money stored in banks and cash. It depends on if banks become merely "money vaults" or investment/speculative vehicles.
>It's all a consensual hallucination which works only as long as everyone still has confidence in the system.
Yes, but delusion is not as irrational as it sounds. http://www.interfluidity.com/v2/2669.html
Gold, Bitcoin and paper cash are also subject to confiscation, tax or other legal controls, speculation and devaluation. There is no safe haven from a government which wants to confiscate your belongings or redistribute wealth.
When I started to become poor, I started valueing cash. As soon as I had some balance on my account, I would withdraw it.
Why? So no automatic payments would succeed which were running on the account, immediatly destroying my balance.
With cash in your pocket you can buy food.
Re:The Death of Cash
by marssaxman on Saturday July 25, 2015 @02:46PM
(#9948548)
Yeah, I learned to avoid automatic payments when I was poor, and have never chosen to trust them since. I don't care how convenient it is, I'm not letting somebody else's bank determine my financial priorities.
The credit card companiesand banks probably make most of their money from charging the merchants. Not from the rates on customers.
The "credit card companies" (i.e. the networks like Visa) make their money from the transaction fees which they split with the issuing banks. The transaction fees are also a significant money-maker for the banks but my understanding is that they typically make more from interest and fees (including both annual fees and late fees). Unsurprisingly the high-end cards make relatively less from interest.