News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by amix on Monday December 14, 2009 @12:06PM (#994473)
Being the co-founder and lead dev of Plurk I can tell you this sucks :-( But we are looking at our legal options, thought legal war with Microsoft and especially legal war at Microsoft in China would require a lot of resources.

I think this will become a major concern for all startups that are doing lots of client-side stuff. If people have determination they can copy your code (even if all your code is obfuscated, which Plurk's is). And I don't know what the solution is - other than stronger IP laws in emerging countries.

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by mikeryan on Monday December 14, 2009 @12:37PM (#994560)
Look I doubt anyone very high up at MS knows of this and when they do you might be able to get some scratch out of this.

They're really going to have 3 ways to deal with this.

1. pull down the existing site while they retool. 2. Pay you a licensing fee while the rewrite from scratch. 3. Do nothing and get a ton of bad press

See if you can get 1 or 2 and maybe make some money off the deal.

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by jf on Monday December 14, 2009 @01:10PM (#994647)
I just started working for Microsoft so that I can be a voice inside the company for startups. I'm forwarding this thread to my legal contact.
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by eob on Monday December 14, 2009 @01:41PM (#994728)
Was that really the prime motivator in joining MS? How do you mean "be a voice for startups"? Cool.

People usually cite this reasoning for joining the government -- an organization whose mandate is toward the greater good of its people, but I've never heard it applied toward a corporate entity, whose mandate is solely profit.

Would you mind posting a bit more about your motivations and thinking? I would really like to hear.

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by clemesha on Monday December 14, 2009 @01:48PM (#994744)
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by abossy on Monday December 14, 2009 @03:11PM (#994968)
Joel sounds like he's replacing Don Dodge.
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by jf on Monday December 14, 2009 @06:28PM (#995419)
I was not hired to replace Don Dodge. I was hired because the person who previously held my role moved internally.

I actually don't know much about Don Dodge - I haven't met him yet. All that I know is that he is well liked and respected.

I can only hope to earn a similar level of respect from the startup community.

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by thefool on Monday December 14, 2009 @08:11PM (#995580)
were you hired, or were you moved internally?

Its cool that they have someone devoted to worrying about these issues.

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by jf on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @02:52AM (#996127)
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by robryan on Monday December 14, 2009 @03:49PM (#995062)
Sounds like a better role though, not necessarily pushing Microsoft products.
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by gcb on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @08:20AM (#996394)
two months from here he will realise that the VPs expect him to know from startups why they aren't using IIS.
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by dhs on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @09:10AM (#996465)
So Microsoft VPs want to find out why people do not accept their products. Could be a good thing, if they would then insist on improvement of the products guided by the data that the "dev evangelist" provides. You, though, make it sound like it's a bad thing. Care to explain?
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by jf on Wednesday December 16, 2009 @12:36AM (#998184)
I've already started to have conversations inside Microsoft about why startups in the Silicon Valley don't want (or need) to use Microsoft products.
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by netcan on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @12:48AM (#995996)
What an excellent place to start (this thread/problem). This certainly requires some diplomacy.
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by tptacek on Monday December 14, 2009 @02:15PM (#994803)
A reasonable person might conclude that they could have more influence over the industry in 4 years at Microsoft than in 2-3 more small startups.
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by FreeRadical on Monday December 14, 2009 @05:32PM (#995304)
Cool, I hope you keep visiting HN often to stay in touch with the start up scene here.
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by jf on Monday December 14, 2009 @06:16PM (#995387)
You can count on it!
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by blantonl on Monday December 14, 2009 @08:52PM (#995630)
karma?
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by betterlabs on Monday December 14, 2009 @11:48PM (#995912)
I agree. Its highly unlikely that this was done on purpose with complete transparency to higher management. But I still wonder how the manager or the manager's manager of the project didn't see this happening. I am pretty sure the team and their 1 or 2 levels up researched plurk and its success in the region enough to recognize that it was copied. The product manager could not have missed this. I am sure a lot of people are under fire for this.
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by ericb on Monday December 14, 2009 @12:49PM (#994592)
You forgot 4. Buy you out.
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by UncleOxidant on Monday December 14, 2009 @08:06PM (#995575)
4. Microsoft could buy Plurk to save face.
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by mustpax on Monday December 14, 2009 @12:11PM (#994497)
You are clearly in the right. But a bit of advice: skip the whole look and feel issue* and stick to copyright infringement. Their code is exactly the same or highly derivative of Plurk code. This is pretty well-worn copyright territory, I don't think it would take much for Microsoft to back down.

* Apple sued Microsoft back in the day for stealing the look and feel of Mac OS, and failed. So that argument can be very hard to make.

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by grellas on Monday December 14, 2009 @07:45PM (#995547)
Under U.S. law, copyright protection automatically affixes to any original work of authorship that becomes fixed in any tangible medium of expression. It does not extend to ideas themselves.

Illegal copying can occur by exact copying of source or object code or by paraphrasing (misappropriating a program's structure or architecture, its inter-modular relationships, and/or its algorithms and data structures, at least insofar as these elements do not constitute unprotectable ideas - this can occur by copying the fundamental essence or structure of a copyrighted work even while rephrasing or restating it in immaterial respects).

Impermissible copying can also involve exact duplication of a user interface, or a "paraphrasing" of that interface (e.g., by creating screen displays and menu commands which are very similar but not identical to those of a copyrighted program).

Though interface elements can potentially be copyrighted, the advice you give is sound in most cases because of the courts' reluctance to give any party a monopoly on interface ideas in the guise of copyright (thus, Apple had sought unsuccessfully via copyright to gain exclusive use of a variety of interface elements, such as a visual depiction of a trash can). This is where "look and feel" cases become so difficult - who wants to give anybody exclusive rights via copyright, for example, to the basic ideas behind a spreadsheet? That is why many of those older cases failed.

In spite of this, I don't know that I would simply dismiss the look-and-feel aspect of this case based on the interface involved here. On its face, there appears to be more involved with this interface than mere ideas and, when there are creative forms of expression involved, and the copying is exact or so significantly "paraphrased" as to be almost indistinguishable, an interface infringement may have occurred.

All of the above, however, is based on a U.S. law analysis and may be irrelevant (at least legally) in China. If there is some way to bring U.S. legal principles into play, or anything analogous to them, then this would appear to be a fairly flagrant instance of illegal copying. While the costs of launching and pursuing a formal legal fight would be great, as long as you have a reasonable venue in which to launch it (i.e., one that respects IP rights) and the resources to carry it through to the preliminary injunction stage (usually 6 to 8 weeks into the case), winning a preliminary injunction would likely work its effect in causing Microsoft to fold, assuming it otherwise is willing before that to fight and is able to survive a horrible onslaught of bad publicity.

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by padmanabhan01 on Monday December 14, 2009 @12:25PM (#994531)
So, how does this work? Will everything be fine if they maintained the same look and feel and intentionally obfuscated/added more junk to their code to make the code look different?
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by jamesjyu on Monday December 14, 2009 @01:08PM (#994644)
Look and feel is really hard to pin down legally. It's similar to the fashion industry. You just can't copyright a design -- and that is why there are so many knockoffs.

But that's just how it is in the design industry -- new designs come out quickly, so it's usually not worth the effort to fight knockoffs.

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by shpxnvz on Monday December 14, 2009 @06:04PM (#995369)
You just can't copyright a design -- and that is why there are so many knockoffs.

That's because design is an area covered by trademark, not copyright. You can trademark a design if it's distinctive or innovative enough, at least in the U.S., and have protection from imitation. You don't even have to register a trademark to establish rights, you can declare your rights simply by using the (TM) symbol, although you do have to register in order to defend the rights in federal court or claim international protection.

http://www.uspto.gov/trademarks/basics/register.jsp

From a whois check on their domain name, however, Plurk Inc. appears to be Canadian. Anyone have details on the what differences there are in the Canadian trademark system?

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by ajross on Monday December 14, 2009 @12:32PM (#994546)
No. The Apple v. MS and Lotus v. Borland "look and feel" results were about the interface, not implementation. If you steal code (or other copyrighted content) from someone, no amount of obfuscation will "make it OK" legally (though I guess it might make it impossible to detect).

But simply cloning a user interface is legal, at least in US case law.

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by pavs on Monday December 14, 2009 @02:41PM (#994883)
>But simply cloning a user interface is legal, at least in US case law.

Can you give us citation that it is legal, or are making your claim based on the above lawsuits?

Having a look and feel that is "similar" but "not the same" is open to debate, but having 90% of the interface ripped off, pixel by pixel can't be just "ok". We don't know that because something so dumb didn't happen before in the highest level.

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by ajross on Monday December 14, 2009 @03:13PM (#994973)
The Lotus v. Borland decision was, in fact, about an interface that was keystroke-for-keystroke identical between the two applications. Again, there's a very clear case here for copyright infringement of the code. Mixing that with a much less clear case based on the status of the "interface" is just not a good idea.
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by pavs on Monday December 14, 2009 @04:11PM (#995107)
Lotus v. Borland was not the same. As a matter of fact it was a very stupid lawsuit and rightfully dismissed.

>None of the source code or machine code that generated the menus was copied, but the names of the commands and the organization of those commands into a hierarchy were virtually identical.

From: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lotus_Dev._Corp._v._Borland_Int...

In this case MS not only copied the interface of plurk, but from the look of it they also stole the code. Such a blatant copyright infringement has never happened before at this level to the best of my knowledge.

Your claim that it is "legal to copy UI in US law", based on the above example, is false.

Copying a menu, its command name and hierarchy is not the same as copying an interface. A menu is only small sub-set of user interface.

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by eob on Monday December 14, 2009 @01:44PM (#994735)
Amix,

I feel for you, man. This is really awful to wake up and see.

China has totally different laws though -- do you know if this kind of copying is legal there? I have a number of friends who have told me that the whole web startup scene in Beijing is totally different than the US because the rules of the market are completely different over there (rampant copying, theft, DDOS attacks among competitors, etc). One example of this I've heard is that game developers have to give away their games for free and then rely on in-game purchases to make money, because there's no chance of actually selling software upfront.

What are your thoughts?

Best of luck fighting this -- hopefully this will just be a funny war story in a few months time.

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by amix on Monday December 14, 2009 @02:17PM (#994807)
I can't disclose much on the legal aspects, since I might say something stupid. A few months from now I hope the war story will be similar to David vs. Goliath, because that is our current situation - i.e. we are fighting vs. a billion dollar mega corp that has stolen most of our ideas and code and uses their power to come in a market where we are banned [China].
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by qeorge on Monday December 14, 2009 @02:03PM (#994771)
They can't steal what's really valuable about Plurk:

  1) Your loyal community
  2) The team that created this site in the first place
All they got was a snapshot of what you were doing yesterday.
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by stanleydrew on Monday December 14, 2009 @02:19PM (#994817)
Indeed. See the related Steve Blank post and surrounding discussion here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=981167. This is a little different since Microsoft is copying a well-known and already successful product, but the idea still applies.
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by gcb on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @08:21AM (#996397)
is 1 valid in China already?
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by Elepsis on Monday December 14, 2009 @01:02PM (#994628)
Just curious, have you guys tried reaching out to Microsoft at all to get this resolved before going public with it?
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by julio_the_squid on Monday December 14, 2009 @07:25PM (#995507)
Microsoft didn't seem to have a problem with going quite public with it.
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by dangrossman on Monday December 14, 2009 @11:20PM (#995870)
It's hard to say that about a company with 130,000 employees and consultants.

I highly doubt anyone near the VP level at Microsoft has any idea that some team in China did this.

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by furyg3 on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @05:08AM (#996235)
Yes, but just because everyone at the company didn't decide to do this in unison, doesn't mean that the "company" isn't 100% completely responsible for it.

If the "VP level" at MS doesn't have enough control to prevent an entire department in China from ripping off a popular site and going live with it... then damn. I see no difference between that and Ballmer himself copying and pasting the code.

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by messel on Monday December 14, 2009 @04:58PM (#995224)
They'll pay handsomely for the disservice. It's a gold mine and positive press for Plurk. Don't feel too bad, you just won the Internet.
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by socratees on Monday December 14, 2009 @01:17PM (#994665)
This sounds horrible. Microsoft shouldn't be blamed for this entirely though. Why wouldn't the team that created this think through before?

From what I know, people inside Microsoft make sure they don't get in to any legal trouble before they make use of any code or idea that's already available.

Anyways, this episode is a blatant disrespect for IP. Copying the code is something awful. I believe this case deserves the attention of authorities at Microsoft.

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by jf on Monday December 14, 2009 @01:19PM (#994669)
Legal compliance is VERY important at Microsoft, so much so that we aren't supposed to even read Open Source source code.
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by vinutheraj on Monday December 14, 2009 @01:52PM (#994750)
Well, at the other extreme the gnu people also try not to look into other code, even if it is open-source !

http://sourceware.org/ml/libc-help/2008-08/msg00009.html

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by uriel on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @12:39AM (#995974)
And it shows...
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by ErrantX on Monday December 14, 2009 @01:24PM (#994679)
That seems a somewhat knee jerk / extreme approach to the problem :)

Risks stifling innovative code?

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by ubernostrum on Monday December 14, 2009 @02:04PM (#994775)
And yet not uncommon. We (Django) had a rather frustrating mailing-list exchange with IBM folks who wanted to build a DB2 driver for Django; they claimed their corporate policies wouldn't allow them to look at the existing Django DB backends, or anything BSD-licensed, to gather information on the API.
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by henriklied on Monday December 14, 2009 @02:57PM (#994932)
Wow, are you serious? What ended up as the solution?
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by ubernostrum on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @09:19PM (#997954)
Here's the django-dev thread:

http://groups.google.com/group/django-developers/browse_thre...

Eventually they wrote an adapter; I don't have any idea how they got the API spec, since they swore up and down they couldn't look at existing code.

(and, to be honest, the initial released version of their DB2 adapter showed some serious issues which may be related to not understanding how the code was supposed to work)

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by jganetsk on Monday December 14, 2009 @01:32PM (#994699)
I don't think it's an extreme approach. It would otherwise be nearly impossible to prove that Microsoft's code is not derived from GPL'd works. At least without revealing their code.
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by ErrantX on Monday December 14, 2009 @02:01PM (#994767)
I disagree; "you shouldn't read Open Source code" doesn't fix anything much because it's impossible to find out if developers are sticking to it or not (so it doesn't decrease the burden of proof). It's just as impossible to prove that MS work doesn't include GPL code with or without the rule :)

A better (more effective) one is, surely, dont reuse restricted code.... :)

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by jganetsk on Monday December 14, 2009 @02:10PM (#994792)
Microsoft actually tries to enforce the policy of "you shouldn't read Open Source code". For example, they block access to Sourceforge from the Microsoft campus.
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by sriramk on Monday December 14, 2009 @04:29PM (#995154)
That is totally false. There are no restrictions of any kind on the Microsoft network in general (apart from your standard virus/malware/firewall type stuff).

I've synced code for my projects from sourceforge/google code/github often.

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by wglb on Monday December 14, 2009 @07:15PM (#995487)
So if I may ask--how to use sourceforge/google code/github without looking at open source? Perhaps you are contributing without reading?
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by city41 on Monday December 14, 2009 @02:22PM (#994831)
That is not true. I'm on Sourceforge on a MS Corporate machine right now. MS doesn't block anything at all.

It is true we are not supposed to look at anyone else's source code though.

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by ErrantX on Monday December 14, 2009 @02:25PM (#994838)
What about at home?

I realise the policy is probably not as originally worded here: but I was taking it somewhat literally to point out the fallacy of it.

At some point we have to trust devs to do their own work. This should show that no amount of policy can stop people ripping off work! Whatever the intention.

Reading code is always good; there is usually a net gain as long as it is ethical (i.e. not copied)

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by socratees on Monday December 14, 2009 @01:25PM (#994681)
Yeah I know. And if they decide to make use of any 3rd party application or code internally, they make sure they don't unintentionally mess up with legal requirements of the software. This certainly is an isolated case which needs serious investigation.
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by volida on Monday December 14, 2009 @12:43PM (#994576)
wow.

By the way, what do you mean by obfuscation? Because this is really weird, they even copied the variables. So was the code obfuscated or just trimmed of white space. You should consider using the google closure compiler with advanced optimizations, although you will have το do some extra work το get your javascript compile in advanced mode.

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by amix on Monday December 14, 2009 @02:24PM (#994835)
We used Yahoo's compressor for both JS and CSS ( http://developer.yahoo.com/yui/compressor/ ). An example of our JavaScript can be seen here: http://statics.plurk.com/5578b0a824368f9af6afa9dd6e8abf64.js. You can see that not all the variables are converted, since Yahoo's compressor is very conservative and won't change functions or global objects names.

This was the best available option at the time we wrote Plurk. We will take a look at Google Clouse Compiler, thanks.

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by colbyolson on Monday December 14, 2009 @04:19PM (#995130)
What's up with a few of your "to's" at the end of your last sentence? :-)
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by blasdel on Monday December 14, 2009 @05:16PM (#995264)
They're GREEK SMALL LETTER TAU (U+03C4), GREEK SMALL LETTER OMICRON (U+03BF)
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by colbyolson on Monday December 14, 2009 @06:27PM (#995414)
Yea, I know what they are, just curious as to why they're there.
Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by viraptor on Monday December 14, 2009 @11:39PM (#995897)
Just guessing: he's got a layout where alt_gr+t produces a small tau and is typing quite quickly hitting space+alt_gr by accident. I know that's the reason some of my k-s at the beginning of a word are ĸ-s. (you can just miss it while reading later)

OTOH, I may be completely wrong :)

Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk by access_denied on Monday December 14, 2009 @04:10PM (#995104)
By any means: use the visibility you gain from this for your PR/advertising game! Now is the time for a smart play, get the public behind you (in terms of: target audience goes Plurk 'cause it's cool). Granted, this is not 'the solution but an opportunity you can manage to get a win out of this. (Remember, PG wrote the $$ he spent on PR was worth it.)