News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by luso_brazilian on Saturday July 18, 2015 @05:59PM (#9909103)
IMO there is nothing wrong with advertising in the strict sense of the word. "Here is this product. That's how it works. That's how it's different from its competitors. Here is the price. Here is the total cost of ownership as compared to the competitor. Here is how this product can satisfy your needs in this specific case":

But what is being passed today as advertising is nothing like that, it is more like high school psychological and emotional blackmail. "Here is this product. If you don't have it you are not in the ingroup but in the outgroup. You are not beautiful enough without this product. People will look down on you without this product. This product will make you more attractive to the opposite sex and more likely to land a high paying high profile job".

It is very hard to legislate this are because of freedom of speech concerns but the British have a very good set of regulations concerning to advertisement [1] and an independent regulator responsible for this area [2].

[1] http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukdsi/2008/9780110811475/conte...

[2] https://www.asa.org.uk/About-ASA/Our-history.aspx

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by x5n1 on Saturday July 18, 2015 @06:22PM (#9909183)
It's not just high school emotional blackmail, though that's a part of it. Billions of dollars are spent to scientific research and game people's psychology. On top of that billions of dollars are spent to then spread messages on massive scales that affect virtually everyone's thought process. It's social engineering in its truest sense.

The only way to see beyond it is to move to a place which is not affected by the same tools, say very very poor countries and see how different people's psychology is there. In Western civilization we are set up to be miserable from day one. Whether it's through the schooling process or workplace. It's a toxic environment and it is engineered to be that way. To sell more, to be more productive, and to drive everything in a very tight system.

It is a system which just like any other system serve itself much more than it serves the objects, humans, it administers. It encourages unstable mindsets and addictions.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by visarga on Saturday July 18, 2015 @11:38PM (#9909964)
A regular person sees about 5 hours of TV per day of which 30% is advertising. That is over an hour every day of messages telling you what you need to buy to be happy and where you need to travel, what kind of esthetic surgery to have, which car to drive, etc.

The main problem here is that the messages are disingenuous. They present the product being used by beautiful, smiling, sexy people, thus associating it with well being. We are constantly being told: you must get product X or visit country Y and your ego will be rewarded, more attractive, more successful. It's all about self image, how you see yourself. Very very insidious, because the self image is one of the most delicate and vulnerable parts of our psyche.

An opposite to watching ads would be to do mindfulness meditation and cleanse your mind of all this crap thoughts and fake values which are not in your best interest.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by x5n1 on Saturday July 18, 2015 @11:41PM (#9909972)
It's not as simple as hey I watched this ad and it told me to do this and I did or did not do it. Ads are narratives that create meaning. They in many ways define a sort of metaphysics of our world, a way in which we find meaning in who we are and what we do. They define us as people, society and civilization much like religion defined people in the Middle and Dark ages.

Ads are a one way conversation that the producers are having with the consumers. The other side of that is the actual production of the products, namely your jobs. Stuff you spend most of your life toiling away at. Ads are what it means to be human in the 20th and 21st century.

Example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K9vFWA1rnWc

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by imakesnowflakes on Sunday July 19, 2015 @02:56AM (#9910269)
I think this quote from the movie Network, might be relevant here.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0074958/quotes?item=qt0447849

The scene (in fact, the whole movie also) is worth watching too: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NKkRDMil0bw

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by r0s on Sunday July 19, 2015 @12:28AM (#9910052)
On the other hand, that technology and research is always going to be there. Let it loose in public and we can understand it, becoming naturally immune.

Is the alternative a naive public shielded from manipulative media? How long before that weakness is exploited, and by who?

The key to that immunity is education, of course. A little skepticism is all it takes to deconstruct any message with a motive.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by x5n1 on Sunday July 19, 2015 @02:48AM (#9910260)
You can't become immune to your desires, they drive you.
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by r0s on Sunday July 19, 2015 @05:58AM (#9910650)
You can become conscious of them, and then you can choose how you act.

The real question is, when does a person have free will? Ever? We consider people to be adults at some point. What that means is autonomous agents. I don't want to live under laws that do not assume this.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by GeneralTspoon on Saturday July 18, 2015 @07:18PM (#9909371)
> But what is being passed today as advertising is nothing like that

Here's an example of one such piece: http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XkaWyrm8EQg/maxresdefault.jpg

It's from the Superbowl ad for the mobile game 'Game of War: Fire Age'. It has sweet f-all to do with the game. It's literally just boobs + live-action battle scenes (neither of which the game has). Just another sad attempt to appeal to such basic caveman instincts...

'Game? Boobs? Me...game...boobs...like'

I'm tired of junk like that, so at the moment I'm attempting to build an advertising platform for a project of mine to test the theory that advertising doesn't have to be trash (as mentioned above).

The platform doesn't allow any sort of custom images/text by the advertiser.[1]

The idea is that users decide if they're interested or not based on objective information (the same information as presented by organic listings).

For anyone curious, it looks like this in practice: http://i.imgur.com/iI4oon8.png

All the data for the campaigns is totally open for anyone to view & analyze [2] (although there isn't much data yet, as I'm only piloting the system now)

Maybe it works, maybe it doesn't have enough boobs... but an interesting experiment to try anyway I think.

[1] http://getcurated.co/advertising

[2] http://getcurated.co/advertising/campaigns

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by baddox on Saturday July 18, 2015 @11:42PM (#9909976)
That Game of War ad is obviously unrelated to the game and appeals to "baser" instincts, but does it really deserve a label as harsh as "psychological blackmail"?
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by GeneralTspoon on Sunday July 19, 2015 @01:31AM (#9910147)
You're right, perhaps that's not precisely the correct term here.... "Psychological trickery" or just straight up lies maybe. As it's essentially trying to paint a picture of the game in your mind that's just not true.

I would hold them at exactly the same level of sleaziness though.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by imakesnowflakes on Sunday July 19, 2015 @03:08AM (#9910298)
The purpose of the image is to guide your gaze to the ad. And nothing does it better than a scantly clad beautiful women. It is like the oldest trick of the trade.

Ever wonder why all those billboards feature beautiful women when the product has nothing to do with women? If you try, you can recognize how your gaze is captured by the image of the women (thanks to a strong evolutionary instinct built over million of years to quickly identify potential mates), and how your gaze naturally follows to the name of the brand/caption on the board...If it was only the brand name/caption, then you would never have even looked at it.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by GeneralTspoon on Sunday July 19, 2015 @03:38AM (#9910362)
That doesn't really morally justify the lies though...

"Hey, FREE SEX!! Nah, just kidding, but buy our stuff".

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by imakesnowflakes on Sunday July 19, 2015 @03:44AM (#9910376)
I am in no way justifying it. Oh. In fact, I hate it to the very last shred. I hate it so much that if I somehow end up looking at such a billboard, I avert my eyes before my gaze end up where they want it to end up which is their (brand name/ caption). So fuck you ad!
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by GeneralTspoon on Sunday July 19, 2015 @04:12AM (#9910435)
Ha, awesome! Personally, if I happen to see the name of the brand I'll avoid buying their products (if reasonably possible).
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by wdr1 on Saturday July 18, 2015 @08:14PM (#9909510)
Disclaimer: I work in advertising.

> But what is being passed today as advertising is nothing like that, it is more like high school psychological and emotional blackmail. "Here is this product. If you don't have it you are not in the ingroup but in the outgroup. You are not beautiful enough without this product. People will look down on you without this product. This product will make you more attractive to the opposite sex and more likely to land a high paying high profile job".

I don't understand this. If anything advertising is more transparent today than ever before.

Consider in the 1800s it wasn't uncommon for a publisher to be paid for a product & make it seem like they were simply endorsing something they truly liked.

With the advent of TV, products would be place throughout the show.

Today we have much stricter laws about making it clear a publisher is promoting a product because they are paid.

> ... the strict sense of the word. "Here is this product. That's how it works. That's how it's different from its competitors. Here is the price. Here is the total cost of ownership as compared to the competitor. Here is how this product can satisfy your needs in this specific case"

Only a very, very small percentage of things are purchased this way.

Why does your friend pay extra for those Louis Vuitton sunglasses? Hint: It's not because of quality. All sunglasses are basically made by one company.

Why does your friend drink Coke over Pepsi? Hint: It's not because of health reasons & pretty unlikely it's because of taste.

Why does your friend buy Frosted Flakes instead of the store brand? And so on...

A lot of it boils down to "brand equity" -- what you'll pay for a specific brand over something else. Why do people do that? It's because of the association, image, and feeling a brand generates. You don't sell diapers by saying "We sell good diapers." You sell diapers by showing a cute baby with soft music & get mother's to form an emotional bond with the product.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by verbin217 on Saturday July 18, 2015 @08:50PM (#9909602)
Wow. You're basically just describing the mechanism by which you're manipulating people's behavior, very apparently without concern for your redistribution of inherently finite resources. The opposition to modern advertising is in response to exactly this. It's not that much different than cigarettes. You're exploiting subconscious human mechanisms utterly without concern for any effect except number of purchases. People are better off when they can consciously think about what they're doing. There are people who are motivated to promote that in their societies.
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by perfTerm on Saturday July 18, 2015 @09:11PM (#9909646)
This is totally true, but in a world where there are tens of thousands of products in our supermarkets alone, sometimes I prefer an easy subconcious choice. If Old Spice deodorant works, and I got there because of an advertisement that played on subconcious desires, eh. I don't really have the desire to conciously evaluate my deodorant purchase (even though I avoid anti persperants at all cost cause there are weird metals and it just doesn't seem natural to not perspire).

If I choose Pepsi over Coke because of some subconciously altered motive, eh. Whatever.

I'm not sure it'll be a popular opinion, but to be honest, I don't particularly mind not having to conciously evaluate my soda choice.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by gohrt on Sunday July 19, 2015 @02:21AM (#9910217)
> If I choose Pepsi over Coke because of some subconciously altered motive, eh. Whatever.

What if you choose Pepsi or coke over water because of some subconciously altered motive? And it contributes toward obesity and diabetes?

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by verbin217 on Saturday July 18, 2015 @09:47PM (#9909718)
What I want is for someone, somewhere to consciously evaluate my deodorant purchase. At least in some way that doesn't completely disrespect what anyone would want given they had the capacity to consciously evaluate their deodorant purchase. I understand that that is what advertising is supposed to be.
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by imakesnowflakes on Sunday July 19, 2015 @03:21AM (#9910326)
>If I choose Pepsi over Coke because of some subconciously altered motive, eh. Whatever.

It is not about choosing Pepsi over Coke. What make you choose (Coke OR Pepsi) over plain old cold water, when you feel thirsty?

Another issue is when you let Ads work, you are allowing the brand that had the most aggressive ad campaign to reap a profit. Not the one with a better product. Wont this prevent a better product from rising in the market?

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by azernik on Saturday July 18, 2015 @09:53PM (#9909725)
I don't mind either.

What I do mind is the amount of distraction introduced into my environment in an effort to influence that unconscious and irrelevant choice.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by wdr1 on Sunday July 19, 2015 @03:08AM (#9910299)
Yep, this is exactly my objection as well.
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by nitrogen on Saturday July 18, 2015 @11:23PM (#9909936)
One could make an easy conscious choice if all products included objective information about their characteristics and performance. Hypothetical examples:

- Deodorant X was found to prevent odor for 5 hours and reduce it for 19 in tests with subjects similar to you.

- Fragrance A had the highest percentage of positive ratings among your desired gender and demographic.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by baddox on Saturday July 18, 2015 @11:46PM (#9909985)
Even then, is it worth the effort? I suspect that the vast majority of deodorants work well enough that the upside of choosing the best option isn't worth the time spent reading the objective data. Textbook rational ignorance.

And for things like Coke vs. Pepsi, where there is (I presume) very little objective differences that consumers care about, how does this idea apply?

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by nitrogen on Sunday July 19, 2015 @03:29AM (#9910342)
Well enough is not universally defined, though. One person may just want something to mask ordinary human odor. Another might have allergies, or has friends who have allergies. Various people respond differently to different fragrances. Some fragrances might work better in a professional vs. dating environment. Etc. Objective data could resolve all of those questions far better than any sex-driven superbowl ad.

In the case of deodorant, the question one really wants to ask is either "Will this fragrance upset my coworkers with allergies," or "What fragrance will most impress the guy/girl I want to impress?" Objective, empirical data from the nearest demographic comes the closest to answering that question.

There's no reason that objective data has to require time spent. Computer analysis and machine learning could present the right data at the right times, if the algorithms were designed for that instead of for behavioral manipulation. You wouldn't go to the store, see a rack of 150 different varieties of deodorant, and read the data for each one. You would specify your requirements and see a short list of options, with the principal component of the remaining differences emphasized in the displayed statistics.

More effort is put into seductive advertising than would be required to build and present empirical analyses of fundamental product attributes, despite the perception of complexity.

To address your final paragraph, products that offer no meaningful distinction from their competition would die, while those that are truly useful (even for highly subjective definitions of "useful", like "fashionable") would thrive.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by wdr1 on Sunday July 19, 2015 @03:08AM (#9910295)
> The opposition to modern advertising is in response to exactly this.

Personally, I don't believe that. My theory is that a lot of concern about modern advertising is how it can destroy the user experience. E.g., 20+ additional HTTP calls on a mobile device. Or roadblock pages. Or punch-the-monkey ads that animate to try & grab your attention. Those types of things.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by ericd on Sunday July 19, 2015 @03:41AM (#9910367)
Those things are bad too, but my opposition to advertising is primarily the things he was talking about. On TV, at least, it's aggressively manipulative.
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by mozumder on Saturday July 18, 2015 @11:46PM (#9909986)
All debate is about "manipulation".

You don't need advertising to manipulate people.

I am manipulating you right now.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by verbin217 on Sunday July 19, 2015 @12:16AM (#9910030)
You're also not using money to circumvent the normal process we use to proliferate good ideas. If something is good, tell your friends about it. Notably this is exponential and very weak initially, hence the need for legitimate advertising. You may need to circumvent this process to jump start a non-manipulative idea but never to sustain it. Modern advertisers can't pretend to think I am legitimately ignorant to the existence of carbonated sugar water. They're obviously sustaining an otherwise unwanted behavior in the public via manipulation. Theres no protection of free speech when theres a concentration of megaphones "shouting down" (via the most possibly advanced techniques in psychological manipulation) anything but one particular idea.
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by asanagi on Saturday July 18, 2015 @09:18PM (#9909663)
You have to understand, most people are born with a conscience. It takes a long time and concerted effort to erase it. The doublethink and cognitive dissonance on display here is the end result of that process.

These corporations literally employ child psychologists to study the exact rate of white flashes and scene changes in a television spot that grabs their attention and will not release it. Our children are not on a level playing field with PHD educated adult psychologists. Marketers and salespeople will defend this practice. They don't see anything wrong with it.

P.S. I don't wear sunglasses or any article of clothing with a brand, drink coke or pepsi, and I eat the raisin bran I do because it comes in a bag instead of a bag inside a paper box. Mentally rejecting advertising has had the most positive impact on my physical and emotional health of anything I've ever done.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by kuschku on Saturday July 18, 2015 @10:31PM (#9909807)
Why is "brand equity" a thing?

It shouldn’t be. "brand equity" is the issue that’s wrong with today’s market.

Often I can get the exact same product to a far cheaper price if I’m just willing to accept a cheaper-looking label.

And, while that’s very popular in Germany, and led to the rise of Aldi, Lidl, etc, it’s not enough.

Brand equity, as you call it, is the effect that we trust companies based on irrational ideas. That’s actually bordering on violating the EU advertising laws (you can only advertise stuff that is directly related to the product, you can only say stuff that is true, etc).

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by wdr1 on Sunday July 19, 2015 @03:04AM (#9910287)
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by kuschku on Sunday July 19, 2015 @07:22AM (#9910827)
Yes, I know it is a thing – but it shouldn’t be. That’s the issue. Brand equity is abusing emotions to make people buy worse products for a higher price.
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by pawelabrams on Sunday July 19, 2015 @09:01AM (#9911051)
Lidl was caught on 'colonisation' practices in Poland, where they used development loans to drive prices lower than local stores could afford to beat.

Or it's just someone that wanted me to think so. I really don't know now.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by kuschku on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:56PM (#9925282)
Yeah, they are shitty companies trying to drive prices down.

But if you consider how many better known brands do the same, and are still more expensive, it does seem still unfair.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by topoligel on Saturday July 18, 2015 @08:26PM (#9909542)
> soft music & get mother's to form an emotional bond with the product.

What if it turns out that people have a finite amount of 'emotional bond chemicals' available each day, and by isolating that feeling and associating it to a product instead of to the baby, well, let's suggest for some people the newly constructed relationship between people and objects is (mother's emotion -> object, object -> baby's emotions, baby's emotions -> object, object -> mother's emotions) , and it doesn't work as synergistically efficient as you might expect? What if you don't even know how to measure stuff like that?

What if there is a measurable loss that isn't obvious? What if it's linked to the most random of things, so it isn't even predictably rational in how it affects the system it operates within? The problem with advertising and emotional manipulation is that the information only flows one way. And a constant stream of increasing revenue doesn't mean people are happy, it just means they are buying stuff.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by CONTRARlAN on Saturday July 18, 2015 @10:31PM (#9909806)
> Consider in the 1800s it wasn't uncommon for a publisher to be paid for a product & make it seem like they were simply endorsing something they truly liked.

Since you work in advertising, you should know that that kind of thing is more pervasive than ever today.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by nitrogen on Saturday July 18, 2015 @11:26PM (#9909950)
Native marketing combined with retargeting are disturbingly effective. 1800s snake oil peddlers have nothing on modern advertising's insidiousness.
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by harshreality on Saturday July 18, 2015 @06:29PM (#9909206)
It is very simple to regulate without getting into freedom of speech issues. Just declare (yes, I'm aware it's a constitutional/SCOTUS issue, not a legislative one) that corporations are not people and do not deserve freedom of speech. If individuals want to write checks for advertising that abuses psychology, that's a more troublesome issue, but getting rid of just the corporate funded advertising would be a huge step forward.
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by comex on Saturday July 18, 2015 @06:35PM (#9909224)
So you are okay with, say, the EFF and ACLU not having any freedom of speech? (Not that these organizations engage in much advertising, but they do some, and stripping freedom of speech would apply to content posted on their own websites etc. as well as to advertising.)

Or, for that matter, newspapers. Sure, you could make exceptions for the press, but then you have to define it; in general this is very dangerous stuff.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by harshreality on Saturday July 18, 2015 @06:54PM (#9909305)
Neither of them are really advertising products or services, so any regulation (under a "commercial speech needs regulation" paradigm) that would apply to them (or other NGOs we might hold near and dear) would be light or non-existent.

There's a separate argument to be made about whether political speech should be free (mostly unregulated) for corporations... Japan as I understand it is a fairly good example of heavily regulated political speech. As far as I can tell, politics in the modern world is dysfunctional regardless of how light the restrictions on political speech and political organizations' funding and activities. Political speech has many of the same problematic aspects of commercial advertisements, so I think there's room for argument that Citizens United and other precedent on the issue are a disaster, regardless of how much it might help political organizations we like.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by Adlai on Saturday July 18, 2015 @06:53PM (#9909303)
Wouldn't the individuals behind organizations such as the EFF and ACLU gladly stand behind their message?
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by sirsar on Saturday July 18, 2015 @07:08PM (#9909345)
Many would, but I bet fewer would pay the advertising costs out of their own pockets. And any loophole you provide civil liberties organizations (pay them a salary to buy ads) will just as soon be taken advantage of by the corporations we all despise.
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by yummyfajitas on Saturday July 18, 2015 @06:34PM (#9909220)
You are conflating disparate issues.

Corporations are people - this means that a corporation (rather than some of it's individual members) can own property and owe you money. If you want to sue or enforce obligations, you do it against the corporation itself rather than tracking down specific members and enforcing against them. That's all it means. If you eliminate this and then Comcast injures you, who do you sue?

Freedom of speech is held by the owners of a corporation and it's employees; the corporation is property used by the owners to engage in speech. Saying corporations don't have freedom of speech is like saying inanimate objects such as printing presses don't have freedom of the press. Note that printing presses do NOT have personhood, yet they still have freedom of the press.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by jmilloy on Saturday July 18, 2015 @10:04PM (#9909748)
> who do you sue?

This is very strange to me. You sue Comcast, the corporation, of course. There's nothing inherent to the label "people" that allows people to own property or have accounts, nor anything inherent to the label "corporations" the prevents corporations from owning property and having accounts. We could call them "non-person property-holders" or "obbgobblegooks" for all I care, and decide on whatever rules we want.

Isn't it generally quite clear when an owner is purchasing something personal with their own money as opposed to when an owner is authorizing a purchase of something for their corporation with the corporation's money? In theory, what's to prevent us from declaring that corporations are not people, are allowed to have money, property, goods, and debt and are not allowed to spend their money on, among other things, advertising?

This isn't to say that doing so prevents any sort of non-individual spending on advertising. But saying that "corporations have to be people" and "we can't impose any additional control over corporation spending because actually the owners do the spending" seems irrelevant and incorrect.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by yummyfajitas on Saturday July 18, 2015 @10:32PM (#9909809)
There's nothing inherent to the label "people" that allows people to own property or have accounts, nor anything inherent to the label "corporations" the prevents corporations from owning property and having accounts. We could call them "non-person property-holders" or "obbgobblegooks" for all I care, and decide on whatever rules we want.

Yes, we could redefine the term "personhood" to (in the legal context) refer to something else, and then use the word "obbgobblegooks" to refer to the concept that personhood currently refers to.

In theory, what's to prevent us from declaring that corporations are not people, are allowed to have money, property, goods, and debt and are not allowed to spend their money on, among other things, advertising?

The same thing that prevents us from declaring that the constitution doesn't apply to printing presses; the free speech rights of their owners.

If you want to argue against Citizens United, and say that the government should be allowed to apply prior restraints to free speech that uses property, go ahead and do that. But none of this has anything to do with corporate personhood.

Similarly, your right to name your ship "SS Ilovebush" has nothing to do with ship personhood - that's just your free speech right as a guy with a ship and a paintbrush.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by baddox on Saturday July 18, 2015 @11:50PM (#9909992)
It sounds like you don't have any complaints about the actual phenomenon that is commonly referred to as "corporate personhood," and that your only complaint is about the label itself.
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by jmilloy on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @09:34AM (#9968482)
In fact, what I wrote is exactly the opposite of that.
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by yequalsx on Saturday July 18, 2015 @06:49PM (#9909283)
Well, Comcast has hundreds of thousands of owners and they don't all get an equal or even proportional (in reality not in theory) say in how the corporation spends the money of the corporation to get its message across.

Corporations have 'free speech' in the sense that a corporation can spend its money without legal limit on political campaigns. The number of people who have effective control over that money is quite small in relation to the number of owners. Saying a corporation has free speech is not all like saying a printing press has free speech. Corporations have their own bank accounts, their own money, are subject to laws and have legal privileges that printing presses do not.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by yummyfajitas on Saturday July 18, 2015 @07:10PM (#9909349)
I agree that there are issues with shareholder governance; mostly a bunch of well meaning laws from the corporate raider era that prevent shareholder activism. This is a rather separate issue.

Suppose we eliminated corporate personhood. Now a collective of people are bound together in a web of contracts and call themselves "citizens united". They agree to act and use a subset of their property in accordance with a specific governance structure determined by a mutually agreed upon charter. How do you hinder this non-corporate group's rights to free speech?

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by jmilloy on Saturday July 18, 2015 @10:27PM (#9909799)
Now you are saying that we can't regulate corporate spending because can't regulate a non-corporate groups spending. It's like saying we can't stop kids from buying alcohol because we can't stop adults from buying alcohol. It makes no sense.

I think you have a reasonable point to make, but you are not being clear enough.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by yummyfajitas on Saturday July 18, 2015 @10:36PM (#9909821)
Let me be very clear. The First Amendment to the US Constitution says:

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

The court has ruled that this also means that humans can use their property in the furtherance of speech. Such property can be a printing press, a computer connected to the internet, a corporation, a ship, a billboard or other such things.

Some of those pieces of property are legal persons (corporations, ships), others are not. The personhood of the piece of property is irrelevant.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by jmilloy on Saturday July 18, 2015 @10:51PM (#9909862)
There we go!
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by GFK_of_xmaspast on Sunday July 19, 2015 @01:27PM (#9911954)
Didn't we fight a war about people being property one upon a time.
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by qu4z-2 on Monday July 20, 2015 @01:03AM (#9914087)
I... don't believe you did, but I may be wrong.
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by noelsusman on Saturday July 18, 2015 @07:33PM (#9909407)
Corporations are not people. They are granted a subset of the rights and responsibilities that people have. This includes obvious things like the ability to enter into a contract, the ability to be sued in court, the right to own property, etc. They don't have all of the same rights that people do (e.g. they can't vote).

But that's just pedantry. The real issue is that your solution is far too broad and is likely to have unintended side effects. We already have laws curtailing speech of both people and corporations. Free speech is not absolute in the US. We already have "misleading advertising" laws that have been used successfully against corporations.

You can solve this problem if you want by just expanding the scope of existing laws. You don't need to abolish corporate personhood to achieve it.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by wdr1 on Sunday July 19, 2015 @03:11AM (#9910306)
> It is very simple to regulate without getting into freedom of speech issues. Just declare (yes, I'm aware it's a constitutional/SCOTUS issue, not a legislative one) that corporations are not people and do not deserve freedom of speech.

That would be one of the country's easiest laws to work around. It wouldn't be effective.

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by dredmorbius on Saturday July 18, 2015 @07:41PM (#9909436)
Very much this.

If you're not familiar with Adam Curtis's BBC documentary, The Century of the Self, on Edward Bernays, Sigmund Freud (whom Bernays effectively made), and Anna Freud, as well as the influence of advertising, "public relations" (a term coined by Bernays), and propaganda (the term he coined PR to avoid) on the public, corporations, and govenrment.

Also Jerry Mander's Four Arguments for the Elimination of Television, which is an ad-man's perspective on what is fatally flawed with his own industry. See also his later book, The Capitalism Papers.

And of course, Neil Postman's Amusing Ourselves to Death and Technopoly.

There've been a number of recent HN posts on how bloated websites are becoming, and how content is being watered down on the Web. Pretty much all of this can be traced to the current funding mechanism: advertising. Which is increasingly becoming the problem, not the solution. E.g., TJ VanToll's "The Web's Cruft Problem".

Thomas Wells hits on what I see as the two most likely alternative funding mechanisms: a content tax, and philanthropy or patronage. Combining these with some form of decentralised content syndication compensation system seems like a possible path forward. The total value of the US arts and entertainment industry is $528 billion, of which publishing is $152 billion. If 20% of that is online content, it amounts to roughly $100 per person per year.

Phil Hunt of Pirate Party UK's broadband tax proposal is an earlier and similar concept.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Century_of_the_Self

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Arguments_for_the_Elimina...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jerry_Mander

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neil_Postman

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amusing_Ourselves_to_Death

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technopoly

"A Modest Proposal: Universal Online Media Payment Syndication" https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/1uotb3/a_modes...

http://cabalamat.wordpress.com/2009/01/27/a-broadband-tax-fo...

http://developer.telerik.com/featured/the-webs-cruft-problem...

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9897306

Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by ctchocula on Sunday July 19, 2015 @02:34PM (#9912275)
Thank you for these recommendations. I enjoyed reading Amusing Ourselves to Death very much. I'm watching the first episode of The Century of the Self right now and enjoying it very much. It seems quite informative and seems less biased than Manufacturing Consent, which makes it more watchable for me.
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by colechristensen on Saturday July 18, 2015 @06:12PM (#9909154)
To be fair, there _is_ a lot of advertising which is nothing like that.
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by jfoster on Saturday July 18, 2015 @09:46PM (#9909716)
Can you provide an example of an ad that is like psychological and emotional blackmail? The closest thing that comes to mind is perhaps ads for luxury fashion brands. Is that a good example of what you mean?
Re:Is Advertising Morally Justifiable? The Importance of Pro... by mozumder on Saturday July 18, 2015 @11:51PM (#9909996)
The thing about luxury fashion brands, is that they actually look better than basic brands. There is nothing you can buy at Wal Mart that comes close to looking like it was produced by Saint Laurent.

These brands hire the top designers and talent to work with them. They are expected to produce top quality work.

And, if a luxury fashion brand starts to go down in terms of style, then reviewers pan their collections, sales drop, and they stop being a luxury fashion brand.