You would use the same house cleaning professional over and over again but you will likely never ride with the same Uber driver again. This means that the Homejoy house cleaner can bypass Homejoy but the Uber drivers/users can't do without it.
In theory, having your "own" driver would not be a bad thing. But the main difference is in scheduling.
With taxis and Uber, you want a car to show up in 10 minutes at any time of the day without advance booking. This requires a large pool of drivers on standby and a middleman to handle the communication.
A cleaner can visit pretty much any time during the week, and is usually pre-booked for every week indefinitely into the future. This doesn't need a middleman, since you can arrange the details directly.
Consider there are only 40,000 taxi drivers in New York.
All it takes is for a company to find the top 5-50% of Uber/Lift drivers in a city offer them a minimum income of a few k/month assuming they take A% of rides and work y hours and boom instant driver network. Sure, doing it now when Uber is flush with cash is a bad idea, but after it pop’s there is no way they can stay competitive without paper thin margins long term.
Sure there is - the IRS says their drivers are employees and they need to provide multiple years worth of backpay/benefits. Any competitor that's been doing that already wins.
Don't get me wrong there currently very popular and profitable so they don't need to worry about a Pets.com style crash. However, the barriers to entry are relatively low just look at Lyft. Eventually investors are going to want to get their money back, so they either start issuing dividends or face a hostile takeover.
Are they? Everything I've read indicates that they are not.
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/videos/2015-06-30/uber-loses-m...
The quickest numbers I could find were leaked in 2014.
est yearly rev run rate city
======================= ====
$212+mm sf
$312 mm nyc
$141 mm dc
$150 mm chicago
======= =======
$815 mm total
http://www.businessinsider.com/uber-revenue-rides-drivers-an...edits: made table
AKA: Uber pays a lot to get ex: NYC and LA drivers, wins both markets, lowers payouts to make money. New competitor shows up in NYC so Uber dramatically raises rates in NYC and not LA. Then, before that competitor moves to LA a lot of drivers are going to get pissed there stuck with low rates. Basically, by attacking one city, Uber is forced to either raise rates in all its cities’ which it can't afford or piss off all their drivers.
If the good drivers stop working for Uber because Uber is squeezing them, for example, Uber may get a reputation for having poor drivers.
I don't think this creates a very big moat - that's essentially what Uber started out as (dispatch for private driving companies that already existed); they started letting anyone drive in order to meet demand.
If all the services are interchangable (and now, at least for ridesharing, it seems like they are), the winner will be the app that's used by default.