News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by Beached on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @09:50AM (#9891204)
I just had to purchase health insurance two week ago in the state of MI(Just turned 26).

I had 3 options:

1. Obama Care - I qualified for a $16 subsidy...

2. Individual plan from a health care provider in state

3. Health Share plan (think Credit union for health care)

Obama care cost 2x as much as an individual plan, and almost 3x as much as a health share plan, so even after the subsidy, this was not an option.

Health share plan was very affordable, however it only worked with the health care providers on the east side of the state(I live on the west), it had a low yearly deductible, much lower then the individual High deductible HMO, however it had a 20% copay for all health services, including routine physicals and checkups.

Individual Plan from an instate health care plan costs slightly more each month, but all routine check ups, generic brand pharmaceuticals proscribe from my doctor, and any specialist (Chiropractor, Knee Doctor, etc) visits are 100% covered IF I am referred by my primary care physician.

I went with an individual plan for about $140/m and $28/m for dental coverage.

A political side note: this same exact coverage would have only cost me $84/m before 2014 when Obama care went into play. (edit: Health Care cost, not Heath + Dental)

Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by hackuser on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @10:11AM (#9891312)
> Obama care cost 2x as much as an individual plan

What is an Obamacare plan? I thought the ACA created a marketplace that listed plans from insurers, and set minimums for coverage (that would apply to options #2 and #3). I haven't had to deal with it so I don't know.

> this same exact coverage would have only cost me $84/m before 2014 when Obama care went into play

How else has the ACA affected your insurance? For example, I think it allows you to stay on your parents plan until now (i.e., through age 25), guarantees you won't be turned down, eliminates caps on coverage, etc.

EDIT: Remove something that I think was overly provacative, (even if not meant that way).

Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by Beached on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @10:38AM (#9891456)
> What is an Obamacare plan? I thought the ACA created a marketplace that listed plans from insurers, and set minimums for coverage (that would apply to options #2 and #3). I haven't had to deal with it so I don't know.

Ironically a plan through Priority health on the market place cost 2x as much as the same plan purchase through the same insurer individually. This is for a couple reasons:

On the market place, a qualifying plan must meet ALL ACA requirements. This includes a capped deductible, bundled Dental, vision coverage, prenatal coverage/birth control coverage. Also, ACA plans are held to a higher standard then individual plans purchased on the open market. I have fewer options to choose from, and those fewer options all come with lower deductibles and more coverage then I need/want. This means higher monthly premiums.

>Were you pricing insurance 2 years before you need it? Many years ago (before Obama was elected), when I was pricing individual insurance the price was several times more. Insurance companies seemed uninterested in individual consumers.

I had the wonderful experience of working at Priority Health from 2011-mid 2014. I got to see ALL sorts of chaos unfold as they tried to meet all the requirements and deadlines (They did just fine, but there certainly wasn't much cushion on time). This increase in coverage was literally over night, as in 12/31/2013 Individual Plan A (The actual name...) was $84/m, on 1/1/2015 Individual Plan A was $136/m (Priority Health did grandfather in the pre-ACA prices for anyone already on the plan for 1 year, however any new members paid the new price)

>How else has the ACA affected your insurance? For example, I think it allows you to stay on your parents plan until now (i.e., through age 25), guarantees you won't be turned down, eliminates caps on coverage, etc

Overall ACA has negatively affected my coverage and most people I know. However to be fair, I was in the Goldilocks zone for health care coverage. Young, white, healthy athletic male, no pre-existing conditions, never smoked, and located in a relatively low health care area when compared to LA, NY, Chicago, etc. Pre-ACA my health care costs would have been as low as low could be.

I do think that coverage until age 26 is a good additional, however I wish it was through the entire year they turn 26 in, and not just until the month they turned 26, (For me June and I had to find coverage within 30 days of my birthday).

I do like the fact that it give subsidies to the individuals who cannot afford even a $84-$150 monthly premium pre ACA, however I wish that they just expanded the medicare program to give these subsidies as these people only represent about 1/3 of 1% of Americans, and in many cases a large portion of this small percentage would have been covered under medicare anyways

I agree that per-existing conditions should not be denied for coverage, however I do not agree that those without conditions should be required to pay higher premiums to subsidize their premiums. (sounds harsh I know, but thats my opinion.)

I think it is stupid that my obama care plan purchased through the open market also includes Dental, Vision, Prenatal care, and Birth Control coverage. I think its a smart marketing move to bundle these together into one plan for certain females, however it is not possible to unbundle this. And yes that means all you males out there, and all you women after menopause have prenatal and birth control coverage...

I think its stupid that as a male i am REQUIRED to purchase prenatal care and birth control coverage for myself even though i will NEVER use this. why do i have to purchase this? All US Citizens are required to purchase a plan that meets the affordable care acts requirements, it does not mean i must purchase a plan on the open exchange, but yes that mean individual buyers must purchase coverage they will not use in an attempt to make health care for everyone good. If I dont purchase prenatal care, I will qualify for the penalty at tax season.

Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by hackuser on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @12:14PM (#9892137)
> a plan through Priority health on the market place cost 2x as much as the same plan purchase through the same insurer individually. ... On the market place, a qualifying plan must meet ALL ACA requirement

Doesn't the ACA require all insurance plans to meet its standards? If there wasn't that requirement, why would insurance companies offer ACA-compliant plans?

> I agree that per-existing conditions should not be denied for coverage, however I do not agree that those without conditions should be required to pay higher premiums to subsidize their premiums.

That isn't really subsidy, it is almost the definition and purpose of insurance. The total cost of medical care is the same, but we spread the risk (and therefore the cost) evenly over everyone in the insurance pool. Or another way of looking at it is we all subsidize each other; you are subsidized too, for your own unique risks and costs.

That way, when something bad happens and your costs spike, you will receive the medical care you need and won't go bankrupt. If we all simply paid for our own costs (and didn't 'subsidize' each other), we wouldn't be insured.

Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by caseysoftware on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @12:50PM (#9892412)
The problem is that in order to do true risk pooling, you need to be able to charge based on risk. The ACA (Obamacare) has eliminated much of that making the cost the same for everyone at a given level. And it turns out that many healthy people have continued to opt out and many of the new enrollees are people who couldn't get coverage elsewhere.

None of this is a judgement, just the raw math of the situation.

Here's one sample but the problem is nationwide:

"“Our enrollees generated 24 percent more claims than we thought they would when we set our 2014 rates,” said Nathan T. Johns, the chief financial officer of Arches Health Plan, which covers about one-fourth of the people who bought insurance through the federal exchange in Utah. As a result, the company said, it collected premiums of $39.7 million and had claims of $56.3 million in 2014. It has requested rate increases averaging 45 percent for 2016."

Ref: http://www.witn.com/home/headlines/-Health-Insurance-Compani...

Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by hackuser on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @10:04PM (#9895155)
> The problem is that in order to do true risk pooling, you need to be able to charge based on risk. The ACA (Obamacare) has eliminated much of that making the cost the same for everyone at a given level.

Why is that a problem? I'm not sure why a less diverse risk pool is inherently better than a more diverse one. Certainly I want very ill people to receive medical care, and it seems as broad as possible a risk pool facillitates that.

> it turns out that many healthy people have continued to opt out and many of the new enrollees are people who couldn't get coverage elsewhere.

Don't opt-outs have to pay the fine, which funds medical care regardless (or do those funds go elsewhere)? The fines might be less than insurance payments, but I'd assume they are all profit. The opt-outs consume generate zero claims and costs from insurers.

The paragraph you quote doesn't say healthy people are opting out; it says the insurance company is claiming higher costs than they expected and wants a rate increase. Their expectations could have been wrong, or they simply might want to raise rates and are making a case for it (or their claim could be legitimate, of course); I'd guess reality is some mix of the three.

Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by Retric on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @10:41AM (#9891473)
Pre ACA for a 30 year old non smoker with zero heath problems my plan was over 500$/month. Granted, VA health costs are probably higher, but that's a long way from 84$/month. Can you give details such as a link to the actual coverage?
Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by Beached on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @11:03AM (#9891628)
Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by Retric on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @01:58PM (#9892930)
Ok, zero coverage for out of network health care that’s a great way to end up bankrupt if you have an accident on vacation. Add in the 6,400$ deductible it's really not a good deal IMO, but I can see why someone might chose it.
Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by mgkimsal on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @10:55AM (#9891578)
"however I wish that they just expanded the medicare program to give these subsidies"

This would have been a much better overall option vs entire ACA mess. Is the issue access to health insurance or access to health care service? I feel like the two got mixed together quite often (not sure how much was actual intentional deception vs truly not grokking the difference) but... insurance is not the same as care, and moving towards universal health care vs universal health insurance... I don't know when we'll ever get to the former. :/

Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @10:46AM (#9891516)
You are required to buy prenatal care because it wasn't fair for young women to have much higher insurance costs then young men just because they get pregnant more often...you know it takes two to tango.
Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by Beached on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @11:02AM (#9891620)
I am happy to pay for prenatal care IF AND WHEN my wife/partner and I decide to have a child. and in that instance, yes I would be paying for prenatal care, however I do not think it is right for the government to force me to purchase ANY SERVICE that I may not want or may not use, such as prenatal care.

Those young women who made the decision to have sex not knowing if the individual they "Tangoed" with would help with any costs or work will soon learn that it was a poor decision. Sheltering the consequences of ones actions is not an affective way to direct behavior for the masses. That young girls friends will see that it was hell, and their parents will learn it was an expensive decision, and then those other girls and their parents will do a better job being responsible citizen. I shouldnt have to pay for coverage that is ultimately needed because of poor parenting.

And yes, with any statistical examination there will be a small percentage of people that statistics work against, IE. the less the 1% of pregnancies due to rape.

Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by facetube on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @11:17AM (#9891712)
And I'd be happy to pay for car insurance IF AND WHEN I get in to an accident in my own car. You don't get an insurance discount for naively believing that you won't make mistakes, or for believing that undesirable things won't happen to you.
Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by nsxwolf on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @11:41AM (#9891893)
What Beached is saying is that he's not driving a car yet. You don't have to pay for car insurance when you don't have a car.
Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by Beached on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @01:16PM (#9892602)
This^
Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by facetube on Sunday July 19, 2015 @06:57PM (#9913183)
Unintended pregnancies exist, and people have sex. But you're not going to get pulled over and cited for sexing without a license, because it tends to happen in private. So how should an insurance company verify that someone isn't having sex that could result in an immediate need for prenatal care? What happens when you're allowed to opt out, but your contraceptive fails and you have a kid anyway? The risk of ectopic pregnancies and/or miscarriages is high pretty early on, and many of those present in the ER where it's ludicrously expensive to even breathe the air.

How about diabetes or mental health care, should you be allowed to opt out of that coverage it you're sure™ it's not going to happen to you? Can women opt out of most everything to do with the prostate?

On top of all of this, as another commenter explained, the marginal cost of prenatal/pregnancy/postnatal coverage isn't even all that high. The cost of managing the opt-out would probably destroy any savings you were hoping to realize.

Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @05:11PM (#9894110)
I guess the main problem is that pregnancy is considered a health insurance thing at all: it's going to come and birth, like schools, benefits society as a whole. But who pays for it?

If you are a single guy with no kids, do you also complain about property taxes funding public schools? After all you have no kids, you are paying for something you don't use. If you go single or DINK, then it is something you will never use.

Really, this is why I think single payer or just full-on nationalized health would work better in the end. Insurance is just another tax now, and there is no point to put private companies in the middle of it.

Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by Retric on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @02:06PM (#9892982)
Prenatal care like vaccinations more than pay for themselves at the societal level. I can see the argument for keeping the government out of healthcare, but this really does fall under moral hazard.

Also, if a female can go from no prenatal care to prenatal care then there going to swap from one to the other when they decide to have kids which would distort the market. In the end it's the same reason you can't get insurance with and without support for specific diseases.

Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by sehutson on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @11:18AM (#9891721)
As a female who will never have children, I'm even more angered by the new coverage. Being self-employed, I went from a $5k deductible for around $80/month to a $10k deductible and $230/month (and my new plan doesn't have good coverage all over the country, which sucks because I travel a lot).

I have never used my health insurance for any reason in the last 15 years, I eat well, exercise, get plenty of sleep, etc. - so the whole situation makes me mad every time I see the bill.

Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by nimblegorilla on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @10:53AM (#9891568)
> I agree that per-existing conditions should not be denied for coverage, however I do not agree that those without conditions should be required to pay higher premiums to subsidize their premiums. (sounds harsh I know, but thats my opinion.)

The problem is that insurers try to deny claims based on a patient having a pre-existing condition that they weren't paying for.

Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by gwbas1c on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @10:07AM (#9891292)
The cost went up because of the pre-existing condition situation. Pre Obama Care, if you had any kind of pre-existing condition, you wouldn't be able to buy the $84 coverage.

(I got stuck having to get a normal job because of a pre-existing condition.)

Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by smrtinsert on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @10:32AM (#9891422)
Interesting. I know a freelancer couple whos cost when down dramatically with the OC plan. Could the federal prices be different per state?
Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by mgkimsal on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @10:35AM (#9891433)
they're all different per state, because there's no real 'federal pricing' or 'federal policies', AFAICT. The fed govt gives subsidies to insurance companies for low-income folks who sign up to the plans in their individual states/locations. There's no 'federal health plan' (more's the pity, imo).
Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by caseysoftware on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @12:52PM (#9892425)
And it's illegal for companies to sell plans across state lines. Remove that restriction and the situation would change quite a bit.
Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by Beached on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @10:39AM (#9891462)
They are all differant per state, and if he/she is poor with a pre-existing condition/smoked/smokes, over weight, its very likely that his costs went down.
Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by Beached on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @10:11AM (#9891318)
Yes, Since I do not have any pre-existing condition, and have never smoked, that $84 would have been mine. Because no insurer can decline someone, my cost went up to make insurance for people with per-existing conditions more affordable.
Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by Aqueous on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @10:16AM (#9891346)
The fact that you didn't have to buy insurance until 26 is a result of Obamacare too. Think of all the money you saved being on that insurance for several extra years. You're welcome!

And maybe in part because you're spending that $84 now someone else who has a pre-existing condition and no health insurance will be able to not die or go bankrupt if they get something serious.

You have to buy insurance because our system now factors in the strain on the system you would cause if something happened to you and you didn't have insurance. Just think of it like a tax (or the tax penalty like a tax, and the subsidy like a reward for responsible behavior.) That's how the Supreme Court thought of it.

Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by Beached on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @10:55AM (#9891579)
>The fact that you didn't have to buy insurance until 26 is a result of Obamacare too. Think of all the money you saved being on that insurance for several extra years. You're welcome!

yes i am aware that the 26 rule is an obama care result. However, if I am nice, and I am, I pay my parents the extra cost per month to go from a spousal plan to a family plan, which is $85/m, shocker.... However if my parents had other kids younger then me that required a family plan it would have saved me money, yes. in my response to another post, i noted that this was really the only positive to Obama care that I experienced.

>And maybe in part because you're spending that $84 someone else who has a pre-existing condition and no health insurance will be able to not die or go bankrupt if they get something serious.

I dont think it is fair that I have to pay for someone elses health care expenses. ESPECIALLY since that someone else doesnt take the time of day to shop around for the best coverage for the cost, care to look at success rates to avoid re-works, or heaven for bid, self diagnose themselves and go directly to a specialist that can result in more expensive care. If people actually had to pay for the coverage they used, they would take the time to shop around and make informed decisions, and do things like exercise and eat well, avoid smoking and recreational drugs, then people with pre-existing conditions, and low incomes wouldnt have to pay so much for their care. Its called capitalism, and the health insurance industry would look VERY different. Obama care only gets us farther from where we need to be, and makes the entire situation worse. I know I sound like a jack ass right now because some people would suffer in the short term, but if you eliminated obama care, and the health insurance industry, we would be better off in 10 years. keep medicare for the poor, old, and disabled if you want, keeping it will have very little affect as its an income tax and not a premium subsidy.

>You have to buy insurance because our system now factors in the strain on the system you would cause if something happened to you and you didn't have insurance. Just think of it like a tax (or the tax penalty like a tax, and the subsidy like a reward for responsible behavior.) That's how the Supreme Court thought of it.

If the government allowed care providers to go after uninsured individuals assets and not eat the costs. AND if the government allowed back charging for care given to qualified medicare/medicaid individuals, there would be no need to increase the burden on me to help pay for everyone else who goes in for care un covered. over 75% of the uncovered costs pre-ACA are people treating the ER like their PCP anyways. If we allowed capitalism to work, those individuals who go to the ER for a cold would eventually go to a PCP and only pay $25 for the visit and $15 for the generic meds.

Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by lentil_soup on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @11:28AM (#9891806)
I'm sorry dude, but not every pre-codition is because people don't exercise or don't eat well.
Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by gutnor on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @10:48AM (#9891528)
> Since I do not have any pre-existing condition, and have never smoked, that $84

I'm almost 40 and never had use of my health insurance - if you are like me you can save 124$ per month !

Think of all those years I would have been able to save. Same thing for my car (never stolen, no accident), house insurance (no theft), professional liability insurance, travel insurance (no problem so far), life insurance (still alive), payment protection insurance (still employed), critical illness insurance on the mortgage (thanks god).

Don't be bitter about it. I don't regret it for a second all that money spent. I feel lucky every day if the little premium I pay prevent me to see a friend in misery. And by the time you get my age, you will have seen a lot of stuff happening around you (to me it started around age 28, shit happening somewhere is sadly too common nowadays).

Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by Beached on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @11:07AM (#9891645)
I do not regret paying for health insurance, or car insurance for that matter. It would actually be cheaper for me to pay the penalty and not have coverage, however i still have it because it is what I consider a good investment, even at the increased rates. I will say I am a little bitter, since I actually worked at a health insurance company that worked to reduce health care costs instead of just upped the premiums when costs rose, I see how the health industry triad is just making it worse. The ACA on top of that has made it so that the free market will not be able to correct itself and effectively ruined capitalism from working for the health industry.

ACA had good intentions, just very poor execution.

Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by dimino on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @10:13AM (#9891331)
I'm quite sure they appreciate it, thanks. :D
Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by artlogic on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @10:03AM (#9891277)
I'm also in Michigan and curious about the specifics of options 2 and 3. Would you be willing to share the details?
Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by Beached on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @10:10AM (#9891306)
Certainly, 2. The individual plan is from Priority health, it is their individual High deductible HMO HSA plan with a annual deductible of $6300. The entire spectrum health network is covered in the plan, (Spectrum health pretty much owns all of west MI and the Grand Rapids area).

3. http://www.healthshareplan.org/ When I contacted them, they only paid out to UoM and Mercy Health networks, not spectrum health. Since I live in Spectrum health land, this wouldnt work well for me. however if you live in East MI, you may consider this.

Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by artlogic on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @10:15AM (#9891338)
The HSP looks really interesting, and I'm currently living in Ann Arbor so UofM is practically within walking distance. Thanks for the information!
Re:Ask HN: Freelancers in the US: What do you do for health ... by Beached on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @11:12AM (#9891675)
no problem, i will also say that PH insurance has some of the BEST customer service. Both public facing and internal. They actually have an internal department that the public is unaware that does some amazing things that help reduce cost for both them and you as a customer. This department also help make sure the care you receive is the best available for you, as well as thoroughly completed to avoid complications and repeat visits, which also help reduce costs but improve quality of life.

I cant say much more then that because im pretty sure its what they would call a trade secret... I am only aware of it because I worked for them and was involved in supporting this from an IT perspective.

On a side note for all of you people looking for a change of pace. Health care is IMO the most fascinating place to be as far as IT is concerned, I would have never left the health care industry except that I wanted the benefit of working from home full time. When I left, I told my boss and a few other managers to let me know if a full time work from home position became available.