> do something again the blatant corruption, burocratie and tax evasion
Corruption and tax evasion are an economic problem, not a moral one. People decide whether or not to pay taxes based on many factors - convenience, value, habit, punishment, etc... In a 'developing' economy, like Greece, if there's a history of not paying taxes, you need to provide incentive to pay taxes. Because if you all of a sudden raise taxes and enforce it hard, you don't get tax evasion - you get capital flight, which is much, much worse for the economy. And it's all too easy to move around in the Eurozone.
> Stoneage lefties like to discuss, well, preach, all day long while spending other (EU) citizen's money.
Greece did not spend other EU citizen's money. They sold bonds at the market rate to banks and investors that BOUGHT them, and their debt spending was entirely sustainable up to the financial crisis (not sure if you've heard about it) which rocked the whole world. The troika bailed out those banks, with the vast majority of the "EU citizens' money" going to those banks and only a fraction of this money ever made its way to Greece.
> instead of hindering startups, business and innovative people
You know what hinders startups, business, and innovative people? A repressive tax regime. Like the one the troika imposed on Greece...
Not true. The Greek state has traditionally been seen as an enemy of the citizen and something to take advantage of. This is due to the muchtar system established hundreds of years ago by the Osman empire, establishing clientilism. E.g. Estonia is much better on all these metrics, but income levels are similar or below Greece.
> Greece did not spend other EU citizen's money
They took advantage of having access to "Germany's credit card", with interest rates dropping from 25% to 5% post Drachme. Then they proceeded to consume that money. Even in 2014, the public and private consumption relative to net national income was at 114% [1], a completely unsustainable level. If Europe wasn't financing elevated standards of living for Greece before the crisis, they certainly did in the last few years.
[1] http://www.cesifo-group.de/ifoHome/publications/docbase/deta...
> You know what hinders startups, business, and innovative people? A repressive tax regime.
New York and California have comparatively high tax rates, enormous housing costs and expensive wages. They seem to be doing just fine. Also see Germany, Austria, Switzerland and all of the Scandinavian countries.
That's why I'm bombarded with ads that brag about NY's startup program that allows you to operate for 10 years with NO taxes?
http://startup.ny.gov/ http://esd.ny.gov/BusinessPrograms/Taxes_Incentives.html
Anyhow, like I said - businesses and people will pay taxes if they see value - beyond NY's tax free startup program, those are the 2 most populous US states (access to labour). That is a competitive advantage. There's also easier access to financial capital - another advantage.
People don't necessarily go to where the taxes are the cheapest - they go to where there's the best combination of access to labour, capital, customers, taxes, etc... (or they stay put if they think their current location is 'good enough')
Think of human behaviour as a maximization curve - a constant attempt to attain maximum "utility" of our time.
> E.g. Estonia is much better on all these metrics, but income levels are similar or below Greece.
Estonia, business-wise, seems to have quite a few things going for it.
http://www.lowtax.net/features/Estonias-Advantages-571583.ht...
Just reiterates what I'm saying - paying taxes is based on a number of factors, none of them morality (not on a large scale anyway).
Edit - if Greece wants to collect more tax money, they need to provide a good reason for people to pay tax money. Given that the world is a big place and anyone with enough money can move quite easily, it needs to be a more compelling reason than the fear of punishment.
I agree on this one. I would not want to give a corrupt government my money. But then again, this is due to ethics - if not the taxpayer's, then the government's. You will find the topic of corruption mentioned in the "Ethics" section in this world bank report. [1, page 11]
[1] http://www1.worldbank.org/publicsector/civilservice/rsGerman...
Most people don't decide to pay or not pay taxes based on perception of corruption, but rather what they perceive they're receiving.
In Canada, we generally are content to pay taxes because we get such benefits as free health care, cheap medicine, free primary and secondary schooling, subsidized post-secondary schooling, and our cities are generally quite clean with good infrastructure, which is a good accomplishment considering our population density is very low.
My wife is from a third world country where almost no one pays taxes. Then again, what do they get? Infrastructure is non-existent (roads are all gravel or dirt, power is on about 50% of the time, no potable running water, police are non-existent, etc...). This is the conundrum of development economics - how do you go from this stage of development, to a new stage where people pay taxes so the government can provide services? With no services people will avoid taxes, with no tax money the government cannot provide services. The answer of course, is that it's difficult and takes time.
Corruption is an easier problem to solve, but difficult to implement. To get civil servants to stop accepting bribes you need to pay them enough that losing their pay is actually a punishment, or punish them enough that the threat of jail time counters the benefit of accepting bribes (or ideally, a bit of both).
Anyhow, neither problem can be solved in the amount of time that the troika has expected Greece to solve them - and they ARE economic problems, not moral ones.
These places all have other things going for them, though.
Why don't you move to a small town in Nebraska and pay all the Federal and State taxes as well as a 20% income tax, 10% property tax, 20% sales tax, etc. Oh, because you want something for your tax money? Hmmmm.
Please don't do that—it only makes the thread worse, and adds nothing of substance to your comment.
Varoufakis stated:
"Based on months of negotiation, my conviction is that
the German finance minister wants Greece to be pushed out
of the single currency to put the fear of God into the
French and have them accept his model of a disciplinarian
eurozone."
Therefore they are playing the long game, and for that to work, Greece needs to capitulate and exit the Euro. The Eurogroup has tried to make it impossible for Greece to stay in the Euro, but Greece won't bite.Once Greece do exit the Euro, the rest of Europe will see the incredible pain that is involved when your national banks have the rugs pulled out from underneath them.
Once France understands that they have to change or end up like Greece, they'll change. They'll have no choice.
It is an economic invasion at state level.
“Only the French minister [Michel Sapin] made noises that
were different from the German line, and those noises were
very subtle. You could sense he had to use very judicious
language, to be seen not to oppose. And in the final
analysis, when Dr Schäuble responded and effectively
determined the official line, the French minister would
always fold.”France will leave the Eurozone before that happens. There's already discontent with the EU and Euro in France, nationalists rising, etc...
And they're a strong enough economy that leaving the Euro wouldn't leave them with worthless francs...
"In occupied Iraq, the introduction of new paper money took almost a
year, 20 or so Boeing 747s, the mobilisation of the US military’s
might, three printing firms and hundreds of trucks. In the absence of
such support, Grexit would be the equivalent of announcing a large
devaluation more than 18 months in advance: a recipe for liquidating
all Greek capital stock and transferring it abroad by any means
available."
You think France could go back to the Franc without outside help? I highly doubt it. The point Schauble is trying to make is that if France wants to go the way of Greece, it would only involve lots and lots of pain. Abide by their rules, or else.So either they get their act together, which will be very hard due to mentality and political culture, or it will get much worse before it gets better. If France falls, it will be the end of the Euro. Germany is trying to fix these issues, in order to save the historical project of the European Union. Saying that Germany is just economically invading Greece is dishonest, there are huge amounts of German (and other country's) taxpayer money involved. Most people have written them off already.
now, it's a set up. that's the premise of his statements in this article. you disagree or character assassinate, either or, but you don't propose an alternative except the tired lines about Greeks spending other peoples money. Go. learn something. come back when you know something about international finance, the Eurogroup, the ECB, the last 5 years of austerity, the last 2 Greek governments, the German Sub deal (anecdotal, not endemic, but representative of the nature of such transactions) and the macro economics of how +-5 million people shall fare over the next 20-50 years. You come across as a jerk, mean-spirited, and ignorant. Your comment was troll bait and more insulting than any of the articles rhetoric. You use the term "leftie" to describe folks of any political persuasion who make take umbrage at the blatant mafia structure at the core of the euro (currency) laid bare over the last weeks. Please DO go study a bit before you show your face around here again. Thanks Aaron
Greece is in a situation where their economy desperately needs any kind of stimulus. Instead, the rest of Europe decides to make an example of them by forcing them to implement austerity measures that target the masses (and not the tax-evading elite) because that is the fastest way to collect more taxes and cut public spending in a short timeframe (VAT increases, pension cuts). This is the total opposite of what Europe was doing when they were hit by the crisis.
Obviously, the European leadership wasn't happy when someone who understood this and was willing to speak up about it came into power in Greece. Luckily, the media was happy as ever to make this a human interest story and focused on Varoufakis' lifestyle instead of actually looking at what they were trying to achieve and how Greece was in an impossible situation. They've been in power for about 6 months now and are somehow responsible for all the tax evasion, public spending mistakes and, really, anything else Greece gets blamed for.
Where have you been?
The policies imposed to Greece don't make more sense this time that they did the last time, and the last, and the last. But yes, we should all listen to the wise neoliberal policymakers, including the humble Herr Schäuble.
Schäuble, who presides over the public KfW-Bank, which hosts the Greek recovery fund, where 15bn EUR in Greek assets are supposed to end up.
I wonder which transactions will be 'lost' this time.
"When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names."
But I sure can appreciate him speaking English rather than some bureaucratic newspeak that is the norm among elected (and non-elected) officials.
And I can appreciate that he deeply cares for his people over holding on to his government job.
I will take occasional hyperboles over content-free mambo-jumbo any time.
What did you find particularly "stoneage" in his ideas?
It's not the first time I notice criticism (a rather empty one) of "left ideas" based on "being old". Isn't it a little non-sensical, to criticize ideas for being old?
Stoneage lefties like to discuss, well, preach, all day long while spending other (EU) citizen's money. Greece will be saved when he and the anarcho-communist-syndicalist grufties start to modernize greece, e.g. do something again the blatant corruption, burocratie and tax evasion instead of hindering startups, business and innovative people. Imho.