News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by velcro on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @04:19AM (#9883478)
Bugs are always bad (and security bugs even more so) - but I've always felt that Flash gets a disproportional amount of hate/hype in the media. To some degree it should be normal that the more widespread a technology is - the more it gets targeted for security exploits.

If you run the popular browsers/plugins against the National Vulnerability Database, you'd get the following results (as of January 2014):

  - Internet Explorer 366 total vulnerability issues (314 high severity)

  - Google Chrome 235 total vulnerability issues (154 high severity)

  - Adobe Flash 207 total vulnerability issues (169 high  severity)

  - Mozilla Firefox 190 total vulnerability issues (86 high severity)

  - Oracle Java 161 total vulnerability issues (69 high severity)
[source] https://nvd.nist.gov/
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by proactivesvcs on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @06:01AM (#9883804)
I have a lot of experience of end users and they are forever telling me that they get so many different "Update this", "Update that" windows that they can no longer distinguish real from fake. Some of them have been tricked by fake web site pop-ups as a result, others ignore legitimate update messages. I do not blame them.

Internet Explorer and Google Chrome get updated in a way that most end users find to be simple to understand, particularly with Chrome. Firefox is also quite good in this regard. All of them are reliable - it is rare, IME, to come across a Windows Update, Firefox or Chrome instance which is silently failing to update. Or not even bothering to prompt to update.

Flash, however often I install it, just doesn't seem to auto-update reliably. Quite often it only does so after a user log on/reboot, which doesn't happen much in the days of standby. Even on brand new, fresh Windows installs (so we know the OS/Flash isn't broken), I test Flash from time to time and it just doesn't prompt to update at all on some occasions. This is what makes Adobe's poor track record exponentially worse - that their software update mechanism is crap at best.

I was gobsmacked when Microsoft declared they were going to start updating Flash via Windows Update. Gobsmacked and so very relieved. It felt like they'd walked into Adobe's office, grabbed their fire extinguishers and told them "You are so useless that when there's a fire, WE will come and put it out, since you don't seem able to. We are sick of our offices getting burned down because of your idle incompetence."

I won't even address Oracle's Java. Bundling malware with their updater is tantamount to crime.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by jfuhrman on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @08:38AM (#9884367)
Flash bundles things like Chrome, Mcafee etc.

That's the real reason they don't want a auto-update. Google pays them a lot for bundling Chrome(I think it's around $1 per install). They keep breaking the auto-update on purpose so that they can make a ton of money by bundling other software. Same with Java updates.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by digi_owl on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:22AM (#9884628)
And that's downright weird, given that Chrome use a different plugin API and thus get Flash bundled.

Even Windows has Flash via the updater.

Just about the only browser that use the old API is Firefox.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by snuxoll on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @12:11PM (#9885979)
Shock, the only browser that still uses NPAPI is the descendant of the one that invented it!

Really, at this point I think Mozilla is more interested in just getting rid of plugins than trying to implement an alternative to NPAPI - why put all the effort in to support something like PPAPI when plugins should be dead within the decade anyway?

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by pcwalton on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @01:54PM (#9886753)
It's not a secret. The replacement for NPAPI is the Web APIs. The port of Flash to the new NPAPI--the Web APIs--is called Shumway.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by proactivesvcs on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @08:40AM (#9884375)
ah yes good point! I've used a different install method for so long I forgot that. So again, tantamount to crime.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by joosters on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @07:39AM (#9884091)
Yes! I admin my parents' computers and after trying to explain which 'update' windows are genuine, I realised that there just isn't a good way to tell them apart.

Silent auto-updates are really the right way to go for non-techies. Even the post-upgrade 'announcement' popups are confusing. For instance, I've installed Ghostery on their computers and the 'ghostery has been updated' popup is just confusing for them, leading to confusion and phone calls to me.

Flash also doesn't seem to auto-update for them, despite me setting it up. I don't understand it either, as they turn off & on the machine regularly. Why can't Adobe get this right?

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by digi_owl on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:24AM (#9884645)
Given other comments here, i find myself once more reminded of Upton Sinclair.

"It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!"

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by Coding_Cat on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @06:15AM (#9883844)
Flash also comes with McAffee (or some other bundleware). I wouldn't be surprised if the reason why they haven't made a proper auto-updater is because of that. That they'd miss out on those miniscule profits they get from that.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by kijin on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @07:12AM (#9884001)
Yeah, I've been wondering why Adobe sticks to a "visit our website and manually download the new version" update model in this day and age. I think you found the answer.

If you keep ignoring the update prompt, Flash will quietly update itself after 45 days. That's long enough for every interested party to pwn your machine.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by Karunamon on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @02:59PM (#9887244)
This right here pretty much kills any sympathy I had for Adobe in this matter. They sit on their hands for far too long when vulns are announced, and when they do get updates out, they use a completely backwards and useless update model in the name of extracting a few pennies per user.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by syntheticnature on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @07:25AM (#9884042)
I have had multiple non-technical friends, in one case on a fresh install I'd done myself, run into the Flash update window simply showing a gray background that never does anything.

The best solution for this, from Adobe's own forum? Find the corporate-deployment version, download that (ignoring the messages that say it isn't what you want) and run it. This works flawlessly, but even less automatically.

Both the Flash and Java updates almost feel like "Pay Attention To Me!" Just like all those discount cards that exist in part so you carry around a fetish with the corporate logo.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by fao_ on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @06:22AM (#9883855)

  I have a lot of experience of end users and they are 
  forever telling me that they get so many different "Update 
  this", "Update that" windows that they can no longer 
  distinguish real from fake. Some of them have been tricked 
  by fake web site pop-ups as a result, others ignore 
  legitimate update messages. I do not blame them.
One solution to this is to use AdBlock Plus. When a site permits adverts that threaten a computer's security, it is time to add it to the blocklist.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by degenerate on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @08:26AM (#9884303)
Not ABP, ublock origin. Faster and not-for-profit: https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock#performance
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by fao_ on Thursday July 16, 2015 @09:42AM (#9897074)
Ah, and apparently (one other commenter mentioned it) ABP did a deal with advertisers.

Ugh (damn capitalism!), I think I shall move to ublock origin today then.

Thank you for letting me know about it :)

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by sbarre on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @06:31AM (#9883885)
This is not a feasible solution for the average end user.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by tim333 on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @06:56AM (#9883951)
It seems to work ok if you install it for them - I now tend to do that for non tech users who I help out. Though usually uBlock rather than AdBlock Plus. It's scary if you go to a download site these days how many fake download buttons there are near the real one if you don't do something like that.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by scholia on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:25AM (#9885090)
One notable exception is Major Geeks. However, it's important to donate them a few bucks for staff and bandwidth because they are giving up a ton of money by not bundling crapware and confusing people. http://www.majorgeeks.com/mg/topdownloads/index.html
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by gorgak on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @07:04AM (#9883970)
i also use ublock (but ublock origin) because of that whitelist deal that adblock did with er people what make ads.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by stevenh on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @04:40AM (#9883542)
Remote code execution exploits were found in Firefox at least once per month during the first half of 2015. The only reason we didn't hear about these cataclysmic exploits is because it wasn't Flash.

January 20, 2015: https://community.rapid7.com/community/metasploit/blog/2015/...

February 25, 2015: https://msisac.cisecurity.org/advisories/2015/2015-018.cfm

March 1, 2015: https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/security/advisories/mfsa2015-3...

April 22, 2015: https://msisac.cisecurity.org/advisories/2015/2015-046.cfm

May 12, 2015: https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/security/advisories/mfsa2015-5...

Hackers search for remote code execution exploits in Flash first and foremost because they know a successful Flash exploit will reach the highest number of targets (90% or more on the desktop) whereas only 44% of desktop machines are running Chrome and 15% are running Firefox.

Hackers seeking out and exploiting RCE bugs in Firefox is unheard of for the same reason malware targeting Macs has been virtually unheard of over the past decade: It's not that OS X is more secure; it's simply that Windows is a more lucrative target.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by rockdoe on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @05:36AM (#9883711)
Mozilla seems to take anywhere from 1 to 3 months to fix these severe bugs. Adobe takes days.

Source for this complete and utter FUD? Certainly not the links you gave:

Jan 11, 2015: Originally reported to Mozilla as a low-severity DoS, which turned out to be already patched in trunk Jan 13, 2015: Firefox 35.0 shipped with patch

It's hard to get dates out of the others because the bugs are still hidden, but the "fixed in" is often a security fix update after a release, which means it can't possibly have been > 6 weeks.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by stevenh on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @05:58AM (#9883796)
You're right, I misinterpreted the timeline there.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by DavideNL on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @08:13AM (#9884224)
> If you run the popular browsers/plugins against the National Vulnerability Database...

That's misusing statistics, you can't determine how secure something is by just summing up the number of vulnerabilities - equally weighing/comparing browsers with a plugin etc.

By the way, Apple's opinion on Flash in 2010:

Third, there’s reliability, security and performance. Symantec recently highlighted Flash for having one of the worst security records in 2009. We also know first hand that Flash is the number one reason Macs crash. We have been working with Adobe to fix these problems, but they have persisted for several years now. We don’t want to reduce the reliability and security of our iPhones, iPods and iPads by adding Flash.

Source: https://www.apple.com/hotnews/thoughts-on-flash/

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by ArtDev on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @12:00PM (#9885890)
Flash is blocked on Apple devices due to business reasons, nothing more.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by oldmanjay on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @01:16PM (#9886464)
Flash is not blocked, it is simply not present.

Also, considering the track record of Flash on Android, your opinion is not supported by historical fact. It is very clear that Adobe is not on the ball to anyone who pays attention.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by ssalazar on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @02:14PM (#9886931)
Sure, and one of those business reasons is keeping bloated, buggy software that is ill-suited to mobile devices away from their phone's user experience.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by doodpants on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @01:24PM (#9886520)
Flash was never "blocked" on Apple devices. Rather, Safari on iOS simply doesn't support plugins. You can't install Java, Silverlight, or Unity 3D plugins either.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by onion2k on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @04:36AM (#9883529)
So Flash is second in terms of number of high severity bugs and first in terms of the percentage of bugs that are high severity, only being beaten by Internet Explorer. By your evidence the hate for Flash is quite justifiable.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by philh on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @05:42AM (#9883730)
It's second to IE in both those metrics, but "percentage of bugs that are high severity" seems like a strange thing to be measuring in any case.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by jfoster on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @07:57AM (#9884158)
Perhaps it's intended as a proxy for overall quality.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by ild on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @06:02AM (#9883808)
Flash bugs are more important because the are crossbrowser. I will still use Flash though on older computers, because it needs less resources for video.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by braythwayt on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @07:19AM (#9884029)
Yes but Flash vulnerabilities are incremental vulnerabilities.

So just counting high severity vulnerabilities, the chart is

IE: 314. IE with Flash: 483.

Chrome: 154: Chrome with Flash: 323.

Firefox: 86. Firefox with Flash: 255.

And of course, you can add a third column for Java and a fourth column for browser with Flash and Java.

I have no idea what their bugs-per-line-of-code are, perhaps they have the finest code on the planet. But from a surface area perspective, installing Flash makes you more vulnerable, period. And it really is not necessary, whereas it’s not like you can browse the web in pure Flash and not install a browser.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by anon1385 on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @08:21AM (#9884270)
>But from a surface area perspective, installing Flash makes you more vulnerable, period.

So does turning on Javascript. Yet the popular opinion these days is that disabling Javascript makes you a luddite. Mozilla even hid the option for it in Firefox.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by yRetsyM on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @04:30AM (#9883506)
Yes, but Flash alone doubles the attack vector of a browser - that's nothing to be sneezed at. I think it's particularly poignant when you look at the high severity metric.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by tiplus on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:05AM (#9884515)
I am not sure the attack vector argument is 100% valid here, as flash replacement technologies constantly add attack vectors to modern browsers, too. Many traditional Flash features are now covered by webGL accelerated browser functionality, like accelerated 2D canvas elements. My guess would be that this browser-gpu bridge creates a whole zoo of GPU driver related security issues which attackers might focus on once flash is completely obsolete. (My money is on a remote code execution vulnerability in the Firefox Adobe DRM module.)
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by vbezhenar on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @05:59AM (#9883798)
Turing-complete machine running untrusted code is a nightmare for security. There always be bugs and exploits, it's just a matter of time and effort to find them.

JavaScript enabled by default is already bad enough. We don't need Flash, Java, ActiveX or anything similar turned on by default. So it's a good move from security viewpoint. Less attack surface.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by paublyrne on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @05:09AM (#9883624)
They do get more bad press than perhaps others should. There is already a perception about Flash that it is not a great product, which feeds into this. Reasons are varied.

    - Performance has not been good on Macs (my 2007 Macbook Pro literally burned my legs when running anything flashy)

    - Flash updates mechanism seems a little spammy.

    - Long-term perception of Adobe as a maker of a somewhat buggy, somewhat bloated software

    - Steve Jobs' public denigration

    - Backlash against proprietary standards being used on the web
The best thing about click to play Flash is it puts a stop to autoplay videos on the less reputable sites I occasionally and shamefully glance at for sports news.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by visarga on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @06:52AM (#9883937)
... and makes pages load faster.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by jafingi on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @06:38AM (#9883901)
So by disabling Flash by default, Mozilla can theoretically reduce vulnerabilities by half :-) Seems like a good choice to me!

Also, getting rid of the constant update dialogs and crapware installed with Flash will improve the overall user experience.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by Mimu on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @05:10AM (#9883627)
I don't think the hate comes from bugs or exploits. I think people hate flash because it is laggy, slow, make things move in your screen you don't want, widely use for ads or to shit on the user experience, etc.

Granted most of it might be bad programming, but I still think he comes from here rather than exploits.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by kristopolous on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @11:37AM (#9885715)
Clearly all this crap will still happen in a flash free world.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by belorn on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:02AM (#9884940)
In general, plugins are supposed to improve a product by adding or enhancing existing features. Flash however enables websites to break out of the HTML, CSS and JS environments and their security constraints, which should mean that flash have a larger responsibility regarding security. If Flash lived under the constraints of the browser own security, then flash bugs would barely register as news worthy.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by zimbatm on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @08:53AM (#9884439)
Another point that hasn't been raised yet: Flash is a much smaller software than a browser, how come it has more bugs ? It certainly speaks for it's internal code quality.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by halayli on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @05:07AM (#9883617)
You probably missed out on the hacking team leaks. These actions are triggered by the leaks. HT was sitting on a lot of flash 0-day exploits.

This leak was the best thing that happened to the web.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by richardw on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @07:19AM (#9884027)
Cost/benefit seems higher for Flash/Java than browsers. You really need a browser, but you don't really need a [fancy thing that can't be done in JS]. As another commenter said, it doubles your attack surface and for little benefit.

Flash game enthusiasts would probably disagree, but most of us can probably do without it given the risk.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by syntheticnature on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @07:29AM (#9884061)
As an enthusiast for a handful of flash games, it is increasingly tempting to make a VM just for running them. Even then, with all the progress in Javascript, it's questionable whether I should bother.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by richardw on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @06:39AM (#9890610)
There are a couple flash games I'd like to keep as well, but mentioning that didn't seem to strengthen my point :)

I've since found a few work-related apps that need it. Hiss.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by bzbarsky on Thursday July 16, 2015 @01:20AM (#9895589)
The bigger question is how many of those were 0-days: vulnerabilities that were public before a version of the software with the fix had shipped.