News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by ISL on Thursday July 09, 2015 @02:26PM (#9859761)

  U.S. Constitution, Article I, Section 9:
  No Bill of Attainder or ex post facto Law shall be passed.
How does that square with the article's

"The new I.R.S. guidance will be retroactive, applying to all transactions as far back as Jan. 1, 2011."

?

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by dragonwriter on Thursday July 09, 2015 @02:35PM (#9859813)
Ex post facto laws are criminal laws making criminal acts that were not criminal before the law was passed, or increasing the criminal punishment for crimes committed before the law was passed.

Retroactive tax laws are not ex post facto laws, and, anyway, this isn't even a retroactive tax law, its a decision about the manner in which the IRS will apply a law already on the books, which is only sustainable to the extent to which it is, in fact, consistent with the law already on the books. Its essentially the IRS coming to the view that they have not been properly enforcing existing law, and that will change for enforcement going forward (there are limits to how far back the IRS can go in enforcement actions, which presumably is the basis for the 1/1/2011 date.)

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by DannyBee on Thursday July 09, 2015 @02:50PM (#9859930)
1. In the US, the supreme court has repeatedly held that the ex-post-facto clause only applies to criminal laws (See Calder v. Bull, which was decided in 1798).

This is actually consistent with the history of the clause (It was understood to apply to criminal laws. Motions were made to change the wording to say it also applied to civil cases, they were turned down)

2. This is not a law, and may not even be administrative rulemaking (depending on what exactly they issued)

Of course, even if it was, you have a mechanism to challenge it if they hold you to it: the courts.

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by a3camero on Thursday July 09, 2015 @05:50PM (#9860949)
I wouldn't be so quick to buy into the modern idea that this prohibition was always aimed at criminal laws. Excerpted from a paper I wrote in law school on the topic (sources at end of post):

Newly independent Americans in the late 1700s were very concerned with “this shameful abuse of power”, “those engines of oppression”, ex post facto laws. American businessmen were concerned with the macroeconomic effects and unfairness of interference with contracts by provincial/state legislatures.

One of the shameful abuses was the “paper money laws” that changed outstanding debts by permitting payment in paper money where the contract originally called for the use of gold or silver. There was widespread fear of the drying up of credit (in the context of an ongoing major depression at the time) as a result of concern that loans might not be paid back due to legislative intervention.

The dictionary of reference in 1739, Giles Jacob’s Law Dictionary, defined “ex post facto” as “a Term used in the Law, signifying some Thing done after another Thing that was committed before”.

Check out these sources: William Winslow Crosskey, “The True Meaning of the Constitutional Prohibition of Ex-Post-Facto Laws” (1947) 14 U Chicago L Rev 539

Roger W Weiss, “The Issue of Paper Money in the American Colonies, 1720-1774” (1970) 30 J of Economic History 770

Elmer E Smead, “The Rule Against Retroactive Legislation: A Basic Principle of Jurisprudence” (1935) 20 Minn L Rev 775

Harold J Krent, “The Puzzling Boundary Between Criminal and Civil Retroactive Lawmaking” (1996) 84 Georgia L J 2143

W David Slawson, “Constitutional and Legislative Considerations in Retroactive Lawmaking” (48) California L Rev 216

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by ISL on Thursday July 09, 2015 @03:21PM (#9860119)
If the IRS doesn't think I've paid my taxes, I can go to prison.

Doesn't that make this particular case a criminal one?

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by dragonwriter on Thursday July 09, 2015 @03:25PM (#9860144)
> If the IRS doesn't think I've paid my taxes, I can go to prison.

No, if the IRS doesn't think you've paid your taxes, they can attempt to collect the unpaid taxes.

OTOH, if the Department of Justice can prove in a criminal prosecution that you've violated the criminal provisions of the tax law, you can go to prison. If the IRS thinks you've done that (which is different from just not paying your taxes), they can refer you to the DoJ for prosecution.

This change to IRS guidance doesn't change the criminal provisions of the tax law that would apply were the government to prosecute you, therefore, the change is not a change to criminal law, retroactive or otherwise.

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by bd_at_rivenhill on Thursday July 09, 2015 @11:23PM (#9862128)
Fortunately, tax law has been made so complex that the Supreme Court eventually decided that ignorance is a defense: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cheek_v._United_States

So you may end up with penalties and interest, but you have a high probability of avoiding prison absent doing something stupid like trading emails with your broker on how you plan to evade taxes.

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by tsotha on Friday July 10, 2015 @02:30AM (#9862565)
It's only a criminal matter if the IRS thinks you broke the law deliberately. If it's the result of crappy record keeping or something you didn't understand they'll usually tack on some penalties and interest and call it a day.

I know a guy who didn't even file for five or six years. Eventually he got a lawyer and made a deal which had him paying some fraction of his original tax liability.

They'll put you in jail if you make them, but they don't really want to put you in jail. They just want your money.

Oh, this guy? After getting his sweet deal he didn't actually pay them. I think he may end up in jail.

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by alexbock on Thursday July 09, 2015 @02:41PM (#9859864)
I'm guessing the idea here is that the IRS is changing how they interpret their own internal policy for how they will use the powers given to them by an existing law, rather than outright passing a new law with retroactive effects.

...but that justification seems like a horribly slippery slope. If you accept that logic, what stops congress from passing a law that creates the "Criminal Investigation Service" and gives their director the power to make things illegal? Would he then be allowed to make a "policy change" retroactively making something illegal and arresting them for it?

edit: I think Peugh v. United States actually answers this. Retroactive application of changes to US sentencing guidelines by a government commission were ruled to be a violation of ex post facto protections.

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by jeremyt on Thursday July 09, 2015 @02:30PM (#9859787)
Well, in this case the IRS isn't passing a retroactive law, they are clarifying the interpretation of an existing law.
Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by tanderson92 on Thursday July 09, 2015 @02:33PM (#9859806)
The need to clarify the point implies that it was interpreted differently in the past. So this change in interpretation being applied retroactively is what the OP is concerned with.
Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by dragonwriter on Thursday July 09, 2015 @02:37PM (#9859829)
Interpretation isn't law, so in any legal dispute over the IRS actions under the current interpretation, the law which would be controlling is not retroactive.

Not to mention that there is solid precedent that retroactive taxes are not, in general, ex post facto laws in the first place, such that even if this was Congress adopting a retroactive tax law, it still wouldn't fall afoul of the ex post facto prohibition.

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by tanderson92 on Thursday July 09, 2015 @02:53PM (#9859950)
> Interpretation isn't law, so in any legal dispute over the

> IRS actions under the current interpretation, the law which

> would be controlling is not retroactive.

This is to me a very weak argument (not that I disagree that this may be the standard that is applied in practice). If the Congress passed a law saying "the IRS can set tax code as it sees fit" and the IRS proceeds to levy taxes all the way back to 1980 on people as however it so desires, you should not be allowed to use that law as grounds for not having violated the ex post facto requirement. If this is the current understanding of what is allowed, I must vigorously object to whichever judgement left this precedent.

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by dragonwriter on Thursday July 09, 2015 @03:00PM (#9859997)
> If the Congress passed a law saying "the IRS can set tax code as it sees fit"

Then this would be an unconstitutional delegation of legislative authority to the executive. [0] Rendering the consideration of whether any executive action under it would constitute an ex post facto law moot -- if Congress purports to delegate enough power to the executive that retroactive executive action under it would be an ex post facto law, than the whole scheme is an unconstitutional delegation of legislative power whether or not it is applied retroactively.

Heck, even though retroactive taxation isn't generally ex post facto law (which is retroactive criminalization or enhancement of criminal penalties), the law you propose would be an unconstitutional delegation.

> If this is the current understanding of what is allowed

Its not, its just the prohibition that prevents it has nothing to do with (and is much broader than) the ex post facto law prohibition.

[0] See, e.g., https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nondelegation_doctrine#United_...

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by tanderson92 on Thursday July 09, 2015 @03:15PM (#9860086)
> Then this would be an unconstitutional delegation of legislative authority to the executive

And yet this is what we seem to be experiencing in this case, where the IRS can make a policy interpretation retroactively to the tune of $6 billion for a single taxpayer. Your source indicates that congress allows the IRS to decide tax policy, but since tax evasion is itself a crime it seems to indirectly violate the ex post facto law prohibition.

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by dragonwriter on Thursday July 09, 2015 @03:32PM (#9860173)
> And yet this is what we seem to be experiencing in this case

No, Congress passing a law saying that "IRS can set taxes at any level they want" is not what we are seeing.

If you want to argue that the actual laws Congress has passed are unconstitutional delegations, please, point to the specific laws, and make that argument.

> but since tax evasion is itself a crime it seems to indirectly violate the ex post facto law prohibition.

Evasion is a different thing than non-payment. No act that occurred in the past that was not evasion when it occurred becomes evasion as a result of this change in application.

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by tanderson92 on Thursday July 09, 2015 @04:19PM (#9860409)
> Evasion is a different thing than non-payment. No act that occurred in the past that was not evasion when it occurred becomes evasion as a result of this change in application.

Incorrect, but I can see how you might think so. It is the same because if I disagree with the IRS and refuse payment then according to https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/tax_evasion, I have committed tax evasion.

So yes, since the IRS can adjust my tax burden retroactively, tax evasion is involved. Suppose in 2012 I filed my tax returns and was fully honest. The IRS agreed, but now in 2015 they change the 'interpretation', and if I disagree with the new tax they are levying on me, presto chango! I can now be convicted of tax evasion for refusing to pay this arbitrary retroactive tax.

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by dragonwriter on Thursday July 09, 2015 @04:47PM (#9860579)
> It is the same because if I disagree with the IRS and refuse payment

Nonpayment and refusing payment are different things. The act of refusal would happen after the policy change, therefore, the only act that might even arguably be criminalized is an act that would occur after the change, and no retroactive criminalization has occurred.

No act before the policy was adopted is criminalized, even by your characterization.

Now, if the actual law allows arbitrary changes to tax calculation by the IRS, you could argue a nondelegation doctrine violation, rather than an ex post facto violation. But to argue that, you'd actually have to point to the provision of law at issue.

Or you could argue that the policy change is inconsistent with the law Congress has adopted. But, again, you'd have to actually point to the specific provisions that are violated to do that.

If, finally, the IRS simply failed to correctly apply the law as Congress wrote it previously, and the change in guidance is simply closing a gap between IRS policy and the law written by Congress, then you can maybe fault what the IRS was doing before (though, of course, no taxpayer would challenge an overly lax application of the law -- or even have standing to do so), but not what they are doing now.

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by tanderson92 on Thursday July 09, 2015 @05:49PM (#9860942)
Or I could ignore what are obviously semantics following a clear retroactive change in US policy that affects criminal law. It doesn't have to be as complex as you make it out to be.

The NYT even called it a retroactive policy change!

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by dragonwriter on Thursday July 09, 2015 @06:02PM (#9861004)
> Or I could ignore what are obviously semantics following a clear retroactive change in US policy that affects criminal law.

You can ignore whatever you want, but it doesn't change what the words in the Constitution meant in the context they were written, and have been consistently been interpreted by the courts to mean. Arguing that something is unconstitutional just because you've invented an entirely ahistorical set of definitions of the words used is, well, not all that unusual, but still not particularly interesting.

> It doesn't have to be as complex as you make it out to be.

Its not at all complex: A government action is an ex post facto law if it criminalizes, or increases the criminal sanction for, an event that occurred before the act occurred. Even by your own characterization, the only thing this might criminalize is a refusal to pay the newly-calculated tax after the policy. So, no ex post facto law.

You can argue that it is undesirable for other reasons, but you can rest on the Constitutional prohibition of ex post facto laws to do that when its not an ex post facto law.

> The NYT even called it a retroactive policy change!

Its obviously a retroactive policy change, in that it applies to IRS assessment of taxes for prior tax years.

No act that was committed in those tax years becomes criminal because of the policy change, so its not an action which retroactively criminalizes an act or increases the criminal penalty for an act.

"Retroactive policy change" and "ex post facto law" aren't the same thing.

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by charlesdm on Thursday July 09, 2015 @05:13PM (#9860735)
And then you go to court and ask a judge, who is (in general) a neutral party, to interpret the law based on the situation and ask what the correct course of action was.

I guess people have different definitions of evasion, but I would probably define it as having the intent to evade taxes "from the start". As a citizen (or a corporation), you are free to decide on your own interpretation of the law. Tax authorities (around the globe) aren't always right. Hence you ask a judge, because an interpretation is just that: an interpretation. It's not the law. And the law is the only thing that counts.

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by tanderson92 on Thursday July 09, 2015 @05:53PM (#9860965)
> I would probably define it as...

The legal standard for proving tax evasion disagrees with you.

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by charlesdm on Thursday July 09, 2015 @07:03PM (#9861283)
Well, then you just need to make sure your interpretation of the law is more correct than the one of the administration. :-)

Innocent until proven guilty?

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by gohrt on Thursday July 09, 2015 @07:47PM (#9861472)
> I can now be convicted of tax evasion for refusing to pay

Yes, for refusing to pay. If you concede to the IRS interpretation, you just pay the amount you owe plus interest and fees.

> this arbitrary retroactive tax.

that's not what it is

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by gohrt on Thursday July 09, 2015 @02:37PM (#9859836)
but OP's concerns don't matter. The Constitution's concerns matter.

"Battery" is a crime. If the state decides that "smacking someone's back" meets the definition of battery, they can prosecute people who committed that act before the clarification, as long as a judge finds their interpretation to be consistent with the wording of the law.

Law is not computer code that fully specifies a simulation in advance.

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by mahyarm on Thursday July 09, 2015 @02:52PM (#9859945)
So rule decider type B (judges) can effectively create retroactive laws/policies. An interpretation that is enforced is as good as a law.
Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by ForHackernews on Thursday July 09, 2015 @05:55PM (#9860972)
Yes, obviously. How did you think courts worked?
Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by tanderson92 on Thursday July 09, 2015 @02:57PM (#9859979)
I would set up the situation more like the state passing a law saying that an agency, call it the Battery Protection Agency (BPA), can decide what constitutes battery. Then the BPA decides in 2015 that verbal abuse and insults constitutes battery, and prosecutors proceed to arrest people for insults going back 5 years before the BPA's 2015 decision.

The parallels to the IRS case should be obvious, and the above hypothetical scenario is very much what the constitution was meant to protect against.

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by dragonwriter on Thursday July 09, 2015 @03:35PM (#9860195)
> The parallels to the IRS case should be obvious

Please point the specific provision(s) of law parallel to the one in your hypothetical, both as to the unlimited discretion and as to the discretion to decide what constitutes criminal punishment.

Because I don't think the parallels are at all obvious.

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by tanderson92 on Thursday July 09, 2015 @03:56PM (#9860296)
Exactly, my hypothetical would universally not be allowed and is forbidden (esp. by the nondelegation doctrine). The point is that the two situations are very similar in spirit.

I never said the discretion was unlimited; rather, I think that any retroactive decision in guidance/policy/interpretation is prohibited by the constitution. The words are just semantics.

IRS tax avoidance constitutes criminal punishment.

Thanks for the downvotes, everyone.

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by dragonwriter on Thursday July 09, 2015 @04:40PM (#9860525)
> The point is that the two situations are very similar in spirit.

You keep asserting that, but you have failed to even begin to argue that.

> rather, I think that any retroactive decision in guidance/policy/interpretation is prohibited by the constitution.

You are welcome to think that, however, that's not consistent with the history of the use "ex post facto law", which was a legal term of art already in existence at the time the Constitution was written, and whose scope of meaning in the Constitution since, practically, the ink was still wet on the Constitution.

> IRS tax avoidance constitutes criminal punishment.

No, tax avoidance (which is structuring activities in awareness of the law so as not to incur tax liability) isn't something that is subject to criminal punishment; it is perfectly legal.

Nonpayment of tax isn't legal, but isn't generally criminal either.

Tax evasion is criminal, but involves things like false representation to avoid tax liability being correctly assessed. Following the then-current IRS guidance isn't evasion, and doesn't retroactively become evasion when the guidance changes, even though the change in guidance may change the IRS's computation of tax due.

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by tanderson92 on Thursday July 09, 2015 @05:47PM (#9860929)
I believe a reasonable person wills see the situations' similarity. I am not attempting to convince you since you are not interested.

There seems to be no good word for nonpayment of tax; tax evasion you take issue with elsewhere, tax avoidance is not the correct word I agree, but I don't know what word you really would like.

One thing is very clear: the IRS will take what it feels is due ('legally', or retroactively legal) and is willing to use the criminal justice system to do so. I and any freedom-loving American see this as a gross violation of the constitution.

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by Frondo on Thursday July 09, 2015 @11:04PM (#9862078)
I am a freedom-loving American and I do not consider this a gross violation of the constitution.

I consider the IRS as a necessary and permitted part of governance, as a way to pay for the many benefits I enjoy for living in a (mostly) civilized nation.

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by tanderson92 on Thursday July 09, 2015 @11:55PM (#9862226)
Very few people consider the IRS itself to be unconstitutional.

I at least of course do not see the IRS proper as a gross violation of the constitution. Rather, the retroactive judgement of tax owed is a gross violation. That is the context we are having this conversation in, whether the government can retroactively decide that you owe tax to it, in apparent violation of (the spirit, anyway) the constitution.

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by whatgoodisaroad on Thursday July 09, 2015 @02:31PM (#9859793)
My guess would be that because this is "guidance" rather than a law or "bill" then this is not ex post facto application.

In other words, the law is and aways has been that one should pay the appropriate taxes. OTOH, guidance informs the IRS how to interpret market activity in the past and classify it as legal or illegal.

Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by p0ckets on Thursday July 09, 2015 @02:37PM (#9859828)
The IRS doesn't pass laws, it's just issuing a guideline on how it will interpret existing tax law.
Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by sneak on Thursday July 09, 2015 @06:23PM (#9861099)
But if those interpretations are authoritative and violation of the current IRS interpretation (but not the previous one) means you get prosecuted in federal court, how is that not effectively the ability to retroactively change laws?
Re:I.R.S. Cracks Down on Hedge Fund Tax Strategy by ceejayoz on Thursday July 09, 2015 @02:35PM (#9859818)
No new law is being passed.