Newly independent Americans in the late 1700s were very concerned with “this shameful abuse of power”, “those engines of oppression”, ex post facto laws. American businessmen were concerned with the macroeconomic effects and unfairness of interference with contracts by provincial/state legislatures.
One of the shameful abuses was the “paper money laws” that changed outstanding debts by permitting payment in paper money where the contract originally called for the use of gold or silver. There was widespread fear of the drying up of credit (in the context of an ongoing major depression at the time) as a result of concern that loans might not be paid back due to legislative intervention.
The dictionary of reference in 1739, Giles Jacob’s Law Dictionary, defined “ex post facto” as “a Term used in the Law, signifying some Thing done after another Thing that was committed before”.
Check out these sources: William Winslow Crosskey, “The True Meaning of the Constitutional Prohibition of Ex-Post-Facto Laws” (1947) 14 U Chicago L Rev 539
Roger W Weiss, “The Issue of Paper Money in the American Colonies, 1720-1774” (1970) 30 J of Economic History 770
Elmer E Smead, “The Rule Against Retroactive Legislation: A Basic Principle of Jurisprudence” (1935) 20 Minn L Rev 775
Harold J Krent, “The Puzzling Boundary Between Criminal and Civil Retroactive Lawmaking” (1996) 84 Georgia L J 2143
W David Slawson, “Constitutional and Legislative Considerations in Retroactive Lawmaking” (48) California L Rev 216
Doesn't that make this particular case a criminal one?
No, if the IRS doesn't think you've paid your taxes, they can attempt to collect the unpaid taxes.
OTOH, if the Department of Justice can prove in a criminal prosecution that you've violated the criminal provisions of the tax law, you can go to prison. If the IRS thinks you've done that (which is different from just not paying your taxes), they can refer you to the DoJ for prosecution.
This change to IRS guidance doesn't change the criminal provisions of the tax law that would apply were the government to prosecute you, therefore, the change is not a change to criminal law, retroactive or otherwise.
So you may end up with penalties and interest, but you have a high probability of avoiding prison absent doing something stupid like trading emails with your broker on how you plan to evade taxes.
I know a guy who didn't even file for five or six years. Eventually he got a lawyer and made a deal which had him paying some fraction of his original tax liability.
They'll put you in jail if you make them, but they don't really want to put you in jail. They just want your money.
Oh, this guy? After getting his sweet deal he didn't actually pay them. I think he may end up in jail.
This is actually consistent with the history of the clause (It was understood to apply to criminal laws. Motions were made to change the wording to say it also applied to civil cases, they were turned down)
2. This is not a law, and may not even be administrative rulemaking (depending on what exactly they issued)
Of course, even if it was, you have a mechanism to challenge it if they hold you to it: the courts.