Re:Why Is the Federal Government Afraid of Fat?
by someuser1 on Thursday July 09, 2015 @11:35AM
(#9858469)
> the public will very likely and entirely rationally start asking very pointy questions about how such volume could be combined with such error, and what else being communicated with such volume and confidence today may also be wrong.
Probably a good idea
Re:Why Is the Federal Government Afraid of Fat?
by 2mur on Thursday July 09, 2015 @11:56AM
(#9858639)
The 3 hardest words to string together: I was wrong
(see also: the War on Drugs)
Re:Why Is the Federal Government Afraid of Fat?
by gadders on Thursday July 09, 2015 @12:21PM
(#9858850)
(see also: Extreme Global Warming predictions)
Re:Why Is the Federal Government Afraid of Fat?
by ak39 on Thursday July 09, 2015 @05:27PM
(#9860796)
Correct. That's science. And if you can't say that ("I was wrong"), it's simply dogma.
Re:Why Is the Federal Government Afraid of Fat?
by LanceH on Thursday July 09, 2015 @11:29AM
(#9858416)
The next wave of food bans are worse because "everyone is an eventual consumer of healthcare" so the choice to ignore the government on some things is also being taken away.
Re:Why Is the Federal Government Afraid of Fat?
by jerf on Thursday July 09, 2015 @11:38AM
(#9858493)
This is one of the important reasons for my general vague libertarianism. Governments can be wrong, markets can be wrong, individuals can be wrong, clubs can be wrong, companies can be wrong, all people and all elements of the powerset of all people can be wrong. (Except perhaps the null one, but it's also not known for being very right....) But the incentives for what happens next varies widely, and very-large-organizations have horrible horrible ones to double down, triple down, indefinitely keep throwing money on the number that keeps losing over and over, because they seem to inevitably settle on political structures that work that way.
I say "very large organizations" like it's one word because I fully consider "big business" and "government" to merely be two instances of that general problem, and I'm against both in general. It isn't really "government"... it's "the big organizations that humans tend to produce once you have an organization that is fully confident (rightly or wrongly!) that there is absolutely no meaningful threat to its continued existence". Large navel-gazing organizations are dangerous, in general.
Re:Why Is the Federal Government Afraid of Fat?
by JadeNB on Thursday July 09, 2015 @03:26PM
(#9860147)
all elements of the powerset of all people can be wrong … [e]xcept perhaps the null one ….
Are you kidding? Every opinion held by the null set is wrong!
Re:Why Is the Federal Government Afraid of Fat?
by Spivak on Thursday July 09, 2015 @08:03PM
(#9861528)
That's preposterous! Every opinion held by the null set is correct!
Re:Why Is the Federal Government Afraid of Fat?
by CyberDildonics on Thursday July 09, 2015 @05:38PM
(#9860874)
Where did bans come in to play? What food is banned that you want? And please don't say trans fats if you don't understand that they were a harmful preservation method and don't affect taste at all.
Re:Why Is the Federal Government Afraid of Fat?
by LanceH on Monday July 13, 2015 @10:05AM
(#9878102)
"Now, the FDA is taking a step to remove artificial trans fat from the food supply. This step is expected to reduce coronary heart disease and prevent thousands of fatal heart attacks every year."
From http://www.fda.gov/ForConsumers/ConsumerUpdates/ucm372915.ht...
Close enough to use the word "ban".
Re:Why Is the Federal Government Afraid of Fat?
by zo1 on Thursday July 09, 2015 @06:18PM
(#9861076)
I don't think it's so much about banning as it is about "pushing". Look at the subsidies for certain food groups, or the labeling requirements (hint, these feed into peoples' paranoia and preconceived notions of good/bad healthy/unhealthy), etc. So as long as they pipe-up the narrative they want (and scare people about other things), and people listen to it, then they they're effectively creating "ban"-like barriers and hindrances for people making their own choices.
Re:Why Is the Federal Government Afraid of Fat?
by CyberDildonics on Friday July 10, 2015 @01:11PM
(#9865261)
That is very dangerous but trying to tie it into the word 'ban' is severely misrepresenting the problem.
Public policy adds the additional problem that if they admit they were wrong about what was possibly the single clearest message the government has sent the US public in the last 50 years, "Fat is bad for you!", the public will very likely and entirely rationally start asking very pointy questions about how such volume could be combined with such error, and what else being communicated with such volume and confidence today may also be wrong.
The government has a ton of moral capital tied up in fat being bad for you, so it has to be bad for you. It has to be bad. It just has to.
As an individual, you may find it profitable to consider whether this is the sort of incentive structure that produces an authority you want to bet your life on. Considering whether there are similar issues where the government may have gotten stuck on a particular answer and now can not change its mind pretty much regardless of what facts come in left as an exercise for the reader.