News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Our Universities: The Outrageous Reality by apsec112 on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @07:54PM (#9848935)
I find it amazing that someone can write so much about the cost of college, and yet treat tuition bills as if they were handed down on stone tablets at Mt. Sinai, rather than something colleges themselves might have any responsibility for. Colleges have become giant money-sucking machines, similar to Scientology. In fact, they're so similar that I made a handy comparison chart (http://rationalconspiracy.com/2015/06/15/universities-vs-sci...).

The author here insinuates that the increased cost comes from paying for teaching and research. But this is wrong for at least five reasons:

1. Research is not a cost center for colleges. It is a profit center. Usually, research is not funded by the college itself; rather, professors get grants from outside agencies, which the college then takes a large, juicy cut of for itself. (Ask any professor.)

2. At most colleges, the number of faculty members per student has remained stagnant for the last thirty years. The author waves their hands about "new areas of knowledge", but these new areas aren't leading to more hiring.

3. Wages for tenured faculty have also remained stagnant, adjusted for inflation.

4. Colleges are rapidly replacing their tenured faculty with adjuncts, who are given heavy courseloads, and paid peanuts even compared to tenured faculty (barely minimum wage, in a lot of cases).

5. Most of the actual work of research and teaching is done by grad students, of whom there are far more than tenured faculty. Grad students are, again, a profit center rather than a cost center, since the university gets to charge them "tuition" (despite most of them taking few or no classes). This "tuition" is either paid by an outside research agency, or "generously" waived in exchange for the grad student doing teaching and grading, again at very low wages.

Re:Our Universities: The Outrageous Reality by jmspring on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @10:08PM (#9849380)
I'd just like to know the increase in administrative staff and their salaries against the rise in tuition. Local University has many more Assistant, Vice, etc. Deans and Chancellors than it did when I was there awhile ago.
Re:Our Universities: The Outrageous Reality by cfqycwz on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @08:41PM (#9849078)
I'd like to echo drjesusphd and ask if you could point us to any good information you've found on increasing per-student expenditures. My university likes to justify increasing tuition by pointing to a decrease in the proportion of a student's education that is funded by the state. The implication, is that per-student state funding has gone down and that's why tuition is going up, but state funding per student has remained relatively steady in inflation-adjusted terms for decades. It leads one to wonder what exactly they're spending all the extra money on.

I have yet to look into the numbers in greater detail but if you could point me toward some good sources it would be much appreciated.

Re:Our Universities: The Outrageous Reality by nhebb on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @09:38PM (#9849283)
> It leads one to wonder what exactly they're spending all the extra money on.

I just looked up the operating budget for my alma mater (Oregon State University), and if I'm reading it correctly, administrative costs are about 1/3 of the total. Interestingly, the direct instruction and research portion increased 5% since last year whereas the administration portion increased 15%. And looking back 10 years, the the direct instruction and research costs increased 85%, whereas admin costs increased 110%. So the admin : education costs ratio appears to be slowly increasing over time.

Re:Our Universities: The Outrageous Reality by abandonliberty on Wednesday July 08, 2015 @01:46AM (#9850009)
This is the same as in any organization. The wealth filters to those who run it.
Re:Our Universities: The Outrageous Reality by mjn on Wednesday July 08, 2015 @12:06AM (#9849761)
The funding numbers I've found for the University of California system are that per-student expenditures are roughly flat, and that tuition increases are almost 1-for-1 offsets for decreasing state funding. Here is a little ASCII table of the state funding history I collected in 2012: http://www.kmjn.org/misc/uc_funding.txt

I have no idea how representative this is of other universities, though, and wouldn't be surprised if it isn't.

Re:Our Universities: The Outrageous Reality by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @09:18PM (#9849205)
Alyssa, if you want to know what happened, just look at state budgets. Public universities have seen their budgets cut at the same time that private universities have been able to gorge on low-interest student loans (whose collection is backed by the force of the government, and not subject to bankruptcy).
Re:Our Universities: The Outrageous Reality by drjesusphd on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @08:08PM (#9848983)
So who is getting all that money?
Re:Our Universities: The Outrageous Reality by douche on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @08:53PM (#9849123)
Useless middle-manager administration. Look up how many deans there are at your local university, and how many directors of mumble-mumble social justice mumble mumble. Or look at how many wildly expensive infrastructure projects are getting built, with very marginal usefulness.
Re:Our Universities: The Outrageous Reality by milesskorpen on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @09:13PM (#9849181)
I don't think this is fair.

Modern society expects universities to act in loco parentis. We expect them to prevent (or deal with the fall out from) school's alcohol culture. We expect them to prevent sexual assault, or respond to it with some kind of judicial system. We expect a fully staffed career center to help students revise resumes and draft cover letters. We expect them to have a full time staffer dealing with diversity issues, and another with Title IX, and another (few) with financial aid.

These are all new positions, and many are actually required by law.

If you want to argue against middle management, I'm not at all clear the schools are to blame. They're responding to clear demands from the government and from parents.

Re:Our Universities: The Outrageous Reality by oldmanjay on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @10:07PM (#9849377)
I'm completely flummoxed by the notion that universities need a private justice system. The potential for abuse is staggering.
Re:Our Universities: The Outrageous Reality by milesskorpen on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @10:58PM (#9849533)
While you might be flummoxed, colleges & universities are facing substantial federal pressure to have this kind of system.
Re:Our Universities: The Outrageous Reality by joshuapants on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @11:39PM (#9849682)
> colleges & universities are facing substantial federal pressure to have this kind of system

That's the part to be flummoxed about

Re:Our Universities: The Outrageous Reality by drjesusphd on Wednesday July 08, 2015 @10:41AM (#9851795)
As I understand it, they're not justice systems that carry the full legtimacy of the government (they can't put you in prison, for example). It's a system by which they can carry out administrative punishments like community service, suspension, or expulsion.

The potential for abuse is certainly there, but calling it a seperate justice system is a tad disingenuous. Most importantly, it seems that the standards for evidence and the rights of the accused are far less than in real courts.

But how do you solve this? My opinion is that severe things like expulsion should only be considered if found guilty of a felony (or even only a violent felony) in an actual court of law. The difficulty of conviction is a feature, not a bug, of the legitimate justice system. Administrative punishments should only be meted out for administrative "crimes" (cheating, violating housing agreements, etc) that have no corresponding crime in the criminal code.

Re:Our Universities: The Outrageous Reality by oldmanjay on Wednesday July 08, 2015 @11:22AM (#9852129)
I'm not seeing what is disingenuous about it. you certainly didn't make an argument backing that statement, and the stories I'm finding of private tribunals with secret charges and no attorneys give me the impression I'm correct. that universities do not also have a private prison system in no way reduces the fact that they do have a private justice system.
Re:Our Universities: The Outrageous Reality by drjesusphd on Wednesday July 08, 2015 @08:00PM (#9855424)
Fair enough. My point was that there is a place for such "private justice systems" because there are transgressions that the state has no authority over and no interest in persuing.
Re:Our Universities: The Outrageous Reality by guelo on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @08:25PM (#9849031)
I find that a lot of budget arguments in general, not just of Universities but all kinds of government and private institutions, suffer badly from the lack of having two budgets to compare side by side. Say a budget from 1990 and a budget from today, side by side line by line. But clean data is almost impossible to come by. So people just argue in ideological generalities. Which is absurd when it's a numbers question. Can we see the numbers please? No.
Re:Our Universities: The Outrageous Reality by forrestthewoods on Wednesday July 08, 2015 @12:58AM (#9849885)
So where is all the extra tuition money going?
Re:Our Universities: The Outrageous Reality by pstuart on Wednesday July 08, 2015 @01:06AM (#9849909)
The administrators