News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by austenallred on Monday July 06, 2015 @09:48AM (#9839016)
So you're seeing that giving kids birth control reduces teen pregnancy? Shocking.

Everyone knew this would happen, but some believe that giving teens birth control is encouraging them to have sex, so initiatives like this are almost always blocked. It's very much a political problem.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by pavel_lishin on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:01AM (#9839090)
It's very much a "we're not fighting teen pregnancy, we're fighting teen sex" problem.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by scarmig on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:10AM (#9839171)
I don't know the data, but it doesn't strike me as insane to think that decreasing the marginal cost of a subset of sex would increase overall amounts of sex.

It's just that optimizing over "minimizing sex" is idiotic compared to optimizing over "minimizing unsafe sex."

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by austenallred on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:21AM (#9839262)
That's exactly what it is. Different groups optimizing for different outcomes.

For most religious folk, teens having sex is bad regardless of whether it's safe or not, so it makes sense to push for abstinence-only education. Giving out condoms is like giving up. Or maybe even slightly worse than giving up - implicitly encouraging kids to go out and have sex.

Of course, this doesn't stop kids from having sex, but it does make it so that when they do they're generally unprotected.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by GuiA on Monday July 06, 2015 @01:08PM (#9840552)
I've worked heavily with teenagers over the past 10 years, mostly in the context of summer camps (where 40 teenagers are spending 3 weeks of their summer in close quarter).

Where I'm from, France, you need a state certificate to work as an educator (BAFA), which is issued after a few weeks of training.

In my first week of training, which is mostly "theoretical", we had a debate about whether to carry condoms in the camp's sanitary supplies, to give them to teenagers if they ask for them. There is no legal imperative in France - it's mostly at the discretion of the camp director/organizer. I was against, because I was a 17 year old teenager full of convictions (albeit not religious ones) that having condoms available was implicitly encouraging teenagers to have sex.

Then I worked in actual teenage camps and realized how much of an idiot I was. No matter how vigilant and organized the educators are, the fact is that you have 40 teenagers full of hormones living together for 3 weeks. If you don't want STDs/pregnancies, you need condoms.

Anytime I hear people advocating the opposite, it becomes clear to me that they are deluded idealists and that they've never had to manage a community of teenagers.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by pluma on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:51PM (#9841749)
To quote my grandmother: "there's nothing [adolescents] can do at night that they won't do during daytime".

The religious right in the US has this strange obsession with other people's sex life. I think after roughly two millenia of Christians trying to prevent their kids from having extramarital sex it's safe to say that the exercise is ultimately futile and the only thing it's accomplishing is worse outcomes (e.g. STDs, pregnancies and bad decisions).

Of course debating that point is entirely useless when the underlying idea is that extramarital (and therefore also teenage) sex is the worst possible outcome in and of itself. It's a failure of humanity that 40-odd thousand years into civilization we still haven't overcome our obsessions with valuing scripture over rational thought.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by ma2rten on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:28AM (#9839314)
I don't think it's about marginal cost, it's psychological. In these people's minds, giving a teenager a box of condoms sends a message: "It's okay to have sex".
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by toothbrush on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:33AM (#9839357)
Thing is though, it is okay to have sex—safe and consensual sex, that is.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by kedean on Monday July 06, 2015 @11:06AM (#9839597)
That's where opinion comes in. You can't just force your opinion on people with deeply held, millenia old beliefs and expect it to suddenly work smoothly. It's not even as 'easy' as gay marriage, because now you're actually interfering with how people raise their children.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by XorNot on Monday July 06, 2015 @11:17AM (#9839682)
Are these people vampires? In which case it's not millenia old, it's just the thing they somehow decided at some time.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by vlunkr on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:11PM (#9840140)
I don't think they implied that the people are millenia old, the beliefs are. They are culturally engrained for a huge part of the population.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by genericuser on Monday July 06, 2015 @01:23PM (#9840676)
They were making a joke about the fact that in order for a group of people to hold a belief that it is not alright to do something necessary for reproduction for 1000 years that either they are hypocritical of that belief or they are 1000 years old.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by fineman on Monday July 06, 2015 @01:45PM (#9840856)
It's their children who are forcing the issue - by having sex. Denying access to proper medical consultations and care is recognized as a human rights violation.

You don't have a right to forbid your child's access to the health care, justice, etc.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by genericuser on Monday July 06, 2015 @11:28AM (#9839778)
Presumably the people actually having sex believe that having sex is alright, so no one is really forcing their views on them. People don't have to hold the same values their parents hold now for them.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by thaumasiotes on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:18PM (#9840198)
It's a famous result that the people who believe premarital sex isn't wrong account for fairly little of the premarital sex. People do things they believe are wrong all the time.

    I remember Christian teachers telling me long ago that I must
    hate a bad man's actions but not hate the bad man: or,
    as they would say, hate the sin but not the sinner. [...]
    I used to think this a silly, straw-splitting distinction:
    how could you hate what a man did and not hate the man?
    But years later it occurred to me that there was one man
    to whom I had been doing this all my life -- namely myself.
    However much I might dislike my own cowardice or conceit
    or greed, I went on loving myself. There had never been
    the slightest difficulty about it. In fact the very reason why
    I hated the things was that I loved the man.
    Just because I loved myself, I was sorry to find that
    I was the sort of man who did those things.
(Attributed to C. S. Lewis here: https://www.goodreads.com/work/quotes/801500-mere-christiani... )
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by genericuser on Monday July 06, 2015 @01:11PM (#9840569)
I guess I just see a disconnect between beliefs a person actually holds, and fake beliefs a person says they hold because they are under impression those are the 'correct' beliefs to hold.

I mean it comes down to a definition of the word belief which we seem to disagree on. There are probably only a handful of people in this world for which our differing definitions of belief would provide the same sets of beliefs.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by thaumasiotes on Monday July 06, 2015 @01:22PM (#9840667)
> I guess I just see a disconnect between beliefs a person actually holds, and beliefs a person says they hold because they are under impression those are the 'correct' beliefs to hold.

How do you know which is which? I definitely haven't said "it's your belief if you claim it aloud, no matter what you really think about it".

Consider the population of wives cheating on their husbands. Do you really believe that only an insignificant number of them think what they're doing is wrong?

> There are probably only a handful of people in this world for which our differing definitions of belief would provide the same sets of beliefs.

First, you need to establish that we differ in our definitions.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by genericuser on Monday July 06, 2015 @01:48PM (#9840871)
Let me ask you, how does a person make a decision?

To me people use what they believe to be true to make that decision. To me all decisions demonstrate a persons actual beliefs, as why would they decide to do something if they did not honestly believe it would yield a desirable outcome. (that outcome does not have to be viewed as desirable to anyone but them, for instance suicide. Nor does it have to be the immediate outcome which is desirable, it could be part of a long con.)

>Consider the population of wives cheating on their husbands. Do you really believe that only an insignificant number of them think what they're doing is wrong?

Yes, I believe that all cheating spouses, people who commit crimes, and sociopaths have developed an internal belief structure which lets them justify actions that may come at a cost to themselves or others as being probable of a desirable outcome for them.

>First, you need to establish that we differ in our definitions.

Have I done so to your satisfaction? I thought it was common knowledge that people often echo views they do not actually adhere to so that they will appear to conform to societal norms, which represents the crux of my definition. Politicians frequently offer a very obvious example of such a tendency, but if you know anyone well enough you can see the inconsistencies in what they say and what they do. Their actions demonstrate how they actually make decisions and what they believe in my opinion, not what they say.

You will know which are which by being introspective about the decisions you have made in the past and are considering making currently, and try to understand what basis you are truly using for that decision, besides the surface 'Well this feels right' reason.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by thaumasiotes on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:25PM (#9841106)
I think it's worth quoting an extract from http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Academic/Course_Pages/legal_sy... 's discussion of Qing Chinese law:

> There are multiple cases where someone commits an offense on orders from a superior member of his extended family; the attitude of the court seems to be that although he must obey the order he is still criminally liable for the act; there appears to be no assumption in the legal system that an individual always has the option of acting in a way that does not violate one rule or another.

When I read this, it was more interesting to me that American society is fairly committed to the fiction that such an option always exists.

I don't believe that the mere fact that a person took some action itself demonstrates that the person believed that action to be morally blameless. Of two paths, both can be wrong. Of many paths, all can be wrong -- or the conseqences of staying on the "right" one might be personally unbearable. I imagine that a mother who opted not to rescue her child from a burning building might be haunted by the thought that this was wrong, regardless of a generally positive message from society.

Also, I've tried really hard to read your comment in a way that allows for the existence of guilt. I can't see it. Do you believe people can feel guilt? Why would C. S. Lewis feel sorrow, in the privacy of his own mind, to discover that he is the kind of person who would do certain things?

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by genericuser on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:42PM (#9841262)
I can not perceive of right and wrong as absolute concepts. Only as concepts which exist when comparing one possible outcome relatively to others. People use some factors to inevitably choose between the choices they see available to them, they will choose what they perceive as having the outcome they desire given those decision trees that they construct. An outcome which they can not see a path to is not a choice, it effectively does not yet exist so they can not choose it.

Guilt to me is what people feel when they realize they made decisions with incorrect or incomplete information, and would of made them differently had they known. Even when the person had no way of knowing the correct or complete information at the time of decision making, in this edge case society has developed a term to attempt to remove guilt from the person by calling it an 'accident'. Often I find the source of guilt to be not looking very far ahead on the decision trees which I eliminate early on as not effecting me. (Guilt can also be simply an act, as demonstrating guilt often leads to fewer negative consequences in our society. Think of all the people convicted where not demonstrating remorse was used as a factor in sentencing or parole denial.)

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by thaumasiotes on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:09PM (#9841458)
> Guilt to me is what people feel when they realize they made decisions with incorrect or incomplete information, and would of made them differently had they known.

That's wrong. This is regret.

> I can not perceive of right and wrong as absolute concepts.

That's fine. But you're here denying that other people can and do. You're wrong about that.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by genericuser on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:41PM (#9841681)
No, it is not. Regret does not require you to currently see a way for you to of made decisions which would of led to a more desirable outcome had you known (you may see them but it is not required). You can have regret over the passing of you cat, even though you know there was nothing you could of done to prevent it. Guilt is a regret but with you having the idea that it could of been prevented and a better outcome achieved had you done something differently.

Can they though? Or are people just too arrogant to admit that they can not define them in absolute terms, and if they can what could the definition of right be besides 'what is most beneficial among possible outcomes' and wrong be 'what is not most beneficial among possible outcomes'? That can not in my opinion be a definition of anything absolute as it varies based on the circumstances and individual values.

Feel free to propose an absolute version of right and wrong, to me it seems like an impossible task, but perhaps you could enlighten me. Until this last reply you had asked very good questions, showing that you welcome discourse on the subject, and I hope you can return to doing so rather than simply stating that I am wrong.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by thaumasiotes on Monday July 06, 2015 @04:27PM (#9841956)
Look, here's the relevant sense of guilt (that is, the sense unrelated to the legal system) from Merriam-Webster:

> a bad feeling caused by knowing or thinking that you have done something bad or wrong

Here it is from Cambridge:

> Guilt is also a feeling of anxiety or unhappiness that you have done something immoral or wrong, such as causing harm to another person: She was tormented by feelings of guilt after putting her mother in a nursing home.

There is no requirement that things could have gone differently, or that if they could have gone differently a different outcome would have been better.

Your definition is not compatible with this, or even related to this. You've stated fairly clearly that you don't believe guilt exists. That's odd, but defensible. (Though trust me, you're wrong.) Pretending it means something other than what everyone but you thinks it means isn't defensible.

> Feel free to propose an absolute version of right and wrong, to me it seems like an impossible task

I didn't say there was an absolute definition of right and wrong. I said there are people who conceive of the world this way, and that's true; they are quite numerous. By weakening to just the idea that certain actions in a definite fixed context could be correctly labeled "right" or "wrong", you pick up many, many more believers, practically the entire world.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by genericuser on Monday July 06, 2015 @05:22PM (#9842269)
I personally do not see a conflict with how I define guilt and how Webster defines it. And while not in perfect agreement with the Cambridge definition, I see them as similar.

I mean how can you be aware you have done something wrong or bad if you do see what could of been a better outcome? If everything you have to compare it to as possible outcomes is worse than what happened then you did nothing wrong or bad, you did the best that was possible.

I was never intending to say guilt does not exist just that it simply as Webster has defined and that choosing solutions which you later realize are sub-optimal are what Webster describes as something bad or wrong. I am not pretending it means anything other than what you have provided here as the definition. How can one recognize bad without good? These things are inherently relative as one can not exist without the other also existing.

>I didn't say there was an absolute definition of right and wrong. I said there are people who conceive of the world this way, and that's true; they are quite numerous.

How does one conceive of something which can not be defined? To me that seems like being able to visualize the concept of infinity. It can be defined in a relative sense, so I stand by my view that the relative sense is the only one that matters.

>By weakening to just the idea that certain actions in a definite fixed context could be correctly labeled "right" or "wrong", you pick up many, many more believers, practically the entire world.

I think you underestimate the cultural differences present in the world and the ability of anyone to actually define a fixed context which 'practically the entire world' will be able to relate to.

Any scenario you did manage to get 'practically the entire world' to agree on would be so vague and hypothetical as to be virtually meaningless. Like 'would you give everyone in the world cancer or ice cream', although the example I have provided itself is flawed I think most examples will have flaws. In my example if people have a violent enough allergy to ice cream they may in fact choose cancer as being "right".

This has been a rather long way about this but do you at least concede that we do indeed have different ideas of what a belief is and that only a small number of people if any would have beliefs which were consistent with both our definitions?

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by webjprgm on Monday July 06, 2015 @11:50AM (#9839961)
But the government or a school giving birth control is someone teaching the children something parents don't want taught. So you are trampling on the rights of the parents in that case. If the child were to independently decide having sex was fine then it would be about the child's freedom to choose.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by pluma on Monday July 06, 2015 @04:08PM (#9841857)
The rights of the parents end where the rights of the child are concerned. No person in a society lives in isolation and sometimes society has to protect a person from harmful influence by their supposed wardens.

It's okay to have consensual sex. If kids aren't properly educated about sex (and the consequences having sex can bring, from biological to social), they can't have consensual sex -- but that doesn't mean they won't have sex at all.

So no, sex education does not infringe on religious rights. And making condoms available to teenagers who intend on having sex doesn't either.

We're not talking about teachers throwing condoms at their students yelling "Fornicate! All of you! With each other! All the time!". We're talking about making condoms available to teenagers who ask for them and letting them know they don't have to expect any invasions of their privacy as a consequence (because doing so would discourage them from asking, thus encouraging unsafe sex).

Again: kids are going to have sex. Uneducated kids are going to have more dangerous sex. Educated kids are going to have safer sex.

Nobody has the right to deny the kid's independent decision whether to have sex or not. But this goes both ways: not only can't teachers tell a kid whether to have sex or not, but neither can the parents.

It's ridiculous that the people who fight against abortion because it infringes upon the rights of the unborn child are often the same people who then raise moral panic about children having sex and try to deny them the right to sex education (and access to things like condoms for when they decide to have sex). Especially if you consider that access to condoms and education also has a positive effect on when those kids decide to have sex, with whom and in what kind of situations -- i.e. if you properly educate kids about sex, they may even come to the realization that they are not actually ready yet and that it's okay to say "no" to horny peers.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by thaumasiotes on Monday July 06, 2015 @04:30PM (#9841981)
> Nobody has the right to deny the kid's independent decision whether to have sex or not.

Unless, of course, their partner is older than they are.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by pluma on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @04:28PM (#9847863)
Correct, but only partially so. How most of US law deals with this is ridiculous (i.e. the older partner becoming a sex offender). If two minors within a certain age range have sex, they may theoretically be "raping each other", but considering that an actual criminal offense in itself is absurd.

Now, an adult having sex with a child on the other hand is obviously acting criminally. It's the adult's responsibility to act in the child's best interests due to the child's lack of ability to give consent -- even if the child (for whatever reason) engages it, it's against their best interests to follow through.

As for sexually active "minors" and very young adults, especially at very narrow age ranges, that's not as trivial to answer. A hard cut-off seems the most straightforward answer but creates absurd outcomes in edge cases (e.g. someone who just turned 18 having sex with someone about to turn 18 in a country where 18 is the age of consent would be considered a rapist but not if both of them were just a tiny bit younger or older). I guess it's best to have case law deal with these situations individually.

Maybe I should clarify that the reason I used the word "kids" was to make it clear we're not specifically talking about "children" in the intuitive sense. The danger that six year olds will randomly decide to have sex with each other is relatively low (if we ignore "sex play", which is a different can of worms). That's not what the article is about. We're specifically talking about "kids" (i.e. minors, which depending on where you live can include anyone between 12 and 21) who are fairly likely to be already sexually active without any external motivation/dissuasion.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by thaumasiotes on Wednesday July 08, 2015 @03:51AM (#9850335)
Was it really against Priscilla Presley's best interests to sleep with Elvis?
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by pluma on Wednesday July 08, 2015 @09:34AM (#9851379)
Economically? Probably not. But the problem with psychological long-term effects is that they are very difficult to determine and can vary widely from person to person and situation to situation.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by genericuser on Monday July 06, 2015 @01:12PM (#9840579)
The parents are free to home school their children if they do not want them to learn the curriculum being taught. If we let every parent determine the curriculum for all students, well we would never even get the curriculum defined. So what is taught has to be chosen based on what is most beneficial for the children (as a whole) to be functioning members of society, and not on parent preference.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by fineman on Monday July 06, 2015 @01:52PM (#9840899)
Unfortunately "free to home school" their children is really a code-word for keeping their children inhumanely isolated for cult compliance reasons. Thought control.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by austenallred on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:52AM (#9839501)
Most people in the town I grew up in would disagree with that statement
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by webjprgm on Monday July 06, 2015 @11:52AM (#9839988)
And I disagree with that statement too. So do various researchers on families and marriage. (I'm horrible at remembering sources, I'd have to hunt them down if you really want them.) And I'm sure there's differing conclusions among researchers since there always are. But my point is that there are legitimate oppositions to the idea that consensual sex is OK, both religion/moral and scientific.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by oldmanjay on Monday July 06, 2015 @01:27PM (#9840704)
I won't bother chasing down religious or moral objections, but please do back up your statement that there is scientific opposition to consensual sex.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by aidenn0 on Monday July 06, 2015 @11:59AM (#9840043)
In all states teenagers under 16 cannot legally consent to sex.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by a_c_s on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:55PM (#9840457)
Due to "Romeo & Juliet" clauses, this isn't actually true in many states.

For example, in Iowa somebody 14 or 15 can have sex with somebody less than 4 years older than them.

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ages_of_consent_in_North_Ameri...

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by fineman on Monday July 06, 2015 @01:40PM (#9840815)
I'm pretty sure you have enough data to know that that argument is actually bunk in this case.

It's not like teens (and the poor, etc) are saving up to afford condoms and only having sex when they can afford them. The profusion of unplanned babies and the well-known tendency of the poor to have more children than they can support should prove this.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by scarmig on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:18PM (#9841054)
I would guess that the effect is marginal, though real and positive.

Empiricism, however, is a stronger basis for policy making than personal anecdote and untested theories.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by fineman on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:44PM (#9841277)
Exactly, and my answer is 1000 times more empirical than yours. You imagine some tiny butterfly effect that might impact something vague but are ignoring the masses of evidence of the straight forward problems.

Hoofbeats, horses, etc. Also, when we deal with the horses we'll have a chance to check for any odd zebra.

(ie, even if you're right, the way to check is deal with the other 99% of the problem first...)

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by scarmig on Monday July 06, 2015 @04:36PM (#9842025)
Your "empirical evidence" amounts to repeating anecdotes and strongly held suppositions with higher and higher levels of emotion. It's not at all convincing to me--someone who's predisposed to support very high levels of access to birth control, for everyone--and is certainly not convincing to anyone who's predisposed to oppose it.

Also, a nit: the butterfly effect has nothing to do with this discussion. It's an effect in chaotic systems where a small perturbation in initial conditions leads to large, unpredictable, non-linear differences in later states. I'm arguing that it's not crazy to think a small perturbation in policy (an x% decrease in the total cost of having sex) would likely lead to a small and proportionate response in behavior (a roughly x% increase in the amount of sex had).

Resolution of the truth-value of that requires, yes, actual scientific studies (which have almost certainly already been done already). The fact that some religiously-inclined folk might come to the "wrong" conclusion from a confirmation of this effect doesn't obviate the value of studying it.

ETA: Just as an example of such a study, look at this one [0]. It's about how certain abstinence-only programs, which presumably doesn't include access to contraceptives, can legitimately prevent the onset of teenage sexual activity. I'm sure there's plenty of room for methodological critiques, and there are also plenty of studies that come to other conclusions, naturally. I personally still would expect those to be confirmed in the end. But this isn't a question that you can resolve by loudly proclaiming that anyone who asks for evidence is an idiot.

[0] http://archpedi.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=38279...

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by fineman on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @01:03AM (#9843727)
> Also, a nit: the butterfly effect has nothing to do with this discussion. It's an effect [...]

Sorry, I had assumed it as an idiom without establishing a shared lexicon. I mean, an effect so small as to only possibly be significant via an appeal to the butterfly effect. As in, ultimately we can't rule out that assassinating Hitler when he was a teen would have caused the sun to go supernova, because X, but it's vanishingly unlikely.

> I'm arguing that it's not crazy to think a small perturbation in policy (an x% decrease in the total cost of having sex) would likely lead to a small and proportionate response in behavior [...]

Sure, this can always happen. We always need to have our eye on the metric (the 21st century "ball").

But unless you've actually got a good argument for why it's likely that this program will go wrong, you're more likely to cause harm by kvetching than by letting change happen.

> [...] as an example of such a study, look at this one [0]. It's about how certain abstinence-only programs [...]

Sure, if the alternative is emulating reality shows then anything, including _Catholic Hour in the Nursery_ would probably be better. Thankfully we don't live in a black and white world.

And of course any classes should include a huge dose of self-esteem and other training supporting the right/desire to say "No", but when a couple want to have sex do we really want to punish their offspring? Sins of the father? Srs?

Or do you really deny the plight of the unwanted/required (high death-rate) child?

TL;DR What I'm saying is that we know people will have sex despite it being wise. (Do you really require a cite? If so, list the keywords you've searched and I'll help you use the internet.) So when they do, though we may wish/help to delay that a while, lets help them do so safely when they inevitable do.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by auganov on Monday July 06, 2015 @11:36AM (#9839840)
Say if they use depo provera injections as the long term contraceptive it could very well reduce their willingness to do it. And help with [painful] periods btw.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by nsgi on Monday July 06, 2015 @06:34PM (#9842599)
Using depo provera injections could their willingness to have sex?
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by auganov on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @11:49AM (#9846157)
Well, more accurately speaking it should reduce/get rid of [testosterone]-induced libidinal impulses. Of course some inherent preference, cultural compulsion and your partner[s] are big factors too (I'm guessing haha). But yea, I'm willing to bet some money that if used for over a year it would significantly reduce sexual behavior in the treated population. Which also makes me surprised why pro-abstinence people are often opposed to such methods.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by euroclydon on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:23AM (#9839276)
> but some believe that giving teens birth control is encouraging them to have sex

Do teenagers really need to be encouraged to have sex? An absence of discouragement should be sufficient, for mutually attracted pairs.

High-availability abortions and contraceptives given out in schools are just examples of governments giving people what they want. However many in the anti-abortion and abstinence movements are engaged in an ambitious social engineering effort, telling teens to resist their strong biological urges to have sex, in favor of marriage and monogamy, because they believe this leads to a more spiritually healthy outcome, long-term.

There is surprisingly little innovation in this space. It's taken for granted that teenage-pregnancy is a bad word, that 30-40 year olds make better parents because they have more money. Society could choose to support early marriage and childbirth. Parenting requires a lot of energy, something that youth have in abundance. Also, young people remember what it's like to be a child, and make more empathetic parents.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by donohoe on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:48AM (#9839470)
Gonna have to disagree with you on that last paragraph. You make very broad assumptions that I'd dispute as an accurate generalization.

As a dad to 2 kids (became a father at 28) I would strongly urge people to wait until they were 30-38 before having kids.

Given the great innovations in this space I'd even say 40 is a great age to have kids - though it gets harder with age beyond this imho.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by facepalm on Monday July 06, 2015 @11:40AM (#9839870)
I had my first kid with 38 and I wish it would have been sooner. I love having a kid now. But I worry about staying healthy enough to do the fun things I want to do with them.

And grandparents are a major factor, too. They are a great help, and also they really enjoy being with their children. Supposing my kids also wait until they are 38 to have kids, my odds at enjoying quality time with grandchildren are greatly reduced.

I'll probably be almost of pension age when my kids finish their education. That's another thing where I worry I might not be able to help them out as much as I could if I would still be earning money and connected in the business world.

It would perhaps be different if I had toiled and saved money all the time up to age 38, but I didn't. If you have kids, odds are you get more serious about those things.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by ta92929 on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:53AM (#9839511)
Why do you feel that way? Biologically that's not really the way humans were designed. It's unfortunate that the modern first world economy and society is so incompatible with biology.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by Kluny on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:33PM (#9840274)
My mother waited until she was nearly 40 to have me, and as a result I was born with birth defects (I'm deaf). There is no way to deal with all of the risks.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by hessenwolf on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:16PM (#9840178)
Expecting at 36, I disagree with you. It's given us less time. There is no way to wait until you have managed away all the risks.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by __z on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:04PM (#9840082)
There's advantages and disadvantages of both early and late childbearing. I don't believe there is an "optimal" choice. 28 is hardly an "old" age to become a father.

I do take issue with the statement that young people (people in their 20s) have energy "in abundance."

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by JoeAltmaier on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:06PM (#9840094)
Spoken like a young person.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by __z on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:42PM (#9840338)
I'm certainly no spring chicken.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by webjprgm on Monday July 06, 2015 @11:59AM (#9840038)
It isn't just lack of money. Teenagers are not as emotionally mature, they have not finished figuring out what to accomplish with their lives (career or otherwise), and often they end up being single parents. There is tons of family research on why it is better to have two parents in a family.

Government giving people what they want? Please. Teenagers can't even vote, so they aren't voting themselves contraceptives. This is adults imposing yet another view on their children. It just so happens that this is a differing view than the traditional religious view of teaching abstinence. (Or of teaching that teenagers who get pregnant should then immediately get married and the dad get a job.)

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by pluma on Monday July 06, 2015 @04:13PM (#9841893)
> An absence of discouragement should be sufficient

In fact, discouragement has been proven time and again not to work (or worse: to result in more erratic behaviour as a consequence of the cognitive dissonance of enjoying something you've been vehemently taught to think of as evil).

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by KirinDave on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:43PM (#9840357)
Your argument is that maybe it's okay if teens are pregnant, totally ignoring the social reality around you. Bravo, sir!

Let's trap women in an unending economic and social perdition because they'll have empathy!

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by oldmanjay on Monday July 06, 2015 @01:24PM (#9840684)
With freely available birth control, including plan b and abortion, pregnant teens are a simply fixed medical issue with no real consequences.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by KirinDave on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:54PM (#9841353)
You have a very, very, very odd definition of "free."
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by oldmanjay on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:36PM (#9841639)
Do I? Please enlighten me as to my definition, near as I can tell I used the adverbial form exactly as defined here: "not under the control of another; as one wishes."

Were you inferring that I meant that abortions and birth control are always freely available? I did not state that.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by KirinDave on Monday July 06, 2015 @08:43PM (#9842992)
Neither is the case legally, economically or socially for many women all over the world. The US is no exception.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by a8da6b0c91d on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:49AM (#9839477)
What you propose makes a ton of sense absent the welfare state. In a world where extended families are the support network, young parenthood makes a great deal of sense. As things stand now what we see in practice is a massive transfer of wealth from the 40% of people who pay taxes to high time preference people who are net tax drains.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by gwern on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:18PM (#9840193)
> Shocking.

Everything needs to be tested. How many treatments, therapies, and drugs seem like pure common sense and then turn out to be useless when rigorously examined or outright harmful?

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by rdudek on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:07AM (#9839142)
Not shocking, this is common knowledge and I'm glad this actually helps the poor folks. Raising a family is tough.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by genericuser on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:08AM (#9839147)
I agree, but the people who write head lines understand that including the word 'Startling' increases their clicks dramatically, despite the fact it would of been more accurate without that word added.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by eli_gottlieb on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:07AM (#9839137)
>Everyone knew this would happen, but some believe that giving teens birth control is encouraging them to have sex

I don't see the problem.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by a8da6b0c91d on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:18AM (#9839240)
There is an STD pandemic. Multi-drug resistant STIs are rapidly spreading. The "sexual revolution" was basically the twenty year period when a shot of penicillin cleared anything up. That's over.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by eli_gottlieb on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:47PM (#9841308)
>There is an STD pandemic. Multi-drug resistant STIs are rapidly spreading.

As a happily, permanently monogamous individual who knows nothing about this... could I get some sources on that?

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by dylanjermiah on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:03AM (#9839110)
>but some believe that giving teens birth control is encouraging them to have sex

I don't understand, encouraging them to use contraception while having sex (and perhaps lead to more intercourse)? or encourage more unprotected sex?

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by noelwelsh on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:08AM (#9839149)
A vocal chunk of the US still believes that access to contraception will lead to a mass outbreak of fucking amongst the youth.

Look in this very thread and you will see much hang-wringing about STI rates, which is a code-word for OMG-the-youth-are-getting-it-on. As if they weren't already (pregnancy rates are dropping ...), as if this was somehow wrong (if anything is natural, sex is), as if there were huge surges of STI rates in countries without these hangups about sex, and so on.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by seiji on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:12AM (#9839183)
and perhaps lead to more intercourse

In America, the popular public society-wide meme opinion is "sex is bad outside of procreation." You're not allowed to encourage it, you're not allowed to make it safer, and many doctors aren't even comfortable talking about it.

Running a "birth-free sex" program is an affront to the victorian sensibilities of genital shame and a general war on happiness. The one true path is dedication to god and hard work, not personal enjoyment of anything. And we're going to have our 80 year old half-senile business moguls fund all politicians to ensure sex is always dangerous, unsafe, and bad for you.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by digi_owl on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:19AM (#9839247)
Heh, i recall reading the experience of someone from some Nordic nation or other who went to USA to visit his in-laws to be.

"Back home" they were sharing a bed and sleeping in their undies each night.

While visiting it was pajamas and sleeping in different ends of the house.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by seiji on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:27AM (#9839309)
That's reasonably common in the US if the parents are religious. If the kid and their significant other are visiting parents and aren't married then they aren't allowed to sleep in the same room (because they might do shenanigans!).
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by digi_owl on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:36AM (#9839376)
I see i forgot to include that i think the couple was both well into their 20s, just not married (yet).
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by seiji on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:44AM (#9839443)
They are still children in the eyes of their parents. :)

Doesn't matter if it's 20/30/40, you still need to be protected from the temptation of living in sin.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by digi_owl on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:52AM (#9839500)
* They are still children in the eyes of their parents. :) *

True, and something that transcends cultures.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by steverb on Monday July 06, 2015 @11:11AM (#9839633)
Actually, I apply to rule to all house guests. You're not married, you sleep in separate rooms.

My house, my rules. You're welcome to stay at the hotel down the street if you can't handle sleeping apart from each other and we'll cheerfully roll out the red carpet and provide chauffeur service for you.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by vezzy-fnord on Monday July 06, 2015 @11:30AM (#9839792)
You're not married, you sleep in separate rooms.

Do the criteria require one of a civic marriage, a religious marriage or both? If the latter in isolation is acceptable, as it has no legal power, would domestic partnerships then also be an acceptable alternative?

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by steverb on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:00PM (#9840044)
The criteria is whatever I happen to feel comfortable with.

I don't draw a distinction between and civil and religious marriage ceremony though and I have no clue what a domestic partnership is... :-)

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by deelowe on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:13AM (#9839197)
It's seen as implicit approval of teen sex. Period.

The issue is that acknowledgement of birth control as a valid form of contraception also acknowledges that a significant number of teens have sex. The conservative religious crowd feel that this isn't the right solution. They don't want "underage sex" to be seen as something that's so commonplace that contraceptive is readily available. They feel it's taboo and offering tools that lessen the risk of underage sex is also taboo.

As another person stated, some aren't interested in fighting teen pregnancy and poverty. They are interested in fighting teen sex. Two very different things.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by mikeash on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:20AM (#9839254)
For a really dramatic example of this, look at the controversy over the HPV vaccine. People fought the vaccine viciously. They would rather have people die than do something they see as encouraging sex before marriage.
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by balls187 on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:12AM (#9839181)
The former.

The logic certain politicians in the US use is that the only acceptable form of birth control the government can support is abstinence. This is often tied to Judeo-christian beliefs, and often used to gain favor with the conservative base.

If the consequences of sex (i.e. pregnancy) are mitigated, it will encourage teenagers to have sex.

Typically there is some form of slut shaming that happens during the debate on birth control.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by aidos on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:06AM (#9839128)
Encouraging them to have sex at all, presumably. If you help with contraception, it's an implicit endorsement of sexual intercourse (at least, that's what many would argue).
Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by Ntrails on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:21AM (#9839261)
The former. By telling people 'how' to have sex it carries an implication of approval. This will lead, logically, to more people thinking it's ok to have sex (otherwise why would they be being told how).

This probably does increase the levels of total sex-having somewhat, but it also allows for much much higher levels of safe and informed sex having. Apparently this is not always considered an acceptable trade off.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by XorNot on Monday July 06, 2015 @11:20AM (#9839708)
This has been shown to be wrong. Basically the only thing abstinence only education does is delay by a year or two, the age at which people first have sex.

Then they proceed to have higher rates of every negative outcome.

Re:Colorado’s Effort Against Teenage Pregnancies Is a Startl... by Ntrails on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @05:46AM (#9844414)
So what you are saying is that people have sex later, thereby there is less sex having, which is exactly what the abstinence teachers want.

Then you say higher rates of negative outcome, without mentioning whether you consider rate of sex having to be a negative outcome.

(I don't disagree with the assessment, it follows the exact logic I posited. I'm not sure why you're taking my comment as being in support of abstinence - it clearly isn't)