You could generalize most of those to "financial fraud", though. Although there are some cases of identities being used for non-financial (or not directly financial) purposes.
> In a signature based authentication system, the banks suggest YOU are the victim of identity theft if someone gets your credit card number when it's their authentication system that was 'hacked.'
And yet you're the one who has to go to the trouble and possible expense of dealing with it. Describing you as the victim seems more relevant.
Now, who and what you're the victim of is a different question. When yet another break-in turns up millions of plaintext passwords, we don't just blame those who obtained them illicitly; we also blame the company that stored them in plaintext.
So, I don't think it's reasonable to describe a bank as a victim in "identity theft". On the contrary, I think it's reasonable to describe them as negligent in protecting your account and personal information.
"""
“Identity theft” is a lie. There is no such thing as “identity theft”, it’s all fraud. The term “identity theft” was created to put the burden back on the consumer, away from financial institutions. The actual problem is that the cost of actually verifying identity is higher than financial institutions want to bear. Most of the cost would be in missed loan opportunities. Financial institutions don’t want to bear the cost of verifying identity so they experience fraud (surprise!) and then tell us that somehow we have to protect our identity. It’s insane.
If it was legally required that you appear in a bank with an ID to get a loan or a credit card, imagine what would happen to “identity theft”. There’s nothing wrong with filing electronically, but how about having people come to the post office, with ID and a thumb drive, show ID and sign a log, then file from there?
"""
There are very real, persistent, and hugely negative repercussions suffered by a consumer in identity theft. Destroyed credit, unknown debt tied to their identity, etc.
Well. Sure. But that's the point. That's why it's called identity theft. Someone has acquired the information about you needed to effectively pretend to be you.
For example, say I convince the police that you committed murder. As a result they arrest you and put you in jail. By your logic, you're not a victim in this scenario because if the police didn't get fooled into arresting you nothing would have happened.
I think almost any reasonable person would agree that you were a victim in the above scenario. Regardless whether a third party bears some level of responsibility or was used as an instrument in that victimization.
This low bar is set by the banks!
I'm not saying that innocent third parties that the banks and financial system harass are not victims, I'm saying that the central role of the bank in the crime makes it more reasonable to describe it as bank fraud.
The murder analogy sort of breaks down, the dead guy (which I see as analogous to the bank) can't do a whole lot to push the consequences of you murdering him onto me. A bank that opens a fraudulent account can (and in fact, this is the major source of the problems for those that are impersonated).
I honestly love this point. It's never occured to me.
Unlike a Gilliamesque world in which a bad actor assumes your identity, generally a bad guy gains access to your resources, bypassing the protections set in. While the consumer is guilty of this sometimes, the victim harmed is almost always the institution, not the consumer; and yet the consumer is framed as the victim.
In a signature based authentication system, the banks suggest YOU are the victim of identity theft if someone gets your credit card number when it's their authentication system that was 'hacked.'
Similarly, checking account numbers, etc.
Of course there are exceptions, people use bad passwords, they allow others to get their info, etc.
But, I do think this term "identity theft" is often overused.