News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Objects of consciousness by based2 on Saturday July 04, 2015 @09:19AM (#9830058)
"How can consciousness be cast in a mathematical formalism without losing something essential?

The mathematics does lose something essential, viz., consciousness itself. Similarly, mathematical models of weather also lose something essential, viz., weather itself. A mathematical model of hurricanes won't create rain, and a mathematical model of consciousness won't create consciousness. The math is not the territory. But, properly constructed, mathematics reveals the structure of the territory."

http://www.pnas.org/content/105/7/2745.full Bayesian learning of visual chunks by human observers

Re:Objects of consciousness by Lambdanaut on Saturday July 04, 2015 @09:32AM (#9830089)
The eerie thing is that as far as we can tell, our brains are no more than models of consciousness, and yet they are conscious.

The line is very blury between a model of consciousness and the point where it can not only be described as conscious but truly has that ethereally, hard to define quality that we "feel" as consciousness.

Would the first truly general AIs simply be working models of consciousness, or would they also feel consciousness as we do? When does the viz creep into our model?

Re:Objects of consciousness by geophile on Saturday July 04, 2015 @10:46AM (#9830295)
> The eerie thing is that as far as we can tell, our brains are no more than models of consciousness, and yet they are conscious.

Wow. That is an extremely good description of the problem of consciousness. Is this your own formulation? If not, where did you run into it?

Re:Objects of consciousness by Lambdanaut on Saturday July 04, 2015 @04:44PM (#9831548)
I've been thinking about it a long time and hadn't heard it from anyone else. I'm glad to get feedback :)
Re:Objects of consciousness by icebraining on Saturday July 04, 2015 @12:34PM (#9830655)
Isn't a brain an implementation of a model of consciousness, rather than a model itself? I don't see how they are "no more than models of consciousness". Of course, this is using "model" as "mathematical/scientific model", not as "reproduction".
Re:Objects of consciousness by orasis on Saturday July 04, 2015 @11:14AM (#9830380)
Right, which is exactly why our brains do not directly perceive the "truth" of physical reality. It's models all the way down.
Re:Objects of consciousness by escherplex on Saturday July 04, 2015 @03:16PM (#9831284)
Bingo. In common philosophical usage 'consciousness' is conflated with what is evinced in consciousness, or process contents (cogito ergo sum). Back in 1988, Bernard Baars in 'A Cognitive Theory of Consciousness' separated self-iterative 'awareness' from process and posited 'awareness' as a 'global workspace' interfacing with parallel subliminal neural subprocessors which collectively manufacture an interactive model of 'reality'. By extension this would reduce all human intellectual modeling of ascertained 'reality' to projections of native intellectual predispositions hard-wired into the neural architecture. But what's basic? Here you're still faced with the same problem which still confronts experimental physics: to study a phenomena you have to employ instrumentation synthesized from the same building blocks of which the phenomena itself is constituted.
Re:Objects of consciousness by deciplex on Saturday July 04, 2015 @12:58PM (#9830736)
> A mathematical model of hurricanes won't create rain

What about a detailed simulation of global climate at a granularity of, let's say, individual quarks. Is there a point at which a map is so detailed that it becomes, in some sense at least, itself a territory?

Re:Objects of consciousness by p1esk on Saturday July 04, 2015 @02:40PM (#9831142)
I think there's an important distinction between a rain and a consciousness. Rain is a movement of physical objects, that's all it is. Consciousness, on the other hand, is not just movement of physical objects (e.g. electrons), it's more than that. The movement of electrons that gives rise to consciousness (or is interpreted as consciousness), creates information. This process is an abstraction from the physical world. A math model of a rain does not create rain, and a math model of consciousness does not create consciousness, but a computer simulation of consciousness might actually create the real consciousness, unlike a computer simulation of a rain.
Re:Objects of consciousness by deciplex on Sunday July 05, 2015 @11:44AM (#9833876)
> The movement of electrons that gives rise to consciousness (or is interpreted as consciousness), creates information. This process is an abstraction from the physical world.

It's not clear to me what you mean when you say consciousness is an abstraction - is this dualism? Consciousness seems pretty thoroughly grounded in real stuff. Intelligent agents might "create information" in some sense, but there is no indication that they do it by breaking the laws of thermodynamics.

Re:Objects of consciousness by p1esk on Monday July 06, 2015 @01:28AM (#9836975)
No, not dualism. I meant this abstraction in the same sense as moving from the level of transistors when talking about a computer, to the level of, say, C++ objects in the software that runs on that computer. I'm not sure I understand your reference to thermodynamics. Information is created when a certain meaning is assigned to a pattern. Who assigns that meaning? As you said - an intelligent agent. This intelligent agent is the abstraction I'm talking about. It can be implemented with electrons flowing between neurons, or with photons in some kind of an optical computer - the physical implementation is not important. The high level structure and operation are important, that's why I think that simulating a human consciousness on a computer will result in a real consciousness, unlike simulating a rain. It might not be exactly the same consciousness as the original one, but it can be arbitrary close. For example, we can simulate Atari 2600 console on a modern computer in sufficient detail to play games exactly the same as we would play them on the real, physical console. We don't need to simulate every transistor in the original console for that.
Re:Objects of consciousness by deciplex on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:53AM (#9837500)
Fair enough. I brought up thermodynamics because you seemed to be implying that intelligent agents would assign meaning to things without doing any work. It wasn't clear to me from where the "information" was being created.

Would you agree that, in order for simulated rain to be "really rain", you would require a conscious person inside the simulation who regards it as such?

Re:Objects of consciousness by p1esk on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:11PM (#9841466)
"Would you agree that, in order for simulated rain to be "really rain", you would require a conscious person inside the simulation who regards it as such?"

I'm not sure about your question: are you asking if we should regard the simulated rain to be real if it's real for a simulated person?

This reminds me: "If a tree falls down in a forest, and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?"

Let's compare two situations: 1. There are real people on the other side of the world, who experience a real rain (but we, on this side of the world, can't experience that rain directly). 2. There are simulated people who experience a simulated rain, which is real to them.

The simulated people have real consciousness, and are indistinguishable from real people if viewed within their virtual world. They can even control robotic human-like bodies in the real world. Can we say the simulated people are real? What if we regard the virtual world to be an extension of the real world, like the "New World" (the Americas) was considered to be an extension of the Old World? In that case, the rain experienced by virtual people is just as real as the rain experienced by the real people on the other side of the real world.

Thanks for such an interesting question!