> The eerie thing is that as far as we can tell, our brains are no more than models of consciousness, and yet they are conscious.
Wow. That is an extremely good description of the problem of consciousness. Is this your own formulation? If not, where did you run into it?
Re:Objects of consciousness
by Lambdanaut on Saturday July 04, 2015 @04:44PM
(#9831548)
I've been thinking about it a long time and hadn't heard it from anyone else. I'm glad to get feedback :)
Re:Objects of consciousness
by icebraining on Saturday July 04, 2015 @12:34PM
(#9830655)
Isn't a brain an implementation of a model of consciousness, rather than a model itself? I don't see how they are "no more than models of consciousness". Of course, this is using "model" as "mathematical/scientific model", not as "reproduction".
Right, which is exactly why our brains do not directly perceive the "truth" of physical reality. It's models all the way down.
Re:Objects of consciousness
by escherplex on Saturday July 04, 2015 @03:16PM
(#9831284)
Bingo. In common philosophical usage 'consciousness' is conflated with what is evinced in consciousness, or process contents (cogito ergo sum). Back in 1988, Bernard Baars in 'A Cognitive Theory of Consciousness' separated self-iterative 'awareness' from process and posited 'awareness' as a 'global workspace' interfacing with parallel subliminal neural subprocessors which collectively manufacture an interactive model of 'reality'. By extension this would reduce all human intellectual modeling of ascertained 'reality' to projections of native intellectual predispositions hard-wired into the neural architecture. But what's basic? Here you're still faced with the same problem which still confronts experimental physics: to study a phenomena you have to employ instrumentation synthesized from the same building blocks of which the phenomena itself is constituted.
The line is very blury between a model of consciousness and the point where it can not only be described as conscious but truly has that ethereally, hard to define quality that we "feel" as consciousness.
Would the first truly general AIs simply be working models of consciousness, or would they also feel consciousness as we do? When does the viz creep into our model?