News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Farewell to America: Returning to England After 12 Years ... by cb18 on Friday July 03, 2015 @11:27PM (#9829027)
This appears to be a long-winded telling of the kind of nonsensical crap that has been circulating as of late that tries to convince people a circle is a square, or up is down or something equally preposterous.

How did the descendants of immigrants become xenophobic?

The founders of the USA were not immigrants, they didn't immigrate to join Indian tribes, they were founders of a country. And until very recently, immigrants to the USA immigrated and integrated, they became Americans, they didn't immigrate and expect to receive special treatment because they were a member of group X.

It's not xenophobic to simply not want your country and culture to be overrun with competing cultures. The idea of multiculturalism is nonsense. Cultures can't coexist that's just not how it works, a culture is the dominant way of life in an area, you can't invite another culture to come and live within the confines of another culture, that makes no sense. What is being done in such a case is you are inviting significant changes to the host culture, and it shouldn't be surprising that most people are pretty content with their home culture and they're not receptive to the idea of having foreign cultures thrust into their home.

cannot pay a visit to their home country because they are undocumented

Are you f-ing kidding me? Can't do you something because it is likely to reveal that they are in violation of a law they willfully chose to violate? That's some kind of big problem we should be concerned with?

A nation without laws is no nation at all. What's the point of any country having rules and regulations for the people they admit if people who break those rules are simply overlooked, much less greeted with pity and concern for their plight of possibly getting caught?

When matters such as these are written about in the media why is it that preference is so often given to euphemisms such as 'undocumented' when what they are actually trying to describe is illegal alien?

-

Another commenter mentioned the race angle that was brought up in this article, I luckily missed most of that in my brief skimming.

The real race problem that never seems to be addressed, and it's an uncomfortable reality and whatever the solution is, it is not immediately apparent and I suppose that is one reason why there is a near and total blackout on the subject in the national media. But it doesn't explain why the national media tries to portray the facts in a way that is near 180 degrees opposite to reality.

The real race problem is that when it comes to interracial violence, and black on white vs white on black, the facts are black on white racial violence is off the charts compared to white on black racial violence. It's not even close.

Re:Farewell to America: Returning to England After 12 Years ... by lambda on Saturday July 04, 2015 @12:38AM (#9829222)
> they didn't immigrate and expect to receive special treatment because they were a member of group X.

No one is asking for "special treatment". They are asking not to get special treatment that consists of being killed by police officers.

And yes, too many white people are killed by police. The police in the US have both a tendency to shoot too many people, and have a tendency to target too many black people, which both add up to shooting disproportionately many black people.

And yeah, the problem is more complex than simple racism by police. There are problems of too many criminals being armed in the US (both black and white), meaning that the police are more prone to shoot in supposed self defense. There are problems of class and poverty, that lead people into violence. There are a lot of complex, interrelated factors that lead to this.

But all of that said, it is undeniable that there are a disproportionate number of law abiding or peaceful, unarmed black men who are killed by police in this country.

> The real race problem is that when it comes to interracial violence, and black on white vs white on black, the facts are black on white racial violence is off the charts compared to white on black racial violence. It's not even close.

Interracial violence is a pretty small fraction of all violence.

Most violence is intraracial. Source: http://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/htius.pdf (2010, reporting data up to 2005, see page 67); about 42% of homicides are black on black, about 45% are white on white, about 8.8% are black on white, about 3.2% are white on black. If you're white, I'd be a lot more worried about that 45% than the 8.8%.

You know what's likely to be the most likely way to avoid getting killed or shot? Not having family members who have ready access to firearms. You are a lot more likely to be shot by a family member in anger than you are by a stranger of another race.

Re:Farewell to America: Returning to England After 12 Years ... by artimaeis on Saturday July 04, 2015 @12:46AM (#9829241)
>> "The idea of multiculturalism is nonsense"

Say that sentence on St Patrick's day sometime and see how much sense it makes. Or Cinco de Mayo. Or eat at a cal-mex or tex-mex restaurant. Here in America we celebrate our multiculturalism. We sure don't avoid it because it's "nonsense".

>> "the facts are black on white racial violence is off the charts compared to white on black racial violence"

Care to cite that? I'm not sure exactly what metric you'd be citing, but I was pretty quickly able to find that the majority of hate crimes are committed by white offenders: https://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/hate-crime/2010/narrat...

Re:Farewell to America: Returning to England After 12 Years ... by cb18 on Saturday July 04, 2015 @02:59AM (#9829499)
Say that sentence on St Patrick's day sometime and see how much sense it makes. Or Cinco de Mayo. Or eat at a cal-mex or tex-mex restaurant.

Those are examples of heritage. Multiple heritages can form a culture. Cultures are the formal and informal laws, social mores, and general modus operandi of a people. An example of the unwelcome effects of attempting to fuse incompatible cultures - https://duckduckgo.com/?q=rotherham+rapes+pakistani

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-debate/the-unspeakable-...

Here in America we celebrate our multiculturalism. We sure don't avoid it because it's "nonsense".

It's not a question of whether it is celebrated or not. It's a matter of if you think about it for a bit it makes no sense, it's logically impossible. There could be two or more adjacent cultures and as history shows, they are likely to come into conflict. But there cannot be one culture that is composed of multiple cultures because what a culture is, it's very definition, is what a group and area have in common.

Also, as you may or may not be aware, Cinco de Mayo is a mostly American invention.

And if "multiculturalism" whatever that is, is so great, you'd think someone would have come up with support for that notion by now beyond "Ethnic food!"

Care to cite that? I'm not sure exactly what metric you'd be citing, but I was pretty quickly able to find that the majority of hate crimes

If it wasn't clear, by 'violence' I meant things like rape, murder, and assault.

You cite something for which there is actually a degree of ambiguity, discretion, even politics in its prosecution, 'hate crimes.'

Why don't we just stick to the basics, numbers to numbers, dead bodies. A murder seems to be ipso facto a hate crime. Blacks kill whites far more often than vice versa.

Re:Farewell to America: Returning to England After 12 Years ... by g8oz on Saturday July 04, 2015 @12:02PM (#9830519)
>>A murder seems to be ipso facto a hate crime. Blacks kill whites far more often than vice versa.

Wrong. Murder committed in the course of a robbery is not a hate crime. Even robbing and killing a white person because "white people got money" is not a hate crime. A quick Google search will let you know the real definition.

Re:Farewell to America: Returning to England After 12 Years ... by cb18 on Saturday July 04, 2015 @01:10PM (#9830772)
I'm not talking about the politically motivated definition of "hate crime." Look up "ipso facto."

I made the point that anyone who kills another individual for some trivial material gain, or other arbitrary reason, no doubt harbors more than a little hate for themselves, others and society.

-

On a meta note, I wish people would learn to formulate their cases without leading with a blurt of things like "Wrong." Then they would hopefully devote a little more thought to the issues they are discussing, especially the important ones

Re:Farewell to America: Returning to England After 12 Years ... by lambda on Sunday July 05, 2015 @02:18PM (#9834366)
> It's a matter of if you think about it for a bit it makes no sense, it's logically impossible.

Let's take a look at a dictionary definition of culture: "the way of life, especially the general customs and beliefs, of a particular group of people at a particular time" (http://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/british/culture)

Now, note the "particular group of people" part. A person can be a member of more than one group. Some groups are sub-groups of others; some overlap with others.

For example, I am an American, and as such I have been brought up in American culture, with many of the traditions and ideals that that entails; Thanksgiving, the 4th of July, a strong belief in civil liberties, and a love of strawberry rhubarb pie.

American culture is also a subset of Western European culture, with influences from Catholic and Protestant branches of Christianity, so while I am not myself Christian, I celebrate Christmas and Easter and have many Christian influences on my values and life.

However, I am also a member of other cultures. My most recent ancestors to travel to the US were Scottish; and so Scottish culture is also part of my culture, but not most other people in the US. I wear kilts to weddings, and have an uncle and cousin who play bagpipes at weddings and funerals. That's a part of my culture, but that is not a part of overall American culture.

I'm also a software engineer and computer geek, and involved in free software, advocacy for civil liberties online, advocate for strong encryption and privacy, and the like. This is a particular subculture that tends to promote strong protections for individual privacy and liberty, while openness and transparency on behalf of institutions such as corporations and governments. This is not part of mainstream American culture, but it is part of my culture; and this particular subculture spans multiple countries as well, so in many of these ways, I have more cultural values in common with a Brazilian or German who is also involved in these communities than I do with the average American.

There are many other subcultures I could describe myself as a member of. And the same goes for anyone you ask. "Culture" is not one big, monolithic thing with clear boundaries. Because it is a set of customs and beliefs shared with a group, that set can be larger or smaller, and stronger or weaker, depending on how big of a group you choose.

> And if "multiculturalism" whatever that is, is so great, you'd think someone would have come up with support for that notion by now beyond "Ethnic food!"

Food is a pretty fundamental part of any culture. As something that is necessary for sustaining life, it's something that everyone does. In almost every culture I've seen, meals are a large part of fostering community, of strengthening social bonds. You have meals with family, with friends, with coworkers. "Breaking bread" is a term rich with culture connotations of mutual trust, peace, welcoming, because sharing food with someone is so important; and the same holds in many other cultures, one of the most generous and welcoming things you can do is invite someone to your table and share your food with them.

So don't be so quick to dismiss "ethnic food" as an important part of multiculturalism. Food is in many ways the heart of of a culture, and exploring the food culture of another people can be a strong way to share something with them.

However, multiculturalism can extend far beyond that as well.

The musical heritage of America is quite strongly multicultural. Ragtime, blues, jazz, R&B, and hip-hop all have their roots in black culture in the US, but have had enormous influences in white culture as well. Of course a large amount of American musical traditions comes from Western European classical and pop traditions as well, and then there are a variety of folk traditions, such as Celtic, that have been integrated into the mainstream through bluegrass and country music.

But there's a lot more than just that. A large number of cultures have made substantial impact on film in America. Many of our "Western" genre is actually a product of Italy; but that in turn influence Akira Kurosawa in Japan, with Samurai westerns such as Yojimbo. His work has also influenced Western work, where The Magnificent Seven is a western remake of Kurosawa's Seven Samurai, and his The Hidden Fortress is one of the major influences on Star Wars.

Let's see, getting back to day to day life, Jewish culture has also had a fairly large impact; from Yiddish, we get words like "schmuck", "chutzpa" and "klutz". We also get bagels (oops, back to food again),

On the musical front again, some of the best American music like Gershwin's Rhapsody in Blue had roots in Western classical tradition, jazz, and klezmer, traditional Ashkenazi folk music.

I could go on, but man, detailing all of the positive effects of multiculturalism on American society could fill up hundreds of volumes of books, not just a single comment on HN.

> A murder seems to be ipso facto a hate crime.

That is not what is meant by the term "hate crime." Simply redefining a term that has a particular meaning to mean something else does not really add to the discussion.

I'll quote from Wikipedia:

> In both crime and law, hate crime (also known as bias-motivated crime) is a usually violent, prejudice motivated crime that occurs when a perpetrator targets a victim because of his or her perceived membership in a certain social group. Examples of such groups include but are not limited to: ethnicity, gender identity, disability, language, nationality, physical appearance, religion, or sexual orientation.

A "hate crime" is not simply any violent crime. It is a crime in which the attacker was motivated by their perception of the victim's membership of some other group.

There are several things that can motivate a criminal to commit a crime. Poverty, greed, hatred of a particular group, hatred of a particular person, sheer anti-social tendencies, and I'm sure many other motivating factors. Only one of these falls under the term "hate crime" as it is commonly defined; those crimes in which hatred of a particular group of people is a primary motivator.

If you look at the statistics I cited in a previous comment, while it is true that black on white murder happens more often than white on black, white on white murder far surpasses either (and likewise, black on black). No amount of arguing about the black on white vs. white on black levels of crime will make these intraracial crimes go away, and the levels of intraracial crime is a very strong signal that racial animus is not actually the motivation for the majority of crime that occurs.

The reason it is important to look at the motivation behind a crime, and not just the statistics about whether a crime happened, is that the motivations can help tell you the best way to reduce that type of crime in the future.

Hate crimes, in the sense of any crime committed on behalf of membership in some group, can be particularly dangerous because they can lead to either prolonged violence between those two groups, or ethnic cleansing or genocide. These types of crimes, when allowed to escalate, have escalated into some of the greatest atrocities of a last couple of centuries. Breaking the chain of hate-motivated violence by discouraging the use of rhetoric of hate, by changing laws that institutionalize disparities between these groups, and by applying harsher penalties to those crimes committed for these reasons, are some ways to deal with these types of crimes.

Crimes committed due to a hatred of a particular person, however, are fairly different. They are usually based on some aspect of those people's relationship; perhaps an abusive domestic relationship, a cheating spouse, or the like. Here, there isn't some group-based animus, but a dysfunctional personal relationship. Here, the better way to deal with the problems are to provide better outlets for change than violence; provide shelters for people to escape from abusive relationships, allow divorce, as it it preferable to violence or murder.

Crimes that are committed due to poverty, to people having as sense of hopelessness and no further opportunity but to turn to crime, are another kind of problem. Here providing better social services, better education, better access to affordable housing, and the like can all help take that pressure off that can push people over the edge.

In all of these cases, the actual perpetrators of actual crimes do need to be punished; there needs to be deterrence as well. However, on a societal level, there can be many things done to reduce the temptation and pressure to engage in criminal behavior. And even on the individual level, knowing someone's motivation for a crime can be important in rehabilitating them and reintroducing them back to society.

Re:Farewell to America: Returning to England After 12 Years ... by bruceb on Saturday July 04, 2015 @01:03AM (#9829294)
hate crimes offenders: 58.6 percent were white. 18.4 percent were black.

Whites being a majority of the country this isn't an overwhelming number.

Re:Farewell to America: Returning to England After 12 Years ... by jbert on Saturday July 04, 2015 @06:20PM (#9831781)
> The founders of the USA were not immigrants, they didn't immigrate to join Indian tribes, they were founders of a country.

Sorry, I'm afraid I don't understand the distinction you're drawing.

If some people move from one country to another, and the other place has people living there already, what characteristics of the move classify it as founding a country rather than immigration?

Re:Farewell to America: Returning to England After 12 Years ... by cb18 on Saturday July 04, 2015 @08:50PM (#9832112)
I wish I could believe you weren't serious, especially today, July 4. But, oh well.

The fact that there was no existing country here in the sense the European migrants understood one to be, and the fact they didn't integrate with Indian tribes or attempt to.

The fact they literally founded a country, established the institutions intrinsic to, and expounded extensively on said founded country and the characteristics necessary to make said new country successful.

Re:Farewell to America: Returning to England After 12 Years ... by 1stop on Saturday July 04, 2015 @12:49AM (#9829254)
Firstly, provide a citation for the White-on-Black vs Black-on-white violence stats. Also indicating level of violence (i.e assaults, robberies, murders, etc).

Your definition of an immigrant is interesting, and seems to suggest an assimilation rather than an immigration. Trying to pretend that "Nation founding" was not cultural destruction is an amazing cognitive disconnect.

If you don't want to change your culture then don't try to exploit foreign workers(through immigration) to prop up your failing economy. Certainly don't prop up your economy then get upset with the underclass you are exploiting to do it when they complain they are being exploited.

It's amazing how righteous "whites" can be about the sheer disgusting way they have acted in their history.

Re:Farewell to America: Returning to England After 12 Years ... by kingmanaz on Friday July 03, 2015 @11:50PM (#9829106)
This needed to be said and needs to be heard.