News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin is Unsustainable? by golergka on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @04:40AM (#9803777)
> the only thing funding the miners will be transaction fees

How does that work, exactly? I thought that the only reward that the miners get is the block reward hard-wired in the system. Is there another mechanism that allows them to negotiate transaction prices with clients and accept/decline transactions?

Re:Bitcoin is Unsustainable? by modeless on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @04:25PM (#9808204)
Bitcoin transactions include an optional fee, chosen by the sender, which is paid to the miner who mines the block containing that transaction. Miners choose which transactions go into their blocks. They can accept or decline transactions at will, and also choose which transactions are processed first. Rational miners will process higher fee transactions first, and may also set a fee threshold below which they reject transactions. This mechanism is already in place and working.

Currently transaction fees are negligible compared to the block reward. Many miners are willing to process 0 fee transactions because it hardly costs them anything and promotes use of the network. However this will change over time as the block reward declines and transaction fees become more important.

Re:Bitcoin is Unsustainable? by ufo on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @01:47PM (#9807100)
Bitcoin fees are more like "tips"m there is no negotiation involved. When someone posts a bitcoin transaction to the network, they can optionally include a fee along with it. When miners bundle up transactions into blocks to add to the blockchain they give priority to transactions with higher fees.

Of course, the huge problem here is that there is only an incentive to add substantial fees if the number of transactions is larger than the maximum the network can handle. If they increase the blocksize to allow for more transactions per minute then there will be less incentive to pay fees. The fee system is also not very friendly to microtransactions because its not percentage based.

Re:Bitcoin is Unsustainable? by drdeca on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @01:44PM (#9807068)
Iirc, a transaction has some number of ongoing and outgoing things, and the part of the ingoing things which don't go to outgoing things goes to the miner of the block that includes the transaction.

The specifics of that might not be quite right.

But a transaction generally specifies some amount which goes to whoever mines a block which includes the transaction.

If one wants their transaction to be included in a block more quickly, one can include a higher transaction fee, so that miners have a greater incentive to include your transaction in a block compared to other transactions.

I am fairly sure that the above is basically correct, but not entirely sure.

I don't actually own and have not used bitcoin, I'm just interested in the space.