News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by PMan74 on Monday June 29, 2015 @06:06AM (#9797218)
> with their lack of assigned seating.

I'm pretty sure unassigned seating has been proven to be the fastest way to load an aircraft in practice.

> what makes this less possible than it was back then?

I'm not sure, I'd guess there are controls in place now that were not in place then e.g. passenger manifest reconciliation for security, ID checks, etc.

Ryanair (European Southwest essentially) target 25 minutes. If there were a way to do if faster I think they'd have found it.

Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by ssmoot on Monday June 29, 2015 @09:14AM (#9797818)
The "unassigned seating" thing is a little amusing since IME SouthWest actually has like 7 levels of "special" (at least it feels like that) before general seating is allowed.

I probably wouldn't change it (the special priorities) given the choice, but it is mildly annoying when it feels like you're waiting in line for an extra 10 or 15 minutes because you're not pregnant, a veteran, a VIP, etc.

Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by djrogers on Monday June 29, 2015 @11:28AM (#9798661)
Southwest has 1 (one) pre boarding phase - the vast majority of passengers in that phase are physically handicapped and need extra time to board. I fly southwest frequently (a-list) and have never seen it any other way - you get a blue sleeve, you pre-board. If not, you get in line with your group.

If they occasionally let a veteran or pregnant woman in that line who cares?

Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by jcfiala on Monday June 29, 2015 @01:41PM (#9799609)
I do know that families with small children often board between the A and B groups. Which is nice, because families often want or need to sit together, but it still makes having an A ticket special.
Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by ssmoot on Monday June 29, 2015 @11:51AM (#9798836)
Maybe it depends on airport. I've definitely never seen a "blue sleeve". And I've definitely heard veteran pre-board called out at Love Field.

Either way, like I said, I probably wouldn't change it. It has no real impact on where I sit. It's just the whole making a slow, inconvenient, annoying process just that much slower, more annoying.

Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by fudgie on Monday June 29, 2015 @08:27AM (#9797608)
Mythbusters had a go at testing plane boarding time and customer statisfaction: http://mythbustersresults.com/airplane-boarding
Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by protomyth on Monday June 29, 2015 @11:47AM (#9798814)
Yeah, they are entertaining, but their methods are pretty flawed. The episode with the snow plow http://mythbustersresults.com/episode56 was beyond flawed and actually gave a dangerous result.
Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by Nicholas_C on Monday June 29, 2015 @11:15AM (#9798579)
>Ryanair (European Southwest essentially)

I would say they're the European equivalent of Spirit Airlines, or rather Spirit Airlines is the American equivalent of Ryanair.

Southwest is head and shoulders above both those carriers as far as customer experience goes (Two free carry ons (1 overhead item and one personal item), two FREE checked bags, free peanuts/almonds).

Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by MadManE on Monday June 29, 2015 @11:25AM (#9798639)
>free peanuts/almonds

Is this really a selling point? A bag of $0.50 nuts to accompany a $500.00 ticket?

Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by JadeNB on Monday June 29, 2015 @01:28PM (#9799519)
I think that people haven't yet really got out of the mindset where you couldn't bring your own food on planes. Now that you can, their providing food (or not) is much less of an issue, but it's still hard, for me, at least, to resist the frisson of thinking "free food!" (even if, as you say, I have already more than paid for it).
Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by Nicholas_C on Monday June 29, 2015 @11:51AM (#9798832)
No, it's not a deal breaker, but it's something small that makes the customer feel valued/appreciated and not like a walking dollar sign whose presence is an annoyance to the flight crew.

And in an industry characterized by extremely low margins a $0.50 bag of peanuts per person is definitely significant money out of their pocket.

Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by Symbiote on Monday June 29, 2015 @04:28PM (#9800769)
On Ryanair it would be.

The cheapest fare advertised on their homepage is £7.99, London Stansted to Strasbourg (15 August, debit card payment, carry-on luggage only).

A bag of nuts, according to the menu in their FAQ section, is €2.

Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by jkestner on Monday June 29, 2015 @07:14PM (#9801802)
Its value is a lot more than 50 cents when you've been hauling a baby through airports, sat on the tarmac because of weather, and didn't have time to grab a scrap of food yourself.
Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by aaronbrethorst on Monday June 29, 2015 @01:05PM (#9799344)
You should go look into how Ryanair works. They sell cheap tickets, and then nickel and dime you on everything else.
Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by talideon on Monday June 29, 2015 @12:34PM (#9799147)
Ryanair have gotten a bit better, mainly due to the actual experience of buying tickets from them online recently becoming much less of a hassle than it used to be.

Still, there's no chance they'll go easier on carry-on and checked baggage: for them, that's about minimising fuel usage and maximising profit.

Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by tomarr on Monday June 29, 2015 @07:19AM (#9797402)
> I'm pretty sure unassigned seating has been proven to be the fastest way to load an aircraft in practice.

I would disagree with this. My experience is of low-cost operators in Europe (Ryanair, Easyjet, Wizz etc.), and I believe their experiences have been the opposite. Whilst most of the carriers used to operate on an unassigned seating basis, with fees for reserved seating, now seating is 'randomly' assigned at online check-in (although if possible groups are sat together). You can still pay for reserved seating but the benefit is obviously a lot less now.

My anecdotal evidence is that this has massively quickened the boarding process. Before, there would be delays waiting for people to sort out their seating and luggage arrangements (families especially), now it is much less of an issue and turnaround times are quicker.

It's also possible that the massive increase in people taking only hand-luggage in recent years has been a factor, but I'm not sure.

Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by ghshephard on Monday June 29, 2015 @09:10AM (#9797799)
The various controlled studies I've seen, including the mythbusters report, all show unassigned seating to be fastest.
Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by e12e on Monday June 29, 2015 @10:12AM (#9798152)
It's not clear from the link posted earlier[1] if mythbusters did a run of 10-100 seatings and calculated the average/median for each method - but it looks like they just did each once. If so I don't think a difference of +/-1 minute is significant. A difference of 100 in customer satisfaction probably is.

This is also culture dependent. Nobody boards planes like a group of Japanese. Be that salarymen or high-schoolers on a school trip.

The rest of the world might board in more reasonable time if they got help to stand in line by their seat numbers (better yet, print seatnumber and an integer on the ticket - have people line up at the gate prior to boarding in accordance to the integer).

Would work except for the Scandinavians that'd consider themselves exempt... ;-)

[1] http://mythbustersresults.com/airplane-boarding

Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by mindslight on Monday June 29, 2015 @12:28PM (#9799100)
IMHO the reason Southwest free-for-all boarding works is that people choose their seat and then stick with it.

On assigned seating flights, I've noticed plenty of people deliberately sitting in the wrong seat. They know their assigned seat is waiting for them so they might as well try to score a better one. In addition, there are the more reasonable people who find their seat then ask people to switch to be closer to friends etc. This all takes time.

Having to play the seat game is stressful (o hai nonchalant couple straddling the middle seat...), but certainly not as stressful as getting fondled by the blue shirted molesters or wondering if you'll get into an argument with a flight attendant who wants to gate check your electronics-laden carryon.

Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by JadeNB on Monday June 29, 2015 @01:30PM (#9799532)
> have people line up at the gate prior to boarding in accordance to the integer

Whenever I've had to queue way in advance of boarding in order just not to be at the end of my line, I've wished for this sort of solution—but, every time, it seems to me that you'd just run into the trouble where the lower-numbered folks wouldn't all show up on time, and then you'd have to (1) find a way to insert them into the line, which seems like it would have to slow them down, or (2) put them at the back of the line, in which case the whole point of the numbering scheme would be lost and we'd be right back to lines forming long before they need to do so.

Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by e12e on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @03:52AM (#9803627)
If one had to print tickets, that might be a problem. But with cellphones, you could just have everyone et their seating at the gate. And "dynamically" move people that are late, out of the way.

So, lets say a plane seat 100, 75 show up on time - seat them automatically when the show up at the gate according to preferences. Those that remain, get what remains when they arrive. Want your seat? Want to sit with your group? Be at the gate 10 minutes before boarding (or however long it takes people to line up).

Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by dhimes on Monday June 29, 2015 @07:50AM (#9797479)
I guess maybe the practical limits of traveler behavior trump the theoretical ideal? The mathematical solution to boarding passengers was examined a while back:

http://phys.org/news/2008-02-board-plane.html

Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by imglorp on Monday June 29, 2015 @08:03AM (#9797515)
> although if possible groups are sat together

At times they have taken this to a new low: upselling the benefit of sitting together. The seat assignment algorithm is probably optimizing profit, not retaining groups.

http://www.foxnews.com/travel/2014/07/30/airlines-and-parent...

Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by jdmichal on Monday June 29, 2015 @12:18PM (#9799028)
It gets far, far worse than that. I had an American Airlines flight which showed every seat except the "premium" paid ones as full. Since I highly value sitting next to my wife, I went ahead and coughed up the $20 necessary to buy two seats together.

The plane flew at about 20% capacity. That diagram showing all the seats except premium ones filled? Complete and utter bullshit. I got a refund in my email a couple days later; I can only assume due to my complaining to the flight attendant about the situation. And I haven't flown American since.

Re:The Man Who Saved Southwest Airlines with a '10-Minute' Idea by jedrek on Monday June 29, 2015 @06:42AM (#9797319)
More like: if they haven't found it, it's not for a lack of trying.