News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Request to econ and math people: solve the Delhi Universi... by yummyfajitas on Friday June 26, 2015 @07:25AM (#9783581)
How do you reliably and objectively identify the gems?

Note that an American-style "holistic" system is unnecessary since India explicitly allows racism into the process (so no need for convoluted schemes to hide it).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reservation_in_India#Governmen...

Re:Request to econ and math people: solve the Delhi Universi... by piyush_soni on Friday June 26, 2015 @07:43AM (#9783636)
As much as I hate the Reservation system in Indian colleges, I wouldn't call that 'racism'. They are two different things. They are trying to _mitigate_ the effects of a possible racism by doing this. Just that they don't understand they have to give that reservation advantage to them really early in life - not while admitting students for Doctor and Engineer degrees.
Re:Request to econ and math people: solve the Delhi Universi... by yummyfajitas on Friday June 26, 2015 @07:59AM (#9783705)
The fact that one might allude to cancelling one bit of racism with another doesn't make it not racism. (I'm defining "racism" as "discrimination based on race", not "any cause for a statistical disparity" as some other people do.)

I must say that I do prefer the Indian system to the US system, however. It's at least explicit and can be debated on merits. The purveyors of the US system are secretive so as to prevent opponents from gathering facts to argue against it.

Re:Request to econ and math people: solve the Delhi Universi... by ejstronge on Friday June 26, 2015 @09:07AM (#9784011)
I think you (and others) have espoused this viewpoint in other threads.

I'll just say that having an outsider (perhaps a politician) re-appropriate words that have a clear, technical definition (say surveillance or security) must be frustrating for experts who understand those words.

Redefining a well-understood technical word is a good rhetorical technique but side steps whatever logic underlies the word's original defintion.

Re:Request to econ and math people: solve the Delhi Universi... by colechristensen on Friday June 26, 2015 @07:48AM (#9783662)
Give everyone between 16 and 20 basic income, access to MOOCs (supported by advisers, TA's, etc.), dorm-like housing and let anybody try to do anything.

Select those who've made something of themselves for 2 years of university undergraduate finishing.

Re:Request to econ and math people: solve the Delhi Universi... by yummyfajitas on Friday June 26, 2015 @08:05AM (#9783735)
You've cooked up a scheme that's vastly more expensive than the current one (let me remind you that India is poor) and you still haven't even explicitly defined "made something of themselves".

Let me also remind you that unlike the US, India is a country with real problems - with the money you spend on this crazy vague subjective university admission scheme, you could instead do something useful like building more toilets.

Re:Request to econ and math people: solve the Delhi Universi... by witty_username on Friday June 26, 2015 @10:34AM (#9784623)
Just because there are "real problems" doesn't mean other problems are insignificant and worthless. Because India is a poor country, cost of living is cheaper so less money would be needed for basic income, which somewhat reduces the effect of less tax income.
Re:Request to econ and math people: solve the Delhi Universi... by yummyfajitas on Friday June 26, 2015 @11:35AM (#9785221)
The cost of constructing toilets is also cheaper. The opportunity cost (measured in # of toilets built, or rapes prevented by police, or children who don't starve) remains the same.
Re:Request to econ and math people: solve the Delhi Universi... by colechristensen on Friday June 26, 2015 @08:19AM (#9783787)
>unlike the US, India is a country with real problems

Every country has "real problems" unless your definition of a real problem is the winner of a who-suffers-the-most pissing contest. (In which case perhaps the Congo is the only country with real problems.)

Re:Request to econ and math people: solve the Delhi Universi... by sumitviii on Friday June 26, 2015 @08:18AM (#9783785)
This argument is just like the one used against Mars program. In competitions, asymmetrical developments are often better than symmetrical ones.

We can build more toilets (aren't we already?) or we can educate next generation to aspire to do something great.

Re:Request to econ and math people: solve the Delhi Universi... by yummyfajitas on Friday June 26, 2015 @08:48AM (#9783929)
We are already educating the next generation. The question is whether we should adopt some incredibly expensive scheme to implement a vague and subjective university enrollment method when we already have a very effective one, or whether we should spend the money on toilets for the bottom half instead.

Every ~2500rs spent on colechristensen's basic income is one less toilet. That's the core calculation.

And yes, I do think the money spent on the Mars orbiter was just an exercise in national pride and would have been better spent on toilets, protecting women's dignity, literacy/arithmetic/english and similar low hanging fruit.

Re:Request to econ and math people: solve the Delhi Universi... by sumitviii on Friday June 26, 2015 @10:06AM (#9784404)
>money spent on the Mars orbiter was just an exercise in national pride

When start-ups compete against big corporations, do they try to follow corporate crap and other slow things? The advantage of being second is that you can learn from those ahead of you.

Although I agree that at least basic sanitation is more important than this, but this is not the case in general. In general, we need to invest in next generation technologies and advancements. Only then can we create income sources which dwarf all coming from the advancements of rest of the world.

Re:Request to econ and math people: solve the Delhi Universi... by MichaelCrawford on Friday June 26, 2015 @07:36AM (#9783612)
I studied astronomybat caltech.

The valedictorian of the other high school didnt get an interview.

The valedictorian of my high school didnt apply.

I totally blew off high school to do my own thing.

However I was crushed that I was not accepted to MIT.

I didnt apply to stanford. I expect I would have gotten in but didnt think we could afford it. In reality stanford is so expensive so people like me can get great financial aid.

Caltech was quite cheap for a private school no doubt because it is small but with a hufe endowment.

Re:Request to econ and math people: solve the Delhi Universi... by TheLoneWolfling on Friday June 26, 2015 @08:47AM (#9783922)
astronomybat == astronomy at?