Re:Request to econ and math people: solve the Delhi Universi...
by piyush_soni on Friday June 26, 2015 @07:43AM
(#9783636)
As much as I hate the Reservation system in Indian colleges, I wouldn't call that 'racism'. They are two different things. They are trying to _mitigate_ the effects of a possible racism by doing this. Just that they don't understand they have to give that reservation advantage to them really early in life - not while admitting students for Doctor and Engineer degrees.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Request to econ and math people: solve the Delhi Universi...
by yummyfajitas on Friday June 26, 2015 @07:59AM
(#9783705)
The fact that one might allude to cancelling one bit of racism with another doesn't make it not racism. (I'm defining "racism" as "discrimination based on race", not "any cause for a statistical disparity" as some other people do.)
I must say that I do prefer the Indian system to the US system, however. It's at least explicit and can be debated on merits. The purveyors of the US system are secretive so as to prevent opponents from gathering facts to argue against it.
Re:Request to econ and math people: solve the Delhi Universi...
by ejstronge on Friday June 26, 2015 @09:07AM
(#9784011)
I think you (and others) have espoused this viewpoint in other threads.
I'll just say that having an outsider (perhaps a politician) re-appropriate words that have a clear, technical definition (say surveillance or security) must be frustrating for experts who understand those words.
Redefining a well-understood technical word is a good rhetorical technique but side steps whatever logic underlies the word's original defintion.