The question of whether you would prefer a licensed taxi or an Uber is a different one which I won't get into for now :)
For international travelers it's the franchising aspect that is most appealing.
So if you don't know the local taxi regulation, your Uber might get pulled over by the cops who take the driver and you're left in the middle of nowhere. This has happened in Helsinki, for example (where the local taxi service is very reliable, albeit somewhat expensive and may be busy at certain hours).
In general, when visiting a country, you are expected to roughly know what the local legislation is.
There might be some reasonable middle ground but I'm quite happy paying for a reliable, regulated service despite it's flaws rather than a wild west situation.
Legal != no rip-off
And I know there is a regulated dispute resolution procedure. But so far Uber/Lyft seem to be a much better process for that too.
I guess my point was that using the same app I use in London and knowing that I'm not going to get ripped off in a strange* city was quite nice
* that's strange as in unfamiliar ;-)
The incumbents never really seem to make an argument beyond shrieking that their protected racket is being disrupted though. I remember one hilarious picture on the news of a cabbie f-ing and blinding to a reporter out of his window at a protest against uber. Just behind him in his cab was a sign saying "cash only".
When an innovation comes along and starts stealing your lunch, screaming that you were here first isn't really going to help you much!
Restricting markets, so you can only use politician approved services is the exact opposite of helping the consumer.
Too expensive? Well I don't really have a choice....
No laws dictated these qualities, no legislation demanded this level of safety. These practices were conceived via market forces, and safety was a by product.
> ...in order to compete in a free market...
The entire point of Uber is that the taxi industry is not a free market, therefore the things necessary to compete in a theoretical "free market" are not relevant and can't be assumed to be why Uber is successful.
Uber uses roads that were designed to comply with government safety regulations and their drivers drive cars designed to comply with a different set of government safety regulations. Those regulations exist because experience has shown that they need to.
Unless I'm wrong you're arguing that Uber is safe and efficient because market forces made it so. It's efficient because of technological advances and it's safe literally to the extent required by law.
Because they've opted out of the regulations their competitors are subject to Uber could offer a a more dangerous and less efficient service than current taxi companies and still "compete".
Quality of black cabs and mini-cabs in London in also wildly variable. At least with uber you can actually leave a bad review (I'm not sure what comes of those) but I get a response on bad reviews at least.
Except the whole point is that taxi license owners want to prevent me from doing that.
What a groundbreaking discovery.
That should kind of leave you asking: exactly who are those regulations supposed to be protecting, anyway?
There are a few apps that work great in Paris like 'Taxis Bleus' and are more convenient than Uber since you can get a taxi to pick you up in a few minutes (they are usually more taxis around you than Uber cars).
Having said that, I'm all for competing cab services. The French taxi system has been games to protect a the taxi drivers at the expense of the users, resulting in high prices and an less convenience (can't hail a taxi).
So while I sympathize with taxi drivers, they really can't expect consumers to not prefer something that's manifestly better for them.
BTW in London, before uber a black cab might cost me £60-70 to get home if I'd missed a train. An uber now can be as little as £25, which is low enough that I can just not worry about the terribly unreliable and sparse trains and plan my trip home that way.