News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Tube map of the London Underground that's more useful t... by bbx on Tuesday June 23, 2015 @04:43AM (#9763363)
"more useful"

That is certainly up debate.

The reason why the diagrammatic layout was (and is) highly praised by the public is because of its readibility.

People only look at 2 locations: their current one and their destination. They will eventually look at possible routes and keep track of a couple of intersections. But everything in between remains unnoticed. It's like believing that users look at every pixel of your website while they actually scan a few spots only.

The physical inaccuracy is irrelevant because you travel underground and only have a sense of time, not of space. Nobody would think "Wait, why is the tube turning North? We're supposed to go East!".

You would think the geographical accuracy of the updated map could be useful for determining which route is the quickest (assuming that physically shorter == quicker). But several additional factors come into play, like traffic, distance between 2 platforms, distance to the street...

This new map also mixes accurate layouts and schematic ones (for outer stations). So it's hard to tell at what point you can still rely upon the map for physical accuracy.

I actually find this unofficial version really appealing. Probably because it's a fresh view on a familiar visual, and provides some "Oh, that's what it looks like" moments. I'm just questioning its usefulness, especially in a time where looking at a map has been rendered obsolete thanks to Citymapper.

Re:A Tube map of the London Underground that's more useful t... by sklogic on Tuesday June 23, 2015 @06:03AM (#9763622)
Definitely useful for me: I walk fast and long distances, and often interested in picking up a tube station which is located roughly in my destination area, with the easiest route from where I am now. Binding stations and lines to a physical map is very useful in this case.
Re:A Tube map of the London Underground that's more useful t... by gadders on Tuesday June 23, 2015 @05:16AM (#9763482)
I think the only time greater geographic accuracy is handy is when you decide to take a shortcut by walking between stations - EG Charing Cross to Embankment.
Re:A Tube map of the London Underground that's more useful t... by learnstats2 on Tuesday June 23, 2015 @06:30AM (#9763707)
"Wait, why is the tube turning North? We're supposed to go East!".

This is actually very irritating for inexperienced tube users.

For example, the Piccadilly line is often signed as running Westbound and Eastbound, but a significant part of it runs North-South, according to all the maps, and compared to the Victoria Line which is indeed signed Northbound and Southbound.

Then Euston-Kings Cross is Northbound on one line, and Southbound on another.

Re:A Tube map of the London Underground that's more useful t... by dcminter on Tuesday June 23, 2015 @06:49AM (#9763773)
Or indeed my favourite anomaly the Circle Line which is signposted as "East" and "West" bound despite being a loop!

(Ok, it has a terminus now which it didn't used to - but that doesn't really clarify anything for baffled tourists at Bayswater).

Re:A Tube map of the London Underground that's more useful t... by dgmdoug on Tuesday June 23, 2015 @07:14AM (#9763869)
I concur -- travelling in Boston can be frustrating for those who are inexperienced. They use 'inbound' and 'outbound', but without knowledge of the centre point for that line this information is useless!
Re:A Tube map of the London Underground that's more useful t... by mcphage on Tuesday June 23, 2015 @02:12PM (#9766507)
> They use 'inbound' and 'outbound', but without knowledge of the centre point for that line this information is useless!

Especially since that changes once you cross the center—you can go "inbound" to your destination, and then "inbound" to go home.

Re:A Tube map of the London Underground that's more useful t... by wereHamster on Tuesday June 23, 2015 @05:32AM (#9763527)
> Nobody would think "Wait, why is the tube turning North? We're supposed to go East!".

I need to go to the tower of london. It is east of my current location, I know because I looked at a tourist map. According to this tube map though the line towards the tower of london stop goes north. Wait, that's not right. Am I going to the right station? Should I be taking another line? Is there maybe a different station that is closer to the tower? Maybe I should take one of the lines that go straight east. Hm. I'm confused. This tube map is confusing. It doesn't match the tourist map that I'm holding in my hand.

Re:A Tube map of the London Underground that's more useful t... by DanBC on Tuesday June 23, 2015 @05:42AM (#9763556)
I need to go to the Tower of London. This tourist map tells me I need to go to Tower Hill station. I'm currently at X, which means I need Y line, it's 4 stops away. I have no idea how long it's going to take to travel those stops. And I don't know how far I'm going to travel.
Re:A Tube map of the London Underground that's more useful t... by callum85 on Tuesday June 23, 2015 @06:41AM (#9763748)
Who gets confused by that? It's obviously just a diagram, not a real 'map'. Of course it's not going to look the same as a geographical map.
Re:A Tube map of the London Underground that's more useful t... by estefan on Tuesday June 23, 2015 @04:49AM (#9763382)
The original maps used to look something similar to this, then that electrical engineer created the current version like an electrical circuit diagram. I think the current one is far more readable...
Re:A Tube map of the London Underground that's more useful t... by joosters on Tuesday June 23, 2015 @05:19AM (#9763492)
I think you're dead right about the Citymapper comment. I like this map as well, especially because it includes some overground railway lines that I would otherwise never think of using. But nowadays I'd just put my destination into Citymapper and it can show me the most useful routes from those, as well as bus lines & plain old walking.

It's always a good feeling when I discover a new way of reaching somewhere when in the past I'd have just gone on the tube.