2. It was someone else who was describing something and likened this other thing to IMAX. Ars was quoting this person, not writing it themselves.
Don’t drag out the “confusion with consumers” thing – absolutely no-one would think that this thing actually was an IMAX™ – it was a comparison. Would I be sued by Coca-Cola if I said that “Pepsi is kind of like Coca-Cola”? Would I cause “confusion with consumers”? No. Trademark law does not mean that trademark owners can control every use of the word, despite what they (and apparently you) would wish for.
But that consumers could think it was IMAX certified or some such. That sort of thing is worth defending.
Making the leap from what was written in the article to "IMAX certified" is a hilariously wide leap. It's about two orders of magnitude too wide to justify the threat letter from IMAX.
For example, if IMAX's point of view is correct here, the entire article linked below[1] wouldn't be legal to write as it compares AMD's new GPUs to Nvidia's GPUs. Simply put, it's a staple of product journalism to compare with other similar technology, and this has always been the case. IMAX is clearly and wholly in the wrong.
It used to mean that, not any more. IMAX screens are allowed to be much, much smaller than before.
And that's because a trademark is exclusive rights over using the name for a commercial purpose. So the IMAX folks could make a product called IMAX-VR if they made a VR headset. But the Oculus folks, if they got some 8k phone screen, couldn't call it Oculus-IMAX without a licensing agreement, because IMAX owns the name IMAX with respect to product names.
But owning it with respect to product names doesn't mean you can prevent people from using it at all. How else would Coke (tm) be able to tell you in a commercial how much better they are than Pepsi (tm) as a result of some ridiculously staged "public tastings" where regular people prefer Coke (tm) to Pepsi (tm) three to one?
Anyone can refer to someone else's trademarked product name full stop. The only thing a trademark does is prevent other people from naming their products the same as, or confusingly similar to, the one which was trademarked first. And if someone thinks their new product name is different enough to be confusing the trademark holder still has to take them to court to prove it.
Nope. It was smaller than the unbranded "Monster Screen" at my local theater in the middle of nowhere.
IMAX no longer really means anything to me.
That "innovation" is >5 years old: http://www.bigscreen.com/journal.php?id=1505
We're left with Lincoln square in NYC and possibly New Rochelle, NY as the only remaining large format IMAX in the area.
And I do think that's a potential valid source of confusion with consumers, who could potentially think SteamVR lives up to the same image projection standards.
It's not as clear cut to me as Ars is making it out to be.