News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by dylanjermiah on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:34PM (#9736270)
"Pao, who has said she would appeal, has offered to drop her case for $2.7 million, Kleiner Perkins said in a court filing earlier this month."
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by rnovak on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:59PM (#9736388)
I get that people will probably disagree, but she just seems to not make very good business decisions. Maybe I'm way off base, but I've read a bunch of well qualified lawyers say that juries are just plain unpredictable, and that no competent lawyer can "guarantee" to win. In that light, even if the $1M settlement wasn't what you're asking for, I would think it paints a better picture of you than losing and having to pay the other side? Anyone care to explain something that I might be missing?
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by obstinate on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:19PM (#9736464)
This logic would basically forbid any lawsuit, no matter how meritorious. Leaving aside what you think her odds are, this isn't how it works. You have to balance the odds of each outcome, not just the absolute best and worst cases.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by rnovak on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:32AM (#9736851)
Aren't like 95%[0] of all cases settled before they even reach trial? To me it seems like that would indicate this logic isn't entirely flawed.

[0]http://thelawdictionary.org/article/what-percentage-of-lawsu...

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by Steko on Thursday June 18, 2015 @02:55AM (#9737144)
The problem with the logic is you can basically plug any number in there and say they should have settled for that number too. If people always just settled becuase they might lose guess how much Big Corps will offer for settlements?

It's easy to say she should have settled in hindsight but if she had won big we'd be saying KP should have offered her more.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by WalterGR on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:15PM (#9736437)

    Anyone care to explain something that I might be missing?
Perhaps her primary concern isn't a cash payout.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by AnkhMorporkian on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:21PM (#9736473)
Were that the case she wouldn't offer to drop her appeal for $2.7 million.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by WalterGR on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:24PM (#9736485)
Her offering a high or higher number doesn't imply that she was only out for cash. Perhaps that amount was what she considered sufficient to punish KP appropriately.

And for the record: Consider this statement as me playing the race card.

But look: I wasn't on the jury, and I haven't reviewed the court records, and like everyone else here I'm playing armchair quarterback.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by AnkhMorporkian on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:46PM (#9736571)
I'm not making any judgements on the case itself; I didn't follow it at all beyond blurbs I heard here on HN and on reddit. However, part of what I heard and just now validated is that $2.7 million is the exact amount that her husband owes in legal fees regarding that ponzi scheme he supposedly ran. If the numbers didn't match up exactly I might have a different reaction, but with that settlement amount it seems entirely pragmatic, not principled.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by WalterGR on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:03PM (#9736623)

    $2.7 million is the exact amount that her husband owes in legal
    fees regarding that ponzi scheme he supposedly ran.
So, on one hand that sounds suspicious. On the other, I know how quickly the Internet (flash) mob is to pick up torches and pitchforks.

At the end of the day, what are we to do? Trust juries as the final arbiter, when we know that they're not infallible? Trust reddit - same, if not more? Has her husband been convicted of running a Ponzi scheme - or is it merely "alleged"? Did literally none of EP's lawyers think, "You know... that number is too obvious. We should fudge it a little."?

Armchair quarterbacks. :)

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by jn1234 on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:17PM (#9736664)
If she wanted to punish KP, she should've said that she would donate whatever she wins minus legal bills to a charity.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by WalterGR on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:24AM (#9736836)
You should contact her and let her know that that's the min bar.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by ctrlfrk on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:36PM (#9736536)
It has been pointed out that $2.7 Million is exactly the amount that her husband owes in unpaid legal bills: http://nypost.com/2015/02/18/case-builds-against-former-ny-h...
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by PythonicAlpha on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:39PM (#9736292)
What do you want to say?

Should everybody just pick the money and run? Without knowing the details of the case and the reasoning of the people, it also could be possible that this woman was not looking for the money, but righteousness.

And no, I am not convinced (without knowing any details), that because the judgement was against her, that this is justness. (I have seen so many unjust judgments in my own country that where based on the fact, that one side had the better lawyers or better experts they hired)

Jurisdiction in human hands can always be an approximation of justness.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by albertop on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:45PM (#9736323)
righteousness == $2.7M ?
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by PythonicAlpha on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:47PM (#9736331)
That is just the opposite of what I tried to say. I am not a native speaker, so I might have been misunderstood ...??

Some things just go beyond figures ...

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by WalterGR on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:37PM (#9736543)

   I am not a native speaker, so I might have been misunderstood ...??
No, you weren't. In the U.S. the primary way to get redress in these kinds of situations is a lawsuit with a concrete financial reward. And to some people, the seeking of a financial reward implies only the desire for the financial reward.

So by that logic: by virtue of seeking redress you're only out for some cold hard cash. And what easier reason is there to decide to not believe a person's claims?

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by PythonicAlpha on Thursday June 18, 2015 @09:11AM (#9738268)
Yes, it seems to be a little two-faced. You are stupid, if you don't take hard cash, but when you do, you are called crooked.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by lugg on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:20PM (#9736467)
albertop, and I, are confused by your post, because you are defending her decision to refuse the 1 million with "righteousness" but must have missed the part of the article where it states she counter offered to settle for 2.7 million.

.. or, 2.7m = righteousness

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by PythonicAlpha on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:29PM (#9736505)
Ok, that was a detail, I simply misunderstood. I thought, that she refused the settlement and wanted to bring it to court.

Still, without knowing the details, it is difficult to judge over a persons motives.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by tomlongson on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:36PM (#9736278)
Kleiner Perkins offered her $1M not to appeal.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by nimos on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:50PM (#9736346)
They offered her $1M not to go to trial. I believe they offered to not go after her for legal fees if she agreed to not appeal.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by arca_vorago on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:56PM (#9736377)
I highly suggest reading this before forming an opinion on the matter. Keep in mind who wrote it as well.

https://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/25617...

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by twir on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:13PM (#9736428)
Very interesting - thanks for sharing. Is there a corresponding brief by the plaintiff? I'd like to see both sides of the story.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by jrockway on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:34PM (#9736272)
Reddit is a "microblogging company"?
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by raldi on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:44PM (#9736318)
Great reporting by the bicycle-repair shop known as Reuters.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by Andrenid on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:51PM (#9736353)
Not to mention there's a typo:

> because she is woman.

If you're going to credit an editor at the bottom, they should probably learn to edit something so simple that Word would've picked it up automatically.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by comex on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:49PM (#9736343)
I thought they were an Australian-themed maker of networking equipment that forwards data between different networks.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by zedadex on Thursday June 18, 2015 @06:20AM (#9737682)
> an Australian-themed maker of networking equipment

"We build networks and get in fights"

[deleted]
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by adventured on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:35PM (#9736529)
Were I a journalist, maybe:

"Reddit is a large Internet forum with thousands of different communities."

It's short, points out the scale, and would be at least modestly comprehensible to the bottom 85% of people when it comes to technology understanding. They mostly know what a forum is, and they know what a community is, and they know what the Internet is.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by macspoofing on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:47PM (#9736334)
It's as good as any description.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by headShrinker on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:09PM (#9736413)
It's as good as literally "any description"; science forum, racist feedback command center, gay hookup site, blog response community, 10th largest website in the solar system, click-bait blog-spam sales site, blue trombone weekly meetup organization, micro blogging community...

It's actually by definition a link aggregate website.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by raldi on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:55PM (#9736367)
How about "online community", "news aggregator", "link-discussion forum"...
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by MBCook on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:32PM (#9736515)
Bulletin board, social network, content farm...
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by tzs on Thursday June 18, 2015 @02:42AM (#9737121)
The long Vanity Fair article from 2013 on Pao and Fletcher that someone else linked to is actually really interesting, but the comments that included the link were inflammatory and derailed discussion, so I'm guessing many people who would have enjoyed the Vanity Fair article skipped it.

Here's the link: http://www.vanityfair.com/style/scandal/2013/03/buddy-fletch...

AMC or HBO or Netflix could make a pretty interesting TV show out of this.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by _s on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:59PM (#9736610)
From the prosecution:

https://s3.amazonaws.com/s3.documentcloud.org/documents/1672...

From the defence:

https://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/25617...

--- Personal opinion below ----

Not necessarily relevant (I believe it is) but provides some more of a background is her husband (whom she married in 2007) - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buddy_Fletcher.

Why it's relevant in my opinion? An old saying translates to something along the lines of "you are the sum of who support, live, work and play with", which I find tends to hold very true.

From what I've read, but haven't been able to look up sources (someone else might chip in here) - her demands for payment (settlements) have always equated to exactly or greater than the sums owed by both her and her husband to their respective creditors.

Edit: I believe she was discriminated against for not being a reliable/honest/good person to work with, not because of her gender.

2nd Edit: Having thought about it, I now agree with /u/obstinate below moreso - her husbands dealings have nothing to do with her. We only know of our partners doings from our partners themselves, so we can't truly be objective and tend to err on the side of trust and loyalty.

She felt as if she was discriminated against, so he likely supported her in her lawsuit. He's lost his business and a home, so of course she'll do what she can to support him.

I still reserve my personal opinion against both, as others will do from reading this against me. I'm leaving my original comment and edit for context.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by obstinate on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:22PM (#9736681)
It is disgusting that you think it's acceptable to tar someone with the alleged crimes of their spouse.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by _s on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:38PM (#9736728)
Trustee report: http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/1127fletche...

Token paragraph at the end of page 13:

"Based on the Trustee’s investigation, the answer to the question of why FILB had no meaningful assets at the time of the bankruptcy filing is principally that the Funds were victims of a fraud defined by the extensive use of wildly inflated valuations, the existence of fictitious assets under management (“AUM”) numbers, the improper payment of excessive fees, the misuse of investor money, and efforts wrongly to deny the Louisiana Pension Funds a key benefit of their investment agreement – mandatory redemption of their investment under certain circumstances. The Funds were also victims of an environment where self-interest all too often trumped fiduciary obligations."

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by obstinate on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:41PM (#9736737)
I don't see anything in here about a conviction, and also nothing about Pao being the alleged perpetrator, and thus remain in a state of appalled disgust at what you have written.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by 001sky on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:12AM (#9736796)
But that just shows you don't understant the relevant word(s) and/or you haven't done any homework (like read even the cover page) on the trustee report.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by obstinate on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:15AM (#9736806)
Why would I read that? A trustee report isn't nor can it be a conviction. And it also has nothing to do with Ellen Pao, the person we are discussing.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by 001sky on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:14PM (#9740125)
1) A nexus with a civil fraud case.

2) That is fundamental due dilligence for any fiduciary appointment.

3) A criminal conviction is un-neccessary to prove civil fraud in relation to (1,2).

(Those are legitimate issues/topics of dicsussion).

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by minimaxir on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:38PM (#9736287)
If the cost of work is $229k, and the reward is $276k, then why is there a $47k difference? Making the defendants whole?
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by michaelhoffman on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:44PM (#9736314)
There are other expenses besides the ones allocated at $229,000.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by phkahler on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:43PM (#9736311)
Why is there any award at all? I keep hearing that defending a case can bankrupt a person or company that doesn't have deep pockets even if they are successful. Why do these guys get reimbursed?
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by dctoedt on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:27PM (#9736500)
> Why do these guys [Kleiner Perkins] get reimbursed?

From the Reuters report, it appears that Kleiner made an offer of judgment under section 998 of the California Code of Civil Procedure, [1] which provides in part:

<blockquote>

(c) (1) If an offer made by a defendant is not accepted and the plaintiff fails to obtain a more favorable judgment or award, the plaintiff shall not recover his or her postoffer costs and shall pay the defendant's costs from the time of the offer.

In addition, in any action or proceeding other than an eminent domain action, the court or arbitrator, in its discretion, may require the plaintiff to pay a reasonable sum to cover costs of the services of expert witnesses, who are not regular employees of any party, actually incurred and reasonably necessary in either, or both, preparation for trial or arbitration, or during trial or arbitration, of the case by the defendant.

</blockquote>

(Emphasis and extra paragraphing added)

"Costs," incidentally, means costs of court such as filing fees, court reporter charges, etc. [2] In this case, by statute (quoted above) the term also include expert witness fees. "Costs" usually does not include attorneys' fees.

[1] http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/displaycode?section=ccp&gr...

[2] http://dictionary.law.com/Default.aspx?selected=382

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by MBCook on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:45PM (#9736741)
I've never heard of a rule like that. Is it common in other states to have a similar 'catch' on making settlement offers?

What's the rational? I could see it as a way to try to prevent SLAPP type suits with quick settlements, but it seems like an awfully sharp double edged sword.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by dctoedt on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:22AM (#9736829)
It's not a catch on making settlement offers; it's a catch on refusing to accept a settlement offer, and then failing to match or beat the offer at trial. The rationale is, you could have had a better deal if you'd accepted the other side's settlement offer, but you dragged the other side through a trial, so you have to pay their court costs.

This is also seen in Rule 68 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Some states have similar rules but also provide for attorneys' fees. See the annotations at http://www.commondraft.org/#SettlementIncentiveClause (self-cite).

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by cheald on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:08AM (#9736790)
The rationale is specifically to encourage parties to try to settle out of court before tying up the justice system with a case. As is illustrated here, it makes the cost of saying "no" to a reasonable settlement both the loss of the settlement and the potential payment of your opponent's costs.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by michaelhoffman on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:46PM (#9736326)
They only get reimbursed for some costs. In this case, chiefly witness fees. They probably paid hundreds of thousands in fees to lawyers which are not reimbursed.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by pixel on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:57PM (#9736383)
The $229k was simply the Jude's guess at the cost. The firm stated it was 865k.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by pixel on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:58PM (#9736386)
Why does she have to pay the legal fees incurred by the defendants because she tried to extort money? Is that what you're asking? She has to pay because she lost, and they weren't doing anything wrong.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by WalterGR on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:20PM (#9736469)

    ...she tried to extort money? ...she lost, and they weren't
    doing anything wrong.
Sorry, sarcasm doesn't carry well over the Internet...

Are you saying that because she lost that implies that she was engaging in extortion?

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by obstinate on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:24PM (#9736486)
Correction: when you sue someone and lose, that does not necessarily mean you were extorting them. In fact, it almost necessarily precludes extortion, since extortion is the act of threatening to reveal a damaging secret unless you are conpensated. It also doesn't necessarily mean that the defendants did nothing wrong, as in the example of failed lawsuits against the NSA.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by monochromatic on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:25PM (#9736490)
No, that's generally not enough. The U.S. courts generally follow the American Rule, not the English Rule.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_rule_%28attorney%27s_...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_rule_%28attorney%27s_f...

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by atorralb on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:07PM (#9736408)
One thing is for sure, Ellen Pao is not liked in Reddit.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by mcphage on Thursday June 18, 2015 @09:09AM (#9738260)
There are certainly parts of Reddit where she isn't liked, definitely. But there are parts of Reddit where they don't like anyone who doesn't let them behave like spoiled, obnoxious children, so I wouldn't consider that indicative of anything.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by cjensen on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:18PM (#9736460)
Because of the ban on groups which actively harass others? Or is there another reason?
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by DanBlake on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:21PM (#9736471)
I think its because of the censoring of stuff which is critical of her and her husband and less about the banning of fat hate subs - See: https://twitter.com/arrington/status/609065906900066304

It especially does not help the fact that her husband was at the helm of a massive scheme that defrauded untold amounts of public workers in regards to their pension

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buddy_Fletcher

http://nypost.com/2015/02/18/case-builds-against-former-ny-h...

Who you are friends with says alot about you. Who you are married to says much, much more.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by obstinate on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:33PM (#9736517)
Yeah, so, SHE did not censor those posts. Nor did admins. Sub moderators did. I mean, it even says that in the news articles you posted.

And who hates a woman because of something her husband did? That is just gross, medieval thinking.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by 001sky on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:39PM (#9736551)
You should probably check your facts on this.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by obstinate on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:57PM (#9736607)
I mean, I just read the news articles that that person posted. If you have evidence to the contrary of these stories, by all means bring it to light.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by 001sky on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:16PM (#9736663)
So the larger point is that you are triviallizing legitimate issues whithout yourself having a grasp on what those issues really are.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by obstinate on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:18PM (#9736671)
Uh. Is this apropos of anything? It seems unrelated to the comment you're responding to. Are you a bot?
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by gooeyblob on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:03PM (#9736622)
We could say the same to you?
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by jfuhrman on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:09AM (#9736792)
Are you serious? Do you even know how Reddit works?
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by knyte on Thursday June 18, 2015 @04:18AM (#9737358)
Admins also have censoring power. I can't find it, but there was a post by I think /u/karmanaut saying that the admins were filtering out Pao-related content in a way that didn't allow mods to re-approve it.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by jfuhrman on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:18PM (#9739604)
Nah there isn't.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by majani on Thursday June 18, 2015 @05:03AM (#9737478)
Let's not forget Ellen Pao's husband is an openly gay male hedge fund manager.

fortune.com/2012/10/25/ellen-pao-buddy-fletcher/

That to me screams that she's a big time financial schemer.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by MichaelGG on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:28PM (#9736502)
The summary I read basically had a few reasons. First that her lawsuit was rather manipulative, with things like refusing to cooperate with investigators after she reported misconduct. Or her classifying a voluntary relationship as coerced.

Additionally, folks on Reddit seem to believe that she coordinated with the previous CEO to take over the job so she'd have a CEO title going in to the lawsuit. Hence the sudden resignation of Yishan for no apparent reason.

There's other things, like refusing to negotiate salaries "because women do worse", which is really just an anti-employee action.

All this was before the banning of subreddits. I also don't find it credible that people dislike her because she's a woman. I don't know if the bits I read are true (they seem well presented, but many false things are), but if so, that's certainly enough reason regardless of gender.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by obstinate on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:19PM (#9736465)
Well, she's a woman, which alone is enough to catch a lot of heat on Reddit.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by BinaryIdiot on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:35PM (#9736528)
I'm not sure that's accurate. I rarely see women get "heat" on reddit but once someone identifies as a women they seem to get far more comments, many even sexual. I'd say women get hit on versus catching heat.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by obstinate on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:38PM (#9736548)
Dear lord. Are you telling me you believe unsolicited sexual advances in response to any non-sexual thing one might post is desirable to women? News flash: it ain't. If you think that women aren't treated badly on Reddit, go to /R/shitredditsays. If you have a problem with the politics of that group, you need not read the comments. Just peruse the linked posts. A pattern quickly begins to emerge.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by cactusface on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:49PM (#9736581)
I think he just means that sexual harassment is different from "heat", however you want to define that.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by obstinate on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:13PM (#9736653)
To catch heat means roughly the same thing as to catch flak. In other words, to be complained about/insulted/whatever.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by BinaryIdiot on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:55PM (#9736769)
> To catch heat means roughly the same thing as to catch flak

Correct.

> In other words, to be complained about/insulted/whatever.

No, that's not what that means. To catch heat or flak is angering / upsetting others due to your actions then being on the receiving of said anger. It has nothing to do with one sided insults.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by obstinate on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:08AM (#9736789)
Not necessarily due to your actions, nor due to wrong actions. Pao is catching heat/flak over removing comments (which there is zero evidence of) or extortion and lying (which suing someone and losing is not) and over banning harassmemt/hate subs (which decision she announces and likely had a hand in, but was a right action).
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by BinaryIdiot on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:35PM (#9739767)
Maybe it's a cultural thing but I've never seen the phrases "catching heat / catching flak" used when it's not in return of an action (I don't see any official definitions online either but as far as I can tell it's in return of some sort of action). What you're describing just sounds like typical insulting / disparagement.

I don't really know how much evidence is in any of those claims (I thought there was supposedly evidence, not zero, but I really don't care enough to bother looking anyway) as I never really wanted to talk or even fight about anything relating to Pao but I could see that changing the context for catching heat / flak if there is or isn't evidence.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by BinaryIdiot on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:49PM (#9736758)
> Are you telling me you believe unsolicited sexual advances in response to any non-sexual thing one might post is desirable to women?

Perhaps you didn't read my post clearly but I said nothing of the sort.

> If you think that women aren't treated badly on Reddit, go to /R/shitredditsays

I said the exact opposite; women are hit on pretty heavily in reddit. I don't see that as being treated well; it's obviously unwanted (at least in the vast, vast majority of the time).

I have no idea where you could get the idea that my post said or even implied anything but women being treated poorly on reddit...

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by obstinate on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:06AM (#9736785)
You said that women don't catch heat, which to me meant you thought they were treated well. To catch heat (without a cause) is to be mistreated, and it seemed to me as if you were saying this was not the case. My apologies if I misunderstood you.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by BinaryIdiot on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:22AM (#9736828)
> You said that women don't catch heat

Please take a look at my original comment as I did not say that. Women catch heat all the time. All I said was, in my experience, I rarely see it when compared to all of the sexual harassment they receive.

> To catch heat (without a cause)

I haven't seen this phrase used without a "cause"; isn't that just an insult? Can you even "catch heat" without doing anything?

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by obstinate on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:39AM (#9736869)
"I rarely see women get 'heat' on Reddit." -- You. I understand now that you were making a comparative statement, but at the time I believed you were making an absolute one.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by BinaryIdiot on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:29PM (#9739706)
> "I rarely see women get 'heat' on Reddit." -- You

I'm not sure why you're quoting that; it doesn't support your assertion. Rarely does not mean an absolute don't.

> I understand now that you were making a comparative statement, but at the time I believed you were making an absolute one.

Even if it was absolute I was certainly highlighting a problem with women being sexual harassed on Reddit which you still somehow took as me thinking it's desirable. Worst yet you never corrected your mistake within the editing window so my comment is being downvoted to hell and people probably think I'm supporting the sexual harassment of women.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by Macha on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:27PM (#9736497)
She was unpopular long before the bans though.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by hoopd on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:01PM (#9736617)
The argument is that the moderation policies are selectively enforced in order to shape the prevailing ideologies expressed on the website.

Reddit's response is that it isn't "safe" and they want to make it that way. If you've been labeled as somebody who makes the site "unsafe" your actions are assumed to be those of an aggressor and an oppressor. If you're somebody trying to make the site "safe" even when you cross the line you're viewed as an oppressed person fighting back.

It's an intentionally uneven playing field and the people it's slanted against aren't happy about it.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by pushnpop on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:45PM (#9736566)
Chairwoman Pao owes every penny. She was not discriminated against because she is a woman, she was discriminated against because she is a terrible employee, venture capitalist, and person. She sued Kleiner because she wanted to pay off the debt her scumbag husband owes for fraud.

http://www.vanityfair.com/style/scandal/2013/03/buddy-fletch...

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by krschultz on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:08PM (#9736634)
Go back to reddit. This comment is over the line. Your other comment in this discussion is even worse.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9736628

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by thaumaturgy on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:22AM (#9736956)
HN has been prominently mentioned as an alternative to Reddit lately in a lot of the Pao-related threads ... I think we're going to be seeing a lot more Reddit behavior here, unfortunately.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by hoopd on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:21PM (#9736677)
I dislike Pao, the lawsuit, and the surrounding politics but I agree that this is unacceptable.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by pushnpop on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:14PM (#9736656)
What line? Which part of the article are you responding to?
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by kibibu on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:38PM (#9736725)
Perhaps the line where you make thinly veiled references to the man who architected the deaths of tens of millions of people?
[dead]
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by DAddYE on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:01AM (#9736778)
Are we talking about the sentence or your thoughts about reddit?

Allegations? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buddy_Fletcher#Fund_bankruptcy

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by robot22 on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:55AM (#9736909)
Disappointing that you view all criticisms against Ellen Pao as inherently sexist. I think if anything people would be just as critical of her if she was a guy. Who appoints a lawyer to run Reddit?
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by obstinate on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:21PM (#9736678)
My big question is: are we ever going to get past this crap? Or is this the enlightened future of discourse. I guess I'm just getting old -- the gish gallop isn't new, but this form feels more terrible and insidious.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by hoopd on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:34PM (#9736714)
The sad statement about the level of discourse is that you apparently care about it but still think granparent comment qualifies. It even breaks the first two rules of HN commenting guidelines: be civil, don't call people names.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by obstinate on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:37PM (#9736721)
I'm cool with calling sexists names, HN guidelines notwithstanding.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by hoopd on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:54PM (#9736768)
Maybe you only speak of the future of discourse because it's a deep sounding insult, but if you actually care I encourage you to read this essay and reconsider your acceptance of namecalling.

http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by obstinate on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:59PM (#9736773)
I have read this essay a number of times. While I agree it is great, it has an assumption of good faith on the part of the counterparty that I find unsubstantiated in terms of sexists, including many of the anti-Pao folks in this thread. If your discourse consists mostly of repeating unsubstantiated rumors or outright falsehoods, or are otherwise laced with misogyny, like the induhviduals who have made comments about her husband, I feel there's a point at which it is fine for me to give up on you. At that point, the best way to raise the level of discourse is to remove the bad actors from the conversation.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by hoopd on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:38AM (#9736865)
The reason to set a higher bar is this: in a heated debate where core beliefs are being challenged there will always a temptation to decide you're dealing with an idiot or a monster even when you aren't.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by obstinate on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:57AM (#9736912)
I understand the theory. I do not believe that this is the optimal approach in practice.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by danbolt on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:50AM (#9737024)
If you don't mind me asking, perhaps you could give a reason why you feel this isn't always the optimal approach?

I can certainly understand that it's not exactly the most pleasant thing to do at times, but I feel as though it's an ideal where the side effects of striving for it are beneficial. It would mean a lot of me to hear your take on it.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by obstinate on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:57AM (#9737047)
Of course I do not mind. I believe ostracization and marginalization have historically been more effective for this type of objectionable opinion. The main differentiating factor is that misogyny is not rooted in reason. Thus, reason is an ineffective tool for attacking it, especially on the internet.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by hoopd on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:14PM (#9740119)
I'm not saying misogyny is rooted in reason, I'm saying the social justice movement has a habit of misclassifying opposing viewpoints as misogyny in order to dismiss them.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by mrbtie on Thursday June 18, 2015 @02:38AM (#9737114)
Do you have any reason to believe that name-calling is the optimal way to "remove the bad actors from the conversation"? In my experience, its only likely outcome is the destruction of potentially healthy debate.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by obstinate on Thursday June 18, 2015 @10:55AM (#9738889)
There is nothing potentially healthy about the kind of smear campaign happening in this thread. If we saw no discussion of her husband, the posts that she did not actually remove, or claims that she extorted kp or lied about things that happened, then maybe.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by hoopd on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:12PM (#9740098)
This is why you are part of the problem.

It's reasonable to say his personal life should be left out but in your anger you've moved that line to a point where it prevents important information from entering the discussion.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by pushnpop on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:32PM (#9736710)
Who is KiA?
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by MBCook on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:38PM (#9736727)
/r/KotakuInAction, which I believe is one of the main forums and rallying/coordination points for GamgerGate or like minded individuals.
[dead]
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by nols on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:51PM (#9736354)
This balogna is getting posted on HN now? For the record she was appointed CEO before her trial (although after she filed suit) to replace Yishan Wong and people have been crying about censorship on Reddit long before she ever worked there. Also Alexis Ohanian has publicly talked about sexism in tech since before Pao worked at Reddit[0].

0. http://alexisohanian.com/dear-fellow-geeks-what-the-fuck

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by whyenot on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:39PM (#9736294)
How is that related to her lawsuit? It seems completely unrelated to me.

In any case, 10k "people" (it's easy to game these things) is just a drop in the bucket of reddit's userbase.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by javert on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:47PM (#9736330)
Most of us aren't in the position to get sued for gender discrimination.

So this whole Ellen Pao thing is just a bunch of nerds eating popcorn. It's our version of a celebrity magazine.

So in that sense, more gossip about Ellen Pao's personal life/actions at reddit (which she is ruining) are completely par for the course.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by gooeyblob on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:55PM (#9736368)
How is she ruining reddit?
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by javert on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:07PM (#9736409)
Because banning certain reddits is a value to no-one and a disvalue to everyone.

It does not add value to me to have subreddits Ellen Pao personally disagrees with be banned. Rather, it takes away value.

And now that the precedent has been set, the same will be the case with future reddit leadership.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by nols on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:17PM (#9736453)
It is a mistake to assume Ellen Pao is the reason for /r/fatpeoplehate's removal, both /r/jailbait and /r/creepshots were banned before she worked at Reddit. Who's to say /r/fatpeoplehate wasn't also removed at a consensus by the staff?
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by gooeyblob on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:26PM (#9736495)
Do you really think Ellen came in one day from a mountain on high and decreed "these subreddits shall be banned"? What planet are you from that you think a company is run that way?
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by javert on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:18PM (#9736673)
She's the CEO, it happened under her watch.

> What planet are you from that you think a company is run that way?

Well, not a planet where I try to persuade people of my views by sarcastically asking what planet they're from. That is not an argument and it's devoid of intellectual content.

> Ellen

So you are on a first-name basis with her? Maybe you can tell us the inside story. Otherwise, calling someone by a first name alone is vulgar.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by Steko on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:18PM (#9736456)
Banning hate and harrassment subreddits has value to many people.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by javert on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:21AM (#9736955)
I agree with banning subreddits that actually go outside their own subreddit to harass people. Otherwise, I don't.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by ekianjo on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:46PM (#9736328)
Because someone suing for false claims is now at the head of Reddit, and she has the power to censor things she does not like (and actively uses it). I'd day it's related.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by krschultz on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:50PM (#9736345)
Not proving her case and making false claims are two different things.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by gooeyblob on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:56PM (#9736370)
What evidence do you have that she actively uses it?
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by Karunamon on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:00PM (#9736391)
There've been some rather high-profile shadowbans (hellban/otherwise you're banned but don't know it) issued against people who did apparently did nothing but publicly state that Pao is a scam artist.

Given that those comments don't actually violate any of Reddit's stated rules, there aren't many other reasonable explanations.

Then again, I called every single one of them liars, publicly, by name, after the recent subreddit closing drama, and I'm not shadowbanned so, who knows.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by this_user on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:10PM (#9736419)
So, you are saying they did nothing but slander her and are now surprised they were banned?
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by Karunamon on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:12PM (#9736648)
I think you're unclear on the definition of slander.

To put it as charitably as possible, the facts that came out during the failed lawsuit (and later attempt to get 2.7M out of the company to get her to go away) do not paint Pao in a good light.

Calling her a scam artist is putting it mildly, IMO. Real gender discrimination cases are tainted by this kind of BS.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by gooeyblob on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:14PM (#9736432)
I would love to see these claims, please stop spreading FUD and show real evidence.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by hellbanTHIS on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:46PM (#9736569)
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by vernie on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:38PM (#9736290)
It's clearly about ethics in link sharing.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by minimaxir on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:38PM (#9736291)
Not related at all.

That's related to Reddit drama and Reddit drama alone.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by arenaninja on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:43PM (#9736312)
While I wouldn't sign the petition and I don't care about her lawsuit or the recent subreddits that were banned, I'm turned off from reddit by their reaction to the fallout, particularly their fudging of the front page and /r/all and blocking comments mentioning an imgur alternative. I'm back to reading funnies from fark.com and now looking at voat.co. It's been a long time coming, longer than Pao has been CEO, and I'm not sure how many people realize that
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by gooeyblob on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:57PM (#9736379)
Yeah I'd love to see the evidence there is any 'fudging' of the frontpage or blocking comments. I seriously doubt there is.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by hellbanTHIS on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:54PM (#9736594)
Last week /r/all/rising was mostly swastkas and dick pics with most of them going to a site called slimgur which they then supposedly shadow blocked.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by reubenmorais on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:05PM (#9736404)
I believe he's referring to the admins banning all the new subreddits that were created after the announcement to spam /r/all, for ban evasion.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by WalterGR on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:50PM (#9736347)
Sources? That all sounds interesting.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by arenaninja on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:12PM (#9736425)
The fudging of /r/all is from what I saw, the troll posts disappeared from the front page after about 4 hours but they were all there if you checked /r/all/top. After a few hours, they were all contained in /r/all/rising, every day they're still there. I actually didn't even know subreddits had been banned until I missed a touch on my phone and instead of hitting the reddit front page I hit /r/all on my phone, these are next to each other on the reddit is fun app on android.

The imgur alternative I mentioned is apparently slimgur.com. Here's a post with the story, this is where I read it from: http://www.reddit.com/r/KotakuInAction/comments/39nang/reddi.... As of now, it has over 4k points, a mod presumably sharing the details (comments with slimgur links have to be approved by moderators). It was at the top of /r/all/rising when I saw it a few days ago

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by MBCook on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:40PM (#9736552)
Interesting. I noticed that the "sympathy" posts disappeared from my front page (mostly from /r/pics) within a few hours.

Did they rig things? That would make sense.

Frankly it's fine with me. I was worried I'd have to stay off Reddit for a few days until the juvenile hate-mongering died down. I've had to do it before.

I'm with the GP. Every time one of these things happen I get more and more uneasy about Reddit. This, the jailbait thing, Boston Bomber witch hunt. Every time 'the community' speaks up I end up disgusted and a little sick.

Most of the subs I'm in are too small for this garbage, so it often passes me by, thankfully. But then some event reminds me of the putrid filth just out of sight.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by akhilcacharya on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:14PM (#9736658)
Stay on /r/babyelephantgifs. Always.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by gooeyblob on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:59PM (#9736389)
There are no sources, it's the same garbage people keep repeating with zero evidence.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by macspoofing on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:49PM (#9736340)
Are online petitions still a thing?
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by rosser on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:04PM (#9736402)
Not remotely related. Please take your off-topic hate elsewhere.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by gavanwoolery on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:41PM (#9736304)
(downvote at will, rephrased to make it a bit more polite) As far as I could tell, people were relatively content with Reddit even when it had bad stuff, but people started getting noisy when the censorship started.

Comes down to a debate on censorship, which is admittedly quite divided. I don't condone hate speech, but its also sometimes tricky to separate hatred from a rational opinion about something. Ultimately you can't control the voices of people, they will find creative ways to broadcast their message for better or worse (as we saw when reddit shut down FPH). Censorship really only hits the beehive and makes the bad people more visible. As one example of this, I had no idea that FPH existed until Reddit shut it down.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by codesushi42 on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:56PM (#9736372)
Freedom of speech does not apply here. Reddit is not a forum owned by the public, it's a business. Reddit is within their rights to remove any content as they see fit.

Yeah, people complain once they realize walled gardens like Reddit start censoring whatever they choose only /after/ they get too big to stop. Same goes for closed ecosystems like the App Store and Google Play. Guess you should have read the fine print before giving your unquestioned allegiance to all these closed platforms.

I yearn for the days when the Internet was truly open. You can still launch any kind of site you want. But the truth is there is an ever shrinking number of players who now get to decide what content should or shouldn't be seen, and who should get referral traffic. The censorship I see is both ideological and business motivated. A relative few will control all of the information everyone gets to actually see, because no one will bother to look elsewhere. Sad really.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by PopeOfNope on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:24PM (#9736484)
> I yearn for the days when the Internet was truly open.

When was that? Back in the early days, ISPs and hosts would shut down sites with very little provocation. I remember big outcries around sites being taken down by their ISP and/or having their domains seized by the FBI for file sharing and/or hate speech.

In fact, you could argue that the internet is more resistant to censorship now than it was back then. The ISPs in the early days had fewer customers and more competition, making them vulnerable to bad press. They pretty much had to act on any crank who complained about objectionable content hosted on their servers. ISPs today are bigger and have de facto monopolies (TWC and Comcast), so they don't respond so much to bad press. While that may be bad news for customer service, it's good news for the conspiracy theorist who wants to discuss which Rothschild is behind 9/11. Also, ISPs don't have to take sites down as often as they used to because most of them are hosted through third party companies like wordpress and google (blogspot).

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by codesushi42 on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:33PM (#9736522)
True. I wasn't specifically talking about hate speech though. I was talking more about launching a site/app/business or spreading an idea. More often these happen entirely through a few closed channels (social networks, Reddit, app stores) and/or are completely reliant on a few closed channels to get any traction.

The Internet used to have more of a creative and community driven focus when people ran their own websites and found information through link networks. Now it's a continuous stream of information fed through a few closed platforms. If you don't submit yourself to the follies and whims of these platforms, you will never be seen.

I think that's most of what made Reddit so successful which is reminiscent of the old days-- its subreddits and link network of those communities.

I wish RSS, or something like it, hadn't failed.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by acveilleux on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:14PM (#9736433)
I've seen 8chan and after that I do not yearn for a fully open Internet.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by codesushi42 on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:25PM (#9736488)
No one is forcing you go to (\d)chan.

Hate speech is an easy target. But the censoring and anticompetitive practices have spread further than that.

Google, Apple, Facebook, can change their ToS to bring down potential competitors. They can remove your app for any reason, block access to their APIs, and ban you for posting content that leads to your own external page. It's happened plenty, and Reddit is no exception. These guys want you to live in their closed ecosystems where they control who the winners and losers are and what information is seen.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by MBCook on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:46PM (#9736567)
No, but 8chan reaches out to the real world and other forums and people end up receiving death threats.

Makes it REALLY HARD to support anonymity online, as it often seems like more people get horribly harassed or SWATed than we get benefits from anonymous whistleblowers and such.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by codesushi42 on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:50PM (#9736584)
Sounds like the same argument that the threat of terrorism makes it really hard to support civil liberties and personal privacy. Same old rhetoric. Pretty scary that a growing number of people seem to share the same opinion.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by MBCook on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:55PM (#9736599)
I suppose you're right. I don't think I'd make the call to actually do it, but things have gotten so bad in the last year I'm just exasperated. And since law enforcement has been so apathetic/ineffective at dealing with even the most blatant cases that the negative externalities that would normally be there (arrests, social pressure, etc) can't seem to keep the dangerous behavior in check.

Don't know what else to do. Can't ignore it, and it's not getting better. Posting about how it's bad isn't useful/doesn't accomplish anything. Actively engaging has proven to very dangerous to people and doesn't seem to have helped.

Sometimes the call for censorship is a purposeful play to stamp out or control a group, sometimes it's just exasperation at a lack of any other idea of how to deal with a situation.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by gavanwoolery on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:16PM (#9736443)
haha :)
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by gavanwoolery on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:05PM (#9736405)
I agree - good points :)
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by rtpg on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:44PM (#9736315)
No it wasn't, it was creating cesspits of hate when left to itself. Considering the amount of good communities on that website, the last thing I would want is for it to be overrun by such negativeness.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by JeremyBanks on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:53PM (#9736356)
My searches on Reddit for entirely unrelated keywords have been increasingly polluted by distracting hateful crap that I do not want to see. Subreddits aren't independent/isolated enough that they can do whatever they want without it having an impact on the site as a whole. Reddit's looking for more growth. I'm sure that many potential users have been turned away from the site by similar experiences. If they manage to clean up the site without killing it, it could really help.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by gavanwoolery on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:04PM (#9736399)
I can respect that - I never use Reddit's search function so I have been relatively unaware of that. I think the problem is that its almost impossible to police all of reddit - even if you shut down one thing (as we saw) 10 more pop up. Not sure there is a good solution, but the lesser of evils might be to just ignore the antagonists.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by y2bd on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:16PM (#9736445)
Given that /r/all currently has pretty much zero note of the crapshow from a couple days ago, I would think actually facing it and just bracing for a couple of days pays off a lot more than just ignoring it and letting it build up over time.
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:54PM (#9736595)
> Given that /r/all currently has pretty much zero note of the crapshow from a couple days ago, I would think actually facing it and just bracing for a couple of days pays off a lot more than just ignoring it and letting it build up over time.

A controlled burn of the forest if you will.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by gavanwoolery on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:18PM (#9736455)
Could very well be the case :)
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by gavanwoolery on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:20PM (#9736470)
I agree on the cesspits of hate, but I think the good in people always overwhelms the bad. Or at least, I hope. :)
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by nickysielicki on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:24PM (#9736483)
> "it was creating cesspits of hate when left to itself."

'it' is humanity. If you can't handle looking at a true reflection of humanity then you're worse than the bigots, IMHO.

If we plug our ears and hum, "la la la" to the uncomfortable opinions held within pockets of society, we remove all possibility of discourse on the topic. No one should ever be so sure that they're right and others are wrong to take that leap. Even with racism, sexism, fat-hate, and so on.

Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by vernie on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:48PM (#9736336)
You were already being down-voted when you added that bit. Reddit doesn't exactly have the best record of self-policing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Controversial_Reddit_communiti...
Re:Ellen Pao owes Kleiner Perkins $276,000 for lawsuit costs... by mberning on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:54PM (#9736361)
This will surely be flagged just like all the other less than favorable posts about her and her tenure at Reddit.