News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by Roritharr on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:36AM (#9732550)
As per my comment on the Stephen Elop Thread:

Ex Microsoft Manager went to Nokia, destroyed its Market Value, sold the debris back to Microsoft is now leaving Microsoft again. Time to short whatever company he is going to next. ;)

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by hbharadwaj on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @02:24PM (#9734146)
As an ex-management consultant, I don't see any other plays that were possible for Elop. I am going off of the Bloomberg article for some conclusions. He is vilified simply because he became the last CEO of a beloved empire which was already gasping for it's last breaths. His plays were the right plays from a Business Perspective. But at that point, it was already too late and Apple/Google had already conquered the market. The only viable option would have been to re-invent the cell phone.

1. Nokia had a Maps business. Obviously, Elop wanted to see it on the chosen platform. 2. Nokia had a host of apps that they wanted to see on the chosen platform. 3. Google refused to allow modifications to their MADA. 4. Meego/Maemo were not viable/not ready. 5. Microsoft's offer came with an infusion of cash.

(Bloomberg article: http://www.bloomberg.com/bw/magazine/content/11_24/b42320567...)

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by sangnoir on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @05:17PM (#9735384)
> He is vilified simply because he became the last CEO of a beloved empire which was already gasping for it's last breaths

That's being overly generous to Elop. The 'Burning Platform' memo was by his own volition and it played a big part in the decline. This essay nails what Elop did wrong[1] (a bit over-the-top though). Namely, he called his own product crap, and when he distributed the memo, Nokia had no solution ready - they were waiting on Microsoft (Osborne effect). "Hey guys, our phones are currently crap. That Maemo phone you're about to buy - we're discontinuing it. We will have awesome ones sometime in the future though. Remember to by a Nokia ;-)".

1. http://communities-dominate.blogs.com/brands/2011/08/coining...

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by snowwrestler on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:01PM (#9739997)
> The 'Burning Platform' memo was by his own volition and it played a big part in the decline.

He wrote the memo but the question is to what extent it simply described the situation as it actually existed. If he had never written that memo, would Nokia be a competitive mobile platform ecosystem today? I find that hard to believe. I don't think it's realistic to blame so much on a few hundred words.

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by sangnoir on Thursday June 18, 2015 @03:40PM (#9741132)
By describing 'the situation as it actually existed', he did a massive disservice to the company he helmed. I am not saying it was the reason Nokia failed, only that it was a huge contributing factor.

You do not expect a company CEO to do negative PR - he damaged Nokia's brand and greatly harmed the confidence developers/consumers had in Nokia.

> I don't think it's realistic to blame so much on a few hundred words.

From the article I previously linked: "Gerald Ratner[1] was CEO of British jewelry group Ratners (since renamed Signet Group). He made a famous speech in London to the Institute of Directors in 1991 in which he said his company products were sold for such low prices "because its total crap." This remark was then published and caused his company to collapse and was only saved by his departure - and the rebranding of the company to Signet."

Ratner destroyed his company in 43 words (relevant part of speech is on Wikipedia).

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerald_Ratner

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by cwyers on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:12PM (#9736216)
The burning platform memo was leaked. It wasn't as if it was sent out as a press release.
Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by JoshTriplett on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:34PM (#9736269)
It's completely ridiculous to send a memo to any significant fraction of the employees of a 60+k person company and not make plans for it being the top story in tomorrow's news.
Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by cwyers on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:19AM (#9736817)
If it was impossible for him to communicate with the people who worked fine him about the need for changed strategy without dooming the company, they were already doomed.
Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by tdicola on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @03:13PM (#9734528)
Samsung rose to power as the biggest (and most profitable) Android manufacturer during the same time Nokia made its big (company breaking) bet on Windows Phone. If Nokia had gone with Android perhaps they could have been the dominant Android hardware...
Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by cwyers on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @04:29PM (#9735035)
And maybe they could have been like the OTHER Android OEMs. I know which I think is more likely. And even being Samsung isn't all that hot:

http://www.zdnet.com/article/apple-takes-89-percent-of-all-s...

Apple is, I think like 20% of the smartphone market worldwide? But about 90% of the profits. And Samsung has to make almost all of its profits at sale, with Google making all the ongoing profits from stuff like Maps and app stores; if Microsoft cut Nokia in on any of that money (Nokia shipped mapping and music apps for their Windows Phone, for example), it may have looked like a better deal than Android offers Samsung currently.

Compare the sale price of Motorola Mobility to Lenovo (after Google stripped it of its patent portfolio) to how much money Nokia's handset business sold to Microsoft for without patents attached. What Elop did with Nokia's phone business may have been the best case scenario for it.

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by tres on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @06:33PM (#9735715)
Sorry, but there's not much to support the idea that Nokia could have magically made it if only they had picked Android.

The first Samsung Galaxy was shipped in 2009[0] -- over a year before Elop was made CEO of Nokia [1] and nearly two years before the "Windows Phone Strategy" was announced.

In 2011 -- years before any strategy shift to either Windows or Android would have been able to be implemented, Samsung was already shipping more smartphones than anyone else -- including Apple [2]. Nokia didn't ship their first Windows Phone device until November 2011.

It would have been a Blackberry Storm kind of stupid to try taking on Samsung with Android as the platform. There's no compelling reason to pick Nokia over Samsung when the target market is just looking for value. At least with Windows Phone, there was some differentiation they could hope to appeal to consumers with.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samsung_Galaxy

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephen_Elop

[2] https://gigaom.com/2012/02/07/npd-apple-sold-most-smartphone...

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by jpatokal on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:30PM (#9736509)
While I agree with most of what you say, Nokia did have a differentiator: awesome, reliable, rugged, (occasionally) stylish hardware -- not a strength for most Android manufacturers, I think you'll agree. But Nokia's software is generally terrible.

Nokia hardware & Android software could have been a pretty killer combo, and a sufficient differentiator to get some extra profit margin; plus Nokia was (is) very experienced in producing at huge volume.

Unsurprisingly, the rump of Nokia that was not merged into Microsoft is now climbing on the Android bandwagon in a big way... but unfortunately everybody else now has a 10-year headstart.

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by ChuckMcM on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @04:20PM (#9734975)
I agree, and everyone loves to hate the bad guy but what I find interesting is that my wife loves her Lumia phone running Windows, she really really wants a Lumia 640 and they are just barely becoming available in the US after a lot of really great reviews in Europe. There is a small but vocal group of people who could be excellent advocates here and logistics issues? or something are plaguing the roll out. That is a bigger systemic problem. Hopefully aligning both windows and hardware will highlight situations where you have a hardware 'winner' that is under funded.
Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by tomjen3 on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @02:55PM (#9734419)
I think what most of us hate him for is going the MS route rather than making Android phones. Nokia used to make great phones, but with sub-par OS. Why not combine the best of both worlds?
Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by IanDrake on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @03:26PM (#9734621)
At the time, I don't think normal users would have called Android better than 'sub-par'. I'll admit that with Material Design and recent OS releases, they've gotten much better, but still many of my non-geek friends tolerate their Android phone that they got for "the big screen".

Now that Apple has solved the "I want a big screen" problem, I think those people will run back to iOS.

I'm sure Elop thought MS was going to put some more effort behind WP. They got a lot of things right, but not the UI and certainly not the marketing.

For what it's worth, I've been using WP for about 3 years now. It's performance is underrated, but Metro went too far as a flat UI.

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by dworin on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @03:29PM (#9734642)
Making phones right now is really a game of supply chain mastery and scale. Nokia didn't have an particular advantage in either area, especially when it came to smart phones. If they started making android phones, it's more likely they'd be another HTC or LG than another Samsung or Apple.
Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by jpkeisala on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @01:09PM (#9733487)
Nokia lost 17 million euros a day it's market value while Elop was CEO of Nokia. I guess he is going down in the history as one of the worst CEO's. Though, some say he wasn't a mole but was hired to sinking ship but somehow it is hard for me to believe from his actions.
Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by pjmlp on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @01:20PM (#9733588)
He was hired by the Nokia board to do exactly what he did. So blame the greedy board members only looking for their bank accounts.

http://www.forbes.com/sites/terokuittinen/2013/09/24/nokia-a...

http://blogs.marketwatch.com/thetell/2013/09/24/nokia-board-...

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by rbanffy on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @02:02PM (#9733950)
To destroy the company and reduce its value until someone (how odd it's his previous employer) acquires it? That's a bit hard to swallow.
Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by nostrademons on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @02:48PM (#9734372)
Nokia (as a cell phone company) died the day the iPhone came out. They were too big and bureaucratic to react with competitive products, and there's no way you can turn that around (regardless of CEO) on the timescale that consumer cell-phone purchasing decisions are made.

Note that Blackberry, Motorola, and Palm also died, and LG and HTC aren't doing so hot.

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by rbanffy on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @04:04PM (#9734868)
That's not exactly true. Nokia pretty much owned the featurephone market and had all the right relationships with telcos that were the primary channel.

The excuse they were too large and bureaucratic to change does not fly when you are the CEO - he had the power to make the required changes. Nokia also had good technology, on par with Android, at least. The mistake was not to realize that iOS's and Android's strength is not on their technology, but the rich ecosystem built around it.

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by nostrademons on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @04:19PM (#9734963)
CEOs have less power to steer the ship than you think. The main assets of a corporation in a knowledge industry are the particular skillsets of its employees and the web of personal relationships between them. If the knowledge required to adapt to a market shift doesn't exist within the company, then the only option that a CEO has is to bring it inside the company, and assimilate it into the existing web of relationships without having the existing power structures reject the new talent. This is challenging in the best of times, with the most forceful CEO, and virtually impossible when you've got only a couple years to live, a complacent workforce, and a board that's only interested in salvaging what they can.

Assuming that you're right that iOS and Android's strength is their ecosystem rather than their technology, there's no way Nokia could've capitalized on that. They couldn't bring on hardware partners, like Android, because all of the hardware partners were their competitors and wouldn't trust anything they did. They had no expertise in engaging independent developers; Nokia has never had a product where they've had to, and their OS (Symbian) was reportedly a pain in the ass to develop for. And while they knew how to build a mass-market consumer product, they didn't know how to build a mass market consumer platform - first-hand experience of what consumers could do with an open-ended computational device wasn't in their DNA the way it is in Apple & Google's.

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by rbanffy on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @05:02PM (#9735284)
CEOs cannot make magic, but Nokia had everything they needed inside the company except perhaps the willingness to realize the market had changed and that they had no longer a viable application layer. That much was evident since the first Android - it would be a two horse race and Android was the only one they could ride.
Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by giovannibajo1 on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @05:52PM (#9735543)
Except they weren't so strong on software and platforms. Their programmers had mostly worked on feature phones, and Symbian was made by an external company at the time.

The first reaction to the iPhone was to buy Symbian in 2008, which in retrospect is so wrong that's surprising, but the vast majority of people at all level (people in the street, geeks, executives) didn't understand the real change that iPhone was bringing until maybe 2009-2010.

Then Nokia tried to fix the software problem buying Qt. That ended up as being a mistake as well. Qt was built on the idea that you can create a UI framework that unifies all platforms; that was realistic when the support OS were all desktop and thus similar in main concepts and interaction patterns; Qt also nominally ran on embedded at the time, but the experience was suboptimal at best. So Nokia drank the idea that adding "another backend" to Qt was the solution, also because developers loved Qt. But of course it's not that easy. It took them 2-3 years to come up with a new codebase that could handle the new interaction patterns (QML) and that's a geological era in smartphones. At that point, they still didn't have a complete working solution for a qt iPhone killer, and Elop had to cut the chord. That day, the fate of Nokia was already written.

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by pjmlp on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @05:18PM (#9735390)
Once upon a time there was the presentation of the first Maemo device to the employees. The feedback about it becoming an hit if GSM support was added, was just ignored.

Very few also had the opportunity to see a Nokia 7710 live besides us, as it was quickly killed after a few months on sale.

Also the famous blog post about how shitty Symbian C++ was, that only Nokia employees would be willing to use it.

Some years ago The Register had a pretty good report about the internal politics going on there.

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by ntakasaki on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @02:12PM (#9734032)
Boards have to approve every major move by a CEO and can fire a CEO at any given time for any or no reason.

This person was the chairman of the board, read through his profile:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jorma_Ollila

>Prior to joining Nokia in 1985, Ollila worked for eight years in corporate banking at Citibank's London and Helsinki offices, and when he joined Nokia his tasks involved international investment deals. A year later, in 1986, Ollila found himself as head of finance during Nokia's renewal under then CEO Kari Kairamo. He was appointed as chief of the mobile phones section in 1990, and CEO two years later in 1992. When Ollila first came to power, the company had suffered from internal disputes and had had a financial crisis for a number of years.

>As CEO of Nokia he has led the strategy that restructured the former industrial conglomerate into one of the major companies in the mobile phone and telecommunications infrastructure markets.

>In 1999, Ollila seriously considered taking part in the Finnish presidential election, following a request from a member of the National Coalition Party, Sauli Niinistö[citation needed] who was at that time Finnish finance minister and who later became Speaker of the Finnish Parliament. This was in spite the fact that Ollila belongs to a different party, the Finnish Centre party, which he has been involved with since his activities in student politics at the University of Helsinki[citation needed].

>He was CEO of Nokia from 1999 to 2006. He was succeeded as CEO by Olli-Pekka Kallasvuo. On 15 September 2010, he announced he intended to step down from the position of Chairman in 2012[2] and did so on 3 May 2012.[3]

>Ollila is the Chairman of the Research Institute of the Finnish Economy (ETLA), the most reputed economic and social studies think tank in Finland. Since 2005, he is chairman of the European Round Table of Industrialists (ERT).

That doesn't look like someone who would trash a company they built for whatever conspiracy theories people cook up about how Elop got hired.

It's funny how Microsoft is ascribed the superpowers of a comic book super villian around these parts while they barely break 3% in the mobile market.

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by pjmlp on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @02:06PM (#9733983)
Most likely because his previous employer was the company that had the better contacts.

However I do believe he wasn't a mole rather another manager driven by greed alonside the board members.

Once upon a time I worked for that Finn company.

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by odiroot on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @01:17PM (#9733569)
Also killing the most exciting software platform -- Maemo/Meego.

On the other hand we now have Jolla so it's not that bad.

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by freehunter on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @01:27PM (#9733661)
>one of the worst CEO's

Leo Apotheker?

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by ameen on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @02:24PM (#9734157)
They're both up there. Having destroyed one of the most promising products (WebOS / Maemo) in recent times among other things.
Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by hga on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @02:29PM (#9734205)
HP is much less dead than Nokia. On the other hand, Nokia was in much worse shape, right?
Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by pavlov on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @02:41PM (#9734314)
Nokia isn't dead though. They are a top-tier player in network equipment along with Ericsson and Huawei.

The company is profitable, its market cap is around $26 billion USD, and they recently announced a major deal to acquire Alcatel-Lucent. They seem to have survived the amputation of the mobile phone division quite well.

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by hga on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @03:18PM (#9734560)
That's why I said "less dead" ^_^.

Buying Alcatel-Lucent suggests to me they aren't all that healthy, based in part on my working at Lucent in 2001 and paying attention to that field since then. And "amputating" what was once more than 2/3rds of the company, going back to 2002, yikes. But, still, you might be right depending on how you define this sort of business health.

Scary how their revenue peaked the year the iPhone came out....

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by walterbell on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @12:22PM (#9732991)
At least he is assured a permanent place in business school case studies.
Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by untog on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @01:11PM (#9733500)
He will always be vilified, but the truth is that Nokia was on the way out anyway, no matter who was in charge.
Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by josu on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @01:15PM (#9733547)
So was Apple in 97.
Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by pavlov on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @01:35PM (#9733731)
Which kind of affirms the grandparent poster's point. Corporate turnarounds like Jobs's return to Apple are one in a million.

If Jobs hadn't been available, who could have saved Apple in 1997? I can't imagine a non-founder CEO up to the task.

Nokia had been fatally wounded by the short-sighted strategy of Elop's predecessors. He took a risk -- jumped off the famous "burning platform" and drowned. But the platform was already going down in flames.

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by freehunter on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @01:29PM (#9733673)
And Microsoft stepped in with their help and a huge cash injection, and Jobs was vilified for letting them.
Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by krylon on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @03:18PM (#9734559)
I have sometimes wondered if the people at Microsoft in charge of that move have since regretted it.

IIRC, they did it mostly, because they were under investigation for antitrust charges (and very nearly were broken up), so they could show the DOJ they had an actual competitor. If that is true, they seem to have gotten a little more than they bargained for (the stock they bought must be worth a fortune today, though).

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by sumedh on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:34PM (#9736712)
> the stock they bought must be worth a fortune today, though

I dont have the source to back me up but I read MS sold the stock long time back even before the iphone.

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by JimmaDaRustla on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @07:11PM (#9735860)
Probably not, they knew that their jobs would be much harder if Apple failed.
Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by macintux on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @01:46PM (#9733817)
Heh. IIRC, that was actually a payoff for IP infringement, and it wasn't particularly huge, relatively speaking.

Having said that, committing to Office on the Mac was significant.

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by huxley on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @03:02PM (#9734453)
Yeah, it was related to QuickTime.

San Francisco Canyon Company was hired by Apple to port QuickTime to Windows, later it was hired by Intel to do some work on Indeo. Intel and Microsoft used the work done by San Francisco Canyon Company to jointly to improve Video for Windows performance, but San Francisco Canyon Company allegedly included QuickTime code and proprietary information without Apple's permission.

Things got nasty but Jobs opted to use this leverage to give Apple some credibility when it had suffered a serious blow from the Copland wreck.

Jobs set the terms: Apple and Microsoft agreed to cross-license each others patents, current and prospective lawsuits were dropped, Apple agreed to make IE the default browser, Microsoft agreed to continue developing Microsoft Office for Mac for 5 years and Microsoft would announce the purchase $150 million in non-voting stock.

It wasn't done out of pity, Microsoft's lawyers likely believed they would lose the case and this was a sweetheart deal which it would have been stupid to refuse.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Francisco_Canyon_Company

http://www.theregister.co.uk/1999/02/01/maritz_on_apple/

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by tomjen3 on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @03:07PM (#9734478)
Apple was saved by their founder. Usually the only people who can really turn a company around are their founders and even then stories of that are rare.

I would buy stock in MS if Gates ever came back, but I don't expect it.

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by nivla on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @04:48PM (#9735185)
I am not sure if I agree with the statement that Nokia's market share were destroyed by MS. If I recall Nokia was on its downfall even before Apple's iPhone came into market. I grew up with the 3330, so I always have a soft corner for them, it was my first phone and lasted forever. However, with the emergence of the iPhone, Nokia's fate was sealed. Most people here on HN including me considered Nokia DOA and it wasn't until the emergence of Lumia phones with its incredible Camera that people started to take notice. The comments went from "pfft DOA" to "I would totally consider if they made one in android!".

Strategically I think it was a better plan for Nokia to go with Windows regardless of the CEO. Apple doesn't do partnerships and the only other popular option was Android, which was ruled by Samsung and to compete against them would be to compete against a Goliath. So indirectly I think MS did help them even though it was for their own gains.

Also keep in mind, only the phone division was sold to MS. The rest of the company is intact and still trading in the stock market.

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by rbanffy on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @01:58PM (#9733906)
Microsoft has perfected the use of executive outplacement as an offensive weapon. Watching where he goes now will prove entertaining.

Let's just pray he doesn't go to Blackberry. QNX deserves better.

Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by bernadus_edwin on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @02:12PM (#9734031)
Betting website should add this prediction. Elop new company will sell in two years -> 1 : 4
Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by rurban on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @05:00PM (#9735271)
And a new unofficial national holiday for Finland. Finally!
Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by fredgrott on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @05:22PM (#9735406)
side note: MS does not pay premiums when buying companies..ever
Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by RyJones on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @01:48PM (#9733836)
Steve Ballmer destroyed ~3.8 Enrons of shareholder wealth during his reign. http://www.ar15.com/forums/t_1_5/1754661_Shareholder_decimat...
Re:Microsoft Shakes Up Its Leadership and Internal Structure by ntakasaki on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @02:23PM (#9734134)
That doesn't even take into account dividends paid or the dotcom boom. My bad for clicking on a low quality non tech forum site.