News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by topynate on Sunday June 07, 2015 @11:46AM (#9675071)
Kicking people from your tech conference because they were racist outside of it hands veto power to whoever determines what racism is and when something is 'too racist'. The same goes for the other beyond-the-pale isms like sexism, fascism, etc.

I commented on a flagged post on why this is an issue for me personally: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9674958

Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by ncallaway on Sunday June 07, 2015 @11:59AM (#9675139)
> it hands veto power to whoever determines what racism is and when something is 'too racist'

This sounds like the function of the free marketplace of ideas. One is allowed to espouse any ideology that you wish. However, other people are allowed to respond with their own speech. They can call the idea racist if they want. They can take away speaking platforms if they want.

Whether a statement is "racist" is a determination made by the current social taboos and mores of a society. I think there are a lot of terrible ideologies out there, and I like that we don't have to give them equal platforms. The free marketplace of ideas means we don't have to "teach the controversy" and give both sides "equal opportunity for debate".

Which is great. There are plenty of people who's methods and ideas I so disagree with that I don't think it's worth my time to listen to them (neo-nazis, members of the Westboro Baptist Church).

Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by theorique on Sunday June 07, 2015 @06:59PM (#9676637)
This sounds like the function of the free marketplace of ideas. One is allowed to espouse any ideology that you wish. However, other people are allowed to respond with their own speech. They can call the idea racist if they want. They can take away speaking platforms if they want.

Ideally, it operates like the free market of ideas.

In practice, it tends to offer a disproportionate amount of power to those who are most easily offended, and provides them with a de facto "hecklers' veto" over people with views outside the mainstream.

In the Moldbug case, some people wre "so genuinely offended" by the prospect of him speaking (or even being present at the conference) that they were willing to request that his talk offer be revoked. This was the case even when the subject of his talk is completely unrelated to his controversial politics. (Most people would probably agree that a technical conference is the wrong venue for him to speak about his controversial politics.)

Would most people attending the conference have known about his politics if there weren't this outcry to bring publicity? Unlikely. This was a deliberate message to alienate and exclude those with conservative politics from the tech industry.

Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by yummyfajitas on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:09PM (#9675202)
Similarly, if Jessitron (singling her out solely because she wrote a really good blog post today [1]) wants to talk about microservices in clojure, and folks want to keep her out because of her views on women in technology, you are ok with that also?

Let me also emphasize that no one disputes that strangeloop has the legal right to do this. The discussion is simply over whether the strangeloop organizers are a bunch of anti-intellectuals who deserve to be in the spotlight for their decisions.

[1] http://blog.jessitron.com/2015/06/ultratestable-coding-style...

Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by ncallaway on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:44PM (#9675345)
Again, a disclaimer: I know pretty much nothing about this specific instance except the linked article. I don't know the candidate speaker, their political views, or anything of that nature. No examples in this comment are meant to be reflective of this specific situation.

> "wants to talk about microservices in clojure, and folks want to keep her out because of her views on women in technology"

For me, it comes down to how they express their opinions in the public sphere.

This matters a lot. If someone develops a persona known for lobbing rhetorical grenades, making ad hominem attacks, or is unnecessarily mean or negative, then I don't have a problem holding them out of a conference — even if I agree with their viewpoints.

If they, on the other hand tend to behave in a reasonable way, and are capable of having calm and rational debates, then I would want to see them included in the conference — even if I disagree with their viewpoints.

Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by 13thLetter on Tuesday June 09, 2015 @01:06AM (#9684177)
Then it sounds like you're fully on the side of Yarvin and fully opposed to Strangeloop's actions, since (even when he dared to write about unpopular political opinions) he was never anything less than calm and rational.
Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by obstinate on Sunday June 07, 2015 @06:53PM (#9676617)
It really depends on what her views on women in technology are. If she's pro, then I imagine a conference explicitly trying to ban that category would have little traction, so it hardly matters. If she's con, then yea, sure, ban her from speaking.
Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by ThrustVectoring on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:12PM (#9675221)
There are extremely good game-theoretic reasons to support a policy of allowing full debate on ideas and zero tolerance on attacking the person holding the idea.

Specifically, I'm imagining a degenerate case where there's a norm of killing people who do X, as well as people who don't kill people who do X, as well as people who advocate making the anti-X policy more lenient.

My point is that we can end up in a bad situation that nobody is better off trying to fix. We're arguably in this situation right now with excessive punishment of "sex crimes".

Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by ncallaway on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:30PM (#9675291)
As a disclaimer: I don't have any context outside of the linked article. I don't know the candidate, what viewpoints they hold, or how those viewpoints have been previously expressed.

> "support a policy of allowing full debate on ideas and zero tolerance on attacking the person holding the idea."

If I had infinite time on this planet, I'd agree with you. However, my time is extremely limited. It's the most precious resource I have, so I have to aggressively consider the opportunity cost of listening to every person.

It's more valuable to me to have a debate with someone I disagree with rather than someone I agree with. However, if someone has reached a conclusion that I find to be shockingly suspect ("all foreigners are terrible people"; "protest the funerals of homosexual service-members"), I am not going to spend time listening to any aspects of that person's reasoning.

So, due to my limited time, I'm now punishing this person for expressing their ideas on a specific topic. How does the game-theory deal with the trade-offs of finite time and the opportunity cost of listening to specific speakers?

Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by ThrustVectoring on Sunday June 07, 2015 @11:45PM (#9677227)
I think we're talking about slightly different topics here. What I'm hearing from you is along the lines of "I shouldn't feel obligated to spend my time listening to racists about their racist ideology." I was trying to aim more at "we shouldn't interfere with a racist having on-topic technology discussions with third parties." Both the differences are important. Choosing who you will and won't engage with is a different beast than who is and isn't allowed to talk about things. Whether certain topics are appropriate for a given context is a different thing than whether choosing wrong on one topic means you are no longer an appropriate person to talk about another.

In short, I'm encouraging you to ignore the crank, but not censor him from talking about context-relevant topics.

Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by topynate on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:10PM (#9675203)
I am not suggesting that racists (however defined) be invited to advocate racism to people who find that repugnant. I'm suggesting that that racism not disqualify them in other matters.

You are quite correct that people can boycott or pressure for no-platform if they want to. Who on earth would benefit from forced contact? What I'm suggesting is that people decide not to do that. Further, that when that does happen, those who disagree speak up about it.

Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by ncallaway on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:53PM (#9675377)
> "What I'm suggesting is that people decide not to [boycott or pressure for no platform]"

I don't like how this argument generalizes.

For example, I am a strong opponent of the labor situation in Qatar as it relates to the World Cup. I want FIFA to either relocate venues or force Qatar to immediately improve their labor practices. Yet, I have no leverage over FIFA, so instead I decide to boycott FIFA's sponsors (Coke, Nike, and Adidas).

Now I'm actively punishing those companies because of their speech. And I'm doing it purely because it's my only way to attempt to change the behavior of an actor two-steps removed from them.

So, now I'd like one of two things:

- Help me find the lines for legitimate boycotts, or

- Help me determine why my boycott of Coke, Nike, and Adidas is a poor decision

Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by DanBC on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:56PM (#9675395)
Did you tell coke, nike, and adidas that you're boycotting them?
Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by ncallaway on Sunday June 07, 2015 @02:19PM (#9675750)
Truth be told, I didn't really "start" boycotting Nike products as I didn't happen to be purchasing much from them already. I included them rhetorically as the three-beat felt much more natural in that context.

I did tell Coke and Adidas.

Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by learnstats2 on Monday June 08, 2015 @10:10AM (#9679142)
Boycotting Coca-Cola is extremely challenging: they own a lot of competing "hydration" brands and perhaps even the manufacturing processes used by their direct competitors.

I know several people who think they are boycotting Coca-Cola but are extremely ineffective in managing to do so. Although Coke might be disappointed by the damage to their core brand, they might be less than disappointed when you choose their more profitable products as an alternative.

Good luck!

Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by irickt on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:19PM (#9675255)
Yes, and the rejected author can't very well complain because, whether or not his views are "racist", he clearly imagines a society where many people are excluded because of their views.

Any group almost by definition has the right to define policies and police its membership, for any cause (including irrational). No group owes you the right of membership.

Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by 13thLetter on Sunday June 07, 2015 @07:42PM (#9676725)
Nobody is saying otherwise. Please put that argument away. What everyone here is saying is that the policies and policing they are carrying out is _wrong_.
Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by irickt on Monday June 08, 2015 @12:02PM (#9679935)
If you stipulate that argument then you agree that it is only for the group to judge what is right and wrong with regard to its members. Outsiders opinions are irrelevant.
Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by 13thLetter on Monday June 08, 2015 @02:42PM (#9681259)
Does that apply to, say, the state of California when it votes to ban gay marriage?
Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by twoodfin on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:09PM (#9675200)
But what does any of that have to do with a talk on urbit?
Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by braythwayt on Sunday June 07, 2015 @11:50AM (#9675089)
If I am the CEO of a company, and I listen to people before making my own decision, am I “handing them veto power?”

I think this is Alex Miller’s decision.

Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by topynate on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:01PM (#9675151)
A realist view looks at the various players and makes an informed judgment of what their power is. Alex Miller indisputably has final say on who attends the conference. That doesn't make him a dictator. If he doesn't follow people like Steve Klabnik and Alex Payne on stuff like this, the personal and business consequences to him will be immense. As his statement says, he hasn't read Yarvin's political writings. Nevertheless it took him only a few hours to decide that it would not be possible to have Yarvin present. Is that not strong evidence that Miller felt his options were limited?
Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by braythwayt on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:12PM (#9675223)
That’s how it is for dictators, too. They look at the world and make decisions designed to to optimize for the outcomes the desire, without compromising their values.

Let’s say that people on HN decide that they don’t want to attend any conference that has a Code of Conduct, because that interferes with their “right to free speech.”

If a conference organizer decides that HN is enough of a market that they tear up their CoC, that’s their decision. We don’t say that somehow, they have less free will because of the actions of HN. Their options aren’t limited. They chose to do something that involved HN.

If Alex doesn’t like this kind of controversy, Alex can stop running conferences. Sure there are actions by all sorts of players in a complex world, but the buck for every decision stops somewhere, and in this case, it stops with Alex.

Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by paxdickinson on Sunday June 07, 2015 @11:55AM (#9675116)
It'll be his decision next time too. And now that the Red Guards know he'll succumb to even the slightest bit of pressure, there will certainly be a next time.
Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by braythwayt on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:00PM (#9675149)
I don’t know that we can use words like “succumb.” It’s always that way when you have a strong opinion about a particular matter.

For example, we can praise Obama for listening to scientists on certain matters, than complain he is caving under lobbying pressure on others.

In the end, I prefer to say that it is Alex’s decision. He didn’t crumble, succumb, get browbeaten, or anything else. He decided, and that means you can hang the responsibility around his neck.

People who can’t decide shouldn’t run things, it’s that simple.

Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by PopeOfNope on Sunday June 07, 2015 @03:51PM (#9676128)
> He didn’t crumble, succumb, get browbeaten, or anything else.

How can you possibly know that? People have lost their jobs and have been forced out of their own companies for less than allowing somebody who other people might consider "racist", "sexist" or "homophobic" to talk at their conference. You can't be aware that these things have happened to other people and say that it doesn't influence the decision.

Once it was brought to his attention, the decision Alex faced was either let Curtis go on and eventually be forced out of his own conference or disinvite him and strengthen the atmosphere of political compliance. I think he made the right short term choice for him, which is all you can realistically expect people to do, but in the long term allowing this sort of thing to persist will come and bite him in the ass.

The longer this goes on, the more radical you need to be to not become victim to the political correctness mob. In the end, if you're a straight white male, you will fall prey to it because you're not a protected class. You can see this playing out in video games, movies and SF&F publishing right now. Joss Whedon and Wil Wheaton especially are vocal feminists who have taken a beating by feminists because their views aren't extreme enough.

[dead]
Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by PopeOfNope on Sunday June 07, 2015 @06:07PM (#9676493)
Look at the people making the accusations. They're all straight, white men. Socialists are typically upper middle class straight white men. Nice try painting me as racist, sexist or homophobic, though.

Look at the twitter hashtag #notyourshield. The PC hatemob isn't liked by women, people of color or LGBT. They tend to dislike straight, white men telling them what it's like to be black, female or gay.

Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by braythwayt on Sunday June 07, 2015 @07:33PM (#9676698)
I have a real problem with your telling me what people of colour like and don’t like. Last time I checked, you don’t speak for me either.

And the entire premise of your world-view is broken. When you frame these white liberals as “speaking for” people of colour or speaking for women, or speaking for LGBT people, you are presuming that racism, sexism, and homophobia are strictly issues for people of colour, women, and LGBT people.

And therefore, if someone who isn’t one of these people speaks out against it, they must be some kind of paternal mansplaining social justice warrior.

In reality, some such people exist, but so do people who are egalitarian, and feel that racism, sexism, and homophobia are simply wrong. They aren’t speaking for anyone but themselves, and that is why you get some people pointing that out. But just because they don’t speak for me, for example, doesn’t invalidate that they speak truth to power.

As long as they don’t claim to speak for me, thats fine. Unlike you, who tried to suggest what people of colour think without qualifying your statement by admitting that you want to present some cherry-picked examples that suit your cause.

Painting people who speak out as a “PC Hatemob” really speaks to the fact that you relish taking an extremist position.

So given that you are way out in batshit-crazy tinfoil-hat land, what’s in it for me to talk to you? I doubt that anyone reading our respective words is going to be swayed from whatever position they already held. People who agree with you will mindlessly upvote you for saying what Fox News has been saying for years.

Nothing you have said really provokes any kind of “hmmm...” from me. It’s like talking to a well-written Markov Chain that was trained on a corpus of GamerGate tweets.

Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by paxdickinson on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:15PM (#9675238)
If you'd ever personally faced the wrath of the social justice left, you would probably agree that "succumb" is a highly appropriate word for it.
Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by braythwayt on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:23PM (#9675271)
I’m loathe to personalize this discussion with a comparison of your anecdotal experiences and mine. And to be honest, once we start bandying about hot-button phrases like “the social justice left,” I have a feeling that we’re on a slippery slope towards ayn rand and men’s rights.

So I’ll just step off here.

[dead]
Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by dang on Sunday June 07, 2015 @05:54PM (#9676465)
This is not an acceptable Hacker News comment, regardless of the positions it's for and against. Please comment civilly and substantively, or not at all.
Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by kragen on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:13AM (#9698121)
It so perfectly fits the point topynate was making in another thread, though, that it's easy to imagine it's merely a sockpuppet! Because of attitudes like pep888's, it's easy to imagine a conference like Strange Loop banning speakers for being Zionists, especially in Europe rather than the US, and Al3x's decision has moved us a big step closer to that.
Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by paxdickinson on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:03PM (#9675162)
This guy sounds like he would be happy to see anti-Zionism as a litmus test for conference speakers.

Is that the kind of tech industry you want? Should speakers at technical conferences have all their political opinions pre-vetted for approval by a panel of progressives?

Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by PopeOfNope on Sunday June 07, 2015 @03:32PM (#9676047)
Aren't we already there, though? This is one of the reasons I left Silicon Valley three years ago. My personal opinions would get me called racist, sexist and homophobic by Marxist standards and I was exhausted by the political mask I had to assume just to find and keep work. Luckily, SV isn't as large a percentage of the tech industry as it likes to think. It's just over represented on tech news sites.
Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by ZanyProgrammer on Sunday June 07, 2015 @06:31PM (#9676562)
So, you have to be a Marxist to be offended by homophobia? Or are redefining Marxist as "someone who gets offended by non 'politically correct' speech"?
Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by topynate on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:05PM (#9675174)
Much as I dislike entering into this sort of (highly off-topic) conversation, it needs pointing out that "Progressive Except Palestine" was coined by people who agree with you. Just search for it and see what comes up.
Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by pep888 on Tuesday June 09, 2015 @12:44PM (#9686926)
It is true that I was wrong about what PEP meant.

It is also true that you are trying to police and shame entrepreneurs who decided to listen to their customers, because you happen to be a voluntary party to (and supporter of) hate crimes and genocide.

Re:“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop” by kragen on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:15AM (#9698125)
May I ask what the "888" in your name refers to?