News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Holding Your Breath in India by rayiner on Saturday June 06, 2015 @08:00PM (#9672809)
Colonialism was a huge blessing to the subcontinent. Turned the clock forward in terms of culture and institutions at least a hundred years.
Re:Holding Your Breath in India by smtddr on Saturday June 06, 2015 @10:07PM (#9673126)
I don't even know what to say about this comment.

The definition of colonialism, according to Google: "noun: colonialism --- the policy or practice of acquiring full or partial political control over another country, occupying it with settlers, and exploiting it economically." http://i.imgur.com/3wQbW11.png

A blessing you say? Until now I didn't even know anyone considered colonialism much different from an invasion. The definition that I just posted seems to fit "invasion" pretty well imho. And how do you even move a culture forward? It sounds like you're implying that some cultures are better than others. Please tell me you're not saying that. Please tell me there's some other definition of colonialism being used in this thread.

Re:Holding Your Breath in India by chlodwig on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:27AM (#9673394)
There are really three types of colonialism.

Type 1 is where is the colonizers set up new outposts in more-or-less unoccupied land. This happened in Hong Kong and Calcutta. This is usually benign for the host country.

Type 2 is where the colonizers steal the land from the natives and occupy it themselves. This happened in the United States and to some extent in Ireland. This type of colonialism is usually terrible for the natives.

Type 3 is where the colonizers install themselves as a ruling caste, but otherwise let the natives be. They extract taxes and provide governance in return. This was the case in India. It was also the case when the Normans invaded England, the Spanish invaded Mexico, or the British took over India.

Type 3 often works out better for the natives, because the existing regime had to be pretty backward and corrupt in order to fall to a small band of foreigners. The foreigners install themselves as competent stationary bandits and the country at least enjoys some stability and rule of law.

And how do you even move a culture forward? It sounds like you're implying that some cultures are better than others. Please tell me you're not saying that.

So you're saying Aztec culture wasn't worse than 19th century British culture? Cultures that had human sacrifice are equal to cultures that perfected the steam engine and flush toilets? Please tell me you are not that willfully ignorant.

It should be blindingly obvious that certain elements of culture are worse than others, unless you are willing to argue that religions with human sacrifice are just as good as religions without human sacrifice, or that funerals with Sati are just as good as funerals without Sati. If certain elements of culture are better or worse, than it would be a miracle if all cultures exactly balanced out so that the positive elements and negative elements were equal, thus making all cultures equal to each other.

Re:Holding Your Breath in India by cscurmudgeon on Sunday June 07, 2015 @09:24AM (#9674537)
Ah Europe . The pinnacle of human civilization with burning witches, inquisitions, and my favorite http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanged,_drawn_and_quartered
Re:Holding Your Breath in India by task_queue on Sunday June 07, 2015 @04:15AM (#9673825)
Type 4 the type where you have no idea what you're talking about with regards to British rule in India

Type 5 is where you start enumerating during your rant to make it seem as you have a point beyond "never mind mass murders, famines.. colonialism sure did a lot for culture"

Re:Holding Your Breath in India by selimthegrim on Sunday June 07, 2015 @01:10AM (#9673461)
You may want to find the Satyajit Ray movie A Game of Chess and watch it. A Bengali director, no less (apt for rayiner's case), and his take on colonialism.
Re:Holding Your Breath in India by reagency on Sunday June 07, 2015 @03:19AM (#9673733)
Type 3 covers the Nazi occupation of France, so...
Re:Holding Your Breath in India by Dylan16807 on Sunday June 07, 2015 @01:45PM (#9675593)
So what? Please make your point, because I can't guess it.

Yes, Nazis are bad, and war is bad.

But if you put the German government in charge of France and look at the long-term effects that would have? Not a terrible thing.

Also you're ignoring "small band". France could not have fallen to a small number of troops. An area without a strong government could.

Re:Holding Your Breath in India by fractalb on Sunday June 07, 2015 @07:10AM (#9674171)
>> Type 3 often works out better for the natives, because the existing regime had to be pretty backward and corrupt in order to fall to a small band of foreigners. The foreigners install themselves as competent stationary bandits and the country at least enjoys some stability and rule of law.

Occupying a country is actually making them a favour!

Re:Holding Your Breath in India by mistermann on Sunday June 07, 2015 @10:30AM (#9674738)
Hong Kong and Singapore seemed to have done all right, especially when compared to mainland China.
Re:Holding Your Breath in India by mistermann on Sunday June 07, 2015 @01:10AM (#9673463)
> It sounds like you're implying that some cultures are better than others. Please tell me you're not saying that.

Assuming you believe the word culture actually has objectively true meaning, do you believe that while cultures are different, all differences everywhere somehow all balance out to a precisely equal level of "good"? And furthermore, are they all also equal with respect to any individual topic (sanitation, environment, honestly, etc)?

Re:Holding Your Breath in India by rayiner on Saturday June 06, 2015 @10:57PM (#9673220)
Yes, some cultures are better than others. My parents immigrated from Bangladesh to America for a reason, and it wasn't the weather I assure you.
Re:Holding Your Breath in India by rsync on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:41AM (#9673419)
Some cultures are better than others.
Re:Holding Your Breath in India by gone35 on Saturday June 06, 2015 @09:42PM (#9673073)
That's debatable, to say the least. One can make the argument that British colonialism was primarily (no surprises here) extractive, not developmental. And apparently to some extent it shows in the empirical pattern[1].

None of these arguments are 100% proof of course, but they should at least weigh in on one's priors, I think.

[1] http://www.people.hbs.edu/liyer/iyer_colonial_oct2004.pdf

Re:Holding Your Breath in India by chlodwig on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:06AM (#9673358)
Virtually all governments are extractive. Governments are simply property owners that happen to own an entire country.

If you are lucky, you get a stationary bandit that extracts, but does not want to kill the golden goose. The stationary bandit wants to act as a gardener and grow production.

If you are unlucky, you get a roving bandit that will pillage as much as possible in the short term, not caring about long-term growth.

It strikes me that the corruption of the Indian government is much more akin to a roving bandit. Each official wants his share, no matter the impact on growth for the nation as a whole.

Re:Holding Your Breath in India by reagency on Sunday June 07, 2015 @03:21AM (#9673739)
What are you on about? Did you fail to notice the past few centuries of republicanism?
Re:Holding Your Breath in India by chimeracoder on Saturday June 06, 2015 @08:44PM (#9672953)
> Turned the clock forward in terms of culture

First, this presumes a linear progression and objective ranking of "quality" or "utility" of cultures, which any serious sociologist or anthropologist would reject.

Really, what you're saying is "colonialism turned Indian culture into something which more closely resembles present-day British (or perhaps Western European) culture". Phrased that way, it's easier to see that this argument is not particularly interesting. It's pretty obvious that colonialism will have that impact; that's basically the definition of hegemony.

Secondly, this ignores the immense impact that Indian culture (and other colonial cultures) have had on Britain (or their respective colonial powers). One of the well-known effects of colonialism (both in India and elsewhere) is the erasure of this influence. That is, cultural elements of the colonial subjects are appropriated by the colonial power as a "new" invention of that culture, rather than viewed (by the contemporary discourse) as an adoption of some aspect of the colonial culture. The reverse is not true; aspects of the colonial power's culture that are adopted by the colonial subjects are not viewed by either culture as being native to the colonial subjects[0].

Finally, this also overlooks the many ways that colonial rule appears to be a 'regression' even from the fallacious lens of a linear progression of culture. For example, the current criminialization of homosexuality in India is a due to a law imposed by the British during colonial rule. Before colonial rule, the concept of a nation-state didn't exist and enforcement of law was very different in practice, so we can't compare directly by looking for national legal codes. But it's very clear that homosexuality was not only not universally criminal in India, but was in fact an established and accepted cultural phenomenon in certain pockets of society. After the decriminalization of those practices, they disappeared entirely (in their then-current form; homosexuality itself obviously did not end).

[0] If anyone is interested in reading more about this, this principle is most famously explicated by Foucault. (No, the irony of referencing Foucault on cultural appropriation is not lost on me.)

Re:Holding Your Breath in India by chlodwig on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:10AM (#9673366)
What are three positive aspects of modern British culture that were imported from India (besides food and tea)?
Re:Holding Your Breath in India by akhatri_aus on Sunday June 07, 2015 @03:23AM (#9673744)
It's said Chicken Tikka Masala is actually the most popular dish in the UK, well knocked off the very top but its still up there.

Mathematics, Jewellery, Ideas on Governance, A strong work ethic, Missiles & Weaponry (yup)... There are loads of other things. I think the tone of your question suggests one shouldn't bother to bring this out too much as it will not change your ideas.

Re:Holding Your Breath in India by Dylan16807 on Sunday June 07, 2015 @01:56PM (#9675650)
Britain imported a strong work ethic from India? I wouldn't have realized that was possible. I'm fascinated, can you refer me to more information?
Re:Holding Your Breath in India by akhatri_aus on Sunday June 07, 2015 @04:20PM (#9676229)
Britain's current handout culture something that was better back then I assume?

Please have a look at the income of Indian families in the UK/US relative to other ethnic groups. Asian culture emphasizes a strong work ethic. It's not just Indians with this one.

Re:Holding Your Breath in India by Dylan16807 on Monday June 08, 2015 @04:12AM (#9677797)
Importing Indians doesn't count. Did they import the work ethic to the other people living in Britain?

If the actual Indian families have higher income, it sounds like you're saying the answer is no...

Re:Holding Your Breath in India by akhatri_aus on Monday June 08, 2015 @08:12AM (#9678436)
Importing Indians does count 1), 2) labour pricing does affect everyone else in the market. A hard working labour pool forces others to compete.

The Indians part seems irrelevant from what you're saying. It seems you think British people are lazy?

Re:Holding Your Breath in India by Dylan16807 on Monday June 08, 2015 @03:01PM (#9681404)
When the question is what things British culture has absorbed from Indian culture, only things that have gone mainstream count, not things that are exclusive to immigrant communities.

>The Indians part seems irrelevant from what you're saying. It seems you think British people are lazy?

What? Not at all. I have no idea how lazy British people are. I was reacting to your statement that I should "Please have a look at the income of Indian families in the UK/US relative to other ethnic groups." That implies that there is a significant difference between mainstream culture and Indian immigrant culture.

Re:Holding Your Breath in India by cactusface on Sunday June 07, 2015 @01:10AM (#9673462)
Textiles, yoga, and Buddhism? Indian people themselves, plenty of whom live in the UK?
Re:Holding Your Breath in India by bjones22 on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:03AM (#9673351)
Japan was able to modernize without brutal colonial rulers. What makes you say India wasn't capable of the same thing?
Re:Holding Your Breath in India by kijin on Sunday June 07, 2015 @12:57AM (#9673439)
Japan achieved modernization, in part, by becoming brutal colonial rulers themselves.
Re:Holding Your Breath in India by cactusface on Sunday June 07, 2015 @03:09AM (#9673709)
And then a vassal state...
Re:Holding Your Breath in India by bjones22 on Monday June 08, 2015 @12:12AM (#9677287)
shh we only remember the good parts of history...

/s

Fair point. But I think it still nullifies the argument that countries can't modernize without 'civilized' colonial rulers.

Re:Holding Your Breath in India by cactusface on Monday June 08, 2015 @02:54AM (#9677572)
Well there's so much going on in the modernization process that it's a bit unclear. Was the US required for Japan to (fully) modernize?
Re:Holding Your Breath in India by cscurmudgeon on Sunday June 07, 2015 @09:21AM (#9674532)
You should read more.
Re:Holding Your Breath in India by enupten on Sunday June 07, 2015 @01:56AM (#9673561)
I'm sure that helps you think well of yourself.

Thankfully the British kept a meticulous record of the beautiful civilization they destroyed with utmost cruelty.

India was much more advanced than Britain at the time. Now the thief claims to be a civilizer ? Irony has known no bounds.

https://archive.org/details/DharampalCollectedWritingsIn5Vol...

Re:Holding Your Breath in India by akhatri_aus on Sunday June 07, 2015 @03:17AM (#9673728)
I don't think I can argue much with nationalism. India has had nearly 70 years now without colonialism

I think you may find a large proportion of grandparents who will say the positive developments aren't anywhere to be found. Though there have been some nice things going on like having no one rule & no one to opress.

From my point of view, better the British than the Mughals.

If you're a keen scholar of history you may also find that if it were not for the British India would be many many small countries today.

I'm not sure if that counts but it would have had a different sort of destruction this way, perhaps it may have turned out better. Would you say secessionist states today are good for India?

Re:Holding Your Breath in India by enupten on Sunday June 07, 2015 @03:42AM (#9673769)
Nation \neq Civilization.

If I were a fish, I'd want not to be eaten. I don't care two bits whether I'm fried in margarine or in butter (to paraphrase Nehru).

Enough said.

Re:Holding Your Breath in India by akhatri_aus on Sunday June 07, 2015 @03:47AM (#9673780)
When the British came the Mughals were already there. It is a bit different to remove that fish from butter and place it in margarine since it's not free to begin with.

I'm glad you said that. Indian culture and civilization still lives strong, it's just not only in India anymore.

You can thank the British for that (though I guess you hate them).

[deleted]
Re:Holding Your Breath in India by akhatri_aus on Sunday June 07, 2015 @04:02AM (#9673811)
Guy, instead of arguing with me on HN where nothing will happen run in for politics or something where you can impact people's lives instead. Our family left long ago. Though we've left we're still quite attached.

68 years is long enough after colonial rule not to blame them on the current problems. Singapore did it and got independence later than India did.

Re:Holding Your Breath in India by selimthegrim on Monday June 08, 2015 @01:20PM (#9680595)
Good lord, enupten quoting Nehru? I'd better check outside to see all the pigs queued for takeoff at the local airport....