News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by panorama on Saturday June 06, 2015 @04:36AM (#9670160)
Sometimes you pay a price to be able to do the things you love. However, the plight isn't necessarily with Lee Young Ho (aka "FlaSh"), who was winning $50,000 tournaments multiple times a year while on a 200-300k per year salary (I stopped following after the end of professional Brood War, not sure what it's like now).

The plight lies with those who aren't among the top 1% in their already elite field who are subject to the same amount of physical and mental stress and grueling 12 hour practices while making welfare wages. Maybe that's changed with more capital flowing into eSports these days, but I doubt it.

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by EC1 on Saturday June 06, 2015 @05:23AM (#9670240)
I spent four years of my life dedicated to StarCraft. I made GM several seasons on NA ladder. I made GM on Korean ladder for one season. I played many top tier players, and I beat them. Repeatedly.

Then I decided to invest in flying myself down to Dreamhack. All the people I played online and beat about 50% of the time and made connections with, I lost to every single time.

There's many like me, top tier players but who can't win a cent. The disparity in skill from bottom of the Grandmaster ladder to top 100, from 100 to top 50, then top 10, and finally top 5, is massive.

Stopped gaming altogether around that time.

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by fredoliveira on Saturday June 06, 2015 @07:32AM (#9670425)
I did the same with Counter-Strike what seems like a lifetime ago. I feel the world was a lot different back then. My team was the first team to have a sponsorship by Steelseries (they were a tiny company back then), and the numbers were super small. If I told any of the current top players how much we made back then with our sponsorships (which included Samsung and Intel as well), they would laugh.

These days, you have CS:GO players making 5 figures a month, supplementing that with another 5 figures by streaming, and genuinely living like rockstars. It gets better if you look at LoL, because their numbers are fairly larger too (about 2:1 still, even if CSGO is growing significantly).

The amount of work that has to go into getting yourself into a top team is insane these days. Lan houses have for the most part gone away, and finding people with the mentality required to create such a team is hard. Those who do it are certainly well compensated, because there's a ton of money in streaming and brands want to be involved. But there's a chasm between being extremely good and being on the teams you hear about. For the first, life certainly isn't as glamorous.

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by snarfy on Saturday June 06, 2015 @07:59AM (#9670473)
I've had a similar experience, except it was with the Tekken series fighting games. At one point I was ranked in the top 20 in NA. I had a few chances over the years to play the top 5 in NA, and #3 from Korea.

The difference in skill level as you go from #20 down to #1 can be huge. I would have 50% chance against one of the other top 20, but that would go to maybe 5% against someone in the top 5, 1% against #1, and 0% against the Korean #3. I think I beat him one round ever.

I'm not sure I'd want to be #1. There is a point of diminishing returns when the game is no longer fun but work.

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by MichaelGG on Saturday June 06, 2015 @03:20PM (#9671893)
Neat. How does the skill gap change the higher you go? That is, #5 vs #1, is the chance close to equal, or is there that much of a power gap? (There's probably a mathematical description of what I'm asking; I just don't know the name, if someone cares to enlighten me.)

Any speculation on the cause? Is playing at #20 just not so time-dominating, but top 5 is a real full-time career? What factors are at work?

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by snarfy on Saturday June 06, 2015 @04:43PM (#9672190)
In the Tekken scene (this was 14 years ago), the main differences were competitive - the #1-5 all played each other regularly. They were in a league of their own, as were the Koreans. Time dedicated is also a big factor.

You have ~1/4 second (10-15 frames depending on throw) to analyze and react to perform a throw escape, which is pushing the limits of human reaction time. If the buttons are 1,2,3,4, throw escapes were typically 1,2, or 1+2 (rarely 3&4). If you hit the correct button for the throw, you escaped it.

At first, nobody ever escapes throws. It happens too fast. With practice, you can successfully attempt an escape, but it's only a guess at 1,2, or 1+2. You go from 0% success to 33% success.

But you can tell what the escape is by the animation. A 1 escape shows the characters left arm more forward than the right, a 2 and the right arm is more forward, 1+2 and both arms move in unison. If you are really fast and analyze which escapes to do, you can escape throws 100% of the time. This requires more than practice - it requires continuous training, even conditioning to increase your metabolic rate (which changes your perception of time).

This is the difference between the #1-5 guys and everybody else. They could always escape throws, without guessing.

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by spiritplumber on Saturday June 06, 2015 @07:07AM (#9670393)
That's really interesting, could you do an AMA?
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by EC1 on Saturday June 06, 2015 @04:46PM (#9672202)
Where? Here? Reddit? Haha, probably pointless as nobody has ever really heard of me. There's dozens of players like me, dozens! Ask whatever you want.
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by hellbanner on Saturday June 06, 2015 @05:54PM (#9672430)
I'm curious how you saw the metagame evolve -- did top players invest in a character or team only to find that they were weaker to an evolved metagame?
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by EC1 on Saturday June 06, 2015 @06:12PM (#9672495)
Player by player basis. Each one plays differently. It was moreso seeing a bracket, who signed up, then pulling up replays of how they played and reading about them. I made a lot of notes on specific players styles, their timings, unit composition etc. Different strategy for each player + map.

What surprised me was when I went to the tournament, a lot of players had different play styles than what I've studied, which ultimately ruined me.

I'm the guy you're describing. Behind on the meta game. I went for the long game every single time, as safe as possible, so I lost to a lot of early cheese that I didn't even know was possible. Some Korean gave me a 3 stalker push at like the 5:30 or earlier(can't remember). I just sat there wondering to my self "fucking... how?" That moment really stuck with me. You play thousands of games in the top leagues and people still surprise you.

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by hellbanner on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @02:19PM (#9694242)
How much of top-level play do you think is a "guessing" game ala RPS? If you scout properly & manage properly, can you make it to the mid-game safely everytime, or is it luck of the RPS?
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by pdpi on Saturday June 06, 2015 @05:01AM (#9670193)
> The plight lies with those who aren't among the top 1% in their already elite field who are subject to the same amount of physical and mental stress and grueling 12 hour practices while making welfare wages

That's also no different from other pro sports.

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by johnchristopher on Saturday June 06, 2015 @05:53AM (#9670285)
Question: why are the top of the top players earning so much more than the top (excluding advertisements and sponsorship incomes) ?
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by bobcostas55 on Saturday June 06, 2015 @06:01AM (#9670295)
The classic Rosen paper The Economics of Superstars provides a solid explanation.

http://users.polisci.wisc.edu/schatzberg/ps616/Rosen1981.pdf

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by throwaway9324 on Saturday June 06, 2015 @05:26AM (#9670243)
It's plenty of different from other pro sports. The "pro" part largely means getting paid more than it takes to sustain the activity. With some exceptions like pro boxing which isn't exactly a poster boy for ethical practices.
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by culturestate on Saturday June 06, 2015 @05:33AM (#9670255)
It's not as different as you think. Base salary in minor league baseball, for instance, is ~US$1500 per month, and they only get paid during the season.

That obviously changes with service time -- and any service in the majors bumps it up disproportionately -- but guys who toil for 5 or 10 years in the minors without making it to the big club aren't getting rich.

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by solicode on Saturday June 06, 2015 @06:52AM (#9670371)
Yeah, you see this in a lot of sports actually. I feel the biggest differentiator is whether there's a players union or not. The Minors appear to not have their own (I did not know this). Maybe this has to do with how much money the league generates, but I can't say because I don't know the details.

Boxing was already mentioned, but there's also MMA which is in the news right now for this very reason. If you're interested, look up the recent deal between the UFC and Reebok and how nearly all the fighters got screwed by this. Only the top players are getting taken care of, while plenty of others can't even get proper healthcare despite the fact we're talking about a combat sport here. It's unbelievable.

I imagine forming a union must be harder in individual sports rather than team sports. And with e-sports, most players' careers seem to be very short, which can't be helping matters if they ever wanted to form a union. Not much leverage for a variety of reasons.

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by relic on Saturday June 06, 2015 @08:46AM (#9670584)
You're exactly right about the lack of a players union being the reason for disproportionately low salaries in minor league baseball. The reason they don't have one is because the minor league clubs have no incentive to allow one, and the major league clubs that feed from the minor league systems have no incentive to help either. When there are so many guys willing to play for basically nothing but a shot at the bigs, meaningful change is unrealistic, although there are some ex-minor league players attempting to change that. It's likely very similar for other sports.
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by JoeAltmaier on Saturday June 06, 2015 @08:53AM (#9670603)
Plausible. Yet, Hollywood is almost exactly the same scene (so many willing to play for nothing but a shot). Yet they are organized.
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by mcguire on Saturday June 06, 2015 @12:02PM (#9671228)
I believe that is a historical anomaly caused by the way the studio system treated stars and minor-league wanna-bes similarly for many years. When they did organize, they were unable to establish a clear line, major-league/minor-league, differentiation.
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by riffraff on Saturday June 06, 2015 @09:40AM (#9670753)
football in italy has unions, but the same pattern applies.
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by throwaway9324 on Saturday June 06, 2015 @06:28AM (#9670337)
This is kind of an exception though when it comes to popular team sports and far as I know E-sport is still far from even those relatively bad pay and terms.
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by majormajor on Saturday June 06, 2015 @04:36PM (#9672167)
Not really. NBA D-League and minor league hockey salaries aren't exactly anything to write home about either.

And then there's football, where the "minor leagues" are 3 years unpaid in college, where you not only have to batter your body without getting paid, you also have to keep up academic performance at the same time (wouldn't it make more sense to make some money playing football trying to get to the NFL, and then if you don't make it, having that money to get an education if desired on your own schedule, without having to do both at once?).

I often wonder if this, or the similar Hollywood model, is where Silicon Valley will eventually end up. The model is already quite similar, the money at the bottom just hasn't been squeezed out the same way yet. But there is pressure on first time founders who raise funding to pay themselves the minimum at first "to keep them focused," and the same applies to early employee equity stakes. We even have the tech-scene focused gossip/hero-worship of the Hollywood or pro sports scenes down pat!

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by throwaway9324 on Saturday June 06, 2015 @06:12PM (#9672493)
College football is amateur i.e. not professional.

You can go down any sport and find divisions that aren't paid very well, likewise you can find obscure sports that consider themselves professional but aren't very well paid either. I find none of this particularly relevant to the discussion. There are huge differences between how e-sport works and how professional sports organisations work and I guess the people who don't believe that will just have to remain ignorant.

SV is already there to some degree. With angel type funding you will spend most of you salary on living expenses which won't return very good quality of life.

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by majormajor on Saturday June 06, 2015 @06:49PM (#9672614)
The "amateur" state of college football is a joke. It's the only option. It's a de-facto minor leagues for the NFL. The NFL benefits from being able to scout these players through it without having to draft or pay them earlier. The college athletic departments benefit from having found a revenue stream far larger than any other minor league, yet still not having to pay the players who generate that revenue. Heck, even the athletes in other sports get more real benefit than the college football players, since that's a lot of what's funding their scholarships. The football players are in a weird position of playing in front of 50-90,000 adoring fans every week just like they would in the NFL, but seeing nothing more than a scholarship and some stipends.

You haven't explained the huge differences. The vast majority of post-high-school players in any sport are doing it despite it being either a poor financial decision or simply part of a system that's inherently rigged against those players. The 1% get fame and fortune, the 99% wash out with nothing to show for it but years of little income. E-sport aspirants get even less to show for it? It doesn't seem very meaningful to quibble over the difference between "very little" and "practically nothing."

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by throwaway9324 on Sunday June 07, 2015 @04:46AM (#9673864)
Since I'm going to give up my HN activities after this I'll humor you with a response.

While the line between amateur and professional sports have been blurred there are still very real differences. Amateur athletes aren't well compensated, but they are protected from the world of contracts, agents, transfers etc.

People give golf or tennis as examples of professional sports where you can struggle as a professional, which is laughable for anyone who knows sports history. These are sports that because of their status has kept a lot of the original characteristics of amateurism in sports (which from the beginning is a status i.e. upper class thing). Countries which have adopted to a modern amateur approach (with government support, non-profit organisations etc) to those sports have also been punching above their weight.

So what is huge difference between e-sports and other professional sports? For one they don't actually own their sport. I'm not a huge intellectual property fan, but in the case of professional sports it's hugely important. It's the basis for most if not all professional sports organisations. Most of e-sports does not make any salary, if they do or even if the don't they are signed to a team which takes part winnings in tournaments. So you have a situation where it's hard to make a living like in amateur sports, but you don't have the support network or limits of the same. At the same time you have to deal with the contracts and incentives from professional sport, but you don't get the benefits of intellectual property deals and major leagues and therefor salaries.

To some degree this is changing, especially in Korea, but it's still more of a business than a sport. Sports at it's core is competition to find out who is the best. You do that by having fairly similar conditions over a longer time. That's what amateur and professional sport organisations do or, at least, should do.

That said I'm not even sure the discussion should be about if e-sports is a professional or amateur sport, but if it's organized enough to be either or for that matter even considered a sport at all. Is chess a sport? How about poker? Or day trading? Fashion modeling?

I find myself having a severe lack of motivation while writing this, but hopefully it made some sense.

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by jacalata on Saturday June 06, 2015 @09:42AM (#9670760)
Thats not true in the slightest. I know a pro strongman who doesn't make enough in prize money to cover his training, let alone flying to contests, and I used to work in pro tennis where the bottom tier (still pro players) are borrowing money and living off relatives and national sports grants.
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by throwaway9324 on Saturday June 06, 2015 @03:51PM (#9672008)
I've realized that this is pretty useless to discuss on HN, with downvotes and anecdotal evidence.
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by hkmurakami on Saturday June 06, 2015 @07:36AM (#9670433)
Pro golfers in the minor league circuits are often in the red.
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by JonoBB on Saturday June 06, 2015 @07:28AM (#9670419)
Lest anyone thinks that this is not big business, the largest prize pool in gaming is the Dota International (held once a year).

It's currently sitting at > $12m (split between 5 players on a team, their manager, and who knows who else). It will probably rise to over $15m by the time the tournament is on.

Of interest is that the prize pool comes from the "normal" players playing the game - you buy in game items, and 25% of the revenue from that goes to the prize pool for the tournament. The items themselves are completely optional and cosmetic only. And, of course, valve takes the other 75%.

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by jamornh on Saturday June 06, 2015 @11:44AM (#9671143)
> And, of course, valve takes the other 75%.

Not disagreeing, but they probably use a large portion of that money to actually pay for the organization, venue, designs of the compendium, the staffs, and everything else involved with the International. All that can't be cheap so I'm not sure which portion of that 75% is valve's profit. Does anybody have any ideas?

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by plorkyeran on Saturday June 06, 2015 @12:06PM (#9671244)
I don't think it's really meaningful to look at it like that. The tournament isn't funded specifically by sales of the items which contribute to the prize pool; it's just a general marketing expense to increase the number of players. Even if everyone decided to boycott compendiums for some reason, the whole thing could be a net profit if they spent the same amount of money in the dota store on other things (actually, it'd be more profitable...).
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by vicwhiten on Saturday June 06, 2015 @01:06PM (#9671458)
The winning team doesn't take the entire 12 million, thats the prizepool for the entire tournament. However its still a lot of money. If you qualified for the LAN finals you're getting a piece of that. If you look at http://www.esportsearnings.com/players, the top 5 players were the 5 players on team Newbee, the International 4 champions from last year. They each made over 1 million dollars from that one tournament.
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by dylanjermiah on Saturday June 06, 2015 @04:50AM (#9670177)
>"who are subject to the same amount of physical and mental stress and grueling 12 hour practices while making welfare wages. "

They aren't subject to anything. They choose.

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by panorama on Saturday June 06, 2015 @05:38AM (#9670262)
While true, it's not adults getting into pro-gaming, it's usually teenagers. Kids who would rather play Starcraft than study, and, despite being very good, lack the foresight of knowing what kind of hole they're digging themselves into.
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by ghostDancer on Saturday June 06, 2015 @07:48AM (#9670460)
I can show you a lot of teenagers doing the same but playing football(soccer), less hours at least, and even pushed by their parents with the hope that some of them will be the next Messi, Xavi or Ronaldo.
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by zo1 on Saturday June 06, 2015 @12:16PM (#9671282)
Exactly, and because it's part of the "normal culture", then no-one bats an eye (I exaggerate a bit there).

If we were to look at football and basketball sports' effect on children, and how pervasive and time-consuming it is to normal teens/young-adults the same way we do when it comes to "e-sports", then we'd be positively disgusted (a bit of extrapolation there).

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by kendallpark on Saturday June 06, 2015 @02:48PM (#9671769)
I think there is a difference in that sports like football and basketball are more limited by the body's abilities to perform. A natural mechanism for moderation. You don't have gaming binges where someone plays football for 18 hours straight without sleeping. But this happens all the time with gaming.

Furthermore, most traditional sports also improve one's physiological health. This is not the case for e-sports where one is simply sitting in a chair all day. I can understand why a parent would be more concerned about their kid that doesn't leave his computer than their kid that plays three sports a year.

But in both e-sports and traditional sports you have the risk of sacrificing too much for the sake of the game. I have known many athletes in both camps that have done this.

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by MichaelGG on Saturday June 06, 2015 @03:25PM (#9671909)
Is it true that competitive sports are actually physically healthy? I'm probably just over valuing notable cases, but even things like ballet tear up feet pretty badly. And tennis is known for injuries, isn't it? American football is rough, though I suppose normal football is basically the same as targeted running/sprinting.
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by kendallpark on Sunday June 07, 2015 @11:16AM (#9674946)
It really is a trade off. Like I play football competitively and I know that I'm wearing out my joints, but my muscle mass and bone density is way higher than that of the average female. Muscle mass and bone density have a huge effect on your health later in life. Meanwhile, physically inactive people my age (20s) are losing muscle mass, decreasing their metabolism, increasing their body fat percentage, and so on.

Yeah, I probably could just do weightlifting and cardio on their own (and will sometime have to transition to this) but to be honest football is my primary motivation for doing these things in the first place. A lot of competitive athletes make a successful transition from competitive play to less injurious activities after their careers and are none the worse for it. (Minus NFL concussion cases...)

There are also intangible benefits to playing competitive sports. Being part of a team, working hard to achieve a goal, being challenged, pushing your limits, pursuing something you're passionate about, succeeding at an elite level... Sports can give you unique experiences you'll treasure for your lifetime and also shape you as a person.

It really is an optimization between the all the trade offs. Every year I have to weigh what the sport gives me and what the sport takes away and decide whether it's my last season.

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by hacst on Saturday June 06, 2015 @04:19PM (#9672112)
At the very top you'll probably have to search very hard to find a sport that is actually good for your health. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8XnQyI3Mgbc is a great documentary on what it takes to win gold in the Olympics. These athletes knowingly - and willingly - trade their health for a shot at their goals.
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by slavik81 on Saturday June 06, 2015 @04:26PM (#9672135)
Soccer players hit the ball with their head. Hard. I'd be unsurprised if that resulted in measurable damage after a few years.

In fact, it seems it does. http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/does-heading-a-soc...

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by ufmace on Saturday June 06, 2015 @04:25PM (#9672134)
I thought I read somewhere that most physical sports aren't really that healthy when played at the intensity level needed to be a national-level star. Everything in moderation, and all that.
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by dylanjermiah on Saturday June 06, 2015 @06:28AM (#9670335)
I agree, in my opinion there are more productive and 'healthy' uses of ones time. But, my opinion doesn't mean anything. Forcing/coercing kids into doing what you think is best for them is not productive either.
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by bad_user on Saturday June 06, 2015 @07:08AM (#9670395)
Making choices for children, who are otherwise too immature, is the whole point of parenting. Of course, you can "coerce" them, or you can "guide" them, but then we are talking about different means for the same end goal. And then we can talk about parents that are too busy or uninterested to give a fuck and it's precisely in such families that you see children being allowed to play computer games for hours on end.

I don't really get the line on "forcing/coercing" children. If your child would end up a drug addict, would you just let her be? Why is it any different with computer gaming addiction?

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by Omniusaspirer on Saturday June 06, 2015 @09:02AM (#9670634)
Computer gaming is an easy target, but this has been going on for decades with pro sports and music, and probably millennia with art. Teenagers have always gotten hooked on things their parents deem useless or unhealthy.
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by dylanjermiah on Saturday June 06, 2015 @08:05AM (#9670480)
My comment was not from the perspective of a parent.
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by gbog on Saturday June 06, 2015 @09:08AM (#9670653)
Would it be so different with a good friend? If there if someone you are attached to, and if this someone is heading full steam toward a cliff or a dead end, you'll tell them, no? Or do whatever you can to help them. Or maybe you believe that anything about other people is not your concern in any respect?

Parenting is not an exception, it is not a different world where values change. It is just the same world, with people caring or not for others, with some responsibility and affection. It's just a bit more acute and produce good counter examples to those believing one should not care about others.

My third kid was born yesterday. I'm still getting drunk with friends once a week, I do my hobbies in the evening (programming, pictures, music), I spend very good moments with the kids, I let them grow and make sure they have plenty of different thing for their curiosity, gosh I even played gta with my 5yo boy, but I certainly would never encourage any of them to try to become a professional sport player, or e-sport. Or model. Or musician. The odds of having an happy life in these domains is infinitesimal.

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by JoeAltmaier on Saturday June 06, 2015 @09:09AM (#9670655)
Happy? Maybe the wrong word choice. Certainly folks can be happy doing these things. Maybe happier than any other job. They probably cannot be wealthy doing those things.
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by bad_user on Saturday June 06, 2015 @09:22AM (#9670705)
I find it to be a very good choice of words.

The equation for happiness is simple. First of all you need your basic necessities covered, things like food, shelter, clothing, access to health care, plus interactions with other human beings and the possibility of having sex from time to time. Then your expectations have to be smaller than your achievements. When this doesn't happen, it's a recipe for depression.

It's easy to see how sports can lead to unhappiness, but to make matters worse, when comparing soccer or basketball or volley to e-sports, at least from those sports you get a healthy body out of it ;-)

Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by gbog on Saturday June 06, 2015 @09:13AM (#9670665)
I maintain happy. In the article they said these gamers actually do bit like to play anymore. Same with music, in most cases professional musician hate playing music, but of course none of them will ever admit this.
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by JoeAltmaier on Saturday June 06, 2015 @09:21AM (#9670700)
I know many professional musicians. None of them have this attitude. They are on cloud 9 when they are playing. This is sour grapes I think.
Re:The real scars of Korean gaming by iLoch on Saturday June 06, 2015 @05:02AM (#9670196)
Yeah, doesn't this describe the pursuit of at least half the people on HN?