At this point you might be wondering how it’s possible to program with- out variables. How can you express something like X = X + 1 in Erlang? The answer is easy. Invent a new variable whose name hasn’t been used before (say X1), and write X1 = X + 1.
X=#todo{}.
X1 = #todo{status=urgent, text="Fix errata in book"}.
X2 = X1#todo{status=done}.
From Armstrongs thesis X = 5; X1 = X + 10;
I found those just by searching on "X1". There are more X1 examples in the erlang otp sources. Who knows what else is in there.It does, but you'll rarely see this pattern in any real Erlang code base. And when you see it, it will not be "littered". It's an exception, not an idiom.
And those samples from Joe's book and thesis are just snippets with no context. BTW, O'Reilly's "Erlang Programming" doesn't even provide such an example.
Edit: One example when I do use this pattern is constructing proplists for some function calls.
Or, rebinding variables is generally not the clearest way to express the intent of your calculation. Abstractions like fold are more pure descriptions of the desired calculation.
I do agree with the consensus that the clojure recur, expresses something about intent that is missing from Erlang.
I enjoy functional depictions of algorithms, but there are many programmers who are currently more comfortable with imperative code.
f(..., State0) ->
{A,State1} = foo(..., State0),
{B,State2} = bar(..., State1),
{C,State3} = baz(..., State2),
Res = fubar(A, B, C, ...),
{Res,State3}.
Otherwise you just create confusion.The guy you're looking for is Tony Arcieri, and his language is Reia. And here's the FAQ about assignments:
http://wiki.reia-lang.org/wiki/FAQ#Destructive_assignment.3F...
Also, the immutable variable have nothing to do with concurrency. Since threads cant touch each others data, and they can only talk to each other through messages, immutability only applies to a local scope, where its really no big deal.
Last time I checked somebody was making a scripting language built on top of the erlang runtime and he says that immutable variables are nonsense.