Ask HN: Using a mac as the main development system or not
I'm mostly a .net developer. I occasionally work with PHP and node.js.
Recently, my < 2year old laptop that I use as my main dev system has been behaving strangely. It's still under warranty, but I've always wanted to develop apps for OSX and iOS.
So I was wondering if I should get a 15'' macbook pro and dual boot or use parallels to work with windows specific programs. But it seems very overpriced (€3000 ~ $3400) for its hardware. Specially since my current setup is not that bad (I think):
- i7-3630QM 4Cores 6MB cache
- 8GB ram
- 750GB @ 5400rpm
- nvidia GeForce GT 740M (I play games extremely rarely, so this is not an issue)
Battery life and screen size is not really an issue for me. I mainly want a mbp (or air) for ios\osx dev.
Should I still get the 15'' or:
a) Upgrade my system to 512GB SSD + 16 ram (€340 ~ $385) and get a mbp 13'' with (128 or 256 GB ) and (8 or 16) of ram ? just for ios\osx dev
b) Don't upgrade my current setup and get a mbp 13'' with (128 or 256 GB ) and (8 or 16) of ram ? just for ios dev
c) Upgrade (or not) and get a MBA 13'' ?
Thank you
That being said, Bootcamp (dual booting) does not work well. It "works" in the sense that Windows will load and you can do tasks, but the drivers are poorly optimised, often broken, and Apple doesn't prioritise fixing them (and provides near zero support either in-store or over the phone for Bootcamp).
So if you wish to do this, then just come to terms with the fact that OS X will be your MAIN operating system and Windows will be a virtual machine you work in. The whole experience will just be more pleasant that way, as the Parallels team do support their product and DO fix the drivers that interact with their virtual hardware.
If you plan on buying this and MUST duel boot into Windows, then the entire plan is just a bad idea. Buy a Thinkpad instead (or Surface Pro, etc).
The only complaint I have about natively booting into Bootcamp/Windows is that the touchpad driver isn't anywhere near as nice on Windows as on OS X.
The fact that VMware will happily boot a virtualized instance of the Bootcamp Windows partition (when I'm on OS X) is pretty damn fantastic too.
In the past I've also been able to do the reverse: use VMware to boot OS X from within Windows.
Having a second monitor (I've got a 24" Asus) at home/work is really handy, but I have no problem using just the main screen when I'm working mobile.
I was in the same boat as you roughly two months ago (needing to develop on ios/osx) and vmware/vbox ios wasn't cutting it. I was able to snag a 2014 mbp on ebay for a measly $1,000 (ha).
Best of luck either way!
MBP's definitely need an SSD (not sure if they still come with HDDs). Mine had a 500GB HDD, I dropped the laptop when using it and damaged the HDD. I replaced it with a 128GB HDD (as I don't have much large software that's double what I need) and the speed difference is insane. App launches are 5-6x faster, bootup is probably 10x faster and more. If I let the battery run out and it slept, when waking it'd take about 2-3 minutes to resume, now it's 2-3 seconds. I'll never own a machine with a HDD again.
Thanks
I would like to add a small word of caution: The current generation Minis are not upgradable. Previously you could pop them open and turn a 4 GB RAM Mini into a 16 GB Mini for under $70, now the RAM is soldered onto the motherboard so the configuration you buy is the configuration you're stuck with.
PS - This was done without physically shrinking the size of the Mini, so one can only assume Apple did this for profit reasons (either manufacturing savings OR forcing people to buy their overpriced upgrades during purchase).
Very few people upgrade their machines after buying them, it's a small percentage of their user base that ever bothers to. The inconvenience there is worth the trade-off: Any Mini coming in for service is using factory memory, no questions, past this point.
It's was always a nice to have, but it's not exactly a deal-breaker now, their prices aren't anywhere as crazy as server vendors can be. It just means you need to build-to-order a machine as they rarely stock the upgraded models.
Historically it wasn't advantageous to lock it down like that, people would typically upgrade their memory several times over the course of a system's lifecycle. If you look at what the original G3 case was like, where there was a latch on the side that lays the case open with easy access to memory and hard-drives, a design improved upon throughout the early Mac Pro models, you can see they were never intentionally user-hostile.
In the interests of shrinking components and improving reliability, though, in an appliance-like product such as the Mac Mini, it makes sense.
Notice that the new Mac Pro has extremely easy access to the memory slots.
For most people, the memory that comes with their computer is the memory that computer dies with. This holds true for all kinds of systems, especially laptops where in most cases people don't even know or care how much memory they have.
It was nice to be able to save a little by buying third party memory, but it's not the end of the world that you can't. The Mini can only go to 16GB, so the savings are minor. The Mac Pro can go to 128GB, so it's almost expected you can do that.
Good luck.
Isn't it a little disingenuous to advertise that you are able to develop iOS/OSX when you can't at the moment?
YAGNI doesn't really apply to building new skills or gaining new capabilities... especially when said skills and capabilities open up new markets.
I don't want shinny. I want something portable (hence the mbp or mba) and powerful enough to do what I want.
IMO, the Macbook Air is useless. I personally wouldn't bother with it.
The Air isn't "useless", but it isn't really intended as a development machine. It prioritizes size and battery life over horsepower.
You can get a 15" MBP new, with the dedicated graphics card, 16gb ram, and the new SSDs for like... 2500 USD
- http://store.apple.com/fi/buy-mac/macbook-pro
- http://store.apple.com/es/buy-mac/macbook-pro
- http://store.apple.com/pt/buy-mac/macbook-pro
- http://store.apple.com/it/buy-mac/macbook-pro
- http://store.apple.com/ie/buy-mac/macbook-pro
....
A $2500 machine even in the US might cost $2,700 after tax in the US (depending on your state's sales tax % and if Apple has to pay it).
On a site where everyone's concerned with the Hz and the MBs, the UX regularly gets left behind.