News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Does HTML5 excite you? Why or why not? by earl on Saturday November 28, 2009 @10:31PM (#965871)
Programmer.

It doesn't excite me in the least because, since I can't afford to alienate big chunks of my audience, it might have enough penetration to use in, oh, 3-5 years? Meh.

Re:Ask HN: Does HTML5 excite you? Why or why not? by mbrubeck on Saturday November 28, 2009 @11:15PM (#965937)
While it might not be ready for general-audience web projects, I'm already using HTML5 and CSS3 features (including app cache and database storage) for some upcoming Android- and iPhone-specific mobile sites, and for a product that embeds WebKit in a non-browser application. Many of the features are also useful for building Flex/AIR/Silverlight-style "rich" apps, for which you could distribute Prism or another site-specific browser.
Re:Ask HN: Does HTML5 excite you? Why or why not? by frank06 on Sunday November 29, 2009 @06:49AM (#966257)
Year 1993: Does e-mail excite you? No, it doesn't excite me in the least, since I can't afford to alienate all fax and telex users.
Re:Ask HN: Does HTML5 excite you? Why or why not? by waterlesscloud on Saturday November 28, 2009 @10:47PM (#965896)
That's the main issue. The user base for it will be relatively small for several years.

Hopefully many of the people on IE 6 will leapfrog to a HTML 5 browser in the next few years, that would solve a lot of issues.

Re:Ask HN: Does HTML5 excite you? Why or why not? by mark_h on Saturday November 28, 2009 @11:09PM (#965930)
My gut feeling is that the mobile arena might be where html5 takes off first, with the number of webkit-based browsers out there now (iphone, android).
Re:Ask HN: Does HTML5 excite you? Why or why not? by drhowarddrfine on Saturday November 28, 2009 @11:56PM (#965986)
How does that affect you? Your HTML markup will work in HTML5, too. In any case, I keep reading no one will use it for years yet most of the leading developers and designers I know are using it today. And I'm joining them since all my markup is now HTML5 as of six months ago.
Re:Ask HN: Does HTML5 excite you? Why or why not? by jacobolus on Sunday November 29, 2009 @12:49AM (#966042)
When you say that your markup is HTML5, do you just mean that you changed the doctype at the top (That's trivial, and its only real effect is saving a few bytes, though I suppose it's a nice symbolic gesture), or that you are now using all of the new semantic elements like <article> and <section> and <footer>, using <video> instead of plugin-based video, including features like drag-and-drop, or offline use of data-heavy apps, &c. &c.?
Re:Ask HN: Does HTML5 excite you? Why or why not? by drhowarddrfine on Sunday November 29, 2009 @07:20PM (#967114)
Yes, using the newer elements. Haven't had a need for the others yet.
Re:Ask HN: Does HTML5 excite you? Why or why not? by brlewis on Sunday November 29, 2009 @12:00AM (#965991)
That's interesting. Can you fill out your profile with sites you've worked on?
Re:Ask HN: Does HTML5 excite you? Why or why not? by drhowarddrfine on Sunday November 29, 2009 @07:21PM (#967117)
Because I speak my mind, and the truth that many don't wish to hear, I won't do that even though I'd like to.
Re:Ask HN: Does HTML5 excite you? Why or why not? by tlholaday on Saturday November 28, 2009 @10:56PM (#965907)
The Google HTML5 plugin for IE6 might not alienate your audience.
Re:Ask HN: Does HTML5 excite you? Why or why not? by Tichy on Sunday November 29, 2009 @08:59AM (#966328)
I don't get it, though - surely if you are capable of installing a plugin, you are capable of updating your browser, too?
Re:Ask HN: Does HTML5 excite you? Why or why not? by mbrubeck on Sunday November 29, 2009 @10:26AM (#966392)
Corporate users would still need their administrators to install the plugin. But Chrome Frame could let change-fearing companies keep their users on IE6 (no retraining users or retesting existing sites), and use the Chrome engine only for sites that opt in to it.
Re:Ask HN: Does HTML5 excite you? Why or why not? by earl on Sunday November 29, 2009 @05:22PM (#966923)
I think part of the problem is MS encouraged people to write a bunch of ie6 specific sites. Thus, since ie doesn't AFAIK do side-by-side installs, the need to stay on ie6 for line of business apps.
Re:Ask HN: Does HTML5 excite you? Why or why not? by boucher on Saturday November 28, 2009 @10:59PM (#965915)
The Google Chrome Frame plugin is hardly a panacea for old browsers.
Re:Ask HN: Does HTML5 excite you? Why or why not? by sblom on Saturday November 28, 2009 @11:14PM (#965933)
I installed Chrome Frame to make Wave work in IE8, and it ended up breaking Google Reader. Hardly a panacea, indeed.
Re:Ask HN: Does HTML5 excite you? Why or why not? by brlewis on Saturday November 28, 2009 @10:42PM (#965886)
Do you think the web will be a lot better 5 years from now as a result of HTML5?
Re:Ask HN: Does HTML5 excite you? Why or why not? by benwr on Sunday November 29, 2009 @12:31AM (#966020)
Probably. On one hand, People Still Use IE6. And the people who still use IE6 aren't people who install things like Google Chrome Frame, or the latest updates from Microsoft (obviously). So for the time being, more features, along with cleaner syntax and the rest, means more work for web developers who want to use those features and whose audiences aren't particularly ahead of the curve.

On the other hand, those developers whose audiences are ahead of the curve, or who don't mind the blasphemous "Please update your browser. Here are some good ones:" link, will push the industry forward until the number of people still using IE6, or FF1.5, or Mosaic or whatever, approaches zero. It will happen because people will get annoyed, or viruses, or new computers running new operating systems and browsers. In that way html5 is the best thing that could happen to the web. A backwards-incompatible version will (hopefully) throw the few stragglers, who spend money on the web but still don't need css2, into the 21st century.

My grandmother was, until very recently, using MacOS 9 with IE4. She did not care that her homepage (apple.com, as it had been since she bought the computer) was impossible to read. People still using IE6 and even IE7 in five years will not be the kind of person who spends a lot of time or money online.