So it would be a waste of time to read Guns Germs and Steel, since it is mostly disputed? What would be a good alternative then?
(according to this link I just googled, American buffalos are actually bisons http://www.diffen.com/difference/Bison_vs_Buffalo )
First off, Bulls can definitely have nasty dispositions, and secondly they can definitely jump fences. I've personally seen a bull clear a 8 foot fence.
thanks for providing that though!
So you would say they would have been eligible for domestication and native Americans failed to do so for some unknown reason?
The argument here was that Diamond's theory is wrong because the native Americans could have domesticated the bisons after all. The claim that they are too difficult to tame is dismissed as "crap". Then it seems to me why they were not being domesticated needs another explanation (if the one from Diamond is not good enough). Just random chance?
/r/AskHistorians has an entire section devoted to the book, so it's had an impact
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/wiki/historians_views...
Anyway - best everybody make up their own mind, and remember that EVERYBODY has an agenda. Even the good people on reddit. Specifically, perhaps historians don't like it if somebody advances on their territory with a different approach (combining different disciplines). Their agenda is to push their methodology so that they get more funding for their research.
I am only aware of controversy about the Easter Islands which he described in "Collapse". One paper claimed the extinction of trees was actually because of rats, not because of their excessive consumption by the people for building their statues. Then I think I heard the rats theory to be disproved and replaced by something else.
I don't think that necessarily disproves the gist of his argument.
I can't help sometimes when reading anthropological studies or videos of a pre-modern civilization that a terrible amount of time is spent on rituals and dances and other things and perhaps the key is that other, faster developing groups of people simply found a different balance between work and these non-productive activities.
However, the Baining seem to represent the opposite end, doing nothing but productive work, and yet they aren't exactly the unusually advanced Atlanteans of PNG either.
So I was struck by this "and exhibited little curiosity or enthusiasm" and it kind of hits me how important imagination and enthusiasm are in the process of advancing things. Toil gets stuff done, but you're just running in place. Imagination is a kind of play, and it's necessary to move you forward as well.