Re:Californians OK with Google self-driving cars and ban non...
by ChuckMcM on Sunday May 31, 2015 @02:29PM
(#9635016)
Yet another reason to replace stop light controlled intersections with roundabouts. The roundabout is designed for cooperating drivers, stoplights just implement a worst case algorithm.
Re:Californians OK with Google self-driving cars and ban non...
by TTPrograms on Sunday May 31, 2015 @02:40PM
(#9635059)
Roundabouts with unbalanced peak flow traffic can be impossible to enter if a previous entrance has a near-constant peak traffic flow. At rush hour they basically break under this condition. You could mildly gate them with lights to fix that, though.
Re:Californians OK with Google self-driving cars and ban non...
by nitrogen on Sunday May 31, 2015 @02:48PM
(#9635098)
If I am entering a roundabout from a dominant direction I try to leave enough of a gap for an attentive driver on the other entrances to get in. It seems fair, since sometimes I'm that driver who is waiting.
Re:Californians OK with Google self-driving cars and ban non...
by toomuchtodo on Sunday May 31, 2015 @02:41PM
(#9635062)
Roundabouts are for humans. You can have a four way intersection without traffic control if all vehicles are fully automated; they each know when they can proceed and when to yield, with no need to wait on other vehicles except when a conflict occurs.
About thirty percent of traffic in SF is due to people cruising around the block, looking for parking. [1]. Imagine if you could just tell your car, "go park somewhere, I don't care where", and have it come back when you need it. Heck, someone else could use it to get from A to B instead of letting it idle parked.
There's a lot of potential awesome here, but it all springs from rock-solid cooperation routines. If people manage to write aggressive / betraying self-driving algorithms, a lot of those traffic light scenarios could easily get a lot worse. Trust issues are a thing: should the car's driving routines be black-boxed? If there were FOSS car brains, would we trust people to not mod their cars to do illegal stuff? I guess traditional traffic cops could handle a lot of the same things they do now, we'd just need the standard autodrive package to account for and expect other cars to be driven in poor, uncooperative fashions.
[1]: http://shoup.bol.ucla.edu/CruisingForParkingAccess.pdf