For instance, if you can't wrap your head around why a language may be missing 'basic' elements, you would never really master that language.
IMO, basic proficiency is simply the ability to communicate unaided with effort on both parties. Which really only takes the language skills of ~5-7 year old native child.
This is very true and this is what bothers me when reading about these supposed polyglots/hyperglots. As a Portuguese speaker, I get Spanish "for free" as in I'm able to read Spanish, follow a Mexican soap opera on TV, and stumble through an order at a Mexican restaurant. Does that mean I can add Spanish to the list of languages that I speak?
> IMO, basic proficiency is simply the ability to communicate unaided with effort on both parties. Which really only takes the language skills of ~5-7 year old native child.
A 5-7 year old child with normal language development will be fluent, as in mastery of the grammar. There's no comparison between an adult who can get by in a language and a native speaker. For example, a child who is a native speaker of a language with grammatical gender will never mess up gender agreement whereas an adult learner might struggle mightily with that.
As a side note I was reading in a book[1] the rather extreme view that the "corrupt" Japanese or Korean readings of characters maybe seen as a dialect of Chinese.
[1] Élémens de la grammaire chinoise. Abel Rémusat (1822) https://play.google.com/books/reader?printsec=frontcover&out...
I acknowledged, in the post you're replying to, the large body of borrowed vocabulary, but that's not how languages are classified/made into families. Chinese and Japanese do not have a common ancestor and have very, very different grammar and phonetics.
It's not the language that helps, but having the experience of learning it.
I would disagree that learning one language helps you with another unless they are from some kind of language continuum - languages are so vastly different (especially depending on geographic distance) when you try to really master them, often full of idiomatic expressions and expressions you can't understand unless you grow in the historical context the language developed, and accurate translations are basically impossible. Some even use completely different causal logic (like Aymara), or miss elements considered basic in other languages (directions absent in Hawaiian) etc.
Learning languages is driven by curiosity, was handy a bit while traveling around the world and it helps to be near some language school, attend parties with people from all around the world and just have fun trying to chat together natively ;-)