- family & close friends
- acquaintances & loose friends
- school alum
- social groups / clubs
- those who you might work with/for
- linked in, you failed this audience
- interests beyond clubs, outside acquantances
No social network does a good job at allowing a person to share with those groups as desired. What I share on twitter is far more techie than what my friends/family on FB care about (mental note, disconnect twitter from fb). What I follow on twitter doesn't line up with what I post (I also see way to much to actually track twitter or fb, I pop in every few days, and only see the top of the feed). most of the people on FB are more acquaintances or past friends from social groups, and some family.The reality is that what will probably "win" will be a few discrete social networks... one for your career (probably not linkedin), a new one for your family and close friends, facebook for your loose friends and acquantences... and something closer to bulletin boards and/or webchat for social interest groups (probably not meetup).
I don't think the one site to rule them all will survive in the long run. And those groups trying to do so with facebook, twitter and pinterest are failing... those trying to build business models that aren't bought are failing.
Doesn't g+ solve this with the whole "circles" idea? You control which groups you share with.
G+ was a really nice imo way to work through it... too bad nobody used it in practice. I also hope that they work through a few of the issues I have with hangouts, mostly in taking over Google Voice duties, and the limited UX on the desktop (searches from contacts for SMS don't show up before random strangers in G+).
But in the end, the only thing that matters on a closed communications platform is where the people are. Most people won't bother switching platforms and in order for any competitor (G+ or otherwise) to take off is for everyone voluntarily migrate over.
Maybe I'm too cynical, but I'm willing to bet that would have changed if they reached the level of engagement that Facebook did.
I actually think the fact that you have to specifically put people into circles when you follow them makes it pretty straightforward. It only takes a moment, I like the inline dropdown interface to check the circles you want to add them to, and while it does take a few minutes to wrap your head around the first time you use it (probably not a non-tech-Grandma-ready interface), once you get it, it's easy and works well (IMHO).
It was just bad. With something like Facebook rises up from being unknown, its UI was pretty much vouched for early on (otherwise someone else would have won out). Google didn't have to survive competition. They just picked a UI, and I'm sure they followed lots of good UI principles and had lots of experts, but it was completely unappealing.
They also forced everything to integrate with G+ in really useless ways, which made me dislike it before even trying it. It didn't have any material problem in my life that it solved that would have made me put up with the UI. FB did: it was required for mainstream society, and it let me message my friends and others easily on the computer.
If "Google+" was first an initiative to create a universal single sign-on across all their own product lines (OAuth/OpenID), to better unify "profiles" which they did some of but didn't push it... and allowed the individual communities to continue to grow on their own (YouTube, their Blog thing, etc)... actually kept reader and extended with their own comment system etc.
By going that route, they could have made your "Google+ Profile" the center of your presence/contacts for the different social hubs. In the end, this is what happened anyway, at the cost of cannibalizing a few products, and alienating others, instead of doing the profile first, then offering "follows" across the sub-communities in a single interface later.
I think google's engineers are/were skilled enough to go this route, which would have been less "pure" architecturally, but more organic and better received.
I'm sorry, I don't really understand what you mean here. If they don't want to 'follow' you, why would you expect to send them things?
> I can really just group the input feed, not the output feed
You can choose which circle(s) you wish to share with, is that not controlling your output feed?
People can filter their input (who they have in their circles) and their output (which circles they share each piece of content with).
I suppose you can't follow a chosen subset of a single users output, unless you can do something fancy with tagging.
Don't you get recruiter spam through Linked In? What about the more general advertising and marketing industry? They survive off such a model.
> Don't you get recruiter spam through Linked In?
Yes, the rate of which makes LinkedIn just an inbox for job offers for me, not a social network.
Not so good as a subject matter filter though. I can create a list of only tech people on FB, but if a tech friend wants to post about his puppy to everyone, not so much I can do about that.
The fact that people want to use Instagram, Vine, Snapchat and Whatsapp is proof many people don't want a single service for everything. It's just unfortunate that Facebook happens to have acquired many of those.
Thinking of it, it's interesting how long ago Facebook last changed functionality-wise.
I don't like them that much, but I do think Facebook does a decent job of predicting trends. That's also why I think we'll have Facebook around for a long time. In a few years, people may not even think of that they're using Facebook services since they've further specialized and added various apps, all under the Facebook umbrella but only on the back end.
I think Facebook is even on their way of breaking out the friend contacts part from their main site, with Messenger.com now an own website, and other Messenger platform changes like games.
I think that where Facebook wants to go is to no longer require any user to actually use Facebook to stay in touch (we now have Messenger, Groups, Snapchat, Instagram), so that Facebook only becomes a place that pulls them all together (except for sensitive users like youth who don't want Snapchat to get involved with parents). For those who fancy that.
That's a common tipping point that lead to unfavorable side effects.
To be a bit dramatic, I get frustrated whenever:
- I have to choose between identity platforms to sign up for a site. I wouldn't be sad if there was an option (e) that was open source, transparent, not planning to monetize me, and easy to integrate with lots of various apps and services.
- I have to come up with credentials to a new website
- I have to remember what apps and services I've signed up for
- I have to save data on two different distributed file systems that don't interop.
- I have to connect with the same person on two different platforms. Or, I have to decide how much of my life I want a person to be able to see on two different platforms.
- I have to figure out if I'm okay with the privacy and security of various platforms on which I have an identity.
- I have to fill out a form with data I've already given to a service on the web.
- I discover that a friend uses a service I also use and I just wasn't aware of it.
- I have to choose between text, email, snapchat, FB message, gchat, Skype, Whatsapp, Twitter, LinkedIn, or Instagram based on what (I've memorized) a particular friend or colleague uses.
I don't mind the different services doing different things. Users do want to use Instagram for Instagram things and SnapChat for SnapChat things. I just don't like the part where they're all mostly standalone but solving the same problems over and over and forcing me to jump through the same hoops over and over for no benefit. But I don't trust any existing system to aggregate these responsibilities either. I barely and reluctantly trust Google/FB/Twitter enough to use them for identity services across multiple sites, just because the alternative is so painful that I have to.
Is there a service that does everything? I don't see how you connect your proof to what people actually want. It seems more likely that people will just use what is immediately available to them.
> In other words - the Internet.
Can you explain a bit more, because it sounds really strange.I think that those other interest groups will probably come to break off into custom sub-sites with their own message boards and chat.
I think clubs are well suited to discovery by FB, meetup and the like, but a bit too restricted in practice.
The corporate attempts to gather "likes" is B.S. mostly.
What you want potential coworkers to see isn't the same as friends/family...
In the end it's all muddled currently, and I think things may break apart a bit in the near future.
So your enriched version of address book does exist, but only in China, and it is one of the few things I miss so much when living outside China.
Though, I guess, as a tech person, I have the additional preference that whatever I use be fairly open (open-source somehow if possible) and not liable to doing things like selling user data or onboarding corporate partnerships in an attempt to monetize. Even though I know how silly it is to ask for an amazing product for free with no mechanism for generating revenue and a promise not to try to come up with one. Actually, I think I would pay for such a thing.
Actually, I know of Diaspora and Ello having tried this in some capacity, but neither caught on for various reasons.
I'll switch when there's a dominating replacement. All I want, for the rest of my life, is:
- a way to see updates from friends and acquaintances and people I've fallen out of contact with, and post mine for them.
- a way to search for and 'add' people I meet.
- a way to chat with those people (including in groups)
- all of those things, without social baggage that constrains it to 'only teenagers' or 'only colleagues and classmates' etc.
- and in a network that contains most people I meet, or doesn't have social baggage that prevents most people from being willing to join it.
To me it's an enriched version of what I get by having lots of contacts in my phone or email address book: exactly a list of people, plus the additional fact that I feel physically near them in some sense (and I think this is a concrete emotional thing. My family and friends don't feel too far away when I get to see snippets of their life streamed into mine).
Everything else - groups, events, pokes, company pages, apps, games, friend suggestions, wall posts, public about-me sections, places, reviews, ads, etc... I don't care about any of it. Maybe something that trims off all this fat would be innocuous enough to actually find adoption. I could see it living in some peer-to-peer structure too, but it has to still be absolutely trivial for anyone to join.