News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by Maarten88 on Monday May 25, 2015 @06:18AM (#9599382)
To me this whole TTIP feels like the US trying to bundle and export their most profitable corporate lobbying results through the corrupt and payed-for US politicians to the EU. Secret negotiations, state-investor dispute, all of this seems organized to help big corporations screw consumers further.

I simply hope the whole thing fails, I really don't see the benefit to me.

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by mercurial on Monday May 25, 2015 @06:26AM (#9599400)
I'm sure the EU corporations are doing their share of lobbying, but I agree that all these trade agreements seem to be tailored for Big Business at the expense of consumers.
Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by pizza234 on Monday May 25, 2015 @06:42AM (#9599448)
This is a completely different level than lobbying, this is effectively corporative control.

You enforce labeling of "inconvenient" ingredients on food? That hurts Mamacorp, you're going to be sued. You ban pesticides? Mamacorp is going to sue you. You prevent smoking? Mamacorp is going to sue you. You block eternal copyright? Well, you got the rap.

The thing I find terrifying is that virtually any form of social progress can be interpreted as damage to some company's profit.

TTIP is corporatocracy at its finest.

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by Radle on Monday May 25, 2015 @08:46AM (#9599824)
To be honest, as an EU citizen. I am really afraid of it.
Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by mercurial on Monday May 25, 2015 @08:58AM (#9599864)
The end result would be corporate control, but the existence of the draft agreement is a result of lobbying. That said, I agree with you that it is an extremely scary prospect.
Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by rorykoehler on Monday May 25, 2015 @09:36AM (#9599975)
We're not consumers we're people. Please stop calling people consumers as if the only value we bring is the consumption of mass produced goods.
Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by calibraxis on Monday May 25, 2015 @10:23AM (#9600119)
Plus, we're producers too. Corporations try to make us feel grateful to be allowed to be producers, lest we stay depressed at home as unemployed. Not to mention defining out of existence all the uncompensated labor people do...

(And of course, they have their thumb on the macroeconomic scales which result in this curious phenomenon of "unemployment". Pretty sick, irrational societies.)

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by speeder on Monday May 25, 2015 @10:20AM (#9600104)
In the current monetary system that is unfortunately true.

Note that I am not blaming "capitalism" but the current monetary system (that is based on debt). Consumption is necessary for most countries in the world right now to keep them going, as soon consumption stops, the countries fail.

(also you can get into stagflations, that are terrible: ever-increasing prices, including food and rent, while income an jobs are declining, this is happening right now in Brazil... 5 days ago I went to buy cheese, and it is 3 times the price of 5 years ago! And I am unemployed, as is all people that went to college with me 5 years ago!)

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by Brakenshire on Monday May 25, 2015 @06:45AM (#9599454)
Yes, there's no need to make the US the bad guy.

The key point is the way in which a treaty like this puts a whole class of what would once have been domestic legislation beyond the reach of democratic decision-making. Both in the treaties themselves, and their transnational private courts.

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by Elrac on Monday May 25, 2015 @09:01AM (#9599873)
But the US _is_ the bad guy!

Largely through ignorance, incompetence and inaction, the US has allowed its elected government to be bought (at embarrassingly low prices, I might add) by corporate interests and persuaded/bribed to work for the interests of corporations and against the interests of its own citizens.

At the point where this thoroughly corrupt government and its awesome military and economic clout are used to push the interests of corporations on other countries and their citizens, the US is clearly stepping into "bad guy" territory. Be clear about this: the US is using its economic clout (and threats of using it) to coerce other countries to bulldoze the legal provisions that help safeguard their citizens. How much higher than this would you set the bar for "bad guy" behavior??

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by _yosefk on Monday May 25, 2015 @07:01AM (#9599495)
Can't a democratic decision be made to get out of the treaty? Also - international obligations in general, by their nature, restrict democratic or any other kind of sovereign decision-making. Decisions such as waging war, defaulting on debt, etc. which are often made by sovereigns illustrate that restrictions on sovereigns aren't necessarily bad.

(Not saying that TTIP is a good thing, just that I'm a bit baffled by the framing of the problems with it as a conflict between democracy and corporations or such. I'm even more baffled by the framing of defaulting on sovereign debt as a "democratic right" - again, regardless of the fact that a country's citizens might have gotten a raw deal because a corrupt government issued debt it shouldn't have, say, because it was bribed and needed liquidity to buy something useless/overpriced from whoever bribed it, etc.)

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by Brakenshire on Monday May 25, 2015 @07:23AM (#9599546)
That is an extremely limited form of democracy, to only be able to decide on a huge swathe of legislation with just a yes or a no. And on top of that, when something like this is tied in with the trade deals, it would be impossible to reverse it because of the potential for an economic shock and destabilization of the financial system.

If a government came in that wanted to shift the balance - for instance on this issue, of human health, quality of life, and the environment on the one hand, and agricultural productivity on the other - previously they would be able to change the law. Under TTIP, they have to renege on the trade deals covering, what, a third of the economy. That is to all practical purposes impossible. You might as well have written the law into the constitution.

That doesn't mean I'm against all international treaties, but usually those cover issues which are inherently international. TTIP represents the movement of large swathes of what would once have been domestic legislation into international treaties, and the mechanisms which would have been appropriate for, say, an international convention on cross-border child abduction, are not appropriate for deciding whether or not a country is allowed to ban activities which are dangerous to the health of its citizens, within its own borders.

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by pjc50 on Monday May 25, 2015 @07:28AM (#9599567)
The lack of a sensible bankruptcy procedure for countries is a serious problem. Individuals can discharge debts in bankruptcy in order to get back on their feet. Companies have at least two different kinds of bankruptcy depending on whether they can be run as a going concern or not. But a FX-denominated debt is potentially an anchor on your country forever. Look at the Argentine "pari passu" fiasco for example.

Imposing an unpayable debt on a country that forces poverty on its citizens has a real and serious cost in human life. Wars have been fought over this; it's often argued that the reparations debt imposed on Germany after WW1 was a contributing factor to WW2.

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by _yosefk on Monday May 25, 2015 @07:57AM (#9599667)
I'm not saying I know what to do about unpayable sovereign debt, just that defaulting on such debt is not a sensible example of a democratic right. "We had a referendum and decided that you can all wipe your asses with our bonds" is probably not the "sensible bankruptcy procedure" that you mention. I did not claim anything beyond that.

Why do I think my point was worth making? Because there's a huge amount of issues boiling down to poor coordination between different states today, the nature of today's economy ensures this will become increasingly common, and I think it's worth pointing out that simply insisting on "democratic rights" interpreted as "doing whatever the citizens want, the rest of the world be damned" doesn't really cut it. And this "interference with democracy" theme is really really common these days, I bump into this sort of phrasing every other week.

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by marincounty on Monday May 25, 2015 @08:29AM (#9599773)
I agree countries should have some sort of bankruptcy protection. I thought the UN could could invoke the protections of bankruptcy in certain instances?

As to individuals in the U.S. we have two, or three types of bankruptcy protection, and that goes for individuals--not just companies.

I do think we need to keep a close eye on Bankruptcy laws in the United States. I have a feeling if a Rebublican is elected in 2016, federal statutes on bankruptcy laws will be changed, like under the George Bush's rein.

The problems we have with our current bankruptcy statues, right now, is this: The homeowners exemption is too low in most states.(Your primary residence should be exempt from creditors in bankruptcy court--period, especially for unsecured debt! Student loans should be partially dismissable. (I would rather have the government just deny certain collages access to the student loan program, but they aren't moving fast enough.) Those are my biggest gripes with U.S. Bankruptcy laws. If you don't have the money, have nerves of steel, and the ability to internalize Nolo Press's publications on bankruptcy; you can do your own bankruptcy.

Keep in mind you can only do most bankruptcies every 10 years, so use them wisely. I need to do a chapter 7, but am holding off until I start making real money, or a republican is elected in 2016.

(As to credit collectors, keep track of every unauthorized call(keep a diary, or tape the conversations); if you are lucky the weasels will break federal laws, and you might be able to sue? I'm my case, different collection agencies must have called my residence over at least over a 1000 times over the years. I really despise the collection game, along with process servers. These judgements are sold, on most cases for pennies on the dollar. I have thought about buying my own judgement debt. If anyone in the Debt Collection industry reads this--have you heard of anyone successfully buying their own debt? I have found no laws prohibiting it.)

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by inDigiNeous on Monday May 25, 2015 @10:59AM (#9600281)
Why not? What other country goes around bombing civilians and pushing war on every front just in order to get resources in the name of 'democracy'.

The whole US law and political process is very corrupt from the view of an european citizen.

To tell the truth, I really hate the way US acts as if they're not the bad guys. US is the bad guys. I really hope somebody would do something about this, and ultimately this lies in the hands of US citizens to make a change.

I am also very concerned about this TTIP -agreement. They are already doing things in Finland in order to sell our water to companies like Coca Cola and Pepsi (sugar-caffeine drug peddlers). This really makes me mad that with money politicians can be bought, and laws can be reformed to fit those of big huge companies who only think about making a profit in the name of destroying our nature, people, animals and other living forms.

Actually, what I wanna say is: F*CK USA. The whole system is based around killing others and taking their resources. Native Americans know this very well, and US citizens don't seem to even realize that they live there only because the previous inhabitants were killed or driven away from their lands with agreements that were false to begin with.

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by themartorana on Monday May 25, 2015 @08:57AM (#9599863)
I imagine that might be found unconstitutional? I haven't heard anyone speak (intelligently) about whether this sort of business > government in terms of the Constitution. Is it true that democratic power can be signed away in an international treaty?
Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by arca_vorago on Monday May 25, 2015 @09:18AM (#9599916)
My understanding of the Constitution on this matter is that all international treaties and agreements must be considered very high law, but may not invalide or contradict any part of the constitution themselves lest the particular section or whole agreement be considered void and nonbinding. That was my ametuer reading of the section on that.

Also, regarding TTIP and TTP, I think we have to admit NAFTA was in the same vein but we allowed it to pass. The problem here though is we are putting what thin thread of sinewy national sovereignty we have up for grabs. Nader in the 92 debates was right (which is also consequently why the two parties jointly bought out the debate organization to keep other Naders out of the pucture.)

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by arca_vorago on Monday May 25, 2015 @11:24AM (#9600383)
*Perot not Nader though Nader did help write his speeches.
Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by contravariant on Monday May 25, 2015 @09:25AM (#9599942)
Is there even a sharp divide between EU and US corporations anymore? I get the impression that the really large ones operate in both, and those tend to be the ones that will profit most from such an agreement.
Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by deepnet on Monday May 25, 2015 @07:29AM (#9599577)
That is literally the definition of a fascict dictatorship.

This is what Adam Smith warned us against.

I think you have hit the nail on the head.

Governments around the world have capitulated to this.

This seems like the financial wing of the whole spyocracy.

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by joelthelion on Monday May 25, 2015 @08:49AM (#9599837)
> That is literally the definition of a fascict dictatorship.

No, it's not.

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by deepnet on Monday May 25, 2015 @05:56PM (#9601897)
Secret Corporate Control Of Many Government that achieves its aims via secret threats and manipulation ?

Seems textbook fascism

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by deepnet on Monday May 25, 2015 @11:57AM (#9600499)
How not ?
Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by nhebb on Monday May 25, 2015 @10:03AM (#9600046)
You should read George Orwell's piece "What is Fascism?" [1]. It's a short essay worth the read before you're tempted to point the finger and call someone or something fascist.

[1] http://orwell.ru/library/articles/As_I_Please/english/efasc

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by calibraxis on Monday May 25, 2015 @10:18AM (#9600097)
I think we all have experience of fascism. It's not a magic thing; currently it's (unfortunately) a very common mode of human organization.

"Capitalism is a system in which the central institutions of society are in principle under autocratic control. Thus, a corporation or an industry is, if we were to think of it in political terms, fascist; that is, it has tight control at the top and strict obedience has to be established at every level -- there's little bargaining, a little give and take, but the line of authority is perfectly straightforward." — http://www.spunk.org/texts/quotes/sp000096.txt

(I am not trying to make a pedantic point about who is/isn't acting fascist. Just wanting to say we've very much internalized ideologies which we use as epithets.)

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by cbd1984 on Wednesday May 27, 2015 @10:42AM (#9611678)
> I think we all have experience of fascism.

Saying this is spitting in the fact of everyone who actually survived a fascist regime.

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by mplscoder on Monday May 25, 2015 @10:25AM (#9600126)
Pop quiz: who says the text of the TPP must remain secret? Under what authority? Members of Congress are scuttling around like weasels, claiming they can’t disclose what’s in this far-reaching, 12-nation trade treaty. They can go into a sealed room and read a draft, but they can’t copy pages, and they can’t tell the public what they just read. Why not? If there is a US law forbidding disclosure, name the law. Can you recall anything in the Constitution that establishes secret treaties? Is there a prior treaty that states the text of all treaties can be hidden from the people? I see no authority anywhere that justifies withholding the text of the TPP. --WORLD AFFAIRS BRIEF
Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by nraynaud on Monday May 25, 2015 @06:28AM (#9599409)
Actually, treaties are always negotiated in secret. The only openly negotiated one (the EU constitution) was massively rejected afterwards.
Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by Elrac on Monday May 25, 2015 @09:05AM (#9599880)
Treaties are always negotiated in secret? I'd expect at least the decision makers to be in the information loop. I'm not sure that's really the case. Isn't it unusual that (as I've been hearing) even the Congressfolk who are expected to vote on this contract are unable to obtain preliminary copies of the in-progress document other than through WikiLeaks?
Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by jgreen10 on Monday May 25, 2015 @07:08AM (#9599512)
and then quietly renamed Treaty of Lisbon and ratified.
Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by ginko on Monday May 25, 2015 @07:28AM (#9599570)
The EU constitution would have been an entirely different thing. It would have made the EU a lot more democratic, adding a directly elected president, for instance.
Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by Brakenshire on Monday May 25, 2015 @07:33AM (#9599590)
The EU now has a directly elected President in all but name, through the Spitzenkandidaten system. Legally, its supposed to be a joint decision of the Council and the Parliament, but when Cameron tried to object to Juncker, it seemed to be pretty clear that the new expectation is that the Council rubber-stamps Parliament's decision, and Parliament will support the party receiving the largest number of votes.
Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by yxhuvud on Monday May 25, 2015 @08:06AM (#9599695)
All but name? How the heck is some guy that I never got an option to vote for in any way whatsoever directly elected?

You might as well claim that the Council is directly elected, and not the total lack of accountability to citizens that it actually is.

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by munchhausen on Monday May 25, 2015 @11:42AM (#9600441)
A president elected by the parliament used to be a pretty common thing in many European countries. It's simply a different model. Keep in mind that in virtually all European countries, the office of the president is not particularly powerful. The government/parliament combo is where the power is - the president is in many countries little more than a guy/gal opening new motorways and representing the country at international summits (but foreign policy is crafted by the Secretary of Foreign Affairs equivalent).

The "election by parliament" model has been/is now being phased out in favor of direct presidential elections in many countries, but let's not pretend like we're dealing with something particularly unusual here.

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by ginko on Monday May 25, 2015 @08:14AM (#9599724)
You indirectly voted in the EP election.

Well, I hope you did. Otherwise you don't have any right to complain.

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by wsc981 on Monday May 25, 2015 @08:56AM (#9599853)
George Carlin had another perspective: "If you vote, you have no right to complain":

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xIraCchPDhk&feature=youtu.be...

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by alextgordon on Monday May 25, 2015 @10:56AM (#9600270)
I voted Green, then I found they want to shut down ITER. Bastards! Should have stayed home.
Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by abloodywar on Monday May 25, 2015 @08:32AM (#9599781)
How can you even say that you forfeit your rights to complain if someone supposedly didn't vote?

What if every choice is a bad choice? Would you be required to support something you don't approve of - simply to be allowed to voice your opinion?

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by saint_fiasco on Monday May 25, 2015 @11:09AM (#9600328)
You can go vote and write in 'Lady Gaga' or something. The important part is that you getup and go "vote", to signal that you care.

Otherwise, politicians won't be able to tell whether you are dissatisfied or just uninterested. If you are explicitly dissatisfied, they might try to do something to get your vote. Hopefully by enacting good policy.

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by yxhuvud on Monday May 25, 2015 @11:40AM (#9600430)
An indirect vote is not "the same thing except in name" as a direct vote.
Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by tomelders on Monday May 25, 2015 @11:01AM (#9600288)
I'm not an expert on these issues, but I haved heard mention of the Singapore treaty and that it already provides investment protection. Can anyone explain why these protections are deemed no longer suitable?
Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by atmosx on Monday May 25, 2015 @07:43AM (#9599615)
If the EU exists with it's current form in 5 years, we can re-discuss the TTIP, but generally speaking I think it will not matter what the 'EU' agreement was, if the EU gets dissolved ... and from where it appears like if they're trying really hard to dissolve it (even if the state otherwise).
Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by akhatri_aus on Monday May 25, 2015 @10:25AM (#9600127)
I'm not as cynical, but they did say this 5 years ago too. There are many people happy with it contrary to what is usually on the daily news spread.
Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by atmosx on Monday May 25, 2015 @10:37AM (#9600183)
It's just that I see a strong anti-EU trend developing throughout Europe, at least that's the feeling that I'm getting. Time will tell, I guess.

The thing is political integration is going back instead of forward and the financial crisis turned the whole project obsolete IMHO.

Re:EU dropped plans for safer pesticides because of TTIP and... by akhatri_aus on Monday May 25, 2015 @10:40AM (#9600194)
There's both there's an anti EU trend but don't mistake this to think there is no-one for it. There are lots of good things they've done. The whole 'euro' currency thing that gets the attention is just a small part of the system.