The most recent ruling said that APIs, by themselves, are copyrightable[0].
The case is back to the district court now to determine whether the wholesale copying and reimplementation an API falls under the fair-use defense.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oracle_America,_Inc._v._Google...
What courts is this precedent for?
Generally, the way precedent works is that if appeals from court X go to court Y, then the decisions of court Y are precedent for court X. If court Z is not on the appeals path from X, then the decisions of court Z are not binding precedent for X.
For copyright cases, appeals normally do NOT go to the CAFC. They go the Courts of Appeal for the circuit in which the court appealed from resides. E.g., copyright cases from district courts in the 2nd Circuit go to the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals.
In general, that is the appeals path from the Federal district court. Copyright cases aren't specifically singled out.
Oracle vs. Google was tried in the 9th Circuit. If it has just been a copyright case, the appeal would have went to the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals. However, it was also a patent case, and patent cases are singled out. They are explicitly diverted from the normal appeals path and go to the CAFC. If the case is also some other kind of case, such as a copyright case or an antitrust case, the CAFC is allowed to hear those aspects too.
So does this mean that if P sues D in the 9th circuit over copyright, with no patent issues or any other issues that would bring the appeal to the CAFC, then the district court would only use the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals for precedent (which I believe disagrees with CAFC), and ignore CAFC's Google vs. Oracle copyright ruling?
Even more confusing, suppose P sues D over copyright and patents in the 9th Circuit. The district court figures that the case, if appealed, will go to the CAFC, and so follows CAFC precedent for the copyright aspects. Now suppose after the court rules, neither party appeals the court's decisions on any of the patent issues. The only appeal copyright issues. Does the case still go to CAFC? Or does it go the 9th Circuit? If it goes to the 9th Circuit, do they apply their own copyright precedent or CAFC precedent?
But that predates my existence :-)
WINE is a clone of the Windows API. ReactOS is another one.
Also, we should include implementations of software that encodes or decodes data formats, such as audio/video/image codecs. There are numerous examples of free implementations of software that works with proprietary formats, which are analogous to a proprietary API.
Like most non-flagrant potential IP violations, no one can really say for sure until a court hears the case and makes a judgement as to whether the use is fair or unfair, or likely to cause confusion among consumers or not.
IANAL.
Mac OS X looks for a set of firmware variables containing a non-formatted version of following haiku (reproduced for the purpose of artistic comment):
our hard work
by these words guarded
please dont steal
© Apple Computer Inc
If you shipped a transparently Mac-compatible x86 machine, you'd have to include this haiku (in some form) in the firmware.I wonder how far back in OS(X) it dates?
Internally, Mac OS X ran on commodity PCs for quite some time before that and didn't include DSMOS.
In this particular case, I believe what you would have produced would be classified as a "circumvention" device under the DMCA (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-circumvention).
The state of "IP" law makes me very sad.
Any license agreement you or your company have with Slack might "ban" you from doing this; you might e.g. lose your access. That will be a contractual matter between you and them though, not anything criminal.
IANAL; you should probably get actual legal advice.