Re:Ask HN: I wrote a Slack compatible server. Can I open sou...
by glesica on Friday May 22, 2015 @01:37PM
(#9589802)
AFAIK trademarks don't work that way. You can "use" a trademark in a text or computer program more or less freely. What you can't do is do business under the trademarked name, or offer a competing (or substantially similar) product for sale that uses the trademarked name. Trademarks aren't so much about "IP protection" as they are about preventing consumer confusion, thus the standards are different. IANAL.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Ask HN: I wrote a Slack compatible server. Can I open sou...
by dragonwriter on Friday May 22, 2015 @01:43PM
(#9589834)
Trademarks are about IP protection, but the exclusive right in the mark -- the thing that is property -- is the right to use the mark to market products in a particular domain.
Re:Ask HN: I wrote a Slack compatible server. Can I open sou...
by cmdrfred on Friday May 22, 2015 @01:42PM
(#9589828)
Makes sense, then maybe this would prevent him from listing slack anywhere on the repository as it might confuse users that this is a legitimate client.
Re:Ask HN: I wrote a Slack compatible server. Can I open sou...
by cookiecaper on Friday May 22, 2015 @05:36PM
(#9590996)
It's a matter of degree. CentOS infamously chose to refer to Red Hat as "a prominent North American Linux vendor" and completely deleted the term "Red Hat" from everything out of an abundance of caution after receiving threats from Red Hat's lawyers, but that's probably overboard. It's generally allowed to use trademarks as "nominative uses", i.e., in direct reference to another's product that's not designed to create confusion. He would probably be fine to put in his README something like "An open implementation of the chat API provided by Slack". He definitely shouldn't use the term "Slack" in the name of the repo.
Like most non-flagrant potential IP violations, no one can really say for sure until a court hears the case and makes a judgement as to whether the use is fair or unfair, or likely to cause confusion among consumers or not.
IANAL.