News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by ulf on Monday November 23, 2009 @09:27AM (#957385)
While he basically raises some valid points, he ignores two critical ones:

1) With the appstore being the one authority to get apps on your iPhone, you will automatically get much less traction using the web

2) The appstore makes it VERY easy for the devs to actually get paid. If you launch your app web-only, you have to incorporate the whole payment process yourself, which sucks.

Catch 22...

Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by SamAtt on Monday November 23, 2009 @10:12AM (#957445)
You left out one important point that he mentions but doesn't give enough credit to...

3) There's still a lot of features on the iPhone that you can only access through native apps.

He claims most of the apps he has could be web apps. But I just opened my iPhone to the Top 25 paid apps and 7 out of the top 10 could only exist as native apps (and the other three are debatable but in theory you could write them in Javascript)

Here's the list...

Voices: Requires access to the mic

JellyCar: Requires native app for soundtrack (which is actually a big deal in the game)

RedLaser: Requires access to the camera

Call of Duty: Graphics require a native app

All in One Gamebox: Graphics require a native app

Alarm Clock Pro: Has to be able to play music library

Metal Gear: Graphics require a native app

Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by allenbrunson on Monday November 23, 2009 @04:24PM (#958180)
The fact that iPhone web apps can't access iPhone hardware comes up all the time here. It seems odd to me that nobody mentions the fact that, with not much work, it's possible to create an iPhone browser that can give a website access to most of the iPhone hardware through javascript: gps/location services, the camera, the photo library, the music library, the accelerometer, and so on. One enterprising developer wrote an iPhone browser that does just that. here it is: http://www.big5apps.com/

I can't really recommend that app, though. Most of it is open source, so you can go see for yourself that the code is terrible. The app is ugly, leaks abound, and so on. The guy really doesn't know objective-c. I became aware of it because I have a contracting client that wanted to use that app, discovered it was terrible, and paid me to write a better one.

I think this is an idea that is ripe for the picking, but I can't see how, really. I have most of such a browser written. Who can think of a way to monetize this?

Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by wallflower on Monday November 23, 2009 @09:06PM (#958561)
See also http://rhomobile.com/

Rhomobile has a Ruby-on-Rails inspired framework to run a scaled down Ruby 1.9 implementation that seems to act as an internal web server, allowing iPhone/Blackberry apps to be written in Ruby and HTML templates. The code you write seems to have access to native phone capabilities like GPS.

The main drawback of RhoMobile seems to be the lack of a polished feel, looking like the browser application it really is. (Wikimedia mobile uses RhoMobile for its iPhone app).

Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by gord on Tuesday November 24, 2009 @07:02AM (#959080)
The demos look good, although I think the 12.99 price is going to rule it out, because at least initially its too much to pay in order to use one app.

For such a critical component, youd really want something open source [and free as in beer also]... after all it needs to keep pace rapidly, be rock solid, trusted by all developers, etc.

[EDIT : correction.. Big5Lite is free, not sure what non Lite has. Big5 project is opensource it seems - http://code.google.com/p/big5/]

App developers who use it can compete while adding to this common component - it plays the role of the browser. It just happens to be a browser which gives you access to nice hardware features such as geo location, media library, contacts etc [policed by os].

Here lies the solution for some percentage of apps, between 90.0 and 99.95.

Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by mattmaroon on Monday November 23, 2009 @11:32AM (#957608)
All sufficiently popular platforms trend towards games. Graphics alone makes the app store a necessity.
Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by dgallagher on Monday November 23, 2009 @03:41PM (#958083)
When carrier bandwidth allows for it in ~5 or more years, streaming live content to cell phones might become an option (3D games over OnLive, etc). But it's likely going to be a while before carriers can support this, given the need for low latency and high-bandwidth for many games to provide a good end-user experience.

Streaming live video en-masses would likely exist* far before streaming games, given you can buffer video to compensate for latency. Games couldn't be easily buffered as they require instant feedback between button-presses and what's seen on the screen.

*Streaming video does indeed exist for cell phones, but not on a mass-scale, at least in the United States.

Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by dangrossman on Monday November 23, 2009 @07:37PM (#958469)
Unlimited live streaming television was one of the selling points of the Samsung Instinct from Sprint in the US.

Six months later they cut back the free channel lineup so there's nothing interesting to watch.

Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by gord on Tuesday November 24, 2009 @07:07AM (#959087)
Wouldn't the popularity and success of flash games be a counter argument?

Admittedly not for 3D intensive games. But maybe flash+browser will catch up with 3D. Only a year ago RaphealJS was magic.

Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by rodyancy on Monday November 23, 2009 @09:59AM (#957427)
And, the payment system you end up incorporating will not be as dead simple to use as iTunes.

As bad as Apple is at vetting and distributing software (when compared to the web they are bad a distributing software, at least in terms of speed), they are terrific, although expensive, payment processes.

The fact that every iPhone user necessarily has an iTunes account, and they are only one touch and a password away from paying you for your software, can't be overstated.

Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by JunkDNA on Monday November 23, 2009 @10:38AM (#957493)
Bingo. The big attraction is that developers can make a silly puzzle game that would have to be free on the web, but they can charge 99 cents for it in the app store. Plus, billing and credit card processing is just done for you. It makes me wonder if there is an opportunity for a startup to provide a web app store. Would be hard to pull off, and would likely really irritate Apple. But it might be possible.
Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by ubernostrum on Monday November 23, 2009 @11:38AM (#957620)
Counterpoint:

Apple releases a highly-portable computing platform (iPhone) and initially says "if you want to develop for it, all you have to do is write web applications". Developers rage against the irrational locking down of the system.

Google releases a highly-portable computing platform (Chrome OS) and initially says "if you want to develop for it, all you have to do is write web applications". Developers fawn over it and talk about the simplicity and openness of the system.

In other words: if writing a web app is sufficiently bad to not be worth the time on iPhone, why is it apparently generally held that it'll be sufficiently good to be worth the time on Chrome OS?

Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by blasdel on Monday November 23, 2009 @03:07PM (#958038)
1) ChromeOS has Google's NaCL baked in -- you can still build native x86 or ARM code to blit to a framebuffer, just with a browser as the window decoration.

2) Your webapp for ChromeOS does not need to be specialized -- you don't have to account for fat-fingered multitouch on a small fixed screen.

Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by edd on Monday November 23, 2009 @09:44AM (#957409)
Your first point is so valid. Having created a webapp for the iPhone myself there really are few places I can go to put my webapp on a stage that anyone cares about. If someone knows of any I honestly would love to know where they are.
Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by bumblebird on Monday November 23, 2009 @10:33AM (#957480)
This is the problem though. The app store is like "American Idol". Singers see American Idol etc as a quick route to fame. Then they're "famous" for 30 minutes, then not.

It's far better to build up a real sustainable following yourself based on real merits. The app store is full of gimicky one time apps people will use once to show their friends, then never use again :/

Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by patio11 on Monday November 23, 2009 @10:12AM (#957447)
Organic SEO. (Lots of work. Requires savvy. Not guaranteed. Stupendous ROI if you do it right.)
Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by jimboyoungblood on Monday November 23, 2009 @04:54PM (#958228)
Example(s)?
Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by patio11 on Monday November 23, 2009 @08:32PM (#958518)
I get about 60~70% of my new users from organic SEO. (I have not run that calculation in a while -- it may be higher now. It was certainly a lot higher in October.)

Almost every successful startup you've heard of which publishes lots of content has an SEO strategy. Slideshare, Scribd (good golly were they aggressive with it -- good thing they got big before they got smacked), Yelp, etc etc.

Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by jimboyoungblood on Monday November 23, 2009 @09:11PM (#958567)
That applies to standalone websites, not webapps-as-an-appstore-alternative, which is what (I thought) the discussion was about.

As a distribution outlet, nothing (yet) can compete with the app store.

Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by qeorge on Monday November 23, 2009 @06:22PM (#958364)
Its hard to give examples of successful SEO, because you don't want extra competition in your niche. As a result, all we (SEOs) can offer for free is general advice on how to do it yourself.

That said, I've been wanting to write a free guide to SEO aimed at HN-like companies, because I think its important. However, the response from HackerNews to anything involving SEO is so harsh, I've felt it would be a waste of my time. If that's not the case, please let me know.

Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by microkid on Monday November 23, 2009 @10:33AM (#957478)
Why not create an iPhone app, which is simply a WebKit view dedicated to your web app?

The client see's it as a "iPhone app" you can host/sell it in the store, but it's really just a web app.

(Maybe there's a restriction on this, but I can't see why there would be...)

Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by holdenk on Monday November 23, 2009 @01:29PM (#957841)
Its my understanding that Apple would like require an "explicit" rating, since you could change your web page to have pictures of an "inappropriate" nature.

So this doesn't solve the problem.

Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by st3fan on Monday November 23, 2009 @10:59AM (#957544)
Same restrictions apply: the web view has a limited set of functionality and there is no way to communicate between the native cocoa part of the app and the javascript part running in the web view.
Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by Ionic_Walrus on Monday November 23, 2009 @11:37AM (#957619)
simply untrue - its easy to communicate between javascript and native cocoa code. Take a look at the UIWebView and UIWebViewDelegate documentations here - http://developer.apple.com/iphone/library/documentation/UIKi... and here http://developer.apple.com/iphone/library/documentation/UIKi...
Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by lisper on Monday November 23, 2009 @12:45PM (#957756)
3) An appstore app will (or at least could) continue to work even when I don't have network connectivity. A Web app won't.
Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by PanMan on Monday November 23, 2009 @01:23PM (#957829)
That's just not true. In the latest iPhone OS you can have a webapp run offline...
Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by wvenable on Monday November 23, 2009 @01:57PM (#957895)
Any reasonably interesting web app is going to do it's "work" on the server. A web app can run it's UI in offline mode but you've scooped it out's brains.
Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by ynniv on Monday November 23, 2009 @02:29PM (#957945)
Either you meant "it's data", or you're doing it wrong. http://sproutcore.com http://googlecode.blogspot.com/2009/09/chris-anderson-couchd...
Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by wvenable on Tuesday November 24, 2009 @09:36PM (#960494)
Wow, you can store data and retrieve it. Why do we need web browsers at all -- Microsoft released Access decades ago!
Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by ynniv on Friday November 27, 2009 @04:26PM (#964391)
Impressively worthless comment. If MS Access apps were free to develop and worked on any platform in useful sandboxes, your sarcasm would be warranted. Instead you make yourself look like as idiot, suggesting that the Web is popular because people didn't know about Access.
Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by wvenable on Friday November 27, 2009 @05:28PM (#964455)
Whoosh That's the sound of my comment going over your head.

If you think the web is popular because it's a cross platform sandboxed version of Access (which is essentially what you were suggesting) then you're the idiot. There's only so many useful applications you can make by simply storing and retrieving very simple data locally.

Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by ynniv on Monday November 23, 2009 @01:28PM (#957838)
Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by lisper on Monday November 23, 2009 @07:49PM (#958482)
Well whaddyaknow. I wasn't aware of this. (I don't actually develop iPhone apps, I'm just a user.)
Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by buckwilson on Monday November 23, 2009 @01:17PM (#957816)
Yep. And I don't have to bear the time cost of the interface downloading and rendering. As a user and not a developer I will take a native app over a web app any day.

But giving this article any credence is giving it too much credit. It's shock-blogging and nothing more.

Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by mvaerle on Monday November 23, 2009 @10:09AM (#957441)
I don't know if this is already done. But the second point really begs for an entrepreneur to solve this. A simple model for payment for web apps, you could support one off sales, subscriptions models etc. Make an API for developers and handle all the credit-card processing stuff.
Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by tiffani on Monday November 23, 2009 @10:47AM (#957519)
See Spreedly, CheddarGetter, or Recurly. All good for subscription billing at least.

http://www.spreedly.com http://www.cheddargetter.com http://www.recurly.com

Re:PPK: "Apple is not evil. iPhone developers are stupid." by GrandMasterBirt on Monday November 23, 2009 @07:57PM (#958491)
Maybe its a rephrase but:

Currently the App Store is a benevolent dictator. I don't care how much lipstick they put on the pig, I want free speach. I don't care if that means 10% of apps will have a flag "may be spyware or inappropriate" but I want those apps distributed! EVEN if those apps help violate apple's own license terms. I want the courts to decide who takes shit down, not apple. Apple is a company whereas the courts are government.