News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by Vaskivo on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:09AM (#9550650)
I don't like it, but Reddit can do whatever it wants with it's platform. Reddit is not a "free speech platform", it is whatever it wants to be at any moment.

In Portugal we have a saying that translates to something like this: "Who is not well/happy, should move to another place". And that's whats going to happen. Some users will go to another platforms.

And, in the end, we'll always have the chans...

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by Karunamon on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:13AM (#9550676)
That is exactly what it is, by their own reckoning[1]:

    Create a safe space to encourage participation.
    Embrace diversity of viewpoints.
    Allow freedom of expression.
    Be stewards, not dictators. The community owns itself.
As long as they claim to be holding themselves to that standard, people are fully within their rights to call them out on hypocrisy.

[1]:https://www.reddit.com/about/values

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by jerf on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:21AM (#9550750)
I'd be curious about their exact definition of "safe space". That term on college campuses is rapidly evolving exactly into ensuring that a diversity of viewpoints is not even seen or heard, let alone embraced.

I mean this straight; I'd honestly be interested in hearing an elaboration from them, not as snark about how they can't possibly mean it or something. Again, no sarcasm or snark, high principles are hard.

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by jklinger410 on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:31AM (#9550819)
Safe space is just code for coddling the first person to claim offense.

A safe space for you, if we are at odds, is an unsafe space for me. The concept of a universal "safe space" is an impossibility in that regard.

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by untog on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:50AM (#9550983)
A safe space for you, if we are at odds, is an unsafe space for me.

Only if you are determined to be at odds. It's quite possible for an atheist and a die-hard Christian to get dinner together, if they both commit to focusing on the topics they share rather than the ones they disagree on.

Safe space is just code for coddling the first person to claim offense.

seems like a willful misrepresentation of the aims behind the concept.

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by jklinger410 on Friday May 15, 2015 @12:23PM (#9551626)
>Only if you are determined to be at odds. It's quite possible for an atheist and a die-hard Christian to get dinner together, if they both commit to focusing on the topics they share rather than the ones they disagree on.

That's not honest debate.

>seems like a willful misrepresentation of the aims behind the concept.

As a white male I am often told that I'm not allowed to participate in discussions because of my race and gender due to the discussion taking place in "safe space." No matter what the original aims are behind the concept, it is easily corruptible and almost never used in the "best case scenario." It's usually used to set up echo-chambers where individuals can feel safe from criticism or debate. It has no place in a healthy society, IMO.

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by untog on Friday May 15, 2015 @12:30PM (#9551687)
That's not honest debate.

Who says they have to have an honest debate? Why can't they just have a conversation with each other? That's the problem with battling attitudes - there isn't any reason why the two of them must come to blows about their opposing beliefs. They can simply respect each other and move beyond it.

As a white male I am often told that I'm not allowed to participate in discussions because of my race and gender due to the discussion taking place in "safe space."

Interesting, because as a white male myself I have never been told that. I have been told that my opinion in a conversation is not an important one, which is often (not always!) a valid point. But I have never been told I am cannot participate in a discussion solely because it is a "safe space". Where are you having these conversations?

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by Karunamon on Friday May 15, 2015 @12:35PM (#9551731)
Is there a meaningful and substantial difference between those two things? Both amount to "your input is not welcome here", both amount to classifying one's identity more important than the content of their speech, and the entire concept of a "safe space" is one in which mere disagreement is explicitly disallowed.
Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by untog on Friday May 15, 2015 @01:39PM (#9552223)
Absolutely there is a difference. If a group of women are talking about their experiences of sexism in the workplace they ought to be able to do without a man coming in and "actually"-ing them.
Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by Karunamon on Friday May 15, 2015 @01:53PM (#9552345)
This set of questions is going to sound a lot more flippant than the tone it's intended to be in, but I am curious as to the answers:

Why is that?

Why is someone's identity more important than the content of their speech in this particular case?

Is it impossible for anyone/a man to be against sexism and yet disagree with someone's characterization of an event?

Are all ideas sacred and above criticism now, or only some ideas?

Which ones?

Who gets to decide that?

Why them?

Why does the right of people to be free from criticism take priority over the right of people to have a discussion?

Why does mere disagreement necessarily need to be classed as a negative thing (as you just did?)

How can such an environment foster any kind of healthy discussion, as opposed to me-too echo-chambering?

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by AnimalMuppet on Friday May 15, 2015 @03:17PM (#9552980)
Attempt at an honest answer:

If a group has been marginalized, belittled, and excluded for long enough, it can damage the people in that group. They can need a safe place to heal, to realize that they matter, that they are as worthwhile as anyone else, and that they don't have to be what their oppressors said they were. A safe place can be very important in that process.

Or a safe place can be a place where a bunch that feels oppressed because somebody looked at them funny, and feels more oppressed because nobody else thinks they're oppressed, can get together and rehash their sense of victimhood and exclude anyone who disagrees.

Human nature being what it is, the second is perhaps more likely than the first. But that does not make the first invalid (when genuinely needed).

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by jklinger410 on Friday May 15, 2015 @02:50PM (#9552809)
So you advocate judging the validity of a person's points not by their content, but by their sex and race?

Classic illiberal progressivism.

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by djillionsmix on Sunday May 17, 2015 @10:02PM (#9562571)
Heaven forbid we judge viewpoints on their merits and not on the identity of the speaker.
Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by jerf on Friday May 15, 2015 @11:11AM (#9551112)
"It's quite possible for an atheist and a die-hard Christian to get dinner together, if they both commit to focusing on the topics they share rather than the ones they disagree on."

Actually, nothing even precludes them from discussing religion. Just because we're wired to get into angry shouting matches on the matters that pertain to tribal identification (which I used descriptively, not perjoratively... human psychology can not be understood until you understand that we are deeply tribal, and religion is a huge component of that) does not mean that we are obligated to give in to those impulses.

It's just... really hard. For everybody. And increasingly, giving in to those impulses is being held up a virtue, rather than vice. This bodes poorly for the future of civil society.

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by jklinger410 on Friday May 15, 2015 @12:27PM (#9551663)
But doesn't a civil society benefit from discussion on topics rather than ignorance of them?

Because as far as I'm concerned safe spaces only promote ignorance, one sided narratives, and echo chambers.

America, during the red scare, was a "safe space" for capitalism. Even so much as agreeing with a socialist or communist idea would get you publicly denounced at the least, and jailed at the most.

Safe spaces are private communities for people who can't handle alternative views.

A site-wide harassment ban is one thing. A site-wide "safe space" is entirely different.

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by AnimalMuppet on Friday May 15, 2015 @03:18PM (#9552990)
> But doesn't a civil society benefit from discussion on topics rather than ignorance of them?

Discussion, yes. Absolutely.

Shouting matches? Not so much.

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by djillionsmix on Sunday May 17, 2015 @10:00PM (#9562564)
More like a recognition of the concept as demonstrated and practiced.
Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by hoopd on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:59AM (#9551046)
I'm not "them" anymore but I'll try to explain what I can.

Safe space used to be a term for a very small group of people who agreed to be positive and nurturing towards one another no matter what. This is important for sexual assault survivors, closet gays, the heavily marginalized, etc. to have a space in which they can actually speak with other human beings about their experiences. This is, in reality, a very important thing.

However, it doesn't scale well. Some people have thought, "Hey, I like these safe spaces...what if we make everywhere a safe space? Wouldn't that be great?" What they miss is there isn't one universal definition of safe space and you can't just force your definition upon others.

In a very general sense, at the reddit scale, "safe space" means protecting those who need protecting. That means protecting the disempowered, the marginalized, the minorities, etc. from the ignorance and violence of the masses. Protecting them from the hegemonic power of the majority, which means the patriarchy in general and if we're being honest white males in particular.

It sounds good in principle but who is "empowered" and who is "disempowered" isn't an easy question to answer. To make things worse the tools of enforcing a safe space are so powerful that the people fighting against oppression often become oppressors themselves. In the case of reddit there are many members who are openly abusive and believe it's morally justified because they're "punching up" and it's only real abuse when you hurt people lower on the social ladder than you. (As an aside, this a big reason to claim victimhood: once you're a "victim" you get to do things you otherwise wouldn't.)

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by Vaskivo on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:33AM (#9550837)
To me, as a channer, those values are "iffy".

What to you mean by "Create a safe space to encourage participation".

Define a safe space. I can't physically hurt anyone, so that's a given. But are they considering a "safe space" a place where I can't say anything potentially insulting, offending or hurtful? In that case, I don't have freedom of expression and neither is Reddit encouraging (my) participation.

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by mhomde on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:18AM (#9550713)
Yeah, but it also says "a safe space", obviously some rules would have to be in place for that
Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by maxerickson on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:20AM (#9550741)
It doesn't say

    Embrace all viewpoints.
    Allow total freedom of expression.
There is a long tradition of seeking robust debate. There is also a long tradition of expecting some measure of decorum.
Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by talmand on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:32AM (#9550829)
I would say the original statements and your version of the statements are the same thing. If they were not they should read as:

    Embrace some viewpoints.
    Allow some freedom of expression.
With whatever variation on the language as necessary. If the statement doesn't originally place a restriction on the idea, then it isn't necessary to specifically state there is no restriction.

Therefore, I would say that technically:

    Embrace viewpoints.
    Embrace all viewpoints.
Are, in fact, the same thing.

As for maintaining decorum, that where the restrictions come into play and have to be specifically stated:

    Embrace diversity of viewpoints by permitting all 
    statements that follow community guidelines on language 
    pertaining to harassment, crudeness, personal attacks, 
    etc. Any statements may be censored for not following 
    community guidelines.
Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by maxerickson on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:46AM (#9550955)
It's a fuzzy statement of values from a corporation. Reading it as if it is a computer program is a mistake.

I guess you can choose to give them more or less credit based on how closely they hew to a pedantic squeezing of the meaning, but my point was that they do not emphasize that they are absolutes (even where simple language is available to do so).

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by talmand on Monday May 18, 2015 @09:30AM (#9564274)
While true, that doesn't give you license to decide the definition of their statements.
Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by mikeash on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:17AM (#9550705)
We say similar things in English. One might seriously say, "If you don't like it, move to Russia." Implying that if you disagree with anything then you're sympathizing with the enemy, and that as long as we're better than somebody it doesn't matter what's wrong.

Maybe the Portuguese version doesn't have those implications, but I find it to be one of the worst arguments a person can make.

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by untog on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:21AM (#9550749)
Eh, that is usually applied to discussions about living in America, not using a specific service. After all, it doesn't even make any sense in this context (move to Russia and... use Reddit still?).

You're right that this one is an awful argument because it's not within anyone's power to move to Russia, usually (or otherwise move away from the various laws and regulations that apply to them in the US). However, they absolutely can use a site other than Reddit without problems.

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by mikeash on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:30AM (#9550816)
Um, yes, that specific phrase would be applied to living in the US, not using a specific service. I'm describing a similar kind of statement with an explicit example, not saying that exact phrase also applies here.

And the problem is not that you can't do it, it's that it's a way of shutting down criticism without addressing it. It's inherently a non sequitur. It basically says, "The problems you point out are not actually problems, because you can go away."

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by Vaskivo on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:42AM (#9550925)
In portuguese it literally means "going someplace else".

An example: I enter the subway and sit next to a man. For some reason, I stink. The man is unconfortable and asks me to move. I shouldn't move. I am OK where I am. If he's not OK he should be the one moving somewhere else.

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by mrec on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:14AM (#9550682)
The British equivalent comes from this famous WW1 cartoon by Bruce Bairnsfather : http://www.ww1-propaganda-cards.com/images/bb02a.JPG
Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by smrtinsert on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:26AM (#9550780)
Anything banned from reddit that is only allowed on chans does not constitute free speech in my opinion. Most likely it is hateful, or immoral.

I think that probably aligns reddit closer with the USs definition of free speech.

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by lmeter on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:31AM (#9550822)
A definition of free speech that excludes 'hate speech' is faulty.

"Hate speech is not free speech" is a remarkably inane statement.

If you are against hate speech, you are against free speech. Opposing free speech is not an unacceptable position however.

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by mreiland on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:37AM (#9550877)
idealistically, yes. practically, there has to be a limit on speech. Shouting fire in a crowded theater is the canonical example of this.
Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by lmeter on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:42AM (#9550922)
I'm in favour of a few criminal limits - perjury can't be allowed for example.

A person who supports placing legal limits on expression because they offend a group, religion, political party, etc. can't sincerely claim to be an advocate for free speech. Better to avoid the doublethink and stop defining free speech as speech that you approve of.

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by briandh on Friday May 15, 2015 @11:02AM (#9551074)
With respect to that "canonical example": http://popehat.com/2012/09/19/three-generations-of-a-hackney...
Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by mreiland on Friday May 15, 2015 @12:03PM (#9551468)
The protections are practical and necessary, someone complaining that the example gets overused and abused in random arguments isn't really relevant to this discussion.
Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by sgift on Friday May 15, 2015 @12:21PM (#9551609)
The discussion is free speech and "hate speech" (whatever that should be), the "example" used for free speech limits is the "fire in theater" ... how does this example even remotely relate to hate speech? And if it doesn't relate why is telling that not relevant to this discussion?
Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by mreiland on Friday May 15, 2015 @02:28PM (#9552641)
lmeter was clearly making the argument that free speech is defined as speech with no limits, I pointed out a practical reason for limiting speech.
Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by hoopd on Friday May 15, 2015 @02:24PM (#9552615)
There are also limits on the limits of speech.

The current state of reddit includes a large group going around trying to be offended and then bringing the outrage back to home-base so the group at large can also get that outrage-dopamine kick. For their troubles the person who found the offensive comment or post gets some internet points and their group membership is solidified.

It's fascinating in the sense that it happens but I don't think it's reasonable to lurk in social groups you don't belong to and complain about the local norms.

Re:Reddit launches harassment crackdown by stefantalpalaru on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:38AM (#9550893)
You'll easily get banned from a subreddit dedicated to North Korea, as a joke. Create another account from the same IP and try to post something else on that subreddit and now you're hellbanned on the whole site for that IP because of some hidden rule.